What do you think?
Rate this book
Promise Me This
Michael Dunnagan was never supposed to sail on the "Titanic," nor would he have survived if not for the courage of Owen Allen. Determined to carry out his promise to care for Owen's relatives in America and his younger sister, Annie, in England, Michael works hard to strengthen the family's New Jersey garden and landscaping business. Annie Allen doesn't care what Michael promised Owen. She only knows that her brother is gone--like their mother and father--and the grief is enough to swallow her whole. As Annie struggles to navigate life without Owen, Michael reaches out to her through letters. In time, as Annie begins to lay aside her anger that Michael lived when Owen did not, a tentative friendship takes root and blossoms into something neither expected. Just as Michael saves enough money to bring Annie to America, WWI erupts in Europe. When Annie's letters mysteriously stop, Michael risks everything to fulfill his promise--and find the woman he's grown to love--before she's lost forever.
416 pages, Kindle Edition
First published January 1, 2012
321 people are currently reading
3929 people want to read
About the author
Cathy Gohlke
19 books1,331 followersBestselling, Christy Hall of Fame, and Carol and INSPY Award-winning author, Cathy Gohlke writes novels steeped with inspirational lessons, speaking of world and life events through the lens of history. She champions the battle against oppression, celebrating the freedom found only in Christ. Her critically acclaimed novels include This Promised Land, Ladies of the Lake, A Hundred Crickets Singing, Night Bird Calling, The Medallion (Christy Award), Until We Find Home, Secrets She Kept (Christy Award; Carol Award; INSPY Award); Saving Amelie (INSPY AWARD); Band of Sisters; Promise Me This (listed by Library Journal as one of the Best Books of 2012); I Have Seen Him in the Watchfires (Christy Award, American Christian Fiction Writers Award and listed by Library Journal as one of the Best Books of 2008) and William Henry Is a Fine Name (Christy Award).
Cathy has worked as a school librarian, drama director, and director of children's and education ministries. When not traveling to historic sites for research, she and her husband, Dan, divide their time between Northern Virginia and the Jersey Shore, enjoying time with their children and grandchildren. Visit her website at www.cathygohlke.com and find her on Facebook at CathyGohlkeBooks. Follow her on BookBub.
Cathy has worked as a school librarian, drama director, and director of children's and education ministries. When not traveling to historic sites for research, she and her husband, Dan, divide their time between Northern Virginia and the Jersey Shore, enjoying time with their children and grandchildren. Visit her website at www.cathygohlke.com and find her on Facebook at CathyGohlkeBooks. Follow her on BookBub.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 397 reviews
February 27, 2012
First posted on my blog, Legacy of a Writer.
When a book cover captures my attention, and then the synopsis also piques my interests, I’m sold—I must read the book! Which is why I instantly jumped at the chance to read award-winning author Cathy Gohlke’s newest release. In my opinion, Promise Me This is not a book you can just devour in one sitting. It's a book to be read slowly, with characters to be savored and a story to be treasured.
From the very beginning, I was swept away by this poignant story of Annie and Michael. And while I wasn’t fond of Annie in the first part of the book, as I watched her change throughout the years after the disaster of the Titanic, I grew to love her self-sacrificing character. Both Annie and Michael go through so much in Promise Me This that at the end of the book, as the last page is fast approaching, all you hope for is that they get their ‘happily ever after’! And while the ending wasn’t what I thought it’d be, I was still content with how we leave the characters.
There were so many twists and turns in Promise Me This—just when I thought things were looking up for these two, something huge would happen that hurls them straight into the path of danger and separation. Towards the end, there were several convenient “coincidences”, but also some surprises, too.
When I finally read the last page, I didn’t want to leave Annie and Michael! I closed the book, wishing there had been an epilogue of where these two were a few years after the book ended. That’s how real these characters were to me, and how much danger and turmoil they had been through in this 400 page book.
When you begin Promise Me This, be prepared to experience a story that will touch your heart in more ways than one!
I reviewed this book for Tyndale House Publishing. It was not required that I give a positive review, but solely to express my own thoughts and opinions of this book, which I have done.
When a book cover captures my attention, and then the synopsis also piques my interests, I’m sold—I must read the book! Which is why I instantly jumped at the chance to read award-winning author Cathy Gohlke’s newest release. In my opinion, Promise Me This is not a book you can just devour in one sitting. It's a book to be read slowly, with characters to be savored and a story to be treasured.
From the very beginning, I was swept away by this poignant story of Annie and Michael. And while I wasn’t fond of Annie in the first part of the book, as I watched her change throughout the years after the disaster of the Titanic, I grew to love her self-sacrificing character. Both Annie and Michael go through so much in Promise Me This that at the end of the book, as the last page is fast approaching, all you hope for is that they get their ‘happily ever after’! And while the ending wasn’t what I thought it’d be, I was still content with how we leave the characters.
There were so many twists and turns in Promise Me This—just when I thought things were looking up for these two, something huge would happen that hurls them straight into the path of danger and separation. Towards the end, there were several convenient “coincidences”, but also some surprises, too.
When I finally read the last page, I didn’t want to leave Annie and Michael! I closed the book, wishing there had been an epilogue of where these two were a few years after the book ended. That’s how real these characters were to me, and how much danger and turmoil they had been through in this 400 page book.
When you begin Promise Me This, be prepared to experience a story that will touch your heart in more ways than one!
I reviewed this book for Tyndale House Publishing. It was not required that I give a positive review, but solely to express my own thoughts and opinions of this book, which I have done.
October 23, 2016
What a rare and lovely specimen. I feel compelled to sing this book's praises (thus my longer-than-usual-goodreads-review) because--guess what--this was a GOOD Christian Fiction Romance novel!
No, really. Just listen--it held a message that, while not preach-y in any way, was strong in its presentation of the gospel. It was woven into the story in a such a way that it would be hard to separate the message from the story itself—I found it entirely refreshing and inspiring.
The romance was simply lovely. It was sweet and adorable, and there were no moments where things got too "mushy" or even borderline inappropriate. (A rare thing in CFR novels, sadly...)
I also loved the 1910's setting, involving two of the most devastating but fascinating (to me :P) events in history, the sinking of the Titanic, and World War One.
The plot moved a little slowly sometimes, although I was kept on the edge of my seat toward the end of the book in suspense. I enjoyed it, but it also made me a little frustrated by how loooooong the drama was dragged out.
And then there were the characters. I liked a lot of them, although one or two felt a bit contrived. My favorites were definitely Daniel, Owen, Annie, and Michael. Eesh, Michael. I could talk a long bit about this Irishman. But I won't. I'll leave it for you to find out how wonderful he is once you read the book. ;)
No, really. Just listen--it held a message that, while not preach-y in any way, was strong in its presentation of the gospel. It was woven into the story in a such a way that it would be hard to separate the message from the story itself—I found it entirely refreshing and inspiring.
The romance was simply lovely. It was sweet and adorable, and there were no moments where things got too "mushy" or even borderline inappropriate. (A rare thing in CFR novels, sadly...)
I also loved the 1910's setting, involving two of the most devastating but fascinating (to me :P) events in history, the sinking of the Titanic, and World War One.
The plot moved a little slowly sometimes, although I was kept on the edge of my seat toward the end of the book in suspense. I enjoyed it, but it also made me a little frustrated by how loooooong the drama was dragged out.
