What do you think?
Rate this book
The Tapestry #4
The Maelstrom
The world is at the brink of ruin . . . or is it salvation? Astaroth has been weakened, and the demon Prusias is taking full advantage of the situation to create an empire of his own. His formidable armies are on the move, and Rowan is in their sights.
Rowan must rely on Max McDaniels and David Menlo and hope that their combined powers can stop Prusias's war machine before it's too late.
But even as perils loom, danger stalks their every move. Someone has marked Max for death and no one is above suspicion. Should the assassins succeed, Rowan's fate may depend on little Mina whose abilities are prodigious but largely untested.
And where is Astaroth? Has he fled this world or is he biding his time, awaiting his next opportunity?
In the Tapestry's fourth book, author-illustrator Henry H. Neff boldly raises the stakes in an epic tale of mankind's struggle to survive in a world now populated by demons and demigods and everything in between!
Rowan must rely on Max McDaniels and David Menlo and hope that their combined powers can stop Prusias's war machine before it's too late.
But even as perils loom, danger stalks their every move. Someone has marked Max for death and no one is above suspicion. Should the assassins succeed, Rowan's fate may depend on little Mina whose abilities are prodigious but largely untested.
And where is Astaroth? Has he fled this world or is he biding his time, awaiting his next opportunity?
In the Tapestry's fourth book, author-illustrator Henry H. Neff boldly raises the stakes in an epic tale of mankind's struggle to survive in a world now populated by demons and demigods and everything in between!
480 pages, Library Binding
First published October 23, 2012
91 people are currently reading
2265 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 182 reviews
October 28, 2012
Dear Mr. Neff,
Your book, "The Maelstron" ruined my life. This book is why didn't sleep the last two nights. This book is why my eyes are red this morning, and my face is stained with tears. This book is the reason why I have been having insane moodswings. This book was amazing. Literally breathtaking. I was excited for it to arrive, because all the Tapestry book are incredible, but once I started reading, I began to have doubts. "The Maelstrom" put me in so much rage, it made me weep non stop, it shocked me so much I feel out of my chair, (multiple times). This book was utterly genius. I can hardly put to words how much I feel for this book, my emotions about it are still too unstable.
So thank you, Henry H Neff, for writing brilliant literature, drawing fantastic illustrations, and thank you for existing.
Your book, "The Maelstron" ruined my life. This book is why didn't sleep the last two nights. This book is why my eyes are red this morning, and my face is stained with tears. This book is the reason why I have been having insane moodswings. This book was amazing. Literally breathtaking. I was excited for it to arrive, because all the Tapestry book are incredible, but once I started reading, I began to have doubts. "The Maelstrom" put me in so much rage, it made me weep non stop, it shocked me so much I feel out of my chair, (multiple times). This book was utterly genius. I can hardly put to words how much I feel for this book, my emotions about it are still too unstable.
So thank you, Henry H Neff, for writing brilliant literature, drawing fantastic illustrations, and thank you for existing.
November 12, 2012
Yesterday afternoon, I purchased my very own copy of "The Maelstrom", the fourth book in Mr. Henry Neff's beautiful Tapestry series.
And I finished it early this afternoon.
Of course, what can you expect form an avid fan of Henry Neff's remarkable books?
Three words: I loved it. I know, it's pretty vague but I don't know how else to put it.
Mr. Neff puts a spin on many chapters that leaves me gasping and hanging on the edge of my seat. The characters are beautifully written and so realistically thought of. You could see that every page of the book was meticulously written down, which made the characters and setting even more realistic.
You will see that Max McDaniels has grown into a strong leader and a budding young man. He will meet old allies, good friends, new enemies and old enemies as well.
And there might even be new romance as well...hmm, how very intriguing. And as usual, the little sorcerer, David Menlo still remains mysterious, but don't worry, we'll be spending a lot of time getting to know him better in this book (and yes, his love of coffee has gotten stronger). I found it very sweet that Mr. Neff really showed how much Max and David's friendship has grown.
If you've read the third book in the series, "The Fiend and the Forge", then you might remember the meek little orphan girl who touched our hearts: Mina. And of course she'll touch our hearts even more (just like she touched Max and David's) in "The Maelstrom", showing us her true powers and yet never forgetting the happiness and true joys in life.
