The gospel promoted by Paul has for many generations stirred passionate debate. That gospel proclaimed equal salvific access to Jews and gentiles alike. But on what basis? In making sense of such a remarkable step forward in religious history, Jason Staples reexamines texts that have proven thoroughly resistant to easy comprehension. He traces Paul's inclusive theology to a hidden strand of thinking in the earlier story of Israel. Postexilic southern Judah, he argues, did not simply appropriate the identity of the fallen northern kingdom of Israel. Instead, Judah maintained a notion of 'Israel' as referring both to the north and the ongoing reality of a broad, pan-Israelite sensibility to which the descendants of both ancient kingdoms belonged. Paul's concomitant belief was that northern Israel's exile meant assimilation among the nations – effectively a people's death – and that its restoration paradoxically required gentile inclusion to resurrect a greater 'Israel' from the dead.
4.5 stars. One of my favorite bib studies reads in a while. Not impeccable but still fresh and very provocative.
I’ve been aware of Staples’ basic view for a while now after noticing and wondering why Paul used specifically Northern Kingdom passages about gentiles. His is an elegant solution that’s hard to “unsee”.
I was pleasantly surprised by his Christological reading of the OT (or at least that he recognized Paul’s Christological reading) and that he saw Deut 30 as about the new covenant.
Sometimes it feels like he argues for traditional views while claiming that he’s not. I don’t mind, since I hold them 😄. It also felt a bit repetitive and meandering. And yet, it ought to be a game changer for the field. I expect some good academic reviews!
I avoid reading Paul Studies as much as I can but could not resist this one, which will almost certainly come to be seen as a pivotal publication in the field. Staples convincingly and elegantly cuts through the Gordian Knot that is Paul's take on Jews, Israel, Gentiles, the Messiah, the Torah, circumcision, supersessionism, and so forth, by going straight for the jugular -- the Paul passages that have most consistently baffled interpreters.
Ironically, though I understand he is breaking new ground in Paul/NT Studies, as a student of the Book of Mormon his thesis seemed rather familiar and almost obvious (in overall thrust, certainly not in textual detail).
Moving forward, this will be my go-to one-book recommendation to anyone wanting to get an accurate and holistic explanation of what on earth (and heaven) Paul was trying to say.
For me, it is always telling when an interpretation of scripture can make verses that have seemed aloof and disconnected suddenly fall right into place. It has been some time since an author was able to do that as Staples does here, and it was a joy to walk through. Needless to say, Staples accomplished his goal of recreating a paradigm that fits Paul's most elusive passages neatly into the puzzle.
Building on the foundation of Jewish restoration eschatology laid out in his first book (The idea of Israel in Second Temple Judaism), Staples looks to the Pauline corpus to see how this framework informs a reading of Paul's letters. Through a close examination of the texts, focusing mostly on Romans, Staples slowly builds up an impressive argument, interacting with other paradigms for reading Paul along the way. The result is a reading of Paul that, while possibly having some misplaced pieces, stands as a strong edifice among today's interpreters, and must be dealt with.
I'm excited to see the discussions this book and it's proposals will open up moving forward. While I'm not yet convinced of everything put forth here, this book is a must read for anyone seeking to understand the apostle to the gentiles, Jew/Christian identity, and the larger biblical narrative.
This book joins the short list of books (A Secular Age, Gulag Archipelago, Kingdom through Covenant, etc.) that really go beyond what I can convey in a review even if I tried. So I won’t try much. My main plea is just that others would read it so we can think together.
I’ve been asking other Christians “if you could sit down with Jesus and have him explain one passage of Scripture to you, what would it be?” For me, that answer is easily the claim in Romans 11 that “all Israel will be saved.” It doesn’t fit within the rest of my theological framework, and the explanations of likeminded individuals have never satisfied me.
I picked up this book because it addresses that question head on. In fact, it addresses five of Paul’s most challenging chapters head on: Romans 1-2 and 9-11.
Staples makes a compelling analogy when describing mainstream readings of Paul. If you were to build a puzzle, complete it, and then observe that five or six pieces remained unplaced, you wouldn’t assume you had the correct image and try to explain those pieces away; you would reconsider the puzzle in its entirety. This is exactly how I have felt about Paul’s “all Israel claim” (as well as his repeated claims that each will be judged according to their works, which Staple’s also addresses).
This book was not long-winded or redundant. It actually required its length to properly put forward its ideas, which is why summarizing them here is an impossible task. Maybe I’ll try?
God promised to save all of Israel. The Northern tribes disobeyed and were assimilated into the nations as a result, becoming “not a people”. The new covenant promises that Israel will be restored and given new obedient hearts so their restoration can be final. When Paul speaks of “Jews” he is speaking of Judahites, which are a subset of all Israel. The Jews are awaiting the restoration of all Israel. Paul’s Gospel has not led to a political restoration AND it is including Gentiles. He writes Romans 9-11 to the Jews to explain to them how this Gospel is actually God’s faithful fulfillment of his promises. In order to save all Israel, he must bring in the nations because a portion of Israel was assimilated into the nations (queue Romans 9 and other verses about their disobedience being used to accomplish His purposes). Furthermore, the true Israel through whom God’s promises are being realized is comprised of those individuals who are given new obedient hearts, which is expounded upon with the grafting/pruning olive branch analogy. So the Church is not a new Israel, nor is it a replacement for Isreal, nor does it have a distinct destiny from Israel; the church IS the Israel which God promised to save from the beginning.
The above explanation is lengthy and only touched on about 10% of the book’s argument.
Overall, I loved reading this book, but it gets four stars for a few reasons:
1. It was removed from discipleship, evangelism, and church life. I know it is meant to be academic, not pastoral, but the two don’t have to be 100% mutually exclusive. I won’t make assumptions about his character or intentions based on his tone or words not said, but this book is not written to stir affections, build up the body, or encourage.
2. I am no scholar, so I could be missing the mark here, but it felt that part of the books conclusion was: God’s salvation of the Gentiles was necessary to accomplish his purposes for Israel. In isolation, I would agree. And if we are strictly expositing Romans 11 maybe we stop there. But I wanted to zoom out a bit further: God’s salvation of Israel was necessary to accomplish his purposes for all people. God’s promise to Man precedes his promise to Israel, and I’d argue that Israel is merely an instrument within the redemptive history of all peoples. Much more can be said here and there are one million nuances, but at certain points in the book, you could parody Staple’s Gospel as: “Good News! God desired to save His People whom he made a covenant with, and in order to do that he had to bring you along”.
