What do you think?
Rate this book
The Girl in the Glass
Renaissance is a word with hope infused in every letter.
Since she was a child, Meg has dreamed of taking a promised trip to Florence, Italy, and being able to finally step into the place captured in a picture at her grandmother’s house. But after her grandmother passes away and it falls to her less-than-reliable father to take her instead, Meg’s long-anticipated travel plans seem permanently on hold.
When her dad finally tells Meg to book the trip, she prays that the experience will heal the fissures left on her life by her parents’ divorce. But when Meg arrives in Florence, her father is nowhere to be found, leaving aspiring memoir-writer Sophia Borelli to introduce Meg to the rich beauty of the ancient city. Sofia claims to be one of the last surviving members of the Medici family and that a long-ago Medici princess, Nora Orsini, communicates with her from within the great masterpieces of the Italian Renaissance.
When Sophia, Meg, and Nora’s stories intersect, their lives will be indelibly changed as they each answer the What if renaissance isn’t just a word? What if that’s what happens when you dare to believe that what is isn’t what has to be ?
Since she was a child, Meg has dreamed of taking a promised trip to Florence, Italy, and being able to finally step into the place captured in a picture at her grandmother’s house. But after her grandmother passes away and it falls to her less-than-reliable father to take her instead, Meg’s long-anticipated travel plans seem permanently on hold.
When her dad finally tells Meg to book the trip, she prays that the experience will heal the fissures left on her life by her parents’ divorce. But when Meg arrives in Florence, her father is nowhere to be found, leaving aspiring memoir-writer Sophia Borelli to introduce Meg to the rich beauty of the ancient city. Sofia claims to be one of the last surviving members of the Medici family and that a long-ago Medici princess, Nora Orsini, communicates with her from within the great masterpieces of the Italian Renaissance.
When Sophia, Meg, and Nora’s stories intersect, their lives will be indelibly changed as they each answer the What if renaissance isn’t just a word? What if that’s what happens when you dare to believe that what is isn’t what has to be ?
352 pages, Paperback
First published September 1, 2012
679 people are currently reading
4695 people want to read
About the author
Susan Meissner
33 books9,217 followersSusan Meissner is a USA Today bestselling novelist with more than a million books in the hands of readers, and in eighteen languages. Her critically acclaimed works of historical fiction have been named to numerous lists including Publishers Weekly’s annual roster of 100 best books, Library Reads Top Picks, Real Simple annual tally of best books, Goodreads Readers’ Choice awards, Booklist’s Top Ten, and Book of the Month.
She attended Point Loma Nazarene University in San Diego and is a former managing editor of a weekly newspaper. Susan’s expertise as a storyteller and her thoroughly researched topics make her a favorite author of book clubs everywhere. Her engaging and warm speaking style appeal to all manner of women’s groups, literary organizations, libraries and learning institutions, and service clubs.
When she is not working on a new novel, she enjoys teaching workshops on writing, spending time with her family, music, reading great books, and traveling.
She attended Point Loma Nazarene University in San Diego and is a former managing editor of a weekly newspaper. Susan’s expertise as a storyteller and her thoroughly researched topics make her a favorite author of book clubs everywhere. Her engaging and warm speaking style appeal to all manner of women’s groups, literary organizations, libraries and learning institutions, and service clubs.
When she is not working on a new novel, she enjoys teaching workshops on writing, spending time with her family, music, reading great books, and traveling.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 547 reviews
May 21, 2022
2.5 stars....
I usually love Susan Meissner books. I really was excited to read this story and it just sort of went no where. I did feel drawn into the story, but at 50% I was still trying to figure out what the story was about exactly. I won't go into details but the plot just sort of dead-ended. The story of Nora from the past was interesting but became sort of unimportant in the end. The story of Sophia was just sad and depressing. Meg's life was odd and was left resolved but in a sort of rushed way. So, if you haven't read Susan Meissner before, I don't recommend starting with this one.....
I usually love Susan Meissner books. I really was excited to read this story and it just sort of went no where. I did feel drawn into the story, but at 50% I was still trying to figure out what the story was about exactly. I won't go into details but the plot just sort of dead-ended. The story of Nora from the past was interesting but became sort of unimportant in the end. The story of Sophia was just sad and depressing. Meg's life was odd and was left resolved but in a sort of rushed way. So, if you haven't read Susan Meissner before, I don't recommend starting with this one.....