And then there were the characters. I liked a lot of them, although one or two felt a bit contrived. My favorites were definitely Daniel, Owen, Annie, and Michael. Eesh, Michael. I could talk a long bit about this Irishman. But I won't. I'll leave it for you to find out how wonderful he is once you read the book. ;)
November 20, 2020
This book was candy for a history buff like me! It contained historical fiction details about the Titanic, WW1, the Lusitania, the Spanish Flu pandemic of 1918. As well, all the characters were written about so realistically that I had to keep reading to find out more about them, even the not-so-lovable ones.
I would recommend this highly to anyone who enjoys good, excellently researched historical fiction.
Memorable Quotes:
(Pg.250)-“I do not mind so much about the blackouts or the curfew. But I do mind the waiting-forever waiting for the next round of shelling-the strain of not knowing, of lying awake in the night, anxious for a morning that may not come.”
I would recommend this highly to anyone who enjoys good, excellently researched historical fiction.
Memorable Quotes:
(Pg.250)-“I do not mind so much about the blackouts or the curfew. But I do mind the waiting-forever waiting for the next round of shelling-the strain of not knowing, of lying awake in the night, anxious for a morning that may not come.”
August 4, 2017
Originally posted on Reveries Reviews.
Not a great book, but not a bad book. It skipped forward rather suddenly a couple times, oftentimes skimming over years. It was kind of divided into two parts; the Titantic and the war. Between then, the events are kinda foggy. (And yes, a lot of reviewers said the exact thing, but it bears restating.)
Then there were just too many POVs. Don’t get me wrong; I love seeing the world of a book from as many perspectives as possible. However, this was just too much. A lot of characters just got one scene and for the rest of the book either didn’t exist or weren’t important. This was extremely annoying.
I did enjoy it, I just didn’t love it. I don’t think it was as well-done as it could have been, and it was pretty confusing at times.
~Kellyn Roth
Not a great book, but not a bad book. It skipped forward rather suddenly a couple times, oftentimes skimming over years. It was kind of divided into two parts; the Titantic and the war. Between then, the events are kinda foggy. (And yes, a lot of reviewers said the exact thing, but it bears restating.)
Then there were just too many POVs. Don’t get me wrong; I love seeing the world of a book from as many perspectives as possible. However, this was just too much. A lot of characters just got one scene and for the rest of the book either didn’t exist or weren’t important. This was extremely annoying.
I did enjoy it, I just didn’t love it. I don’t think it was as well-done as it could have been, and it was pretty confusing at times.
~Kellyn Roth
May 3, 2018
*sighs* Oh, how I wanted to like this . . .
I'm sorry to say that I just didn't connect much at all with this book or its characters. I had heard a lot of good things about it and really REALLY wanted to like it. But alas - it wasn't meant to be.
L I K E S:
- The idea. Okay, here's the thing: the synopsis sounded SO GOOD. I really loved the idea behind this book & there are a lot of ways I think it could have worked - but it just didn't. So WOOHOO for good ideas! Not so much for execution.
- Owen. Oh, dear Owen. *sniffles* Though I liked some of the characters okay, Owen was the only one I felt attached to and . . . well, read the synopsis. He doesn't stick around long. D:
- Ummm . . . the cover is nice? *scratches head* I know there was something else I liked - but my mind is drawing a blank. We'll just round off the positives with mentioning how pretty this cover is. 'Tis a fine specimen, my friends. *approves*
D I S L I K E S:
- The writing. Oh boyyyyy. The writing about drove. me. crazy. It feels like someone is telling you things the ENTIRE book. You don't get the chance to feel any of the characters' emotions. Instead, you're told them. All the time. The writing is rather void of personality or depth. It felt flat, and because of that, the characters felt flat, too. Not to mention the fact that WE'RE JUMPING IN OTHER CHARACTERS' HEADS EVERY TWO SECONDS. I lost count of how many POVs are in this book, but I'm guessing at least ten or twelve. Would you please just pick a couple POVs and stay there?? Sometimes having a lot of POVs works really well, but in this case, all it ended up doing was making it impossible for me to connect to any of the characters.
- ANNIE. She got much better, I will admit, but I had a lot of Issues with this girl for the majority of the book. She comes across as being extremely petty, condescending, and unfeeling for the first 150 pages or so. (Seriously, she acted like she was 10 years old . . . and I was supposed to believe she was going on 15? *squints*) Not to mention the fact that she Yes, Annie improved greatly later in the book; but I just never liked her as a character or person very much.
- It just didn't work. I don't know how to put this exactly, but this book just did not work, at all. I was under the impression that the book started during WWI, with flashbacks to the Titanic. But it actually started in 1912 and went allllllll the way to 1919. THAT'S SEVEN YEARS, PEEPS. Seven. Years. Everything was rushed and muddled. I felt perpetually confused as to what year we were in. The setting was never really developed, and I felt things just got glossed over. There was so much potential for this story. I can come up with at least 3 or 4 plots that would have worked WAY better. But instead . . . this happened: a book that was trying too hard to include everything and instead ended up feeling cheap, forced, and confusing.
- So many loose ends/missed opportunities/etc. In all, I'm just really disappointed and confused. A lot of interesting aspects of WWI could have been explored instead of just trying to cram in the ENTIRE war + the Titanic + that random time in between. A lot of loose ends and unsatisfactory explanations were given. I felt deprived of the richness and emotion that should have come with these heartbreaking historical events. I didn't FEEL anything. (Except perhaps frustration.) I don't mean to rant, my brain just feels like it's been majorly messed with, and I don't like that. :/
SO YEAH. I'm a very confused/disappointed bookdragon right now. I wanted to like this book, but it sadly fell short of all my expectations. I'm not in any way trying to bash this book - it just was genuinely not for me. :)
2 stars
I'm sorry to say that I just didn't connect much at all with this book or its characters. I had heard a lot of good things about it and really REALLY wanted to like it. But alas - it wasn't meant to be.
L I K E S:
- The idea. Okay, here's the thing: the synopsis sounded SO GOOD. I really loved the idea behind this book & there are a lot of ways I think it could have worked - but it just didn't. So WOOHOO for good ideas! Not so much for execution.
- Owen. Oh, dear Owen. *sniffles* Though I liked some of the characters okay, Owen was the only one I felt attached to and . . . well, read the synopsis. He doesn't stick around long. D:
- Ummm . . . the cover is nice? *scratches head* I know there was something else I liked - but my mind is drawing a blank. We'll just round off the positives with mentioning how pretty this cover is. 'Tis a fine specimen, my friends. *approves*
D I S L I K E S:
- The writing. Oh boyyyyy. The writing about drove. me. crazy. It feels like someone is telling you things the ENTIRE book. You don't get the chance to feel any of the characters' emotions. Instead, you're told them. All the time. The writing is rather void of personality or depth. It felt flat, and because of that, the characters felt flat, too. Not to mention the fact that WE'RE JUMPING IN OTHER CHARACTERS' HEADS EVERY TWO SECONDS. I lost count of how many POVs are in this book, but I'm guessing at least ten or twelve. Would you please just pick a couple POVs and stay there?? Sometimes having a lot of POVs works really well, but in this case, all it ended up doing was making it impossible for me to connect to any of the characters.
- ANNIE. She got much better, I will admit, but I had a lot of Issues with this girl for the majority of the book. She comes across as being extremely petty, condescending, and unfeeling for the first 150 pages or so. (Seriously, she acted like she was 10 years old . . . and I was supposed to believe she was going on 15? *squints*) Not to mention the fact that she Yes, Annie improved greatly later in the book; but I just never liked her as a character or person very much.
