This is a frustrating book for me to review. On one hand, I really like the premise. I liked the world created within this book. It was vivid, and complete. The idea of granted animals was well executed. But this book had major flaws with the way it was written. Frankly, of the two characters I preferred reading Cyric. He was the character you watch make mistake after mistake and you just want to sit him down and give him a hug and set him on the straight and narrow. He, however, was a bit of an odd read. Very simplistic observations and that sort of thing. But a sweet, action-packed hero (?) to follow around. Ellia, however, I didn't understand. She had potential to be such a fabulous character! But she was just... not a three dimensional character. She wasn't the spunky princess, the take charge princess, or even the victimised princess she could have been. She wasn't very emotional about her whole kingdom's destruction, she didn't ever seem particularly passionate... The whole idea behind her character was nice, but I just didn't see her as a leader of a rebellion or that sort of kickass girl. She seemed a little... juvenile? That being said, she had her moments of gusto and gut. The officers around Cyril actually shone as really being thought out and powerful (especially Tobias). The Minstrel (a friend Ellia makes upon her journey) might have been my favorite character as, again, he had that vivaciousness this book really needed. I had a hard time really liking the people of Yanartas as, again, they seemed a bit like props used to illustrate Ellia's awesomeness, without really fulfilling all the hype created about the uber-important mystical people of Yanartas.
But all in all, this book was fine. It was nice. The story was cute, I was rooting for the characters, groaning as I saw poor Cyric make mistake after mistake. But it felt like something that you wrote a few years ago. And you go back, and you say, this is fine. But why didn't I phrase this this way? And what did I have against adjectives? And then you edit it a little, and BAM, you have something FANTASTIC. But here, the story was nice... it just didn't have the polish and sharpness that could have made it truly great. Because the plot is pretty awesome. Just... Where was the big picture. Was this just a book about village-sized countries playing around? Where was the real, gripping evil? The tugging on the heartstrings and grand scale threat of terror and destruction? That's what makes a fantasy book about war and trial gripping! It just... wasn't at its full potential. But still, a good, very PG friendly (any/all references are subtle, nothing particularly graphic), light read. Has the potential to really be top notch, if the main characters were written with more fire in them.
I recommend if you want a good fantasy read, and are interested in seeing some magic, seeing some new exciting beasts, and disappearing into another world for a brief while. I wouldn't reread, but the first run through was fun and light.
Also, what's the deal with chimeras? Who thinks that chimeras are cooler than dragons? Dragons are AWESOME.