Thanks to Booksprout for a copy of this ebook and this is my freely given opinion.
This can be read as a standalone novel, and is part of a new spin off series from Inconvenient Brides. HOWEVER, Nina Jarrett has written a richly intertwined world where there are so many connections and relationships between characters in previous novels, that it would add to the experience to read the previous books, to better appreciate some of the context of behaviours by characters here. For example, why the FMC Lily does not imbibe, and Richard was so hostile when discovering his friend may have ruined a young woman he considers under his protection.
Maybe it is because I have been reading this series from the beginning, but I feel very invested in the characters in this series. I have a great fondness for them, having enjoyed their stories before, and enjoy reading more about them, and Ms. Jarrett has a lovely way of building up the characters and their various relationships that really draw me into the story.
In this story, we return to Brendan Ridley, the brother of the Annabel, from book 1, the current Duchess of Halmesbury. He is a young, carefree rake about town, but has been called to heel by the Baron, as his heir. They have a contentious relationship and Brendan has essentially been estranged from him for years, especially considering how the Baron hates to travel. But because of the coronation of the new king, he is coming to town and decides to push Brendan's buttons as to his responsibilities as heir - marriage to an appropriate woman of society for one.
Brendan, to enjoy his one night before having to face the Baron, goes to visit his current mistress, the Lady Slight (seen previously in book 3, My Fair Bluestocking), and ended up passing the night there and dashes out early in the morning, so as not to be late meeting with the Baron. Unfortunately he rushes home to find the bloodied, dead body of the man. He ends up being targeted by the coroner as the murderer, and faces the risk of hanging, with no one willing to attest to his innocence.
Miss Lily Abbot, the cousin of the Countess of Saunton, is in her third season, and trying to avoid being pushed into a hasty marriage by her loving but smothering mother. She wants a love match, being inspired by the connection shared by her cousin and her husband. Because of circumstances, she is part of those who gathered around to comfort family and friends of Brendan after the death of the Baron, and she had witnessed his whereabouts, by chance the night before his murder. However, as an unwed miss, her word alone of what she observed has no weight. She tries to get those more involved to provide a witness alibi as to Brendan's circumstances, but is unsuccessful, and ends up sacrificing her own reputation to provide an alibi. She would not be able to live with herself if she had the ability to save an innocent man from being accused and hung, and did not step up.
Ultimately, she and Brendan are forced to marry because of her ruined reputation, but they still have to deal with the fact that there is a murderer on the loose, and Brendan, and now Lily, through marriage, are potentially in danger as well - as they navigate a new relationship and marriage between strangers. Brendan and Lily both seek to at least be friends, especially finding, after some mis-steps early in their acquaintance, that they like each other, and having the inspiration of the happy relationships around them. But they do have to navigate the dangers they face, as well as other barriers to happiness such as Brendan's previous rakish ways.
Lily is a sweet character; quite optimistic and chattily effervescent. I am a dour old witch at times myself, so at times I wondered if she was just too sweet and chatty - but this was written as almost a defense mechanism for her to detract and distract, and it did not come off as brainless inanity, so it worked for me. Ultimately, she was a brave, principled, honorable woman who was unwilling to stand silently by while an innocent man suffered, and how can you not appreciate that? I enjoyed the greater relationships outside of the love story, and how the family relationships and friendships were portrayed. Well, except for the butler... did not quite get some of the dynamic between the butler and Brendan. Not clear if that was just the butler's personality, Brendan's misconception, or something more at play...
This story is left on a bit of a cliffhanger... while Brendan and Lily find an HEA, there is still the greater mystery of the murder, and motive that are left unfinished.
But, with all the familiar and rather loved characters and their interplay, this felt like a warm, comforting hug to read.
4.5 stars out of 5