This is a beautiful book, but if you've seen the series, it doesn't offer a lot of new information. I guess I wanted more of a companion book, where the fact that it's written means you get a different kind of approach and thus different information (the Frontier House book works that way, IMHO). While the writing itself is fine, I don't like the way this book is organized. The lodges are presented roughly by the date their park was established -- Yellowstone first, then Yosemite, etc. -- except for Glacier, which was established in 1910 and so should have been between Crater Lake and Grand Canyon, but instead it's at the end.
But this is a book about the Lodges, about the buildings, not the parks (although of course it has park info). Add in the facts that a lot of the same architects were involved, and the various architects sometimes influenced each other, and that's a problem. Because the book is organized by parks, the book keeps jumping around in time -- the first lodge discussed was built in 1904, then it's 1927, back to 1917, jump to 1937, pull back to 1934... So the story of how the architects influenced each other, and how they moved from the idea that buildings should show man's conquest of nature, to the idea that the buildings should fit into their settings, gets pretty lost. Which I think is a pity.
If this had maps and/or floor plans, I'd still buy it (got it from the library), but as it is, probably not. The pictures are fine, but I'd rather watch the series (Netflix has it) -- much the same info, with many more visuals including establishing shots to get you somewhat oriented. I do plan to track down the author's Great Lodges of the West, which uses the same photographers, to see if it's more logically organized.