December 29, 2016
I give this more than 5 stars! This is in my top five books of the year and probably in my life. Florence drew me. While reading the book I walked in the characters' footsteps. I saw the art and the statues and buildings through the eyes of three women. Besides being a great story, the novel is full of deep emotional and psychological truths. I don't read books twice but this one will be the exception. As a side note, I have written a novel taking place in 1550 Florence with some of the same Medici characters. A must read....
April 16, 2024
First time reading this author and although she didn't knock it out of the park, I did like her writing style, her use of three different points of view and the tapestry of stories brought to life by a strong sense of place and some fairly honest characters.
And the best part of all-- this was a gorgeous tribute to Florence and her role in the Renaissance. If you don't want to grab the next flight and stroll thru any number of highlighted cathedrals, gardens and other architectural or cultural destinations in Italy's most celebrated "art town," you didn't read the same book I did.
(Reviewed 8/19/16)
And the best part of all-- this was a gorgeous tribute to Florence and her role in the Renaissance. If you don't want to grab the next flight and stroll thru any number of highlighted cathedrals, gardens and other architectural or cultural destinations in Italy's most celebrated "art town," you didn't read the same book I did.
(Reviewed 8/19/16)
August 20, 2012
I traveled to Florence, Italy and came home too soon. This novel is painted in hues or red and bronze and vibrant colors of romance and discovering self in the place God dreams of for you.
From the minute I started reading Meg’s story I fell in love with her. I actually much preferred her story over the sections of Sophia’s novel. Meg’s story had a pull on me I couldn’t fully explain. Perhaps it was her longing to know where she was meant to be. Perhaps it was her dream to visit a place so magical it almost couldn’t be true. Or perhaps it was her longing to connect with someone who wouldn’t let her down, even if she fully didn’t realize it at first. I think she found a little bit of everything she was looking for…and in turn, so did I. Her ending breathes hope and joy and content.
The novel is almost like a dessert disappearing on the tongue, leaving a lingering sweetness too quickly washed away. Meg is definitely a character that will live on in her Italian countryside and in my dreams.
Sophia’s and Nonia’s stories certainly contributed to the book, but I didn’t become as invested in them, again it was Meg and finally Lorenzo that drew me.
I was blissful at the closing of the book…and a bit sad too. But in the deepest part of my reader’s heart where beloved character’s live, I know she will live on in happiness.
This review is my honest opinion. Thanks to the Amazon Vine program and the publishers for my copy to review.
From the minute I started reading Meg’s story I fell in love with her. I actually much preferred her story over the sections of Sophia’s novel. Meg’s story had a pull on me I couldn’t fully explain. Perhaps it was her longing to know where she was meant to be. Perhaps it was her dream to visit a place so magical it almost couldn’t be true. Or perhaps it was her longing to connect with someone who wouldn’t let her down, even if she fully didn’t realize it at first. I think she found a little bit of everything she was looking for…and in turn, so did I. Her ending breathes hope and joy and content.
The novel is almost like a dessert disappearing on the tongue, leaving a lingering sweetness too quickly washed away. Meg is definitely a character that will live on in her Italian countryside and in my dreams.
Sophia’s and Nonia’s stories certainly contributed to the book, but I didn’t become as invested in them, again it was Meg and finally Lorenzo that drew me.
I was blissful at the closing of the book…and a bit sad too. But in the deepest part of my reader’s heart where beloved character’s live, I know she will live on in happiness.
This review is my honest opinion. Thanks to the Amazon Vine program and the publishers for my copy to review.
October 14, 2016
I'm not quite sure how to rate this story. It kept me reading, although there were parts where I lost interest and skimmed, and I didn't love the way it wrapped up. BUT I think this is mostly because the main character is quite dissimilar to myself (I related more to Renata in the story). I enjoyed taking a little walk down memory lane with the descriptions of Florence, and I enjoyed the women's fiction pace of the tale. Bottom line is that Susan Meissner is a great weaver of tales, and this one is worth reading!
October 18, 2013
When I was asked if I was interested in reading and reviewing this novel, as an Italophile I was absolutely delighted to do so. Always interested in reading a novel set in Italy this did not disappoint, although I have yet to meet a real life Italian that drinks cappucini after midday. It was difficult to decide what genre this should be placed in as it is part historical fiction and part contemporary and as such will appeal to a wide cross section of readers.