So if you remember Mina, then you'll probably remember the mysterious and powerful man who appeared in the end of the third book and left it at a cliffhanger: Elias Bram. Yup, he's really back from the dead (but don't worry, he's not a zombie) and he's just as mysterious as his grandson, David.
As I read the book, I found myself gasping at the most suspenseful parts, laughing at the awkward and silly moments (giggling in the romantic ones) , shaking my head in pity, and tearing up at the parts that truly had an impact on my heart. Yes, Mr. Henry Neff truly has a gift with words, the way he crafts them into powerful beings, likable characters and beautiful settings, he pulls you into the story, feeding your imagination with pictures and words.
All in all, "The Maelstrom" is an engaging and suspenseful book, simply overflowing with emotion, humor, love and heart. With the realistic, lovable characters and his smart, interesting story-telling skills, fans of the books will not be disappointed, because I surely wasn't.
And I finished it early this afternoon.
Of course, what can you expect form an avid fan of Henry Neff's remarkable books?
Three words: I loved it. I know, it's pretty vague but I don't know how else to put it.
Mr. Neff puts a spin on many chapters that leaves me gasping and hanging on the edge of my seat. The characters are beautifully written and so realistically thought of. You could see that every page of the book was meticulously written down, which made the characters and setting even more realistic.
You will see that Max McDaniels has grown into a strong leader and a budding young man. He will meet old allies, good friends, new enemies and old enemies as well.
And there might even be new romance as well...hmm, how very intriguing. And as usual, the little sorcerer, David Menlo still remains mysterious, but don't worry, we'll be spending a lot of time getting to know him better in this book (and yes, his love of coffee has gotten stronger). I found it very sweet that Mr. Neff really showed how much Max and David's friendship has grown.
If you've read the third book in the series, "The Fiend and the Forge", then you might remember the meek little orphan girl who touched our hearts: Mina. And of course she'll touch our hearts even more (just like she touched Max and David's) in "The Maelstrom", showing us her true powers and yet never forgetting the happiness and true joys in life.
So if you remember Mina, then you'll probably remember the mysterious and powerful man who appeared in the end of the third book and left it at a cliffhanger: Elias Bram. Yup, he's really back from the dead (but don't worry, he's not a zombie) and he's just as mysterious as his grandson, David.
As I read the book, I found myself gasping at the most suspenseful parts, laughing at the awkward and silly moments (giggling in the romantic ones) , shaking my head in pity, and tearing up at the parts that truly had an impact on my heart. Yes, Mr. Henry Neff truly has a gift with words, the way he crafts them into powerful beings, likable characters and beautiful settings, he pulls you into the story, feeding your imagination with pictures and words.
All in all, "The Maelstrom" is an engaging and suspenseful book, simply overflowing with emotion, humor, love and heart. With the realistic, lovable characters and his smart, interesting story-telling skills, fans of the books will not be disappointed, because I surely wasn't.
October 25, 2012
There is no word that can completely describe the utter stunning, breathtaking, awesome, extraordinary, mind-blowing, jaw-dropping book that Henry H. Neff wrote. The Maelstrom is the best book I have ever read, period. The plot, the characters, the themes are so beautiful and complex that this story is a work of art.
The thing that makes this book so wonderful is how real it is, yes there are fantasy creatures, gods of old, magic ect. but there is such humanity in Max, such faults, that make his so much more human. He knows he can't win. There is no fan club rooting for the survival of any character, Mr. Neff moves that story as if it was real. He won't save a character or develop a character so that his readers are happy. This book is real, alive and raw. A trait that can be read on every page.
In this book, Max remains the beautiful and fierce fighter we all love but he matures in such bounds, that one can not but feel pride bubble in their chest. He becomes an amazing strategist, a clandestine, black-ops and battlefield war machine. He begins to realize and interpret the world around him in a much deeper way. The treat of the assassins, the Atrops don't seem to bother his hope and belief in life.
I can honestly say that every part of this book was my favorite. The part I relish in however, is how Mr.Neff got rid of Julie. I really didn't like her and max together, she was a needy, stupid girl who did nothing. I don't want to give away too much but Max's new love interest is the most amazing thing that ever happened to him, happiness wise. Although, their love is a little rushed.