3. As usual, I get a little frazzled any time a Christian is making a claim that most other Christians are wrong, and their primary posture is anything but sorrow and urgency. If I were Staples and I believed I was right, I would make the first and last page of the book an all caps and bold plea for readers to pray for all those who are misled. But again, this book is not pastoral. Fine.
Whoof. What a review. If you read this far just go ahead and buy the book or borrow my copy. Then tell me your thoughts.
This is the best book on Paul I have read since Paul and the Gift. I don’t agree with every aspect of interpretation, but this work cuts through several problems in current scholarship in a fresh way and is worth reading and considering.
This is an intense read. But if you want the nitty gritty on what Paul is doing in Romans 1-3 and 9-11 from a Jewish restorationist eschatology perspective, this the book. My main takeaway: we should care about second temple literature because the NT authors read and referenced second temple literature, including Paul.
I am breaking my rule that 5 stars means anybody and everybody should read--this might be a book suited to a particular subset of people--but this was, for me, one of the most stimulating studies of the Bible I've read for a while.
"The preceding unveiling of the mystery has shown that God has by no means rejected his people but has been so faithful as to even incorporate gentiles to facilitate Israel's salvation. Israel's past punishments, including Ephraim's incorporation among the nations, which appeared to be a total and final rejection, has been used to accomplish the very task for which Israel was initially appointed--the redemption and "transformation of the world."
Oh the depths of the riches both of the wisdom and the knowledge of God! How unsearchable are his judgements, and untraceable are his ways! (Rom. 11.33)
Generally speaking, the evangelical views regarding Israel and the church fall into two categories...
The first category might be labeled, Fulfillment Theology (panned as Replacement Theology by its detractors). This view, largely held by Covenant Theologians and Augustinian / Calvinists, contends that the church assumes the place of Israel following the death and resurrection of Christ. Israel ceases to exist as the people of God. The promises made to Israel are now spiritualized and applied to the church as God's new covenant people, made up of former Jews and believing Gentiles. The law is fulfilled in Christ, and serves either as a rule of life for the church, or is abolished and written on the hearts of true believers (depending on your view). Within this camp, there are differing opinions as to what happens to ethnic Israel eschatologically.
The second category might be labeled Dispensationalism. According to Charles Ryrie, the sine qua non of Dispensational Theology includes the understanding that Israel and the church are two distinct programs of God. Many dispensationalists describe the church age as a parenthesis in God's program for Israel. Israel and the church are distinct from one another. Dispensationalism is a moving target, vacillating between the older version which described two means of salvation, a newer version which sees salvation by grace through faith throughout Biblical history, and Progressive Dispensationalism which blurs the lines between Israel and the church, seeking to soften the impact of earlier varieties. All forms of Dispensationalism envision a future for ethnic Israel. The church does not replace Israel, and the unconditional promises of God to Israel are not spiritualized and usurped by the church.
Though I personally cut my teeth on dispensationalism, I have never felt comfortable with Paul's argumentation in Romans 1-2 and 9-11 as seen from either of these perspectives. There seems to be something missing. Paul doesn't argue from either of these presuppositions.
Enter Jason Staples. Building on his earlier work, Staples builds a model for understanding Romans (and the theology of Paul) that, if accurate, is revolutionary. The upshot is that Israel has not been replaced by the church, and the church is not a parenthesis in God's program for Israel. Neither was Paul arguing grace against legalistic Jews attempting to apply Torah to Gentile Christians. Staples' view is something different.
In his book, The Idea of Israel in Second Temple Judaism, Staples differentiates the terms "Jew" and "Israel" as held by postexilic writers including Josephus, highlighting hope for a renewed and restored Israel. In this second volume, Staples maintains the same "restoration eschatology" and applies it to the Apostle Paul. In effect, Paul's underlying concern is that Israel has been lost to the nations, having been relocated and assimilated by the Assyrians. In other words, Israel is dead. But now, by the resurrection of Messiah from the dead, Israel is also resurrected in the form of Gentile converts to Christ. The fulfillment of YHWH's new covenant is found in the ekklesia - which consists of Jews and resurrected Israel (Gentiles in Christ). In Staples' words...
"Death and resurrection is not only the story of Israel's messiah but the story of Israel itself and the vindication of Israel's God. God has sown Israel among the nations in death to be raised in victory." (p.330)
"Paul finds nothing at all wrong in Judaism; instead, he regards the death and resurrection of Jesus and the consequent spiritual transformation of both Jews and gentiles as the fulfillment of the prophetic promises of Israel's restoration." (p.347)
Staples also includes conversation regarding Paul's view of Torah and circumcision as explained by his model. I appreciate the tone of the author, his scholarly approach, and his well-researched, heavily footnoted presentation. His thesis, if followed, solves numerous problems in the interpretation of Romans, and provides a new blueprint for dissecting the conversation surrounding the identity of the church and Israel. What if the church is Jews and Israel, resurrected from among the nations, brought together in Christ, with the law written on hearts, living out the mandate of God to love one another? There is much grist to grind here.
Staples argues that Jew and Israelite are not necessarily referring to the same people. The "Jews" refer to the southern tribe of Judah and "Israel" refers to the non-Judah tribes. In other words, Jews are Israelites, but there are other tribes that are not of the tribe of Judah that are Israelites. By the time we get to Paul's day, the southern tribes had been restored from captivity but the northern tribes hadn't. In addition, the norther tribes of Israel had been assimilated into the nations so that they were essentially gentiles (dead in sin). Paul's letters address the issue here: if the OT prophesied the return of all 12 tribes from exile, how would all Israel be restored? The answer is that the inclusion of the gentiles is God's way of restoring all Israel.
Because Israel's chief issue was ethical failure to keep the covenant, restoration had to entail ethical transformation. Staples leans on this logic to heavily emphasize the giving of the Spirit and double justification. Initial justification is the giving of the Spirit so that Israel is ethically transformed and finally justified on the basis of works wrought by the Spirit (which is a gift of God). Staples seems to then reject imputed righteousness and predestination if I am reading him correctly. He sees both as undermining the ethical transformation that is central to the gospel.
This was a very intriguing book with careful exegesis and interaction with first century literature. I particularly found the main assertion that Paul distinguishes between Jew and Israelite convincing.
There’s good reason Staple's newest book, Paul and the Resurrection of Israel has been showing up everywhere over the last few months, with interviews/spotlights in numerous magazines, podcasts, forums, ect all highlighting the general excitement over its release. It’s interesting, because the book is essentially recasting his body of work in a more cohesive focus on Paul, or Paul’s “Gospel. Which is to say, his work and ideas have been around for while. It seems now it is gaining a firm foothold in the broader field of theological interest.