Susan Meissner has skilfully intertwined the historical story of a real Medici with her contemporary characters. Three women from different generations Nora, Meg and Sofia are the protagonists in this complex but still very easy to read novel. Nora Orsini is a Medici princess from the sixteenth century whose story is told in brief chapters amongst the contemporary ones, which feature Meg an editor with a travel publisher and Sofia an idiosyncratic author whose work has been drawn to Meg's attention.
The story opens in San Diego, USA where Meg feels her life is not living up to her dream, possibly due to the uneasy relationships she has with her divorced parents. Since she was a child her father has been promising her a trip to Florence, Italy so that she can see for herself the beauty of a place she always been familiar with through a painting belonging to her grandmother. It starts to look as if her dream might actually come true when her father tells her to book the trip.
Meg sets off for Florence to discover if the experience will solve her relationship issues with her father, but things do not work out quite as expected. As she explores the rich history of this beautiful city the stunning art and architecture she is surrounded by make her realise that her perspective on her own life is seriously adrift. To discover what happens to her expectations of those around her and her dreams you will have to read this delightful exploration of disillusionment.
http://lindyloumacbookreviews.blogspo...
Susan Meissner has skilfully intertwined the historical story of a real Medici with her contemporary characters. Three women from different generations Nora, Meg and Sofia are the protagonists in this complex but still very easy to read novel. Nora Orsini is a Medici princess from the sixteenth century whose story is told in brief chapters amongst the contemporary ones, which feature Meg an editor with a travel publisher and Sofia an idiosyncratic author whose work has been drawn to Meg's attention.
The story opens in San Diego, USA where Meg feels her life is not living up to her dream, possibly due to the uneasy relationships she has with her divorced parents. Since she was a child her father has been promising her a trip to Florence, Italy so that she can see for herself the beauty of a place she always been familiar with through a painting belonging to her grandmother. It starts to look as if her dream might actually come true when her father tells her to book the trip.
Meg sets off for Florence to discover if the experience will solve her relationship issues with her father, but things do not work out quite as expected. As she explores the rich history of this beautiful city the stunning art and architecture she is surrounded by make her realise that her perspective on her own life is seriously adrift. To discover what happens to her expectations of those around her and her dreams you will have to read this delightful exploration of disillusionment.
http://lindyloumacbookreviews.blogspo...
August 16, 2014
This would be a fabulous read for anyone who loves art history, Florence, Italy, or a gently-paced tale that weaves both historical and contemporary story lines. Some readers may find themselves skimming the art history details, but most of them actually contribute to a depth of discovery that is ultimately meaningful to the main characters. The surprise ending was a delight.
Coming from a Christian publisher and author, I was surprised that there was no faith element in this book beyond a mention that someone asked for prayer. I believe a spiritual thread could have strengthened the theme, but I still give four stars for skillful weaving of stories spanning several centuries, historical details, and for crafting genuinely likeable characters.
Coming from a Christian publisher and author, I was surprised that there was no faith element in this book beyond a mention that someone asked for prayer. I believe a spiritual thread could have strengthened the theme, but I still give four stars for skillful weaving of stories spanning several centuries, historical details, and for crafting genuinely likeable characters.
November 24, 2015
Reading The Girl in the Glass, I felt just as Meg must have in Florence. I was immersed in a dreamlike reality, mistily concrete.
It sparked extensive thought. The themes are a significant part of the book. As I perused it, I decided the ultimate message of the book was that art can bring peace, healing, and hope, even when lives are falling apart. And that is, in part, the motif of the book. But it's also about so much more.
This is a book about hope. It's a book about identity. About experiencing renaissance, rebirth, for ourselves. This is a book about becoming who you are.
Partway through, I began to wonder about the title. At that point in the story, I couldn't see how it fit. But now? No title could be more fitting.
Because this book is about the girl in the glass. The one you see every time you look in the mirror. Ultimately, we are not defined by what happens to us, nor are we defined by reality. We decide who we are.
And now, for a couple of highlights:
This may seem small, but I appreciated Lorenzo's voice. From the beginning of the book, his words rolled off of the paper Italian. I felt like I could hear his accent in his words. All of the characters' voices seemed real, but his stood out to me.
I also want to acknowledge the writing. Meissner's writing was vivid, colorful, and pitch-perfect. I could tell it was written with precision, that the voices of the characters and the words used throughout the book were carefully chosen. The language of The Girl in the Glass made it art.