- It just didn't work. I don't know how to put this exactly, but this book just did not work, at all. I was under the impression that the book started during WWI, with flashbacks to the Titanic. But it actually started in 1912 and went allllllll the way to 1919. THAT'S SEVEN YEARS, PEEPS. Seven. Years. Everything was rushed and muddled. I felt perpetually confused as to what year we were in. The setting was never really developed, and I felt things just got glossed over. There was so much potential for this story. I can come up with at least 3 or 4 plots that would have worked WAY better. But instead . . . this happened: a book that was trying too hard to include everything and instead ended up feeling cheap, forced, and confusing.
- So many loose ends/missed opportunities/etc. In all, I'm just really disappointed and confused. A lot of interesting aspects of WWI could have been explored instead of just trying to cram in the ENTIRE war + the Titanic + that random time in between. A lot of loose ends and unsatisfactory explanations were given. I felt deprived of the richness and emotion that should have come with these heartbreaking historical events. I didn't FEEL anything. (Except perhaps frustration.) I don't mean to rant, my brain just feels like it's been majorly messed with, and I don't like that. :/
SO YEAH. I'm a very confused/disappointed bookdragon right now. I wanted to like this book, but it sadly fell short of all my expectations. I'm not in any way trying to bash this book - it just was genuinely not for me. :)
2 stars
January 1, 2018
3.5 stars
For me, the story is clearly seen in two parts: the Titanic, and WWI. What went on between was a little fuzzy, but the events during the Titanic AND WWI were so amazingly interesting.
History... It seemed very sound and well-researched. I learned a lot about the Titanic and could see myself traveling aboard. I was also brought into the trials and terrors of WWI in France, England, and the hospitals.
Storyline... some people have said that the story started out slow. I thought it was a pretty good start until after Michael reached New Jersey. Then, like I mentioned, it seemed to get a little fuzzy as to why the scenes were important to the plot (it seemed more like the author had to get from one important event to the other). It was still interesting, but it seemed a little...jerky at times.
Characters... The two MCs are Annie and Michael. However, the story continually bounces back and forth between about a dozen other characters -- some are highlighted only for one scene. I understand why the author mixed omniscient with deep POV, as it gave the opportunity to follow history that was woven into the fiction, but as a general rule, I prefer deep POV.
Romance... I really like the first half of the book. ;) And yes, that was before the romance hit. It wasn't awful, but it was very emotional-driven. There were a few kisses mentioned, but more or less the romance was about the characters' emotions being driven.
Spiritual... here is where I knock a star off. The spiritual aspect of the story seemed a little inconsistent. Owen was held up as the peak of Christianity and he did present a strong Gospel message, but it was never clear to me as to whether or not Michael and Annie were actually saved. Overall, they really didn't live a life striving to please God. It was somewhat mentioned toward the beginning, a little in the middle, completely lost during WWI, and then returned in the end. I personally think that the story would have been complete without it (not to sound harsh, but it wasn't that important to the story). So yeah, the spiritual side was a little weak.
All in all, I did enjoy this read, particularly for the historical aspect.
*I got this book from the Tyndale Rewards Program*
For me, the story is clearly seen in two parts: the Titanic, and WWI. What went on between was a little fuzzy, but the events during the Titanic AND WWI were so amazingly interesting.
History... It seemed very sound and well-researched. I learned a lot about the Titanic and could see myself traveling aboard. I was also brought into the trials and terrors of WWI in France, England, and the hospitals.
Storyline... some people have said that the story started out slow. I thought it was a pretty good start until after Michael reached New Jersey. Then, like I mentioned, it seemed to get a little fuzzy as to why the scenes were important to the plot (it seemed more like the author had to get from one important event to the other). It was still interesting, but it seemed a little...jerky at times.
Characters... The two MCs are Annie and Michael. However, the story continually bounces back and forth between about a dozen other characters -- some are highlighted only for one scene. I understand why the author mixed omniscient with deep POV, as it gave the opportunity to follow history that was woven into the fiction, but as a general rule, I prefer deep POV.
Romance... I really like the first half of the book. ;) And yes, that was before the romance hit. It wasn't awful, but it was very emotional-driven. There were a few kisses mentioned, but more or less the romance was about the characters' emotions being driven.
Spiritual... here is where I knock a star off. The spiritual aspect of the story seemed a little inconsistent. Owen was held up as the peak of Christianity and he did present a strong Gospel message, but it was never clear to me as to whether or not Michael and Annie were actually saved. Overall, they really didn't live a life striving to please God. It was somewhat mentioned toward the beginning, a little in the middle, completely lost during WWI, and then returned in the end. I personally think that the story would have been complete without it (not to sound harsh, but it wasn't that important to the story). So yeah, the spiritual side was a little weak.
All in all, I did enjoy this read, particularly for the historical aspect.
*I got this book from the Tyndale Rewards Program*
December 30, 2014
This is my first book from Cathy Gohlke and I truly enjoyed this story.
From the start, I was drawn in by Michael, who lost his parents as a young boy and left at the mercy of a horrible abusive uncle. I felt compassion for Michael since the moment he was introduced and was so happy when Owen took him under his wings, and then Owen's family in America.
I adored the character of Owen, who only being 21, had a maturity far greater. His compassion and love for Michael was a true representation of his relationship with Christ. I was so sad that he died on the Titanic - I actually found myself hoping that somehow he survived.
I loved Annie, and wished number of times I could step into the story and help her. She, like Michael, also lost her parents when she was young and also left with her aunt Eleanor, who is bitter and full of envy because of Annie's mother and who constantly punishes Annie. I never in any story came across such a bitter, hateful character and did't like her at all. Some of the things she did doesn't seem humanly possible.
I think Michael and Annie connected due to the shared loss of family and the emotional hardships they had to endure.
The characters had to deal with a lot, survival's guilt, forgiveness and faith and trust in God.
I have to be honest - I scanned through the last 10% of the book because I didn't like that twist in the story and just want to get through it.
I am more a suspense genre reader, but enjoyed this book. Will definitely recommend it for anyone who loves historical fiction.
The details of the war was very descriptive - to take into account for readers who don't like too much detail of wounds etc.
From the start, I was drawn in by Michael, who lost his parents as a young boy and left at the mercy of a horrible abusive uncle. I felt compassion for Michael since the moment he was introduced and was so happy when Owen took him under his wings, and then Owen's family in America.
I adored the character of Owen, who only being 21, had a maturity far greater. His compassion and love for Michael was a true representation of his relationship with Christ. I was so sad that he died on the Titanic - I actually found myself hoping that somehow he survived.
I loved Annie, and wished number of times I could step into the story and help her. She, like Michael, also lost her parents when she was young and also left with her aunt Eleanor, who is bitter and full of envy because of Annie's mother and who constantly punishes Annie. I never in any story came across such a bitter, hateful character and did't like her at all. Some of the things she did doesn't seem humanly possible.
I think Michael and Annie connected due to the shared loss of family and the emotional hardships they had to endure.
The characters had to deal with a lot, survival's guilt, forgiveness and faith and trust in God.
I have to be honest - I scanned through the last 10% of the book because I didn't like that twist in the story and just want to get through it.
I am more a suspense genre reader, but enjoyed this book. Will definitely recommend it for anyone who loves historical fiction.
The details of the war was very descriptive - to take into account for readers who don't like too much detail of wounds etc.
April 4, 2012
When you pick up a novel about the Titanic, you know there are going to be tears. But I didn't realize how moving the whole book, not only the Titanic scenes, was going to be.