One of the more brilliant aspects of the book is the way Staples brings together the whole of what is a sprawling and diverse field of new perspective theology. New perspective theology is marked by a renewed interest in Pauline scholarship concerning Paul’s relationship to his Jewish faith as a Jewish man operating within his very Jewish world. When Sanders first awoken the world to the possibility that Christian theology, particularly in the West, had lost sight of important and necessary Jewish conceptions of the anticipated Gospel, this stream of scholarship turned its focus to recovering the Gospel in its Jewish world. This resulted in commonplace definitions of words like Law, Gospel, grace, faith, works, etc being reexamined and recontextualized back into their original setting, which of course opened the door for revisiting the way we tell the Christian narrative. As this movement became popularized, it became commonplace to repeat the adage, the new perspective isn't new, it is a reclamation of the old in a fresh light.
There does exist of course, especially now that it is an established stream within the larger umbrella of Christian scholarship, diversity and disagreement. There is however a defining trait of new perspective that continues to distinguish it from, say, Protestant or Reformed Theology (although there are plenty of protestants who subscribe to the new perspective ). It might be more apt to describe the new perspective as a modern reformation in its own right. What Staples does is locate this defining trait (reading Paul in his world) and uses it to narrow in on a single facet of the discussion- distinguishing between the words Israel and Jew- that not only applies to the whole but that he insists the whole has largely neglected. His premise, on its face, is relatively simple: 1. The terms Jew and Israel mean different things in the Scriptures 2. Scholarship has long fallen into the trap of conflating these terms, and the New Perspective, while unconsciously challenging this conflation of terms, has largely remained unaware that this is where the problem stems from and unable to articulate it in appropriate measure.
In short, when Paul uses the word Israel as a Jewish man, he is participating in a well entrenched tradition of preserving the idea of Israel in the face of the exile. Thus Israel means something much different than Jew, which becomes important for recognizing the ways in which the conflation of terms have allowed assumptions about old versus new, Christian versus Jew, to emerge. It is commonplace within segments of western Christianity to assume that the Gospel proclaims a new revelation that supersedes the old, and to approach the conflicts inherent in the Gospels between Jesus and Jewish leaders as a Christian condemnation of Israel, most commonly expressed through the now age old paradigm of grace/faith versus works. The New Perspective has already deconstructed that paradigm as operating on a wrong conception of Israel’s relationship to the Law, Staples simply digs underneath to give it an even stronger and more articulated foundation.
For a Jew like Paul, exile was synonymous with death. This is what it meant for Paul to speak of the old reality as being dead to sin. Israel had been assimilated into the nations. They had effective ceased to be. For Paul, hope is found in the covenant promise for Israel articulated through the Scriptures and his Tradition. He uses his knowledge of these Scriptures to locate a thread connecting the resurrection of Israel with the hope for the whole of creation, stemming from the phrasing “to or for all nations.” This thread becomes the lens through which he can then make sense of a “dead” Israel, qualified as the northern tribes, effectively functioning as Gentiles, leading to what Paul defines as Gentile inclusion. Thus when we get to the words of Paul referencing Jews and Gentiles, the key lies in recognizing how Paul’s operative concern is for the idea of Israel. The story of Israel. He’s not bouncing around from Israel to Gentile, he’s conceiving of how Jesus works into the Jew-Israel problem. A Jew is the only surviving tribe of Israel, and yet the covenant hinges on Israel’s resurrection, by which it means the whole. Israel has died and is now Gentile, being assimilated into the nations. Thus for Israel’s resurrection to happen requires “Gentile inclusion.” For Paul, this is perfectly in line with his Jewish expectations, as for him the resurrection of Israel was always for the world, or for all nations, thus Jesus, as the fulfillment of the covenant, marks the beginning of this new creation mandate by bringing together both the restoration of Biblical Israel and its movement into all the nations (Abrahamic promise).
Not coincidentally, this also becomes the point where we can easily see and locate how conflating these two terms has led to some problematic tendencies and places, even when it comes to the unintentional glossing over (Staples calls it the fly over approach) of passages that simply never fit popularized understandings of an imposed grace/faith-works/Law divide and conflict. Simply put, these terms have been wrongly defined using a narrative born from the catholic-protestant conflict rather than hearing them in their own second temple context. That second temple context comes fully alive when we recover the distinction between Israel and Jew and the narrative this belongs to.
The book is diligently researched and argued. It expresses itself as a monumental turn in not just theological focus but scholarly concern, not just in what it brings to the overall shape and trajectory of new perspective scholarship/theology but in how it how it establishes a fresh stream of focus and concern. Certainly one of the more important and definitive works to release in a while concerning Pauline studies.
Though I still need to process some elements, my initial reaction to Staples' book is that it is going to rework my understanding of Romans 1-2 and 9-11.
The argument here is that Paul essentially holds to a fairly common restorationist eschatology but with some unique wrinkles. In particular he argues that Paul saw Israel (northern tribes) has having been made into gentiles by virtue of their exile, which had no return that might correspond with Judah's. God's restoration of Israel therefore requires the restoration of all nations. So, when NT authors (Paul in particular) preach and teach about gentile inclusion, it is not a new arbitrary idea that God has suddenly had, but rather a part of a grander plan to "restore the kingdom to Israel" (Acts 1:6) and to bless the nations per his promise to Abraham.
This basic summary is laid out in extensive, often technical, detail. I found Staples quite convincing.
Lots to chew on here! This book may be one of the most important contributions to Pauline theology in quite some time. While there are things I would disagree with Staples on, there is much value to be gleaned from this volume. One of the most helpful points that Staples makes is that when Paul refers to “Jews” in his letters, as is consistent with the cultural context, he is referring to those from the tribe of Judah, not the twelve tribes.
What we see play out is that Gentiles are incorporated into Israel and are grafted in. Those who were once alienated from the covenants of promise have been brought near. Not only that, but he points out that the return of Judah did not complete the restoration. Gentiles are part of Israel's restoration.
Paradigm-shifting! In this book, scholar Jason Staples takes you on a deep dive into Paul’s letter to the Romans, in what is arguably the most difficult passages in his corpus (Romans 2 and 9-11). Staples’ premise of Jews being a smaller subset within a larger group “Israel”, sets up his larger argument for a “restorationist eschatology” framework, where Paul looks towards God’s promise to restore the 12 tribes of Israel through the death and resurrection of the Messiah, Jesus. Within this framework, Staples does an amazing job of unveiling the “mystery” of the gospel, where the New Covenant promises made to Israel are now being fulfilled in Spirit-filled gentiles. Grappling with the heavy-hitters of modern day interpreters of Paul, and interweaving his arguments with a milieu of sources from the 2nd Temple period, what Staples accomplishes is nothing short of groundbreaking and monumental, as his work is sure to have rippling effects in generations to come. I came away in awe of God’s plan for salvation towards Israel and the nations, as His love and mercy extends beyond our wildest imaginations and blows past our small view of His wisdom and His eternal purpose towards His people. I thank God for Jason Staples and hope the body of Christ grows more fully into the identity Paul argues for, as the ekklesia of YHWH, where both Jew and Gentile are one, under Israel’s Messiah Jesus.