Needless to say, I loved this book. While it dealt with some depressing topics, the ultimate message of the book was hope. With this book I grew wings, and learned to fly.
This review was published on whimsicallyreal.blogspot.com.
It sparked extensive thought. The themes are a significant part of the book. As I perused it, I decided the ultimate message of the book was that art can bring peace, healing, and hope, even when lives are falling apart. And that is, in part, the motif of the book. But it's also about so much more.
This is a book about hope. It's a book about identity. About experiencing renaissance, rebirth, for ourselves. This is a book about becoming who you are.
Partway through, I began to wonder about the title. At that point in the story, I couldn't see how it fit. But now? No title could be more fitting.
Because this book is about the girl in the glass. The one you see every time you look in the mirror. Ultimately, we are not defined by what happens to us, nor are we defined by reality. We decide who we are.
And now, for a couple of highlights:
This may seem small, but I appreciated Lorenzo's voice. From the beginning of the book, his words rolled off of the paper Italian. I felt like I could hear his accent in his words. All of the characters' voices seemed real, but his stood out to me.
I also want to acknowledge the writing. Meissner's writing was vivid, colorful, and pitch-perfect. I could tell it was written with precision, that the voices of the characters and the words used throughout the book were carefully chosen. The language of The Girl in the Glass made it art.
Needless to say, I loved this book. While it dealt with some depressing topics, the ultimate message of the book was hope. With this book I grew wings, and learned to fly.
This review was published on whimsicallyreal.blogspot.com.
January 13, 2018
I continue to read Susan Meissner's novels. They totally fascinate me as she weaves stories around the main story. In this one there is a young girl who is working at a publishing company and comes across a story of a Medici survivor in Florence Italy. Between a father and a daughter who was promised a trip to Florence and the background of an earlier Medici girl whispering of her life, there is a touching story about what is actually black and white and what is the gray area of ours lives. Now I want to go to Florence also.
September 23, 2016
This is a sweet story. It reads very well and the author's words flow beautifully, but for me it really lacked content and substance.
March 27, 2024
A könyvtárunkban van egy havi egykönyves kihívás, és márciusra az volt a feladat, hogy szerepeljen a címben a „lány” szó. Nézegettem a könyveket, és ez tűnt a legkevésbé borzasztónak. Ami nem egy jó indítás – de a fizikai nyomda plecsnik nagy motivációt jelentenek.
Egyébként viszonylag kellemesen csalódtam, ráadásul többen Susan Meissner egyik legrosszabb regényének tartják. Lassan csordogál a történet egy közepesen idegesítő főszereplő nővel, akinek a daddy issue-i miatt a szerelmi élete sem áll a legfényesebben. Őszintén szólva én nem nevezném romantikus könyvnek, abszolút nem a párkapcsolat állt a fókuszban, sőt az erre vonatkozó részek kifejezetten idegesítők voltak szerintem. És a feloldása is a „jaj-kit-szeretek-igazán” kérdéskörnek.
Maga az írói stílus is egy alulról közepes; a többi karakter is elég felszínes. Ezen kívül a művtöri nálam nem működik igazán könyvben. Hiába írnak nekem mindenfélét Firenzéről, szobrokról, épületekről – ha lusta vagyok kiguglizni, márpedig most az voltam, akkor halottnak a csók.
Így az értékelés végére igazából nem volt jó könyv. De mégis jó volt arra, hogy kicsit kikapcsoljak, elmenjek egy álomvilágba , és tulajdonképpen be tudott néha rántani az érzelmi hullámvasútba Susan Meissner. Szívesen ültem le olvasni. Úgyhogy megengedek magamnak egy felülcsillagozást. Kicsit sikerült visszahoznom a rendszeres olvasást a végtelen horgolás mellé.
Egyébként viszonylag kellemesen csalódtam, ráadásul többen Susan Meissner egyik legrosszabb regényének tartják. Lassan csordogál a történet egy közepesen idegesítő főszereplő nővel, akinek a daddy issue-i miatt a szerelmi élete sem áll a legfényesebben. Őszintén szólva én nem nevezném romantikus könyvnek, abszolút nem a párkapcsolat állt a fókuszban, sőt az erre vonatkozó részek kifejezetten idegesítők voltak szerintem. És a feloldása is a „jaj-kit-szeretek-igazán” kérdéskörnek.