Spoiler Alert****
Scáthach is the an amazing addition, Max is finally with someone who is as awesome as he is.
The thing that makes this book so wonderful is how real it is, yes there are fantasy creatures, gods of old, magic ect. but there is such humanity in Max, such faults, that make his so much more human. He knows he can't win. There is no fan club rooting for the survival of any character, Mr. Neff moves that story as if it was real. He won't save a character or develop a character so that his readers are happy. This book is real, alive and raw. A trait that can be read on every page.
In this book, Max remains the beautiful and fierce fighter we all love but he matures in such bounds, that one can not but feel pride bubble in their chest. He becomes an amazing strategist, a clandestine, black-ops and battlefield war machine. He begins to realize and interpret the world around him in a much deeper way. The treat of the assassins, the Atrops don't seem to bother his hope and belief in life.
I can honestly say that every part of this book was my favorite. The part I relish in however, is how Mr.Neff got rid of Julie. I really didn't like her and max together, she was a needy, stupid girl who did nothing. I don't want to give away too much but Max's new love interest is the most amazing thing that ever happened to him, happiness wise. Although, their love is a little rushed.
Spoiler Alert****
Scáthach is the an amazing addition, Max is finally with someone who is as awesome as he is.
September 1, 2019
"Some people are born great, but no one is born good. That is a choice they must make for themselves."
—The Maelstrom, P. 438
Being ruled for eternity by the Demon known as Astaroth seemed inevitable until Walpurgisnacht; that night, David Menlo freed Elias Bram, the sorcerer who imprisoned Astaroth centuries ago and is the only one who could possibly foil his plans now. Victory for David, Max McDaniels, and Rowan Academy is far from assured, however. Prusias, King of Blys, is more powerful than ever in the aftermath of Walpurgisnacht; the dragon king sends a liaison to extract an oath from Rowan's Director, Gabrielle Richter, that the school will obey Prusias no matter what. Prusias will not await Ms. Richter's formal acceptance of this demand for long; refusal to capitulate will be a death sentence for everyone at Rowan once Prusias marshals his enormous army against them. Max and David embark on a mission to a distant land to meet with Madam Petra Kosa, a wealthy smuggler who may have a lead on how to puncture Prusias's veneer of invulnerability. Without some secret advantage, the dragon king's soldiers will overwhelm Rowan.
The journey to the home of Petra and her preteen daughter Katarina is filled with adventure, but the situation at Rowan is worse by the time Max returns. Elias Bram, the most powerful being on campus, is focusing all his attention on Astaroth, leaving Rowan to prepare without him for Prusias's imminent attack. William Cooper, an Agent for the Red Branch and one of Rowan's top covert operatives, is missing and suspected to be possessed by an evil spirit allied with the Atropos, an organization of assassins thought to have been killed off hundreds of years ago. Rumor has it that the Atropos is back, and have targeted Max by writing his name in their Grey Book. This means the Atropos have sworn to kill him, and they are known to never give up on a target even if it takes centuries to finish the job. The threat to Max couldn't be more serious.
"A warrior craves honor and excellence, not a measure of mild years. Those who cringe at death are half dead themselves; they forever keep to the shallows of life!"
—The Maelstrom, P. 337
Drama surrounds Rowan as the school braces for Prusias's onslaught once his army crosses the sea. Max must be constantly on guard against assassins sent by the Atropos, but he is also called upon to help train Rowan's freedom fighters. They come from many social factions and aren't all on good terms with Rowan's leadership, but blending them into a united front is essential if there's any possibility of defeating Prusias. David Menlo is spreading himself thin trying to crack the code of Prusias's dominant weapon of war; it's true that David is Elias Bram's grandson, but he rarely gets a rest from the demands on his talents and energy. When not training soldiers, Max must deal with secret overtures made to him by Astaroth. Prusias is without equal among the monarchs installed by Astaroth, but the Demon could annihilate Prusias if he were of a mind to. What can Max offer that would convince Astaroth to turn against the King of Blys? Thousands will die if war reaches Rowan, but that may be unavoidable if the school is to continue as humanity's last bastion of freedom. Can Max and his colleagues win this war against Astaroth's most potent underling?