Staples' book is an extremely thought-provoking read and worthwhile for anyone interested in the theology surrounding Gentiles being included in the salvation plan. Staples offers a new perspective that I had never encountered before, but he relies on the biblical texts, as well as references extra-biblical texts and current scholarship, to support what he has to say. Although not written for the layperson, anyone with solid biblical literacy should be able read this book without too much difficulty as its written clearly and logically. I would highly recommend it.
This is an extremely important book. The word “groundbreaking” is rightly applied to it. It breaks new ground when it comes to understanding Romans 9-11 and any future treatments of that passage must grapple with its contents.
There are few books that help me understand the entire biblical storyline better, but this is one of them. Though there are numerous disagreements I had throughout, they are small in comparison to the major thesis of the book, of which Staples has persuaded me.
The first crucial argument is that Jews, Gentiles, and Israel(ites) are 3 distinct categories. Staples made this argument in his book "The Idea of Israel in Second Temple Judaism" which he summarizes in chapter 1 of this book, which is the sequel. Contrary to seeing Jews and Israel(ites) as functionally synonymous, Staples argues that "Jews" (Ioudaios) refer to the people of Israel who are of the region of Judea, either by genealogical descent or by conversion. They are a part of Israel, but it is a mistake to conclude that they are synonymous with Israel. In fact, they are a subset of Israel. "Israel" or "Israelites," on the other hand, refer to one of 3 things: (1) [In the NT] the people of God from of old, (2) the northern kingdom and its tribes, or (3) the entire people of God.
Acceptance of the above distinction will automatically change the way one reads numerous passages of both the Old and New Testaments. Staples' book focuses primarily on what have been traditionally the most difficult passages in Romans, chapters 2 and 9–11. His main argument is that, by understanding the above distinction, one can then see that all of Paul's gospel is concerned with Israel's salvation (all Israel), which is itself concerned in large part with vindicating God's faithfulness to his people. The argument goes:
After the northern kingdom is exiled by the Assyrians, they are effectively gentalized, losing their status as God's people (think "not my people" in Hosea). Thus, the return from exile we see toward the latter part of the Old Testament is not a return of Israel, but a return of Judahites (Jews). For this reason, the return from exile promised in the prophets had not yet happened (and, as Staples demonstrates, none of the Jews thought it had at this time). God had still not united the stick of Ephraim with the stick of Judah. Going into the New Testament, then, we have a returned Jewish population but a still exiled Israel (both in terms of the northern tribes and in terms of "all Israel").
Paul's gospel, facing this reality, is thus a gospel of restoration eschatology, or, put differently, a gospel of salvation for Israel that includes the Gentiles. In Romans, he explains the mystery of Israel, that, because the northern tribes have been cut off and gentalized, this has not shortened the arm of the Lord. Rather, their gentalization has effectively guaranteed the ingathering of the gentiles in the restoration as well as Ephraim, such that Ephraim, whose "offspring shall become a multitude of nations" (Gen. 48:19) comes to include these Gentiles. Thus, Gentile incorporation is not only included in Israel's salvation, it is a necessary element in Israel's salvation.
This is the main argument in the book, but I must note Staples' exegesis of Rom 9:22–24. He argues that this passage refers not to eternal election and reprobation, but to God's work in producing vessels of wrath (temporarily cut off Israelites) shaped (not necessarily permanently!) for destruction, so that God might make known the riches of his glory for vessels of mercy (all Israel). Thus, the passage effectively illustrates his larger argument. The vessels of wrath are vessels which have reshaped by the potter according to his purposes, but they have not (yet) hardened, and so Paul still holds out hope that he might "win some," and even sees the influx of the Gentiles as paradoxical proof that God is accomplishing his promises toward Israel.
This is a very stimulating book. I expect this book will find itself in many scholarly discussions in the future.
I first heard Jason Staples interviewed on the “On Script” podcast and was sufficiently intrigued to purchase the book. And it did not disappoint.
Ever since I did an independent research project in undergrad on the people of God (35 years ago!), I have wrestled with the notion of how the promises to Israel are to be understood—especially since the northern kingdom was subject to the Assyrian policy of mixing conquered peoples. What percentage of one’s lineage is required to be part of Israel? Finally, in Staples compelling study, did I encounter someone whose study explores this question—and so much more! What you encounter in this work is, in a word: brilliant. Staples’ provocative thesis and groundbreaking, careful argument is long overdue in the endless debates about Paul and his teachings about Israel and the church.
As compelling as he is meticulous, Staples advances an understanding of Romans 1-3 and 9-11 rooted in extensive intertextuality.
Staples builds his case on two primary points: (1) Restoration Theology, drawing from Deuteronomy, Jeremiah, Ezekiel and multiple other passages that point consistently to the fact that the Torah itself necessitates God’s intervention to renew his people by circumcising their hearts, pouring out his Spirit, and inscribing Torah on their hearts so that they are able to fulfill the heart of Torah itself: loving God and loving neighbours—as Jesus himself summarized. (2) There is a distinction that needs to be maintained between Jew/Jewish and Israel (this point builds on his earlier substantial work, The Idea of Israel in Second Temple Judaism, which is now on my “to read” list).
Staples contends that ‘works of the Law’ could never fix or restore the covenant. It was broken even before Moses stepped down from Sinai. Only God, acting to renew his people, can bring about renewal and restoration. The outpouring of the Spirit brought about through the death and resurrection of Jesus indicates that this restoration is happening. The influx of Gentiles, then, becomes the question on the table–not the lack of belief among Jews (when Paul wrote Romans the church has as many Jewish believers as Gentile). Staples bold analysis of how Paul answers this question through his careful reading Romans (with its extensive connectivity to the TNK and echoes of other intertestamental literature) is provocative and, in my estimation, compelling.
Be prepared to dig into the Scripture in both Greek and Hebrew, and to be deeply challenged. You may not agree with every interpretive decision made by Staples, but in the end, his presentation of the faithfulness of God to his promises to Israel is a profound step forward in Pauline studies. I am eager to see how this work is received through peer review.
