Oh, my--my sisters said this was a calmer, less heart-wrenching book (less so than other books I have lined up, anyway). And they were right, sort of. But they forgot that I love everything German and WWII and Dietrich Bonhoeffer. So yes, this book captured my heart, too.
Setting: Copper Springs, Arizona, 1943. Though this place is physically removed from the war, the action is largely concerned with the war, and the atmosphere is also connected to the worries of the decade. The setting is integral to the plot, since Louisa Schmetterling was a resistance worker who escaped from Germany. Oh, and did I mention that such a setting--WWII, the fight with Germany and the Resistance--is probably my favorite?
Characters: Due to the interesting writing style, the characters were developed a little differently--mainly because of the first person perspective. Because of that, Louisa's faults were slightly slower in developing, and the views of some of the characters were probably more slanted. But, I think, on the whole, that was an advantage in many ways. I think it especially helped with Louisa and William (also, she called him Wilhelm when speaking in German, which I absolutely adored). Also, Louisa herself is a German and is friends with Dietrich Bonhoeffer. I don't need any more reason to like her, although someone without those biased pleasures might find her to be a pushy annoyance. I did wonder how she survived in Germany that long, to say nothing of the Resistance, with that loud mouth of hers. I don't care if it's 1939 or 1943, one gets in trouble for saying such things about Hitler/Germany to anyone in Germany (Hey, look what happens in the U.S. when we question the "experts").
Ahem. End of rant. Next, Robert. I found him charming, mainly because he was so awkward. The balance of his annoyance with Louisa, because of her outspokenness, and his admiration for her was done well. Many of Louisa's blunt opinions of him, especially his sermons (she compared them to Bonhoeffer's!!!) were so good, because they developed the characters of both him and her simultaneously. I thought Robert's actions throughout the book (but particularly at the end) were realistic and endearing, in a strange way.(He was a strange guy. What can I say?)
Aunt Martha Gordon (whom I prefer to call "Tante Marta" <3) was a strange sort, as well, but ultimately good, which of course is the most important thing. I really enjoyed her portrayal: she obviously wasn't perfect, had erroneous notions, and was proud of the Gordon family name. In other words, realistic. The way Louisa was afraid of her was likewise amusing. William was a pretty sweet little boy--mischevious, of course, but that's also necessary to the plot (of course).
Another thing about the characters which I adored, though it's just personal. Everyone had an ethnic heritage. Not just Louisa and Herr Mueller, the Germans (I still think it should be spelled Müller, since he is actually German, not just American with German heritage), but all the others, as well. The Gordons had Scottish ancestry. Rosita was Mexican, and Ada had a Greek husband. Even Peter Marshall's Scottish accent was mentioned. And of course I loved the German phrases occasionally flavoring the dialogue (even when I ranted about the incorrect grammar).
Plot: For a large part of the book, it was pretty mellow. Before the real excitement started, though, I was entertained by William's plotline, which expertly contributed to the action-packed part of the plot, as well. The mellow but deep problems established in the first part of the book didn't give a clue as to how the book would end, and so I was kept guessing, even before the suspense began. As for the conclusion to the book, it was very well done, in my opinion. Nothing was rushed, and everything had sufficient closure.
Faith content: The characters' faith was woven throughout the plot; nothing too ridiculously outlandish, no heavy-handedness, but their faith was far from an afterthought. Robert was a minister, after all, and I enjoyed seeing how the author portrayed him as not a great preacher, but an amazing ambassador for Christ nonetheless. Louisa's spiritual struggle was portrayed as well--hard, but so, so realistic (unfortunately realistic).
If you're like me, I recommend this book 100%. If you don't fall head over heels in love with Dietrich Bonhoeffer and other anti-Nazi Germans during WWII, though, you might still enjoy the book. For readers who enjoy WWII intrigue in remote places, with a romantic element, this is probably a book for them.