This is a fabulous revisionist history of the emergence of football (soccer) that does not fall into the teleological trap of assuming that the way football turned out must have been the way it was intended. Harvey shows several things: that the Football Association only governs the kicking game seems to have come about by the accident of who was able to get to meetings in November and December 1863; that football as we know it only came about because the stronger football culture of Sheffield 'saved' the FA and sacrificed its ways to the southern game, and that the middle class, public school missionaries of football did not take a new game to the masses, but provided working people with a common game that built on and adapted their local versions. The level of detail is likely to put off general readers, but it is detail that is essential to debunk many of the myths and fantasises modern football and of the analysts of the past whose attention to detail and therefore historical rigour is wanting. One of the two or three most significant books in academic studies of football's past. Vital reading.