It is cool to see after nine ratings every reader has rated this book five stars (it really is that good). After reading this book I may have to revisit my earlier opinion that Paul is inconsistent, especially about the law. Staples portrays Paul as thoroughly Jewish for whom the redemption of Israel was always foremost in his thought. For Paul, rather than the gentiles replacing Israel as God's chosen people, non-Israelites were grafted into the olive tree of Israel (cf. Jeremiah 11.16, Hosea 14.6). By this process they become ethnic Israelites and former gentiles (cf. 1 Corinthians 12.2).
I said I *may* have to revisit because I am not thoroughly convinced on every point. For example, on the question of the difference between Jew and Israelite I am not convinced that there was as much of a distinction between the two in this period as Staples claims there was. He appeals to Josephus quite a bit to prove his point, but Josephus was a historian who would have been more aware of the historical difference between Jew and Israelite than the average writer of this period. Staples claims that Philo also recognized this distinction, and I wish he had provided examples. Perhaps it is most likely that by this period Jew and Israelite were becoming synonymous (and Staples acknowledges that there is a lot of overlap between the two terms), but their becoming full synonyms had to await a later age.
De discussies over de positie van Israël ten opzichte van de kerk, of andersom, krijgen in mijn ervaring zelden echt diepgang. Er worden wat losse teksten genoemd, wie een verkeerde uitdrukking gebruikt is ineens gepromoveerd tot vervangingstheoloog of wie teksten te letterlijk neemt is een chiliast. Dat schiet niet op.
Een grondigere, maar ook gedurfde bespreking van deze relatie vond ik bij Jason A. Staples (niet te verwarren met Jason Arday). Zijn boek Paul and the Resurrection of Israel biedt wel iets meer dan dat, maar in ieder geval niet minder. Waar het hem ook niet aan ontbreekt is zelfvertrouwen. Het is wellicht gewoon Amerikaans, maar vaker dan prettig lees je dat de meeste exegeten en Paulusdeskundigen iets missen wat hij wél ziet. Of dat écht zo is, kan ik niet geheel beoordelen, maar het irriteert op een gegeven moment wel.
Niettemin biedt Staples inzichten die overwegen waard zijn. Bij het lezen van het Nieuwe Testament zijn we geneigd ‘de joden’ en 'Israël' als min of meer synoniem te zien, of in ieder geval dat eerste als datgene wat van het tweede over is. Maar in Koningen, Kronieken en diverse oudtestamentische profeten zoals Ezechiël en Hosea zijn deze duidelijk onderscheiden als het twee- en tienstammenrijk. Het tienstammenrijk zijn is verdwenen, weggevoerd naar Assyrië en compleet geassimileerd. Het is niet teruggekeerd. Het tweestammenrijk, Juda, Benjamin en een deel van de Levieten, is weggevoerd naar Babel en slechts gedeeltelijk teruggekeerd als ‘de joden’.
Jason stelt dat in de ervaring van veel tijdgenoten van Paulus de ballingschap, de tijd van de toorn van God, daarom nooit echt voorbij was gegaan (p.58). De belofte is immers dat God beide huizen van Israël zou verenigen (Bijv. in Hosea, Ezechiël). Wat nu als de christenen uit de heidenen moeten worden begrepen als toevoeging in plaats van ontrouwe Israëlieten, het verdwenen tienstammenrijk. Ontrouw Israël is immers als het ware gezaaid onder de heidenen, tot niet-mijn-volk geworden (p.285). Het gaat er niet om of zij letterlijk van die verloren stammen afstammen (p.316), maar dat God nu de heidenen ontvangt op dezelfde wijze als ware zij de stammen aan wie de verlossing beloofd was. Allen die uit het geloof zijn, zijn immers Abraham nageslacht, want er is geen onderscheid. Samen met de gelovige Joden vormen zij ‘heel Israël', dat zalig wordt. Dát is niets anders dan leven uit de doden, waar de profeten van getuigt hebben (juist in het kader van die hereniging). Paulus ook nog moed voor zijn medejoden, zijn broeders naar het vlees (p.301). Net als dat ontrouw Efraïm is afgebroken, maar terugkeert naar Gods gunst in vorm van heidenen, zo kunnen ook zijn broeders, als zij niet ongelovig blijven, terugkeren en weer ingevoegd worden in de olijfboom. Jason gelooft dus niet in een massabekering van de joden naar het vlees (p. 304). De nadruk van Paulus is dat héél Israël van het nieuwe verbond bestaat uit joden (uit twee stammen) en uit heidenen, ofwel Efraïm. Dat hele Israël wordt zalig. Het is eigenlijk een soort partiële vervangingsleer.
Een groot voordeel van deze visie is dat het toelaten van de heidenen aan de christengemeente nu logischer samenhangt met het nieuwe verbond, waarbij het altijd al ging om het verzoenen van Juda en Israël. Ook biedt het een antwoord op de vraag hoe God deze belofte ooit nog kan vervullen. Meer dan in Paulus’ tijd moet toch de kwestie ons kwellen waar die tien stammen gebleven zijn, als je Ez. 36 (bijvoorbeeld) graag letterlijk wilt lezen.
Jason stelt dat als iemand gelooft (jjood en heiden) hij tot Israël behoort. De bekeerde heidenen zijn ethisch Israëlieten omdat de Thora in hun hart geschreven is en hoeven dus niet etnisch Israël te worden (p.316). Andersom, etnische Israëlieten die wie niet trouw zijn, worden afgesneden en tot niet-Gods-volk (Hosea). Zo bezien zit Staples opmerkelijk dicht bij het oude reformatorische idee dat de Kerk er vanaf Adam geweest is, en altijd de ware gelovigen heeft bestaan (V&A 54 HC). Alleen, a) Jason noemt dat niet De Kerk, maar Israël. en b) Hij maakt het dynamischer, doordat God trouw is aan Israël als geheel dóór de ontrouwe Israëlieten af te snijden (meer dan dat zij er überhaupt nooit bij hoorden) en anderen toe te voegen.
Jason denkt over Gods trouw, rechtvaardiging en verkiezing minder individualistisch. Dat weer heel anders dan de reformatorische lezing. Het is volgens hem niet zo dat Paulus zelf als een soort Luther met een gekweld geweten liep in Romeinen 5-7. Of dat Paulus streedt tegen wetticisme waarbij men als individu rechtvaardig zou proberen te worden voor God. Het zou hem gaan om de vraag of Israël als volk rechtvaardig moest wórden voor God alvorens de Messias kon komen, of dat de Messias zelf het volk (en heidenen) tot rechtvaardigheid zou brengen (p.86-90). Paulus pleit dan sterk voor het laatste. Dat zou de Messias doen door de Geest te geven, die de wet van God in ons hart schrijft. Het onderscheid tussen rechtvaardigmaking en heiligmaking lijkt hiermee wel te vallen. Anderzijds, Staples richt zich primair op de exegese van Paulus, niet op dogmatiek. Toch zijn dit geen losse eilandjes. Is Staples’ voorstel over de visie Israel-kerk los te peuteren van deze elementen?
