I gave this book two stars based on potential. The book had an interesting and original storyline and the idea of this other world was very cool. There were all kinds of maps and diagrams in the beginning and end of the book which I enjoyed looking at. However, this is the end of my praise. I read 100 pages before putting it down with the final thought "almost." It was almost interesting, it almost held my attention, I almost wanted to keep reading. In my mind I kept comparing this book to the Hunger Games, which is maybe unfair, but I feel that series was a well written action packed story which makes it a good comparison and something for writers in this genre to aspire to.
As the daughter of a writer I know how hard it is to get the whole details thing down. I never fully understood the world that the characters live in. There was never a real explanation as to where they are and how this society works - something that I really was missing when the Gars later attack. I couldn't become invested in the characters' lives and I couldn't understand the gravity of their situation since I didn't know who theses people were. I didn't know why they were attacking, what they wanted, or how bad they really were. The main characters left the scene so quickly after the attack began that I didn't know what the Gars did to the city. Burn it to the ground? Take prisoners? For me, I need more details to become invested in the story and want to keep reading. The whole attack took maybe 3 pages and the characters are talking about how they've only been in Trite a week and it feels like a lifetime given the past events. This is a disconnect to me because as the reader it felt like 10 seconds ago they were at home. They left the scene so quick that to me the whole ordeal felt like nothing.
On the flip side, I wanted less detail about the map of Kief's, and the plot line associated with it. It was the main mystery underlying the whole story, but I wasn't allowed to discover what it meant on my own. When Kief discovers there is a professor who studies ancient languages, I can put two and two together and figure out that he should take the map to her to have it translated. Again when the map is translated and the attack on Trite is happening as was depicted on the map, the fun for me as the reader is to figure out that the map predicted this! The joy of discovery is taken away when the author tells you flat out that this is happening. That for me was one of the biggest problems. I think being able to write a good mystery plot, giving away just enough details at the perfect time is an art form, and David Smith just needs to practice with it a little more.
Something that contributed to me not finishing the book, was the elaboration of every sentence of dialogue. Stephen King said you should never have to tell the reader how the character said the line, the words should speak for themselves. This I think is key to being a good writer. I don't want to have to read the dialogue and then be told how the person said it(eg. she squealed, he responded tersely, she persuaded, etc). That takes me away from the story and makes the story move slowly. By the end, i just skipped over everything that came after "____ said".
More somewhat random criticism (if you haven't stopped reading already, sorry David) is the timing of the book. I thought the main characters were eleven or twelve, maybe early teens-then all of a sudden they're in their twenties and going to a college-like academy. I still don't really know if they were always twenty or if the author just skipped ahead without my noticing. And my final bit of what I hope is constructive criticism,is the way the surroundings were described. I don't want to read pages and pages on a single petal of a single flower, but I needed more than what was given. I don't know if it was necessarily the lack of detail, but I just could never wrap my mind around the fact that there were other people in this world. I don't know if they were never mentioned or something but I always had to remind myself that there were other people there. I think that also contributed to that lack of intensity in the attack scene because in my mind all the people in the world made it out of the city unscathed so why is it a big deal that the Gars are coming? I tried to think back to the Hunger Games because I don't specifically remember the author describing lots of people everywhere and what they were doing, and I came to the conclusion that what First Flight was missing was the casual references to the people in the background. Just a minor thing but something else that didn't allow me to really get into the book.
Overall, this book had potential to be a great adventure book, but just missed the mark on too many things for me to continue reading. If you're reading this review and you made it all the way down here, congratulations first and foremost, and secondly I would still recommend that you read this book, I noticed that another first reads winner loved the book, maybe you will too!