Much like the first book in the series, I'll give this one 3 stars. Some parts were much better than others. All in all, even with the "negatives" listed below, I do think this book is stronger than the first book.
Quick aside. Some people think that 3 stars is bad. And for a lot, maybe it is. I rate a little differently. I see star ratings more as a bell curve:
1 star = bottom 10%
2 stars = between 10% and 30%
3 stars = between 30% and 70%
4 stars = between 70% and 90%
5 stars = top 10%
So for me, 3 is somewhere in the middle - an average book - and that's where I rate most books I read. It takes a lot to get 4 stars out of me, and a whole lot to get 5.
Anyway. So on with this book.
What I liked:
- Reed. He's a great male lead. He's a great and compelling mix of
powerful/strong and sweet/vulnerable. I like how he's so open and honest about his feelings toward Evie. The scene in the library where she's listening to his lamenting voicemails, esp in Angelic, was a little heartbreaking. I did love that because it really showed me the depth of his feelings for her. That's nice from a romantic point of view.
- Furthering the above re: Reed, I love the whole angel hierarchy concept, especially the Power class. I like how Reed's character has been put together in that class structure. I wanted a lot more of him in this book.
- Secondaries. Again, I really liked some the secondaries, especially Zephyr. He's fantastic and a worthy side companion for Reed.
- Evie's getting stronger as a female lead. I can see and appreciate that. She's still weak, IMO, but... better. She makes some stupid decisions, but at least I can see that she has good intentions. I love her training sessions and the scenes where we get to see her fight. I love, love, loved the training session with Zee. This is a definite improvement from the first book.
- Considering the above, as contrary as it sounds, I was so happy that Evie let Reed fight on her behalf in the War Council confrontation with Pagan. His character NEEDED to do that. It made sense and IMO was one of the very best parts of this book. It showcased Reed as a character. Loved it.
- Russell isn't *bad*. In fact he's rather likable. And I like that the author has found a way to make him useful through all his past life memories rather than a liability. BUT... more on that below.
- I still enjoy the concept of the world, at least the angelic porton (see below). I like the conflict laid out. It's interesting and fun to read. I love the idea that angels think and behave differently. And I like how the author is actually showing us that (the minivan escape, how Evie is so compelling and intriguing to the angels, etc).
What needed some work / what I didn't like:
- Again, way too many similarities with Twilight. They weren't as pronounced as in the first book, but they are still there and glaringly obvious.
- While I appreciate that the author is trying to create a unique story and world, I feel that she's overreaching and trying to incorporate too many "hot" and "current" things: angels, fallen angels, reincarnated soulmates, ghosts, fae - and not only fae, but *vampiric* fae. It's just too much and I really didn't like the whole segment with Brennus at all. I wish that that conflict would have been with another Fallen and that she'd not even gone down the path of introducing fae. That would have made for a tighter world and plot.
- You know how I said the love triangle was over in the first book? UGH. DAMN IT. I don't doubt that Evie and Reed are the final couple, especially after the last segment in this book where they are bound and essentially "married" (sorry, spoiler), but there was way too much Evie/Russell crap in this book. I hate how this author is using the term "soul mate". It's distracting and it doesn't really add to the story in my opinion. I love Russell as a friend, but I just don't buy the triangle angst crap.
- A little more on that binding thing. While I love the concept, I wished there had been *more* to it. The way it was set up, it was almost more of a convenience than for love. I *know* Reed and Evie are in love - like *forever love* - but I wanted a little more romance and a little less practicality in the way this was set up.
- Accents. I forgot to mention this in the first book's review. But... they are incredibly distracting. I'm from NC, so Russell's supposed accent KILLS me. Not only is it over the top, it's wrong. We dont' say "ya'll" when we mean "you" singular. We say it when we mean "you" plural. It gets even worse when the Irish (vampiric) fae are introduced and not only do we have to read the supposed NC accent of Russell, but the Gaelic accent of the fae. It's too much and really unnecessary.
- SWAPPING POV. For the love of God, no. I despise it when authors decide to go head hopping. The middle segment where we are in Ruseell's POV... UGH. HATED it. To me, this was another blatant Twilight similarity (Breaking Dawn's Jacob POV segment). The entire first book is from Evie's perspective. 2/3 of this book. Except for that pesky middle segment in Russell's POV. Just say no to alternating POVs.
- The beach loving / fade to black. LOL back to the Twilight similarities.
- The predictable Evie leaving Reed in order to keep him safe. That's a rather tired plot direction. I've seen it in dozens of YA books. I'd have liked to have seen Evie choose a better, more mature path - staying with Reed, Zee, Buns, and Brownie, and figuring this out as a team/unit.
I'm not sure when the next book will be out. But the good news is that at least for me, this installment ends in a pretty good place. I'll keep my eye out for the next one, but it's not left on some major cliffhanger, so I'm not clamoring for more. Like the first book, it's a fast read, so low investment. Not the best "angel" book, but not the worst.