Voorlopige conclusies: Staples heeft een consistente uitleg en toepassing voor de beloofde verzoening en hereniging van Juda en Israël; Terecht is Staples waarschuwing tegen een té individueel lezen van Paulus. Gods trouw aan Israël betekent niet dat iedere jood zalig wordt, of één hele generatie; Staples’ lijn doortrekkend betekent dit dat God altijd een volk trouw blijft dat ethisch Israël mag heten, en uit zowel (etnisch én ethisch?) joden als so-called Efraïm bestaat. Maar is dat eerste écht nodig als je Israël al ethisch gedefinieerd hebt? Is Israël dan niet een vaag concept geworden, dat losgeweekt wordt van een concreet land? Jasin voorstel maakt ook niet duidelijk hoe trouw van de Messias, de dood van Christus, ons nu volgens Paulus redt. Verzoening door voldoening lijkt geen rol te spelen. Het is vooral het feit dat Jezus ons Zijn Geest geeft die ons tot trouwe ‘Israëlieten’ maakt; Ook is het niet zo helder waar de refomatoriche soteriologie wel helder is. Hoe wordt ik als individu zalig? Doordat de Geest de wet in mijn hart schrijft? Maar hoe weet ik of ik het dan écht beter doe dan ontrouw Israël, die uitgeworpen zijn?
I may be biased here, the author is my brother-in-law, but this book is a masterpiece and one that will impact scholarship, Christian thought, and Biblical interpretation for years to come. Jason Staples looks at Romans 1-2 and 9-11 and considers Paul’s argument in light of Hebrew scripture prophecies and second temple period texts. It’s a thesis I guarantee you’ve never come across elsewhere but one that ties the entire Bible together wondrously. I’m in awe.
Reading Paul as an ancient Jew, and not one of our tribe Understanding that Israel encompasses all of the tribes The problem with the law is that we don't keep it Implanted on our hearts is where we need it The wrath of God revealed, not just against the gentiles But Israel herself has gone astray and proven hostile Torah can't bring justice, but God himself sure does Messiah make us righteous and empowers us to love Israel is proven unfaithful, but God remains true An unexpected salvation encompassing Gentiles too Israel is cast away into the sea of the nations God brings them back in via Gentile salvation This is the Messiah's work, the only faithful one Israel pursues Torah vainly, because it's already been done But all who trust in hum and pledge their loyalty Are sons by the Holy Spirit and heirs of royalty
This book is a goldmine of exegesis and Pauline theology. The tracing of Paul's argument for Gentile inclusion as the means of restoring the still-yet-in-exile tribes of Israel is rock solid, but there is so much more in here worth chewing on. Whether or not you end up accepting everything he's laying down, you have to come to terms with his detailed exegesis and coherent analytics of Paul's thought.
Key Themes Common Knowledge in Pauline Letters Paul's letters are dense and rely on shared knowledge that many modern readers lack. This can obscure the original meaning and intent behind Paul's arguments.
Modern Interpretations of Paul's Message Staples critiques the modern tendency to view Paul through contemporary lenses. He argues that interpreting Paul's gospel as focusing on inclusiveness and opposing racism reflects modern Western values rather than Paul's original context. This approach can unintentionally reinforce anti-Jewish sentiments by casting Paul as a champion of modern liberal values against a supposedly regressive Jewish particularism.
Defining Israel Staples discusses the challenge of defining who constitutes Israel. Terms like "ethnic" or "empirical" Israel are inadequate and fail to capture the issue's complexity. The distinction between Jews and Israelites is nuanced, as shown by historical and current debates within Jewish communities.
Jews vs. Israelites During the Second Temple period, a distinction existed between Jews (Ioudaioi) and Israelites. Staples notes that "Jews" typically referred to people from Judah, while "Israel" included the broader identity of the northern tribes. This distinction appears in various contexts, such as cultic or eschatological settings, where "Israel" is used to refer to the collective people, including non-Jewish northern tribes.
Significance of the Exile The exile continued even after the return from Babylon. Staples cites the book of Daniel, which suggests that Israel's true redemption is still in the future with the arrival of an "anointed one." This perspective highlights the ongoing nature of Israel's exile and the anticipation of future restoration.
Paul's Approach to the Torah and New Covenant Paul is not "law-free" but advocates for a "law-implanted" approach. He argues that true obedience to God requires a new heart and the indwelling of the sacred spirit, as promised in the new covenant. This transformation enables followers of the resurrected Messiah to genuinely fulfill the Torah's requirements. Staples highlights Paul's use of the distinction between the "letter" and the "Spirit" in 2 Corinthians 3, drawing parallels between Moses and Jesus as mediators of God's promises.
Paul's Inclusive Message Paul's message of inclusiveness is controversial because it extends the restoration promises to uncircumcised Gentiles who receive the spirit and become equal members of restored Israel. This inclusion challenges traditional boundaries and redefines the concept of Israel to encompass all transformed by the spirit.
Exile and Death In ancient Mediterranean thought, exile and death were seen as equivalent, with exile often leading to death. This idea is evident in biblical narratives like the banishment of Adam and Eve from Eden and Cain's punishment after killing Abel. Staples connects this concept to Paul's argument that followers of the Messiah pass from under the Torah through death and resurrection, moving from an age of wrath to an age of favor.
Transformative Justification Staples emphasizes that Paul's view of justification is transformative. God does not change the standard of judgment but changes the person through the spirit, enabling them to fulfill the Torah's requirements. This transformation is necessary for a person to be judged as righteous. Staples argues that this transformative view of justification is central to Paul's message and differs from later Protestant interpretations that emphasize forensic declaration over transformation.
Israel and the Nations Staples highlights the interconnectedness of Israel and the nations in Paul's theology. He argues that Israel's insensibility leads to mercy for the Gentiles, which in turn facilitates Israel's redemption. This reciprocal relationship fulfills the promise of blessings for all nations through Israel's restoration.
Role of the Messiah Staples outlines various perspectives on the coming of the Messiah within Jewish tradition. Paul combines these views, suggesting that the Messiah came at the appointed time for an apostate people, bringing justification and repentance through his death and resurrection. The Messiah will return when Israel has been fully transformed by the spirit, fulfilling the eschatological promises.