Maga az írói stílus is egy alulról közepes; a többi karakter is elég felszínes. Ezen kívül a művtöri nálam nem működik igazán könyvben. Hiába írnak nekem mindenfélét Firenzéről, szobrokról, épületekről – ha lusta vagyok kiguglizni, márpedig most az voltam, akkor halottnak a csók.
Így az értékelés végére igazából nem volt jó könyv. De mégis jó volt arra, hogy kicsit kikapcsoljak, elmenjek egy álomvilágba , és tulajdonképpen be tudott néha rántani az érzelmi hullámvasútba Susan Meissner. Szívesen ültem le olvasni. Úgyhogy megengedek magamnak egy felülcsillagozást. Kicsit sikerült visszahoznom a rendszeres olvasást a végtelen horgolás mellé.
April 13, 2024
This story drew me in right away. First I connected with the lovely main character, Meg. It helped draw me in that she lives in my hometown of San Diego! Then adding the stunning beauty of Florence, Italy was icing on the cake! I felt like I was there in Florence as she experienced this city and the relationships she had with new friends there. This is a deep and sweet story, one that relays holding tight to hope after heartache.
April 1, 2013
One of my favorite authors writing about one of my favorite cities. How can you get better than that? The weaving of three individual stories--Meg's, Nora's, and Sophia's--provided an interesting twist to the Renaissance in the quintessential Renaissance city--Florence, Italy. This is a story of discovery, beauty and love. Susan Meissner's style is as captivating as her characters. Each character challenged readers to forge their own views on life experiences, travel, imagination, dealing with disappointment and difficulties, and confidently facing the future. As I read, life around me literally seemed to fade to a dull hum while Florence became alive. I was mesmerized--once again taking in the Piazza della Signoria, experiencing David at the Accedemia, and walking on the Ponte Vecchio. Yes, Meissner is "that good" of an author. It's a must read.
June 5, 2013
The Girl in the Glass was one of those stories I wanted to read slowly only to make the experience last...it's that good. But I ended up reading it quickly because it is that good. Susan Meissner is a breath of fresh air in the way she tells stories. I could see and smell the city of Florence, understand her characters struggles and desires in a way that made the book hard to put down, and she made me want to see the statue of David so much it hurt. I'm so glad that I had the privilege of reading Susan's latest and highly anticipate her books to come!
February 10, 2020
I have loved all the other Susan Meissner books I've read, so this book was very disappointing. I mostly like the past storyline much better than the current storyline but not with this book. The storyline from the past was very short and confusing and never really went anywhere. The main character in the current storyline was so annoying and hard to like. There was a lot of history of Florence in the book and a lot about art. Maybe if that interests you, this book would be much better. The storyline did pick up towards the end, but not enough to salvage the book for me.
December 28, 2018
This book made me want to go and visit Florence, Italy and I really enjoyed the Meg's story. However, I really disliked Nora's story that was interspersed between Meg's chapters. I ended up skimming them and wanted to skip them entirely, which wouldn't really have detracted from the book at all. There was a tie together between the two plots, but it felt really weak.
February 16, 2020
The concept drew me in, but then the story fell flat. Not only were there too many American clichés about Florence and Italian behaviors in general, but also the characters lacked depth and development. And by the way, people generally don’t drink cappuccinos after morning time in Italy.
February 22, 2017
2.5, this was just okay. I enjoyed the present day story much more then the past which is unusual for me.
May 9, 2020
“When we trust someone, we believe what they tell us is true.” I enjoyed this novel by Susan Meissner. The beauty of Florence, Italy and all the artistic works came alive in her descriptive writing. The individual stories of Nora, Sophia, and Meg were equally written well; separate yet connected. My heart did break for Sophia. I’ll stop there otherwise will need to tap on spoiler alert. I would recommend the read.
January 7, 2024
Starts out with an intriguing premise, but the resolution feels rushed, unsatisfying, and wholly unbelievable. The author also did not have an Italian proof a copy...they would never have approved Italian characters drinking cappuccino after dinner, lol, which honestly was the beginning of the book falling apart for me.
May 14, 2019
By reading this creatively magical story which tours through historic Florence, Italy, I feel I have visited and experienced this utterly magnificent city and works of art.
The Girl in the Glass is a light read with likable contemporary characters. Brings us back to a bit of the renaissance period, also
The Girl in the Glass is a light read with likable contemporary characters. Brings us back to a bit of the renaissance period, also
August 29, 2023
This book felt really scattered. Too many pieces that didn't fit together seamlessly and therefore the book's sections felt disjointed and clunky. Not my favorite book by Meissner, but it was a quick and easy read.
