I'd like to say that this oversized reproduction of Art Spiegelman & Francoise Mouly's 1980s independent 'graphix' magazine is a constantly surprising and utterly remarkable collection of early independent comics. But it's not. It's not far off the mark, and really is a fun bunch of varied styles and genres within the medium at a time when 'independent comics' wasn't even really a phrase yet. This book collects selected bits from the original first three issues of RAW magazine, but we're not really told what has been left out (or why). It is inspirational in making me wonder what the rest of the series was like, but not enough to make me track them down.
We get to see work from eventual indie stalwarts like Bill Griffiths, Drew & Josh Alan Friedman, Mark Beyer, Joost Swarte, Charles Burns and of course Spiegelman & Mouly themselves. For the most part, these fall in the left-of-center suburban flipside kind of story and do a fine job at what they do. None of them, however, is really remarkable and there are even a couple that are just downright incomprehensible.
I'm glad I have this book, as it marks an important point of transition between the 'hippy' comics of the 1970s and the indie boom of the late-80s/early-90s. It's an entertaining bunch of stuff, but not what I'd call 'essential.'
This edition includes a colour insert 'Two-Fisted Painters' mini-comic, all eight of full-colour cardstock Mark Beyer 'City of Terror' trading cards, an informative and interesting intro from Spiegelman & Mouly, and short bios/bibliographies of all the contributors.