I loved this book. It was a beautifully written story, rich with historical detail and character depth. The story kept me intrigued and the characters made a beeline for my heart, pretty much from page one.
I also enjoyed the fact that the Titanic wasn't the sole historical impact in this story...it stretches through WWI, and I truly found the whole story fascinating.
But best of all, the writing. Lyrical and just so, so well-crafted.
Okay, I'm going to stop gushing now, other than to say, this story is absolutely going into my must-read-again pile. And now...I'm going to go search for Cathy Gohlke's other titles.
I loved this book. It was a beautifully written story, rich with historical detail and character depth. The story kept me intrigued and the characters made a beeline for my heart, pretty much from page one.
I also enjoyed the fact that the Titanic wasn't the sole historical impact in this story...it stretches through WWI, and I truly found the whole story fascinating.
But best of all, the writing. Lyrical and just so, so well-crafted.
Okay, I'm going to stop gushing now, other than to say, this story is absolutely going into my must-read-again pile. And now...I'm going to go search for Cathy Gohlke's other titles.
July 31, 2024
4.5⭐️
Was crying by the end🥲
Was crying by the end🥲
October 4, 2018
Oh, wow! What a beautiful story! I loved how the author drew comparisons between Owen's sacrificial character and Christ's great sacrifice for all of mankind. I love how she used Michael's and Annie's stories to flesh out the ideas of what sacrifice and love are all about.
4.75 stars
4.75 stars
July 6, 2017
One of those books where it was so good, at the end I was contemplating going back to the begining and starting over. Wow!
February 19, 2012
This is the first time I have ever read anything by Cathy Gohlke. And boy was it a pleasant surprise! I really enjoyed Promise Me This and her take on the Titanic story. I have always been a fan of reading about the Titanic and what a tragedy took place that day. In this story, Cathy weaves a tale of romance, mystery and suspense as well as a release of bitterness and guilt.
Annie is a young lady who deeply loves her older brother. But he decides to sail on the Titanic to go to New Jersey and make a home there with some family. Then when he has enough money and a business he will send for Annie. These two are very sweet together and I loved their relationship. But Annie gets irritated when her brother, Owen, befriends a street urchin who is actually a runaway from an abusive situation. Michael is the runaway who has never had a friend in his life. He also has a dark secret in his past that he thinks about often but was no fault of his own.
Well, I am sure you guess the plot but Michael finds his way onto the Titanic and ends up as a stowaway. When Owen finds out he takes him under his wing to help him. They share their food and sleeping area but Owen also shares his dreams with Michael. Then in the middle of their plotting and dreaming comes that dreadful night when the Titanic hits an iceburg. And Owen pushes Michael into taking his lifevest and a spot on a lifeboat. And from that moment on, everything has changed in their plans. Owen gave his life for Michael and now the dreams they both had become Michael's responsibility. He takes over the business that Owen wanted and plans for the day he can bring Annie to America.
In the meantime, Annie is dealing with her own troubles and an evil aunt. I have to admit, I felt like slapping the woman a couple times. Annie takes over gardening and the woman pulls them all down and burns them. Annie has to deal with the bitterness she has to this wicked woman and how it is pulling her down personally. She doesn't want to forgive the stowaway who she thinks is the reason her brother died.
In the end there is a lot of joy and freedom from guilt and bitterness but it was a long journey. I like how the author didn't just make everything a bed of roses but went through struggles we have daily in our own lives. I also like how she wove the story of John Bunyan and Pilgrim's Progress in this book. It has long been one of my favorite Christian classics and learning about his tombstone and the inscription made my day. There is the use of a swear word twice in this book in the terms of military time. I didn't like having it in there so I wanted to mention it in my review. I can't wait to see what the author has in store next for us her readers! Excellent book!
You can learn more about Cathy Gohlke at her website or on Facebook. Definitely going to be searching for her other books!
I received a copy of this book for review purposes through Tyndale Publishing. I did not receive any monetary compensation. All thoughts are 100% mine.
Annie is a young lady who deeply loves her older brother. But he decides to sail on the Titanic to go to New Jersey and make a home there with some family. Then when he has enough money and a business he will send for Annie. These two are very sweet together and I loved their relationship. But Annie gets irritated when her brother, Owen, befriends a street urchin who is actually a runaway from an abusive situation. Michael is the runaway who has never had a friend in his life. He also has a dark secret in his past that he thinks about often but was no fault of his own.
Well, I am sure you guess the plot but Michael finds his way onto the Titanic and ends up as a stowaway. When Owen finds out he takes him under his wing to help him. They share their food and sleeping area but Owen also shares his dreams with Michael. Then in the middle of their plotting and dreaming comes that dreadful night when the Titanic hits an iceburg. And Owen pushes Michael into taking his lifevest and a spot on a lifeboat. And from that moment on, everything has changed in their plans. Owen gave his life for Michael and now the dreams they both had become Michael's responsibility. He takes over the business that Owen wanted and plans for the day he can bring Annie to America.
In the meantime, Annie is dealing with her own troubles and an evil aunt. I have to admit, I felt like slapping the woman a couple times. Annie takes over gardening and the woman pulls them all down and burns them. Annie has to deal with the bitterness she has to this wicked woman and how it is pulling her down personally. She doesn't want to forgive the stowaway who she thinks is the reason her brother died.
In the end there is a lot of joy and freedom from guilt and bitterness but it was a long journey. I like how the author didn't just make everything a bed of roses but went through struggles we have daily in our own lives. I also like how she wove the story of John Bunyan and Pilgrim's Progress in this book. It has long been one of my favorite Christian classics and learning about his tombstone and the inscription made my day. There is the use of a swear word twice in this book in the terms of military time. I didn't like having it in there so I wanted to mention it in my review. I can't wait to see what the author has in store next for us her readers! Excellent book!
You can learn more about Cathy Gohlke at her website or on Facebook. Definitely going to be searching for her other books!
I received a copy of this book for review purposes through Tyndale Publishing. I did not receive any monetary compensation. All thoughts are 100% mine.
February 25, 2012
Is gut-wrenching splendour an oxymoron? Because that's how I'd begin to describe Promise Me This. I wouldn't end there though. I might throw in descriptors like 'agonizingly wonderful' or 'despairingly stunning' or ... LOL - clearly this book has sent me into a tailspin but I'll try to regroup.
It is definitely worthy of the title 'epic saga' as the story takes place over several years, crosses continents and is fraught with angst. Michael and Annie are just teens when we meet them first but some cleverly crafted plotting takes us all on a journey we soon won't forget. Gohlke tackles an intriguing period of history that includes the sinking of the Titanic and World War I and has done such a good job of it that I'm still feeling emotionally bruised.
You will find characters to instantly bond with and a plot rife with harrowing and unpredictable twists and turns that will keep you on your toes to the very last sentence. Seriously, I despaired so deeply at one point that I had to take a peek at the last page and I hardly every do that!
And oh, Gohlke's characters -- from the hero and heroine right through to the secondary characters -- all so real, so vibrant and oh so compelling. Artfully crafted, each plays a pivotal role in the story and you'll meet one of the vilest villains in literary history! There's so much more I want to say but won't for fear of unintentionally leaking spoilers. This is definitely a novel worthy of a book club discussion -- one that would go on long into the night because there is so much substance to the story.
Promise Me This is the kind of book that will profoundly effect its readers. On a scale of one to 10, I'd rate it 100.