September 9, 2022
I usually love her books but had a hard time staying interested in this one. The going back and forth between all the different stories was hard to follow and they didn’t all seem relevant.
June 2, 2024
I’m a big Susan Meissner fan, this one not so much. Maybe it was the history of the Renaissance I had trouble following. It won’t deter me from reading more of her historical fiction books tho.
June 4, 2021
3.5 stars, rounded down. A little wacky plot twist, but enjoyed “visiting” Florence, Italy, and liked the way characters and storylines developed pretty well. A little slow, but a nice read.
September 29, 2012
How do you review a book that left you so full, but yet so empty? This book could have been so much more than it was. Since it is published as Christian fiction, you'd expect to find at least something of Christ inside. But there was nothing. There were a few vague mentions of God, but some of them were taking His name in vain. This book, as well as Meissner's previous release, should not have been marketed as Christian fiction. She can write, that's for sure. But she's abusing her position by writing conclusions that are actually contrary to the Bible, and I'm ready to see her removed from Christian circles and into the general fiction market.
I've observed in her past releases that Meissner likes to take three women from different generations or time periods and draw them together somehow. I had not thought she'd mastered that device until this book. Meg, Sofia, and Nora come alive and relate to each other so well. Meg, the heroine, is an editor at a travel guide publishing house. Her Italian grandmother told her so many stories of her hometown of Florence that Meg has always wanted to go, and her father has promised that he'd take her someday. Sofia is an author living in Florence whose work draws Meg in, and when Meg finally gets to see Florence and meet Sofia in person, there's an immediate connection between them. Nora Orsini is a Medici princess from the sixteenth century, who whispers her words of wisdom to Sofia through many of Florence's famous works of art. Nora's story is included in short mini-chapters throughout the book.
The plot is deeply layered and complex, yet not hard to follow. Each character is well-drawn. I felt the emotions were beautifully expressed, whether disappointment, unexpected joy, uncertainty, etc. Like I said, Susan Meissner can write and this is the best of her work that I have seen. On the merit of the story alone, I'd recommend this to anyone. But when it comes to the resolution, Meissner stumbles terribly. If her point was merely that we're not just the products of our parents and circumstances, I could get behind that, because I agree fully. But her point is pretty much that life is what we imagine it can be. That while we do have to face some realities, it's occasionally okay and even a good thing to live in our fantasies. This is not normal or acceptable behavior. Yes, our imaginations are precious gifts from God. But we cannot define our lives. Our lives should be defined by what God says. When we need comfort, we should seek Him. When we need guidance, we should seek Him. When we need love, we should seek Him. Making up realities is not an adult way to behave, and not a Christ-like thing to promote.
I can use my imagination and think about how wonderful this book could have been, had Christ been included. Meg's journey could have taken her closer to Him, where she could have found the love and relationship and comfort she was longing for. She could have realized how He had brought her through and helped her with her past hurts and hard times, and that He had a plan for her future that was only just beginning to unfold. The beauty that she saw in Florence could have correlated to the beauty God was revealing of Himself in her life. But that's not reality. The reality is that Meg was left spiritually unchanged and believing that imagination can define our lives. What a disappointment.
I received an advanced reading copy of this book from the publisher in exchange for this honest review. All opinions are my own.
This review originated at http://reviewsbyerin.livejournal.com
I've observed in her past releases that Meissner likes to take three women from different generations or time periods and draw them together somehow. I had not thought she'd mastered that device until this book. Meg, Sofia, and Nora come alive and relate to each other so well. Meg, the heroine, is an editor at a travel guide publishing house. Her Italian grandmother told her so many stories of her hometown of Florence that Meg has always wanted to go, and her father has promised that he'd take her someday. Sofia is an author living in Florence whose work draws Meg in, and when Meg finally gets to see Florence and meet Sofia in person, there's an immediate connection between them. Nora Orsini is a Medici princess from the sixteenth century, who whispers her words of wisdom to Sofia through many of Florence's famous works of art. Nora's story is included in short mini-chapters throughout the book.