Final Restoration Staples explains that Israel's destruction and dispersion among the nations are part of God's hidden plan for vindication and victory. By incorporating Israel into the nations, God extends his claim to all peoples. This cosmic drama underscores the mystery of Israel's salvation and the ultimate restoration of all things through the Messiah.
I am rethinking everything I thought I knew about Rom 9-11. Staples does an exceptional job at reexamining long held beliefs, asking the right questions, and discovering the answers from their original context. Staples primary finding is that at least from Second Temple Judaism and onward, Jews did not use the term “Israel” except in eschatological contexts or in reference to those Israelites who were exiled by the Assyrians and later dissolved into the gentiles. From there, Staples makes connections throughout Romans 2 and 9-11 and how this changes the way we should understand how “all Israel will be saved.” On top of this, and this is a personal preference, I thoroughly appreciated how at the beginning of every chapter or even chapter divisions Staples would recount what had been discussed to that point. That is incredibly helpful in a book dealing with, at times, dense material. I know when I’m reading books like this, it will often be two or three days before I can come back to it so it was helpful having that to keep me engaged.
Really interesting book. His view of justification is basically Roman Catholic, and he believes that Paul is “within Judaism,” and thus he says that there was nothing wrong with Judaism per se. However, he also only defines Judaism by what he sees as its main tenets - restoration eschatology, the special covenant status of Jews, and the importance of the Old Testament. Thus, he is much closer to a traditional reading of Paul than one that is in the “within Judaism” camp. He has a few niche positions on certain texts, but they are somewhat persuasive. The book is really on Romans 9-11, and his stuff on Romans 9-11 is fascinating. I recommend people read the book for that reason alone.
My overall impression of this book is that it is hands down, one of the best treatises on Paul and the book of Romans, and the understanding of the terms Paul uses in the proper context. Staples has done a marvelous job of shedding light on old scholarship errors, and uses detailed analysis to show the correct understanding of the text. My only real critiques are primarily very minor ones regarding language and translation. In particular, the way Staples defines or uses certain updated terms in place of “traditional” interpretations. For instance, I feel his use of “fidelity” instead of “faith” or “trust” is needlessly complicating the translation. The traditional translation into faith/trust rarely poses an encumbrance to understanding the text, nor is it incongruent with the context, and insisting on using less familiar terms (in these contexts) like “fidelity” only serves to distract from the message of the text rather than truly improving on its meaning. Similarly, he decided to use “Messiah” instead of “Christ,” which in the New Testament Greek context, is both unnecessary and technically not true to the language translation. And as before, substituting the less familiar phrase “Jesus Messiah” instead of the traditional translation of “Jesus Christ” only serves to distract from the message of both the biblical text and Staples’ work. It’s not that it’s grossly incorrect or anything, it’s simply unnecessary and not really helpful, granted these are very minor critiques.
One of my primary language critiques is with Staples’s handling of the Greek Ioudaios. I don’t entirely disagree with him, and for the most part I think he handles it quite well, but sometimes I do think he is unnecessarily complicating the translation issues more than they already are. It’s certainly true that it’s not a black and white issue. Using the term “Jew” is also without a doubt a bit anachronistic, and yet it’s almost necessary in certain scenarios given the complex context in which our translation of the word Ioudaios is mired in. However, Staples approaches this translation from perhaps a little too much purely linguistic perspective and perhaps not enough of the historical perspective. When we combine the linguistic and historical perspectives and place them into the context of the scriptures, not overlooking the nuance for sake of being super technical, a more defined gradient appears. Ultimately, we’re left with three primary translations for Ioudaios: Judahite, Judean, and Jew. And these find a much clearer delineation when you realize their context within Ethnicity, Nationality/Culture, and Religion respectively. For example, when we see the word Ioudaios used in the context of ethnicity, as in those who are genetically descended from the tribe of Judah, the best translation is likely going to be Judahite in most of those cases. An important thing to note here is that a follower of the religion of Judaism who is not descended from the tribe of Judah, cannot be a Judahite. Their relationship to Ioudaios would be religious (one belonging to Judaism), and this is an example of where it would be most proper to translate Ioudaios using the somewhat anachronistic term “Jew” (or “Jewish).”
This is especially important in Hellenistic Judea, because after the forced mass conversions to Judaism by both the Hasmonean and Idumaean dynasties, most of the “Jews” in 1st century Judea were NOT Judahites descended from the tribe of Judah (nor even Israelites), but were largely converted Idumaeans and Canaanites. In this context, these converts would be “Jews” as in, followers of Judaism, but NOT Judahites, as in descendants of Judah, but they would also be Judeans as residents of Judea. Paul was well aware of this (as was Jesus), which is why he specifically mentions those who were called “Jews” but were NOT Judahites in Romans 2:17; “But if you are called a Jew and rely on the Law and boast in God.” This is evident through the rest of chapter 2 as Paul addresses the religious laws perspective of Ioudaios. And depending on where any addressed Ioudaios actually lived, they could also be called Judeans. This is one example of how there can be significant overlap. It is entirely possible that the subject of the word Ioudaios in any given passage, could simultaneously be a descendant of Judah (Judahite), who also is a follower of Judaism (Jew), who also lives in Judea (Judean). So how do we translate Ioudaios then? Context is our best hope. Is the passage dealing with religious law matters of Judaism or the Pharisaic laws? Then the broadest term “Jew/Jewish” may make the most sense. Is the passage in relation to descendant covenants, promises, or physical “seed” of Judah/Israel? Then the term “Judahite” makes more sense. Is it used more ambiguously, or near other contextual terms implying a cultural or nationality perspective (such as the “neither Jew nor Greek” phrases)? Then the term “Judean” is likely the most sensible. And in some cases, more than one of the (or all three) translations is applicable, and given that “Jew” is the broadest, it might be the most sensible in such cases, unless a clear link to Judah or physical descent is evident. So I do sympathize with Staples’s treading delicately on translating this term, but I personally believe it can be a little clearer than he has made it out to be, while at the same time I fully admit it’s no simple task. Does it mean I think all instances of Ioudaios can be definitively translated one way or the other? No, no such luck. But it does mean we can translate many instances, if not most, a little more definitively and get a very logical, context based, readable text.
