I'm going to say for the record: This entire review will contain spoilers. If you want to read this book, don't read my review. And if you're a fan of this book you probably shouldn't read my review, either, because I have nothing good to say about it. And again, I also want to apologize. As a fellow author, I hate leaving bad reviews for another author. I especially don't like stating that I hated a book. But I have very, very strong feelings about this book, so...again, I apologize.
<><><><>
I. HATED. THIS. BOOK.
Ugh.
What in the world did I just read?
I have always felt like Erin and Sam and her family had backseat to the entire Baxter Family.
Kari got her own book. So did Ashley. So did Luke. So did Brooke. Erin had to share all of, what, seven chapters of what should've been her book with a character we don't even care about: Dayne Matthews. Dayne Matthews who, in my opinion, was a last-minute desperate attempt to keep the Baxter family series going past Redemption. He wasn't even mentioned or foreshadowed in the first 4 books of the Redemption series, so the fact that he just sprang up in book 5 out of nowhere like pimples on prom night in the last book was kind of annoying to begin with. And it gets even better. He gets an entire series, plus major roles in the ones after that and Erin gets...
Um, let's see. Honorable mention? At best?
She lives down in Texas with her family. I'd love it if she got her own story, but no. She never did. So, she adopted four kids. I kind of feel like Erin wasn't even a side character, she was an extra, an NPC and so since her part in the story was basically worthless, she was killed off, along with her whole family EXCEPT for one kid.
Now, don't get me wrong. I'm an author who loves to write tragedy. I love making people feel, and I do that by way of tears. But this book, in my opinion, was too tragic. Way too tragic. Like, borderline horror book tragic. The only survivor of an awful accident was a (I don't even know anymore, ten?) ten year old girl. Who acted like she never even went through a trauma after the fact when, in reality, she would have been wrecked for a long time. A death is one thing. But this was traumatic.
Oh, and on John's 70th birthday. So he was robbed of that day, forever tainted because of Erin's accident. JOHN DID NOT DESERVE THAT. What even?
I also found the courtroom scene to be very cringe. I have never known a custody battle to be solved in twenty minutes. Man, if only they were all like that. I found the conduct of both the judge and Candy's attorney to be very unprofessional. Almost like they both didn't know what they were doing.
Oh, and Amy had a vision of her family in Heaven, so that means that a week, yes, a week after the accident, the Baxter family is back to normal, happy, celebrating John's birthday and a little sad because Erin isn't with them. Yes, I know there were tears there, but it just seemed so... "Oh, well, we had our cry and now we can move on!" type thing. After a week or two.
Poor Amy Elizabeth. Poor John. And poor Erin and her family, who were never really anything more than NPC's or extras in the background to a character we don't even care about. Dayne Matthews.
I will never read this again if I can avoid it.