I stumbled on this book while searching for I can't remember what, and remembered the television dramatisation of it, and borrowed it. I think I might even have read some as a child too 🤔
🌳🌿🐴🌿🌳
I liked hearing about Kizzy and her great grandmother living happily in the orchard, with Joe the horse 🙂 including how it links to times where stopping on land by agreement was more common.
and how Kizzy later needs to navigate life without her gran. I liked the sense of a girl/young woman striving for autonomy (against ideas of those who don't really know her)... and protecting the life of her horse!
"the court was not used to defiance from a seven year old" 😉
🌳🌿🐴🌿🌳
it felt abit unrealistic to say the least that the admiral puts himself out to accommodate Kizzy while she's unwell, and nurses her at the manor! I found that hard to believe, even considering some of the backstory the admiral gets, that might speak to some of his potential motivations.
it also felt abit weird that a girl child was attended by adult men 🤔 tho I guess an interesting role reversal.
🌳🌿🐴🌿🌳
I had mixed feelings about the character of Miss Brook... presented as odd in her habits for a woman, not doing what other women do 🙄 she likes gardening, is generally friendly, and is a magistrate!
I liked her as a more independent woman within the novel, and her character expresses some more informed and less biassed perspectives on Travellers as a gorgio.
but she also fairly swiftly becomes 'love interest', with, of course, pretty much everyone falling for her - the Admiral, Peters... well, I probably would too 😉😆
I was abit sad too that by the end of the novel her position as an independent woman was kinda undermined 😕
🌳🌿🐴🌿🌳
there was some disturbing pressure on Kizzy to be the one who makes things up/right, after 14 of the girls set on her and beat her up badly.
but fortunately this was eventually redeemed by her friend Clem who persuades his sister Elizabeth to make things up with Kizzy.
🌳🌿🐴🌿🌳
there's much drama on bonfire night!!!!!!
and abit of a happily ever after ending... for pretty much the whole village 😆
all abit convenient and unbelievable... and rather reinforces a conventional family unit in ways abit at odds with the initial parts of the novel... but kinda cute all the same 😉
🌳🌿🐴🌿🌳
I think the novel contains ALOT of romanticising, but also ALOT of attempts at education and validation wrt the different cultures (Gorgio/Gadje/Gage and Rom/Gypsy/Roma/Traveller), and has a sense of attempts at preservation of some aspects of Rom life/lives past. the bullying Kizzy receives is authentically (and at times graphically) portrayed, tho there's also at least one village child who's a genuine friend, showing this is both a minority and also a possibility. stereotypes and prejudices against Travellers are voiced by some villagers, and clearly countered by others. and there is also some critique of both stereotyping, and of romanticising, GRT folk. there's a few threads that pull both cultures/groups close too, countering the sense of being mutually exclusive, and I especially appreciated these.
🌟
accessed as an RNIB talking book, well enough read by Elizabeth Proud 🙂