Alongside this Ioudaios term difficulty, I think Staples is perhaps missing the chance to add some important context, particularly historical understanding, regarding the term “gentile.” The truth is that it’s a poor term to use in English. It’s really just a transliteration of the Latin word, gentilis, which, like the Greek ethnos, simply means a people or nation(s). The manner in which it later became completely synonymous with “non-Jew” was largely a post 2nd Temple period accretion. Prior to that it had much more fluidity to being used as simply “people,” “nations,” or even “pagans” in the common parlance, and was only occasionally used as an almost pejorative-like term to mean “non-Jew” by the priest/rabbi class within Judaism. In truth, the term gentilis should not have been transliterated, but should have been translated into “nation(s).” But by making the transliterated version a new word, “gentile” grew into something it was never intended to be. Part of the issue is in properly tracing the historical populations of the nations, the ethnos/gentilis, and Israel’s (the northern kingdom) migrations. For that, we go back to the Assyrian captivity of Israel. When Assyria conquered Israel, massive numbers of the northern Kingdom fled north and then westward, settling on the way along the Phoenician coast, along the Caucasus Mountains, and around the Mediterranean in the places we now know as Cyprus, Tarsus, Miletus, Sardis, Rome, Athens, Galatia, Corinth, and as far as Gaul and Iberia, with some groups even settling as far as the Germanic lands and British Isles. These groups, comprising most of the northern kingdom of Israel (the famed “10 lost tribes”), essentially disappeared into other ethnos/nations and lands, and for all intents and purposes BECAME the ethnos/gentilis. And Staples does correctly touch on this in a clear and understandable manner.
He rightly points out that this massive conquering and migration event caused the Israelites of the northern kingdom to become indistinguishable from the ethnos/gentilis whom they settled among, even founding cities. Many interpreters take the position that these people were still distinct but “lost” their ethnic status along with their covenant status, making them only “like” the “gentiles” in nature, but not really “gentiles.” However, historical and textual evidence reveals that they in fact WERE the “gentiles,” more properly understood as the ethnos/gentilis, aka nations. When Paul is addressing the non-Jewish (both non-Judaism and non-Judahite) nations, or “gentiles,” this is very often who he is speaking to. When he writes to the Corinthians, the Romans, or the Galatians, this is the people to whom he is writing – those innumerable descendants of the Hebrew Israelite ethnos/gentilis who settled among and “became” the nations (Gen 15:5; 17:1-7; 26:4), aka the “Gentiles.” When this is understood, the overwhelming majority of Paul’s preaching and theological arguments start to make far more sense. Suddenly his comparison of the “Jews” (Judahites) and the “Gentiles” (nations [ethnos] of Israelites) in regard to ethnicity/seed, covenantal, Torah, and salvific issues makes sense, just as realizing that his comparisons of “Jews” (Judeans) and Greeks, in regard to nationality and/or cultural issues makes more sense. And Staples does a great job covering how Paul’s theology essentially creates an ethnic adoption through Christ, not only bringing those scattered and assimilated gentile Israelites back, but literally ethnically transforming the non-Israelite gentiles with them who also accept Christ as Messiah, into Israelites themselves (see the olive tree discussion). I just felt that sometimes, Staples’ use of the word gentile(s) got in the way more than it helped.
Interestingly enough, even if we accept the term “Gentile” and accept that it means “non-Jew,” then one must also accept the conclusion that the Israelites, the northern kingdom (10 tribes) of Israel, are in fact gentiles because a “Jew” in the ethnic sense as a people group, can only be a descendant of the tribe of Judah, from the southern kingdom. The English term “Jew” is the short form of the term Judah/Judahite (which comes from the Hebrew Yehuda), and was explicitly of an ethnic nature until the birth of Babylonian Judaism which then broadened “Jew” to include not just Judahites (the ethnic perspective), but anyone who adhered to Judaism (the religious perspective), all of which Staples rightly points out. So we can see that either way, the Israelites (Northern kingdom) are in fact the ethnos/gentiles, and when Jesus said he came only for the lost sheep of the House of Israel, he was speaking of gentiles, not the Jews/Judahites.
Ultimately, if one can grasp and follow the complex, but navigable translation issues surrounding Ioudaios with Judahite/Jew/Judean and Ethnos/Gentilis with nations/people over the term “gentiles,” the works of Paul regarding the entire Israel/Gentile/Jew/Judah/Nations issue begins to work itself out in quite a comprehensive and cohesive tapestry for Paul’s theological corpus. And I must give credit to Mr. Staples because despite my very minor criticisms here, he actually did a phenomenal job navigating these cumbersome words/phrases and piecing together a very coherent theology of Paul which many scholars before have struggled with. In my opinion however, before reading this excellent work by Staples, which is definitely a more academic read, I would recommend reading at least two of these three (if not all three) less academic books to establish a good foundation for understanding this Jew/Gentile/Israelite issue a little better:
The Mystery of the Gentiles by Ted Weiland
Israel’s Tribes Today by Steven M. Collins
God’s Covenant People by Ted Weiland
Taken together, reading these books as a primer before reading Staples’ more academic book, will be a fascinating 4 book trek through the history and theology of Israel, Judah, the “Gentiles” and an exploration of Paul’s rather advanced teaching and theology involving these groups. I highly recommend all four, and needless to say, I’m a new fan of Jason Staples’ work.
Really excellent work that is clarifying on a number of fronts. The concept of "restoration eschatology" is valuable to reframe the post new perspective discussion, a number of OT-in-the-NT puzzles are unlocked, and the disambiguation of "Israelites" and "Jews" proves surprisingly illuminating. One of the chief successes of this book is the integration of Romans 9-11 with the rest of the book. Reformed theologians will need to wrestle with certain past emphases surrounding justification by faith alone, as well as the textual basis for concepts of individual election, but will be better for it if that work can be based on a stronger understanding of Paul's deeply OT influenced gospel.
I will note that aside from Moo, Staples' engagement with major Reformed-adjacent commentators consists mostly of articles from the 80's-90's or older (ie, Cranfield), so some fresh comparative work would be useful. Also, a look at the Romans commentaries of the Reformed scholastics might contain some surprises opening up possibilities for integration. I eagerly await more from Staples, as well as the first major Reformed Romans commentary that seriously reckons with this book.
Is there a 6 star option on here? For real. Everything has changed. Literally every Pauline theological paradigm is going to have to reckon with this thesis. Some will have to be discarded, while others will have to nuance pretty heavily. Excellently written, fairly accessible to anyone keeping their ear to the ground of these debates, and a depth charge in the waters of Pauline studies. The game has been changed!
I suspect this is going to be a major work as far as reading Romans and Paul for a long time. He made me pay attention to language and how it is used in the story of Israel that is compelling and makes Paul sound like, well, Paul in chapters 9-11.
And I marveled at what God has done in Christ to redeem Israel and that is worth something!