The plot is deeply layered and complex, yet not hard to follow. Each character is well-drawn. I felt the emotions were beautifully expressed, whether disappointment, unexpected joy, uncertainty, etc. Like I said, Susan Meissner can write and this is the best of her work that I have seen. On the merit of the story alone, I'd recommend this to anyone. But when it comes to the resolution, Meissner stumbles terribly. If her point was merely that we're not just the products of our parents and circumstances, I could get behind that, because I agree fully. But her point is pretty much that life is what we imagine it can be. That while we do have to face some realities, it's occasionally okay and even a good thing to live in our fantasies. This is not normal or acceptable behavior. Yes, our imaginations are precious gifts from God. But we cannot define our lives. Our lives should be defined by what God says. When we need comfort, we should seek Him. When we need guidance, we should seek Him. When we need love, we should seek Him. Making up realities is not an adult way to behave, and not a Christ-like thing to promote.
I can use my imagination and think about how wonderful this book could have been, had Christ been included. Meg's journey could have taken her closer to Him, where she could have found the love and relationship and comfort she was longing for. She could have realized how He had brought her through and helped her with her past hurts and hard times, and that He had a plan for her future that was only just beginning to unfold. The beauty that she saw in Florence could have correlated to the beauty God was revealing of Himself in her life. But that's not reality. The reality is that Meg was left spiritually unchanged and believing that imagination can define our lives. What a disappointment.
I received an advanced reading copy of this book from the publisher in exchange for this honest review. All opinions are my own.
This review originated at http://reviewsbyerin.livejournal.com
July 1, 2020
I'm sure my view of this book is enhanced because it brought back memories of going to Florence. I looked up each painting and sculpture that was mentioned and reminisced about my trip.
Didn't really like the characters and the romance was frustrating at best. But I loved the descriptions of Florence and the fascination to the art. And Meg had nowhere to go but up, she went from supremely irritating to tolerable. The based on supposed reality story within the story was also interesting
Meg's grandmother promised to take her to Florence and she wanted to go with her father when the first promise didn't occur. Unfortunately, Meg's father is a lying, undependable guy. I found Meg supremely irritating. Meg is a travel guide literary agent who hasn't gone anywhere.
Story flips between Meg in present time, Meg's grandmother and Sophia's story of Medici family.
Likes:
* Famous pieces of Florence art
* Cover art
* My personal memories of Florence and sculptures
Dislikes:
* Unreliable assumptions
* Romance was often assumed or imagined
* Many presumptions were inaccurate
Francesca:
Medici princess ~ Francesca "Nora" Eleanora Orsini
With-reservations:
adultery, stealing, jealousy, envy, greed
Didn't really like the characters and the romance was frustrating at best. But I loved the descriptions of Florence and the fascination to the art. And Meg had nowhere to go but up, she went from supremely irritating to tolerable. The based on supposed reality story within the story was also interesting
Meg's grandmother promised to take her to Florence and she wanted to go with her father when the first promise didn't occur. Unfortunately, Meg's father is a lying, undependable guy. I found Meg supremely irritating. Meg is a travel guide literary agent who hasn't gone anywhere.
Story flips between Meg in present time, Meg's grandmother and Sophia's story of Medici family.
Likes:
* Famous pieces of Florence art
* Cover art
* My personal memories of Florence and sculptures
Dislikes:
* Unreliable assumptions
* Romance was often assumed or imagined
* Many presumptions were inaccurate
Francesca:
Medici princess ~ Francesca "Nora" Eleanora Orsini
With-reservations:
adultery, stealing, jealousy, envy, greed
November 8, 2023
As usual, I enjoyed Meissner's beautiful writing. The Girl in the Glass opened up a part of me where magical hopes grow and beauty pushes away the ashes.
December 3, 2012
I received this book for free from WaterBrook Multnomah Publishing Group for this review.
Ever since Meg was a child, she had always dreamed of going to Florence Italy. Her mother had a painting on her wall of herself as a young child posing near a statue that has captivated Meg for a long time and became her calling. When her grandmother passed away, her unreliable father makes a promise to one day take Meg to Florence and unfortunately those plans are put on hold.
Year pass Meg works for a book publisher and keeps in touch with Lorenzo and his sister from Florence who are writing a travel book. When her father shows up on her doorsteps promising to do go on his promise this time, the turn of events that follow Meg is one emotional roller coast.
When Meg arrives in Florence, she has to come to terms that her father is not there to meet her. She ends up staying with Sofia Borelli a woman who claims to be possible the last Medici, who is writing a book about her life and claims to hear Nora Orsini's voice in paintings and statues. Sofia takes Meg on to a tour through Florence and all it's beauty that parts of the book had me wishing that I was there as well. I have never been to Florence but after reading The Girl in The Glass, I kind of wish one day to visit.
