Be prepared to suspend belief and have a little fun. For a cat and mystery lover, Clea Simon provides yet another fun romp with the inimitable Dulcie Schwartz, her kitten, Esme and the ghost of her now departed cat, Mr. Grey. Yes, Mr. Grey comes back periodically giving her advice and comfort, instructing Esme as to how a proper young kitten should behave, and even communicating with Dulcie's boyfriend, Chris. Having moved in with him and still living the life of doctoral candidate/thesis writers, Dulcie is still trying to prove that the obscure Gothic novel she has found called, of all things, The Ravages of Umbria, is more than must an 18th century trifle. In the meantime, her friend, Trista, a Victorian specialist is presenting her own thesis and disappears after telling her that she is in trouble and has been accused of murder. Dulcie, of course, tries to track her down. In the meantime, a rare manuscript is missing from the college library. Then the professor who brought the manuscript to the library is murdered....... This is a fun book. You'll need to go with the flow here and suspend belief. However, it's a fun and relaxing read. Besides, who can resist a kitten?