It is definitely worthy of the title 'epic saga' as the story takes place over several years, crosses continents and is fraught with angst. Michael and Annie are just teens when we meet them first but some cleverly crafted plotting takes us all on a journey we soon won't forget. Gohlke tackles an intriguing period of history that includes the sinking of the Titanic and World War I and has done such a good job of it that I'm still feeling emotionally bruised.
You will find characters to instantly bond with and a plot rife with harrowing and unpredictable twists and turns that will keep you on your toes to the very last sentence. Seriously, I despaired so deeply at one point that I had to take a peek at the last page and I hardly every do that!
And oh, Gohlke's characters -- from the hero and heroine right through to the secondary characters -- all so real, so vibrant and oh so compelling. Artfully crafted, each plays a pivotal role in the story and you'll meet one of the vilest villains in literary history! There's so much more I want to say but won't for fear of unintentionally leaking spoilers. This is definitely a novel worthy of a book club discussion -- one that would go on long into the night because there is so much substance to the story.
Promise Me This is the kind of book that will profoundly effect its readers. On a scale of one to 10, I'd rate it 100.
February 7, 2012
The impressive queen of ships, Titanic, and its unfortunate demise has everything to do with where this book begins, and therefore where it ends. For if the ship itself hadn’t sunk to the bottom of the ocean that blustery cold April night, then there would have been no story to tell.
I know from experience that there are a hundred and one reviews out there for every book published that will tell you what the book is about. That, quite purposefully, is not my intention. What I will tell you is that Promise Me This is more of an epic story in three parts than just a historical novel with a romantic ending. The two main characters, Michael Dunnagan and Annie Allen, are separated throughout most of the novel after meeting briefly as teenagers.
Promise Me This was a touching, though, long story. I have to admit that I grew impatient waiting (years and years) for the two main characters to meet and the romance to begin, which unfortunately wasn’t until about three-fourths into the book. In my opinion, there were too many unneeded character perspectives throughout the book, and not enough time spent on creating the depth I would have liked to see from the two main characters.
I’m certain that anyone who likes to read Historical Fiction will enjoy reading this book. It is a good story and very well written. I give Promise Me This 4 stars.
Visit Cathy Gohlke’s website at www.cathygohlke.com.
Tyndale House Publishers supplied me with a paperback version of Cathy Gohlke’s Promise Me This in return for my honest opinion of the book.
I know from experience that there are a hundred and one reviews out there for every book published that will tell you what the book is about. That, quite purposefully, is not my intention. What I will tell you is that Promise Me This is more of an epic story in three parts than just a historical novel with a romantic ending. The two main characters, Michael Dunnagan and Annie Allen, are separated throughout most of the novel after meeting briefly as teenagers.
Promise Me This was a touching, though, long story. I have to admit that I grew impatient waiting (years and years) for the two main characters to meet and the romance to begin, which unfortunately wasn’t until about three-fourths into the book. In my opinion, there were too many unneeded character perspectives throughout the book, and not enough time spent on creating the depth I would have liked to see from the two main characters.
I’m certain that anyone who likes to read Historical Fiction will enjoy reading this book. It is a good story and very well written. I give Promise Me This 4 stars.
Visit Cathy Gohlke’s website at www.cathygohlke.com.
Tyndale House Publishers supplied me with a paperback version of Cathy Gohlke’s Promise Me This in return for my honest opinion of the book.
December 24, 2015
“As long as a man has two hands and a strong back, he can make things happen. It's no good being fearful. Worry won't change the future a whit, and it misses the joy of this glad day.”
3.5 stars. Let me just say this was a lot different than I expected, but not nescarrily in a bad sense. I really liked the characters and how the author portrayed the struggle of human nature to do what is right. Owen's godliness and care for Michael was touching and poignant.
The romance definitely is worth noting. There are two (I think) not-detailed kisess and everything was appropriate. I liked how the romance wasn't the focus.
I really wanted to give this four stars. The last 150 pages or so I felt like the story really dragged and that everything could have been wrapped up sooner. Also, the fact that Michael and Annie were hardly together during most of the book seemed a bit odd. Toward the end there were some random POVs and circumstances that didn't go with the flow of the story.
All that being said, I very much enjoyed the Titanic and World War 1 theme. The ships sinking and emotions showed during that tramatic time in history really grasped my attention.
I still reccomend this book because it is so clean and showed many important lessons throughout the book.
3.5 stars. Let me just say this was a lot different than I expected, but not nescarrily in a bad sense. I really liked the characters and how the author portrayed the struggle of human nature to do what is right. Owen's godliness and care for Michael was touching and poignant.
The romance definitely is worth noting. There are two (I think) not-detailed kisess and everything was appropriate. I liked how the romance wasn't the focus.
I really wanted to give this four stars. The last 150 pages or so I felt like the story really dragged and that everything could have been wrapped up sooner. Also, the fact that Michael and Annie were hardly together during most of the book seemed a bit odd. Toward the end there were some random POVs and circumstances that didn't go with the flow of the story.
All that being said, I very much enjoyed the Titanic and World War 1 theme. The ships sinking and emotions showed during that tramatic time in history really grasped my attention.
I still reccomend this book because it is so clean and showed many important lessons throughout the book.
February 27, 2022
Michael Dunnagan was never supposed to sail on the "Titanic," but through circumstances he created he ended up a stowaway. He would never have survived if he hadn't been adopted by passenger Owen Allen who claimed him as a brother. Michael Dunnagan was a bit of a scallaywag but it kept him alive in 1912 England. His important goal was to find himself a way to make it to the United States. Owen Allen was headed there to join his uncle's family and continue his landscaping career; and, most importantly, earn enough money to bring his sister, Annie, to the US.
Filled with loveable characters along with a dastardly aunt, Gohlke's story line felt so real and appropriate to the time period. Owen was a caring, concerned, faith filled young man and had many characteristics of Jesus who taught that to lay down you life for another was the right thing to do. He was an excellent role model for Michael to attempt to replicate. Annie was a strong young girl considering her villain of an aunt who abused her both physically and mentally and was a totally unlikeable character. This book was filled with the characteristics of life: sadness, hope, love, laughter, and despair. Another great read from Cathy Gohlke.
Filled with loveable characters along with a dastardly aunt, Gohlke's story line felt so real and appropriate to the time period. Owen was a caring, concerned, faith filled young man and had many characteristics of Jesus who taught that to lay down you life for another was the right thing to do. He was an excellent role model for Michael to attempt to replicate. Annie was a strong young girl considering her villain of an aunt who abused her both physically and mentally and was a totally unlikeable character. This book was filled with the characteristics of life: sadness, hope, love, laughter, and despair. Another great read from Cathy Gohlke.
February 5, 2012
Promise Me This, set during pre-World War I era, is a beautiful love story between a street rat, Michael Dunnagan, and a young woman born to privilege, Annie Allen. They catch a glimpse of each other when they are still children. Annie's older brother, Owen, shows the young Irish lad charity and gives him a job. Promising his sister a new life in America, Owen buys passage on the ill-fated Titanic and tells Annie that he will send for her soon. Also seeking a fresh start, Michael stows away on the Titanic. Only Michael survives, but the brotherly bond between Owen and Michael is so great, Michael promises to one day bring Annie to America.
This is the first book by Cathy that I have read and I must say, I enjoyed it. Her voice is hauntingly romantic, and I felt as if I were watching, instead of reading, a BBC movie based on a novel from ages past. In fact, if it hasn't been optioned for film, it should be; just saying.
