The things I liked about this anthology only marginally outweighed those that I didn't. This is straightforward history of the dullest variety. Nothing analytical. That said, it's hugely comprehensive, not only in terms of the time it spans, but also its geography. I was impressed with the depth of knowledge that went into some of the pieces (particularly those giving information about "the book" in international frameworks). Other pieces seemed under-researched (which is only exacerbated with everything is under-theorized, at least in my mind). There are definitely pieces here that would be useful to assign as background (particularly to an undergraduate book history course), and I don't want to imply that I didn't learn a lot. I guess at the end of the day I've been thoroughly poisoned against history that doesn't go beyond an attempt to present facts.