"War breaks many things...It can break bodies and hearts. It can break promises, too. But it can't break spirits...not if those who are fighting believe in their cause."
—The Maelstrom, P. 436
Like the three previous books of the Tapestry series, The Maelstrom is low-energy but offers a few intriguing fantasy elements. There's more romance, which makes sense as Max nears adulthood. His mandate to mold the "Trench Rats" into dependable warriors is an important part of this novel; the Trench Rats feel disrespected by Rowan's elites because most of them are refugees and orphans. They hold tightly to their resentment, but Rowan can't stave off Prusias without them, and getting these proud young fighters on board with the academy's plan is Max's responsibility. It's remarkable what a group of disenchanted loners can become if they're treated properly. The Maelstrom isn't an exciting or immersive read, but I'm all in on Max's story by this point, and hope someday to read the conclusion, The Red Winter. I want to see how the story plays out.
—The Maelstrom, P. 438
Being ruled for eternity by the Demon known as Astaroth seemed inevitable until Walpurgisnacht; that night, David Menlo freed Elias Bram, the sorcerer who imprisoned Astaroth centuries ago and is the only one who could possibly foil his plans now. Victory for David, Max McDaniels, and Rowan Academy is far from assured, however. Prusias, King of Blys, is more powerful than ever in the aftermath of Walpurgisnacht; the dragon king sends a liaison to extract an oath from Rowan's Director, Gabrielle Richter, that the school will obey Prusias no matter what. Prusias will not await Ms. Richter's formal acceptance of this demand for long; refusal to capitulate will be a death sentence for everyone at Rowan once Prusias marshals his enormous army against them. Max and David embark on a mission to a distant land to meet with Madam Petra Kosa, a wealthy smuggler who may have a lead on how to puncture Prusias's veneer of invulnerability. Without some secret advantage, the dragon king's soldiers will overwhelm Rowan.
The journey to the home of Petra and her preteen daughter Katarina is filled with adventure, but the situation at Rowan is worse by the time Max returns. Elias Bram, the most powerful being on campus, is focusing all his attention on Astaroth, leaving Rowan to prepare without him for Prusias's imminent attack. William Cooper, an Agent for the Red Branch and one of Rowan's top covert operatives, is missing and suspected to be possessed by an evil spirit allied with the Atropos, an organization of assassins thought to have been killed off hundreds of years ago. Rumor has it that the Atropos is back, and have targeted Max by writing his name in their Grey Book. This means the Atropos have sworn to kill him, and they are known to never give up on a target even if it takes centuries to finish the job. The threat to Max couldn't be more serious.
"A warrior craves honor and excellence, not a measure of mild years. Those who cringe at death are half dead themselves; they forever keep to the shallows of life!"
—The Maelstrom, P. 337
Drama surrounds Rowan as the school braces for Prusias's onslaught once his army crosses the sea. Max must be constantly on guard against assassins sent by the Atropos, but he is also called upon to help train Rowan's freedom fighters. They come from many social factions and aren't all on good terms with Rowan's leadership, but blending them into a united front is essential if there's any possibility of defeating Prusias. David Menlo is spreading himself thin trying to crack the code of Prusias's dominant weapon of war; it's true that David is Elias Bram's grandson, but he rarely gets a rest from the demands on his talents and energy. When not training soldiers, Max must deal with secret overtures made to him by Astaroth. Prusias is without equal among the monarchs installed by Astaroth, but the Demon could annihilate Prusias if he were of a mind to. What can Max offer that would convince Astaroth to turn against the King of Blys? Thousands will die if war reaches Rowan, but that may be unavoidable if the school is to continue as humanity's last bastion of freedom. Can Max and his colleagues win this war against Astaroth's most potent underling?
"War breaks many things...It can break bodies and hearts. It can break promises, too. But it can't break spirits...not if those who are fighting believe in their cause."
—The Maelstrom, P. 436
Like the three previous books of the Tapestry series, The Maelstrom is low-energy but offers a few intriguing fantasy elements. There's more romance, which makes sense as Max nears adulthood. His mandate to mold the "Trench Rats" into dependable warriors is an important part of this novel; the Trench Rats feel disrespected by Rowan's elites because most of them are refugees and orphans. They hold tightly to their resentment, but Rowan can't stave off Prusias without them, and getting these proud young fighters on board with the academy's plan is Max's responsibility. It's remarkable what a group of disenchanted loners can become if they're treated properly. The Maelstrom isn't an exciting or immersive read, but I'm all in on Max's story by this point, and hope someday to read the conclusion, The Red Winter. I want to see how the story plays out.
