Beverley Adams, The Forgotten Tudor Royal Margaret Douglas, Grandmother to King James VI & I, Pen & Sword, Pen & Sword History, 2023.
Thank you, NetGalley, for providing me with this uncorrected proof for review.
I was impressed with Beverley Adams’ ability to assemble a plausible story and character development from a small amount of material in The Rebel Suffragette The Life of Edith Rigby (Pen & Sword History 2021) and Ada Lovelace The World’s First Computer Programmer (Pen & Sword, Pen & Sword History 2023). Unfortunately, The Forgotten Tudor Royal Margaret Douglas does not meet the standard of Adams’ previous work. There is repetition, some awkward phrasing and, more importantly, Margaret Douglas does not shine from the pages as do Edith Rigby, in particular, and Ada Lovelace. Nevertheless, for those interested in Tudor history, this book makes a solid contribution to evoking the period, the ramifications of religious, geographic and personal interests that permeated the finery and theatre of the royal courts of Henry V11, Henry V111, Mary 1, Elizabeth 1 and Mary Queen of Scots. From her birth in 1515 to her death at sixty-two, Margaret Douglas had an important role in the Tudor hierarchy as she matured, grasping opportunities for herself and her children. She achieved her aim, her grandson, James became James V1 of Scotland and James 1 of England.
Adams tells this story well, and Margaret becomes known as more than an aside as Lord Darnley’s mother or Henry V111’s niece. This is a major achievement, highlighting the behaviour of a woman of the period who played an instrumental role in mounting a successful intercession in the royal hierarchy. Portrayal of Margaret’s ambition, foolishness, determination and fall in and out of favour sometimes relies on speculation. However, Adams always make a case for her findings that can meet scrutiny. After all, interpretation is an important part of writing any history, and where a case can be made for an opinion it is worth consideration.
Adams links Margaret’s flight in the late stage of pregnancy with that of her mother, Margaret Tudor’s flight from Scotland when she is also bearing a child – the Margaret who is the main protagonist in this work. However, her mother also is given the place she deserves as more than Henry V111’s older sister and wife of James V. Writing of the strength both women demonstrated in this most unenviable position is an inspired touch – the femaleness of the courage of both women is without doubt established. What wouldn’t each of them stop at to achieve their aims? Together with the acknowledgement that their hearts often ruled their heads, to a foolish and dangerous degree, portraying the way women were instrumental in events of state could not be more graphically depicted.
Beverley Adams has provided a well-researched account of the fortitude of two Tudor women – Margaret Tudor and her daughter Margaret Douglas. She has written an excellent explanation of her reasons for opinions that cannot be supported by documentation. Here Adams demonstrates her understanding of women’s place in the Tudor world, but more than that, the way in which women of this calibre met those challenges. There is a useful bibliography of secondary sources and inline resources. At the end of the book the photos make yet another contribution to making less well-known actors in the period recognisable amongst those that are so familiar.