Annie and Michael come from very different backgrounds and each of them face painful struggles attached to their circumstances. Through their present situation of being separated and the pain of losing a loved one, I was very engaged and eager to see how these two young individuals would fight through their grief and connect with each other. Cathy has written obstacle after obstacle into her characters' lives and watching them grow and mature was a pleasant experience. Grief, anger, bitterness, revenge...all our explored in this wonderful story about compassion and forgiveness.
One of my favorite scenes was the sinking of the Titanic. Spread over several chapters, Cathy takes you on a visual tour moving you across the ship from trapped lower level passengers, to upper-class ticket holders being safely loaded into boats, to an elderly couple content to leave the world together, and finally to that famous band that went down playing their instruments. The way she wrote that historical event was fascinating. I believed she captured the range of emotions that must have occurred on that sad night, and I had a vivid image of being safely beside Michael on a lifeboat watching the "unsinkable" ship slip beneath the icy surface and into a watery grave. Even her images of battles occurring during WWI were brilliant, exciting and graphic.
If you haven't read anything by Cathy Gohlke, then I recommend you pick up her latest novel, Promise Me This. You may visit her website and Tyndale House for more on this author and her newest release.
This is the first book by Cathy that I have read and I must say, I enjoyed it. Her voice is hauntingly romantic, and I felt as if I were watching, instead of reading, a BBC movie based on a novel from ages past. In fact, if it hasn't been optioned for film, it should be; just saying.
Annie and Michael come from very different backgrounds and each of them face painful struggles attached to their circumstances. Through their present situation of being separated and the pain of losing a loved one, I was very engaged and eager to see how these two young individuals would fight through their grief and connect with each other. Cathy has written obstacle after obstacle into her characters' lives and watching them grow and mature was a pleasant experience. Grief, anger, bitterness, revenge...all our explored in this wonderful story about compassion and forgiveness.
One of my favorite scenes was the sinking of the Titanic. Spread over several chapters, Cathy takes you on a visual tour moving you across the ship from trapped lower level passengers, to upper-class ticket holders being safely loaded into boats, to an elderly couple content to leave the world together, and finally to that famous band that went down playing their instruments. The way she wrote that historical event was fascinating. I believed she captured the range of emotions that must have occurred on that sad night, and I had a vivid image of being safely beside Michael on a lifeboat watching the "unsinkable" ship slip beneath the icy surface and into a watery grave. Even her images of battles occurring during WWI were brilliant, exciting and graphic.
If you haven't read anything by Cathy Gohlke, then I recommend you pick up her latest novel, Promise Me This. You may visit her website and Tyndale House for more on this author and her newest release.
April 25, 2012
Promise Me This was truly an epic on more than one level. I picked this one up billed entirely on the fact that it had a Titanic theme and felt I had better read at least one of those to mark the 100 years since the sinking.
But this was no mere rerun of Titanic the Movie on a budget. It's a brave move to use one of the most climatic moments of the twentieth century as merely a curtin raiser. And with the ship gone and buried along with her passengers - we move to the main event, the intersecting lives of our two principal characters one different sides of the Atlantic.
Michael Dunnigan - street urchin and orphan - chance encounter and friendship with Owen Allen set in motion an entire new direction and new citizenship in America. Writing back to Owen's sister back in England - at first tentitively, a strong bond of friendship is born.
Owen's sister, Annie meanwhile lives for Michael's letters and slowly but surely she forgives the fact that he survived and her brother did not. As the long shadow of World War I slowly manifests itself, tides begin to turn and the two young loves are torn ever further apart.
I found Cathy Gohlke's writing style to be careful and methodical, never letting the story run away with itself and just when you felt it might be starting to become bogged down in it's subject matter, another twist would take place.
The last few chapters particularly were amazing - consequently read on ANZAC day in New Zealand (our memorial day)which truly painted a vivid picture of the hell that was World War I. Annie's work as a nurse on the front lines was as captivating as it was horrific and Michael's determination to find her, acting as a abulance driver created the heroic heart of the story.
Highly recommended as a historical story from 1912 to the Armistace but also as a jolly good read with a ton of depth.
But this was no mere rerun of Titanic the Movie on a budget. It's a brave move to use one of the most climatic moments of the twentieth century as merely a curtin raiser. And with the ship gone and buried along with her passengers - we move to the main event, the intersecting lives of our two principal characters one different sides of the Atlantic.
Michael Dunnigan - street urchin and orphan - chance encounter and friendship with Owen Allen set in motion an entire new direction and new citizenship in America. Writing back to Owen's sister back in England - at first tentitively, a strong bond of friendship is born.
Owen's sister, Annie meanwhile lives for Michael's letters and slowly but surely she forgives the fact that he survived and her brother did not. As the long shadow of World War I slowly manifests itself, tides begin to turn and the two young loves are torn ever further apart.
I found Cathy Gohlke's writing style to be careful and methodical, never letting the story run away with itself and just when you felt it might be starting to become bogged down in it's subject matter, another twist would take place.
The last few chapters particularly were amazing - consequently read on ANZAC day in New Zealand (our memorial day)which truly painted a vivid picture of the hell that was World War I. Annie's work as a nurse on the front lines was as captivating as it was horrific and Michael's determination to find her, acting as a abulance driver created the heroic heart of the story.
Highly recommended as a historical story from 1912 to the Armistace but also as a jolly good read with a ton of depth.
July 12, 2012
Many books have been written about the Titanic, and I have devoured them all. This book stands out because the focus is not on the sinking of the ship but on the lives of those affected by the loss of life that day. When Owen Allen sets sail on the unsinkable vessel, he leaves behind his beloved sister Annie and finds himself caring for the young Michael, who sneaked onto the ship. When Owen sacrifices his life for Michael’s, Michael carries out Owen’s dreams of creating a gardening business, and over time, Annie and Michael begin a friendship through letters. When WWI breaks out in Europe, Michael risks everything to save the girl he promised to protect.
I loved that this book didn’t stop at the sinking but continued into WWI. It gave time for Annie and Michael, both young at the beginning of the book, time to mature as characters. Annie is somewhat annoying at first, but she grows into a strong, resilient woman, which I suspect was typical of socially elite girls who were thrust into war in the early 1900s. Michael is a scrappy young boy, and I instantly liked him. He too grows up quickly and becomes a man worth of being the hero in a novel.
The book is long—400 pages—and spans several years in time, so it’s hard to talk about it all in a short review. There are so many twists and turns as Annie and Michael both endure hardships continents apart, but each one is grounded in historical events and engage the reader enough to forget how long they have been reading.
Fans of Christian historical fiction will enjoy this story of love, loss, and hope.
I received this book in exchange for my review. My thoughts and opinions are my own.
I loved that this book didn’t stop at the sinking but continued into WWI. It gave time for Annie and Michael, both young at the beginning of the book, time to mature as characters. Annie is somewhat annoying at first, but she grows into a strong, resilient woman, which I suspect was typical of socially elite girls who were thrust into war in the early 1900s. Michael is a scrappy young boy, and I instantly liked him. He too grows up quickly and becomes a man worth of being the hero in a novel.
The book is long—400 pages—and spans several years in time, so it’s hard to talk about it all in a short review. There are so many twists and turns as Annie and Michael both endure hardships continents apart, but each one is grounded in historical events and engage the reader enough to forget how long they have been reading.
Fans of Christian historical fiction will enjoy this story of love, loss, and hope.
I received this book in exchange for my review. My thoughts and opinions are my own.