July 7, 2020
This is a brilliantly crafted story, with an incredible, immersive world and magnificent characters. The pacing, the tone, everything was spot on. Over the previous books, some characters seemed slow to develop, but now they feel like old friends. It is a sin these books are not topping best sellers lists. This series checks all my boxes: a rich fantasy world, magic, mythology, science fiction, political intrigue, adventure, philosophizing on what it means to be human, beautiful relationships, and the power of fighting for what is right and good. I don’t want it to end, but I can’t wait for the finale!
May 12, 2023
The Maelstrom is an engaging young adult novel by Henry Neff that combines elements of fantasy, adventure, and mystery. The story follows the young protagonist, Max McDaniels, as he navigates a dangerous and fantastical world filled with ancient artifacts, magical creatures, and mysterious villains. While the book has several positive aspects, it also has a few shortcomings that may detract from the overall reading experience.
One of the strengths of The Maelstrom is its well-developed world-building. Neff creates a rich and imaginative universe filled with complex histories and unique cultures. The magical artifacts and creatures introduced throughout the book are intricately detailed and add depth to the story. Additionally, the action sequences are well-written and exciting, keeping readers engaged and invested in the story.
Another positive aspect of the book is its character development. Max McDaniels is a relatable and likable protagonist, and his growth throughout the book feels organic and believable. The supporting cast of characters is also well-developed, with each character having their own distinct personality and motivations.
However, there are some negative aspects of The Maelstrom that should be mentioned. One of the most significant issues is the pacing of the book. At times, the plot can feel slow and meandering, with long stretches of exposition and world-building that may not be interesting to some readers. Additionally, some of the plot twists and revelations feel predictable and may not surprise more seasoned readers of the fantasy genre.
Overall, The Maelstrom is a solid young adult novel that will likely appeal to fans of fantasy and adventure. Its imaginative world-building and engaging characters make it a worthwhile read, despite its pacing issues and predictable plot twists.
One of the strengths of The Maelstrom is its well-developed world-building. Neff creates a rich and imaginative universe filled with complex histories and unique cultures. The magical artifacts and creatures introduced throughout the book are intricately detailed and add depth to the story. Additionally, the action sequences are well-written and exciting, keeping readers engaged and invested in the story.
Another positive aspect of the book is its character development. Max McDaniels is a relatable and likable protagonist, and his growth throughout the book feels organic and believable. The supporting cast of characters is also well-developed, with each character having their own distinct personality and motivations.
However, there are some negative aspects of The Maelstrom that should be mentioned. One of the most significant issues is the pacing of the book. At times, the plot can feel slow and meandering, with long stretches of exposition and world-building that may not be interesting to some readers. Additionally, some of the plot twists and revelations feel predictable and may not surprise more seasoned readers of the fantasy genre.
Overall, The Maelstrom is a solid young adult novel that will likely appeal to fans of fantasy and adventure. Its imaginative world-building and engaging characters make it a worthwhile read, despite its pacing issues and predictable plot twists.
July 30, 2024
I like that everything has had a purpose. The blood that Max gave the Workshop has become clones that have played a big part in the third book and now the fourth as well. We learn a lot about the world too as there is a lot of exploring the world and we get to see what it's like. I love that we get even more insight into Astaroth and what he wants as well with the conversation he has with Max. I wasn't a huge fan of the romances David and Max had- especially in this book with Cynthia and Scathach- it just feels rushed and thrown in there simply to give them romantic interests. I like that it leaves you with the characters setting off with a plan, it doesn't exactly feel like a photo finish but more like you're seeing a little part of the lives of the characters, that will continue on with their lives even after you're done with the story.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
February 3, 2019
"I'm a god," he whispered, steam coursing off his body. "A god of war and blood and victory. Every day I grow stronger. I'll drive every army before me. My enemies will know fear like they've never known it before..."