Oh my goodness, I cannot express how I had felt about this book. I was happy and sad and angry. There were times that I wanted to scream and throw the book because of everything that unfolded. Other time my jaw hit the floor. Now, I have not read a book like this in a while and boy was I missing something. Susan Meissner writing is like beautiful magic. The book was amazing. It really was a roller coast ride of emotions. I loved the characters so much it was sad to see them go. I was very attached to Meg, because I know she wanted everything to happen for the best and I really hated Sofia's uncle and Lorenzo's sister – two characters that really mad me kind of mad through the book. I won't go into why or else it will ruin it. I loved Lorenzo as well, he had me rooting for him until the very end. This true was an amazing read.
Even thought this is a Christian book, it was missing the Christian characteristics. It was a comforting clean read that was both engaging and compelling. Where you could truly feel for the characters and their love for Florence Italy.
Ever since Meg was a child, she had always dreamed of going to Florence Italy. Her mother had a painting on her wall of herself as a young child posing near a statue that has captivated Meg for a long time and became her calling. When her grandmother passed away, her unreliable father makes a promise to one day take Meg to Florence and unfortunately those plans are put on hold.
Year pass Meg works for a book publisher and keeps in touch with Lorenzo and his sister from Florence who are writing a travel book. When her father shows up on her doorsteps promising to do go on his promise this time, the turn of events that follow Meg is one emotional roller coast.
When Meg arrives in Florence, she has to come to terms that her father is not there to meet her. She ends up staying with Sofia Borelli a woman who claims to be possible the last Medici, who is writing a book about her life and claims to hear Nora Orsini's voice in paintings and statues. Sofia takes Meg on to a tour through Florence and all it's beauty that parts of the book had me wishing that I was there as well. I have never been to Florence but after reading The Girl in The Glass, I kind of wish one day to visit.
Oh my goodness, I cannot express how I had felt about this book. I was happy and sad and angry. There were times that I wanted to scream and throw the book because of everything that unfolded. Other time my jaw hit the floor. Now, I have not read a book like this in a while and boy was I missing something. Susan Meissner writing is like beautiful magic. The book was amazing. It really was a roller coast ride of emotions. I loved the characters so much it was sad to see them go. I was very attached to Meg, because I know she wanted everything to happen for the best and I really hated Sofia's uncle and Lorenzo's sister – two characters that really mad me kind of mad through the book. I won't go into why or else it will ruin it. I loved Lorenzo as well, he had me rooting for him until the very end. This true was an amazing read.
Even thought this is a Christian book, it was missing the Christian characteristics. It was a comforting clean read that was both engaging and compelling. Where you could truly feel for the characters and their love for Florence Italy.
May 13, 2014
I really enjoyed this book and will definitely read other books by this author.
I liked the book overall but I will say the ending made it all come together. Without the ending as it stands or an alternative ending this story would have been good but the actual ending made the story great. No spoilers here, you must read it for yourself to understand, I promise time well spent.
Ms . Meissner painted a vivid and accurate picture of Florence. She did a wonderful job on her references to art and history as well. She noted all the well known sites in Florence with great detail. Not only did I read a fantastic book but I felt as if I was traveling in Florence. Ms. Meissner's writing made me long for my days in Florence. Thank you for conjuring up fond memories and special times spent in a city and county I enjoy spending my time. Made me smile as I turned every page as I fondly remembered the sites and delights of Florence.
Ms. Meissner has a colorful and easy style that captivates your attention from the first page. She delicately wove three characters with intersecting and parallel similarities without being overdone or confusing. The plot has a little bit of everything laced with a spiritual message that rings deep but not in your face. All the characters are well developed and compliment each other as well as the plot.
My only criticism was of Meg. I did not care for the fact she "crushed" on every man she interacted with but yet it felt contradictory to her grounded nature. Most times I felt that Meg was desperate and looking for love a little too much. She seemed open to love but seemed closed off too - more than her unresolved issues warranted. She just felt too contradictory for my liking - indecisive for the small nuances but very decisive in major decisions of the heart. Drove me nuts. The ending clarified my confusion but I felt frustrated reading the story until the ending shed light on her sketchiness.
All in all this was a delightful book and it should be added to your reading list.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 547 reviews