March 25, 2013
I knew when I started reading Promise Me This that I was setting myself up for heartbreak and sadness. How could I not, the story partially takes place aboard the Titanic, and we all know the events of that fateful night. We know about the hundreds of souls lost to the cold deep Atlantic ocean. Then we have World War I, another tragic momentous stain on our past. So like I said I knew what I getting myself into. Both moments in history that has always fascinated me, along with other events in history. Part of the reason I was drawn to reading this book.
But those were not the only tragic events, yes they are not wide scale as the sinking of the Titanic or the WWI but the personal tragedies that have happened to those in the story, both living and and those who have past on.
This book is about getting past those times, as well as facing them head on. Forgiveness and doing well towards other, no matter who they are or what they have done. Even though sometimes it's hard to see past the hate and pain they have caused. All while dealing with devastating events that take place in the story.
Sometimes after I read a book I don't always read the note from the author, most times I do and this was one of those times I did. I found it interesting to see that Owen Allen was in fact a real person who was a gardener and did actually lose his life with the sinking of the Titanic.
I will for sure be checking out Cathy Gohlke's other works.
But those were not the only tragic events, yes they are not wide scale as the sinking of the Titanic or the WWI but the personal tragedies that have happened to those in the story, both living and and those who have past on.
This book is about getting past those times, as well as facing them head on. Forgiveness and doing well towards other, no matter who they are or what they have done. Even though sometimes it's hard to see past the hate and pain they have caused. All while dealing with devastating events that take place in the story.
Sometimes after I read a book I don't always read the note from the author, most times I do and this was one of those times I did. I found it interesting to see that Owen Allen was in fact a real person who was a gardener and did actually lose his life with the sinking of the Titanic.
I will for sure be checking out Cathy Gohlke's other works.
October 13, 2014
"Promise Me This" is a very moving story about Michael and Annie, two people impacted and brought together by the sinking of the Titanic. It's broken down into three parts, spans several years, and follows the characters through World War I. The history is well-researched. The author's writing voice is pleasant, but I still found it hard to follow the scene action at times. The portrayal of the characters' emotions is amazing, and the plot is organic and flows well. I can see why Gohlke is an award-winning author.
I didn't like that the hero and heroine were away from each other for most of the book--they met briefly as teens, and were reunited during the climax. But Gohlke did an exceptional job weaving their lives together despite the ocean between them, and showing how they fell in love through the man that bound them together and a friendship that blossomed over years of correspondence.
I would recommend this book to those who enjoy savoring the journey rather than devouring a story in one sitting, but there are times of suspense and high stakes when I found the book hard to put down. It reads like a classical music piece--some movements quiet and slow, others loud and fast-paced. Truly a beautiful story. Those who enjoy gardening will especially love it. :-)
I didn't like that the hero and heroine were away from each other for most of the book--they met briefly as teens, and were reunited during the climax. But Gohlke did an exceptional job weaving their lives together despite the ocean between them, and showing how they fell in love through the man that bound them together and a friendship that blossomed over years of correspondence.
I would recommend this book to those who enjoy savoring the journey rather than devouring a story in one sitting, but there are times of suspense and high stakes when I found the book hard to put down. It reads like a classical music piece--some movements quiet and slow, others loud and fast-paced. Truly a beautiful story. Those who enjoy gardening will especially love it. :-)
August 1, 2012
Promise The This is a moving, action-packed read that held me in it's grip from the opening scenes to the satisfying conclusion. Drawing upon the rich historical drama of the sinking of the Titanic and the First World War, the story spans a number of years as it follows the lives of Annie Allen and Michael Dunnagan as they experience heart-ache, seeming insurmountable odds, and disappointment after disappointment. Yet, in the midst of their trials, the light of Jesus shines brightly. Both Annie and Michael experience a highly believable spiritual journey in the pages of this book, coming to realize that no matter what happens in their lives, the God of the Universe is as close as their breath, walking with them through the valley of the shadow of death. I loved watching both Annie and Michael arise triumphant in the midst of their circumstance, and the power of forgiveness and grace is beautifully illustrated in their lives. The discovery and growth of their own love for each other is also poignant to behold.
I literally found it impossible to step away from the pages of this story, and I highly recommend this book for those readers who love historical dramas filled with action and starring believable and inspiring characters. 5 out of 5 stars!
I literally found it impossible to step away from the pages of this story, and I highly recommend this book for those readers who love historical dramas filled with action and starring believable and inspiring characters. 5 out of 5 stars!
June 24, 2014
Sometimes I find a book that captures my attention so completely, that sets my heart racing, and beckons me to return to its pages every spare minute just to find out what will happen to my favorite characters. That riveting book is Promise Me This, and I can promise you that once you meet Owen, Michael and Annie you’ll find that this novel about their lives is divinely written. My first thought when I ordered this book was that it would be interesting to read some historical fiction based on the Titanic’s tragic voyage; but I soon found out that the Titanic is just the starting point of this incredible heart wrenching story of self-sacrifice, death and survival. Because even though someone survived the ice berg, it wasn’t the end, there was a war encroaching right around the corner. Even without the Titanic and the war, just the challenges and hardships these young people went through kept my mind invested in their lives. For me it was a mixture of Dickens and Call the Midwifes; with orphans, and a bitter old rich aunt, selfless nurses, and some kind hearted families to show them love and faith. I loved this quote “He showed us how to live a bigger story than our own, to keep going, keep living and encouraging others to live until our last breath.” Definitely a 5 star rating.
July 24, 2014
I should start out by saying that this book was better than I thought it would be. I suppose I read too many bad reviews before I started it (a bad habit). But the good news is that it exceeded my expectations.
I thought the tale was original and imaginative, and not completely unrealistic. I liked how the author wove real-life people and events into the story to make it more believable.
I do have to agree with most of the bad reviewers that there was just too much heartache and turmoil overall in the book. It seemed like wave after wave of bad things happened, with only tiny moments of good. I wish the author had spent more time on the good events instead of drawing out the bad events.
I am glad they ended up together (spoiler!), but it was a little dissatisfying that their reunion was half of the last page in the whole book. We didn't even get a wedding story or an annoying "5 years in the future". It was like all of that turmoil, and that's all we get?
Like I said, it was better than I thought, but it could have been even better.
I thought the tale was original and imaginative, and not completely unrealistic. I liked how the author wove real-life people and events into the story to make it more believable.
I do have to agree with most of the bad reviewers that there was just too much heartache and turmoil overall in the book. It seemed like wave after wave of bad things happened, with only tiny moments of good. I wish the author had spent more time on the good events instead of drawing out the bad events.
I am glad they ended up together (spoiler!), but it was a little dissatisfying that their reunion was half of the last page in the whole book. We didn't even get a wedding story or an annoying "5 years in the future". It was like all of that turmoil, and that's all we get?
Like I said, it was better than I thought, but it could have been even better.
December 8, 2011
When Michael Dunnegan sneaks onto the Titanic, he can’t imagine how life-altering a decision that is going to be for him, or the long-term consequences. Annie Allen’s brother was one of the passengers who didn’t make it, and as Michael tries to fulfill a promise to take care of the brother’s family he finds himself more and more involved—and then the War breaks out in England and both Annie and Michael must find their way to each other, if they can stay alive.
This was my first time reading anything by Cathy Gohlke and I’ll definitely be looking for more of her books. Vivid settings, real emotion, intense conflict. All of these are packed into each scene so that you can’t put the novel down. The historical aspects of the novel were well done and following these characters as their lives changed was well worth it. An excellent read, highly recommended.
This was my first time reading anything by Cathy Gohlke and I’ll definitely be looking for more of her books. Vivid settings, real emotion, intense conflict. All of these are packed into each scene so that you can’t put the novel down. The historical aspects of the novel were well done and following these characters as their lives changed was well worth it. An excellent read, highly recommended.
January 23, 2016
This historical Christian novel covers a wide span of years from the sinking of the Titanic to the end of World War I and within that span of time, two young teenagers mature into young adults who eventually fall in love despite the poor beginnings of their friendship and who both truly learn how to surrender their burdens to Christ. I really liked the character development in this novel and also enjoyed the theme of sacrifice and what it truly means to live for Christ and for others that was weaved throughout the plot. I really enjoyed the novel, and it has won its place on my favorites' list.
January 3, 2016
I teach in a Christian high school & bought this to share with the readers in my classroom. The characters are well developed & interesting & lived through historical events (Titanic, Lusitania, WWI) that we don't hear as much about nowadays. Great read!
January 5, 2013
This book had me bawling and I stayed up late two nights in a row to finish it! Such a stellar story!
January 24, 2012
Annie Allen is devastated upon learning that her older brother Owen perished when the Titanic went down. Her only remaining family in England is Aunt Eleanor, and Annie has never been close to the bitter spinster. As details unfold, Annie learns that Owen requested a favor of a young street urchin and Titanic stowaway, Michael Dunnagan. Owen asked Michael to fulfill his American dream by going to Swainton, NJ, where Owen’s aunt and uncle own and operate Allen’s Run Gardens. He also requested that Michael bring Annie to America so she could start a new life, far from Eleanor’s disapproving eyes.
As Michael struggles to begin a new life stateside, he struggles under a heavy weight of guilt that he survived and Owen did not. He reaches out to Annie via letter, but she rebuffs his correspondence at first. Eventually though, she warms to Michael’s efforts to build a friendship and letters fly back and forth across the pond.
Michael works overtime to save enough money to bring Annie to NJ, only to see World War 1 erupt, making travel to and from England dangerous. In the meantime, Annie busies herself by training with the Red Cross, and she and a friend sign up to work with the Voluntary Aid Detachment in regional hospitals. As the war drags on, Michael is restless and more concerned for Annie’s safety, and embarks on a perilous journey across the Atlantic to see her. His arrival coincides with Aunt Eleanor’s mysterious dying wish that throws a cruel wrench in Annie’s plans to go to America.
Cathy Gohlke’s stories are not your average run of the mill, predictable fare. This Christy Award winning author has several books under her belt, with tales that envelop the reader with rich descriptions and intriguing plots. Promise Me This is no exception. Just about the time I thought it safe to turn a page and take a breath, Cathy ramped up the action with exciting twists and turns. As a fan of happy endings, I was relieved to see that these seemingly impossible knots were all happily untangled.
One of my favorite aspects of this book was that it was partially set in southern NJ, just minutes from where I grew up. Allen’s Run Gardens was fashioned after a real botanical garden in Swainton that we visited on numerous occasions. Cathy captures the essence of the area and era to lend authenticity to Annie and Michael’s emotional journey through tragedy and beyond.
I seldom give a five star rating to a book, but this one earned it and then some. In my opinion, Cathy Gohlke possesses the gift of bringing stories to life in an amazing way. If you haven’t already guessed, I highly recommend this book.
As Michael struggles to begin a new life stateside, he struggles under a heavy weight of guilt that he survived and Owen did not. He reaches out to Annie via letter, but she rebuffs his correspondence at first. Eventually though, she warms to Michael’s efforts to build a friendship and letters fly back and forth across the pond.
Michael works overtime to save enough money to bring Annie to NJ, only to see World War 1 erupt, making travel to and from England dangerous. In the meantime, Annie busies herself by training with the Red Cross, and she and a friend sign up to work with the Voluntary Aid Detachment in regional hospitals. As the war drags on, Michael is restless and more concerned for Annie’s safety, and embarks on a perilous journey across the Atlantic to see her. His arrival coincides with Aunt Eleanor’s mysterious dying wish that throws a cruel wrench in Annie’s plans to go to America.
Cathy Gohlke’s stories are not your average run of the mill, predictable fare. This Christy Award winning author has several books under her belt, with tales that envelop the reader with rich descriptions and intriguing plots. Promise Me This is no exception. Just about the time I thought it safe to turn a page and take a breath, Cathy ramped up the action with exciting twists and turns. As a fan of happy endings, I was relieved to see that these seemingly impossible knots were all happily untangled.
One of my favorite aspects of this book was that it was partially set in southern NJ, just minutes from where I grew up. Allen’s Run Gardens was fashioned after a real botanical garden in Swainton that we visited on numerous occasions. Cathy captures the essence of the area and era to lend authenticity to Annie and Michael’s emotional journey through tragedy and beyond.
I seldom give a five star rating to a book, but this one earned it and then some. In my opinion, Cathy Gohlke possesses the gift of bringing stories to life in an amazing way. If you haven’t already guessed, I highly recommend this book.
February 27, 2012
If you love historical novels you must read this new one by Christy Award winner, Cathy Gohlke. Promise Me This is a riveting story that begins with a journey on the Titanic and continues through WWI. In it, we meet Owen Allen—the loving, gentle man who tries his best to care for his little sister as well as the hungry teen boy he finds roaming the streets of London. Owen has a dream of a better life for his sister and sets out to meet distant relatives in America in order to make his dreams come true. His sister Annie has many hurdles to cross as she tries to make her way in the world after her brother’s untimely death. Then there is Michael Dunnagan, the hungry orphan who gets a chance at a better life because of Owen’s sacrifice.
While all of the characters are realistic and interesting I found myself especially drawn to Michael. The story of his beginnings and hardships fascinated me and I thrilled as I saw how he grasped the opportunities afforded him and created a better life for himself. His gratitude to Owen and his determination to become a good man just like him was very moving. Equally as moving were Owen’s sacrifices to assure that those he loved had a better chance at life. Annie’s character rounded out the story perfectly with her many struggles to protect her loved ones and survive insurmountable odds. In many ways, this novel reminded me of a Dickens tale with all the different characters and story lines woven together.
When you find a story that not only holds your attention but also has a satisfying ending, you feel your reading time was well spent. When you can also add to that the elements of Godly character, Christian sacrifice and spiritual growth of the people in the story you have found a rare and wonderful book to be read over and over as well as shared with others. This is such a book. I give it six out of five stars.
I received this complimentary copy from Tyndale House Publishers for this review. A positive review was not required and the opinions expressed here are my own.
While all of the characters are realistic and interesting I found myself especially drawn to Michael. The story of his beginnings and hardships fascinated me and I thrilled as I saw how he grasped the opportunities afforded him and created a better life for himself. His gratitude to Owen and his determination to become a good man just like him was very moving. Equally as moving were Owen’s sacrifices to assure that those he loved had a better chance at life. Annie’s character rounded out the story perfectly with her many struggles to protect her loved ones and survive insurmountable odds. In many ways, this novel reminded me of a Dickens tale with all the different characters and story lines woven together.
When you find a story that not only holds your attention but also has a satisfying ending, you feel your reading time was well spent. When you can also add to that the elements of Godly character, Christian sacrifice and spiritual growth of the people in the story you have found a rare and wonderful book to be read over and over as well as shared with others. This is such a book. I give it six out of five stars.
I received this complimentary copy from Tyndale House Publishers for this review. A positive review was not required and the opinions expressed here are my own.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 397 reviews