Rating: 3.75 stars
Is it just me, or is there only so much raising of the stakes an author can do before it becomes repetitive? Don't get me wrong, I love the BA Max moments, but it seems that twice every book the situation becomes serious like it hadn't been before, and it gives it an overwhelming Boy Who Cried Wolf vibe. I think this stems from the concerns I had about the second book. The second book raised the stakes so much, that by the time you get to the fourth book there's not much more that can be done to make the plot of the book more urgent and austere.
I do commend this book for the series' overall improvement in the character arena. I felt that the characters were much more interactive and relatable than in the first three books. I did have some issues with the romance. Julie and Max are together for a few months, and suddenly it's the end of the world for Julie when Max comes back? And like, she's mad at him even though the reason he left was to save the world? And she's still in love with him even though they stopped dating over two years ago and now she's engaged to someone new? And then Scathach just comes in and Max and her are both like "I have such feelings for you pls be with me" even though they barely had non-professional contact before this book??? I don't know if it's just me and my ignorance of Irish mythology, but when Scathach was described in Book 3 I had definitely imagined her as a female version of Chiron from Greek mythology - a wizened older warrior who trains the young 'uns. In short, my brain completely rejected the Max-Scathach relationship.
Still, I can appreciate the characters by themselves, and their friendships better, particularly Max and David as individuals and their relationship. I like how the Old Magic brings them together, and the central conflict feels more like a team effort than a spotlight on Max throughout the book. I appreciated Sarah, Lucia, and Cynthia, although I think we would've gotten more development out of them if they had been more prominent in previous books.
Also, can I just say that I'm a big fan of Astaroth as an antagonist? He's so complex. He doesn't act evil, just manipulative. Astaroth isn't a Voldemort or a Kronos or a President Snow, who are all so outwardly wicked and are trying to take down our protagonist at each encounter. He makes bargains and has vendettas and is overall just sneaky. He only is really cruel when someone steps in his way, unlike Prusias who will kill because it's fun. I wish this series had more of Astaroth as the main villain instead of Prusias, who is predictable and annoying.
But the Old Magic was growing stronger... and in the gae bolga, it had a new and potent ally. Unless Max discovered new reserves of will, this was a battle he would someday lose.
What a setup for Book 5! I expect the next installment to include this "someday", and I look forward to picking it up soon.
Rating: 3.75 stars
Is it just me, or is there only so much raising of the stakes an author can do before it becomes repetitive? Don't get me wrong, I love the BA Max moments, but it seems that twice every book the situation becomes serious like it hadn't been before, and it gives it an overwhelming Boy Who Cried Wolf vibe. I think this stems from the concerns I had about the second book. The second book raised the stakes so much, that by the time you get to the fourth book there's not much more that can be done to make the plot of the book more urgent and austere.
I do commend this book for the series' overall improvement in the character arena. I felt that the characters were much more interactive and relatable than in the first three books. I did have some issues with the romance. Julie and Max are together for a few months, and suddenly it's the end of the world for Julie when Max comes back? And like, she's mad at him even though the reason he left was to save the world? And she's still in love with him even though they stopped dating over two years ago and now she's engaged to someone new? And then Scathach just comes in and Max and her are both like "I have such feelings for you pls be with me" even though they barely had non-professional contact before this book??? I don't know if it's just me and my ignorance of Irish mythology, but when Scathach was described in Book 3 I had definitely imagined her as a female version of Chiron from Greek mythology - a wizened older warrior who trains the young 'uns. In short, my brain completely rejected the Max-Scathach relationship.
Still, I can appreciate the characters by themselves, and their friendships better, particularly Max and David as individuals and their relationship. I like how the Old Magic brings them together, and the central conflict feels more like a team effort than a spotlight on Max throughout the book. I appreciated Sarah, Lucia, and Cynthia, although I think we would've gotten more development out of them if they had been more prominent in previous books.
Also, can I just say that I'm a big fan of Astaroth as an antagonist? He's so complex. He doesn't act evil, just manipulative. Astaroth isn't a Voldemort or a Kronos or a President Snow, who are all so outwardly wicked and are trying to take down our protagonist at each encounter. He makes bargains and has vendettas and is overall just sneaky. He only is really cruel when someone steps in his way, unlike Prusias who will kill because it's fun. I wish this series had more of Astaroth as the main villain instead of Prusias, who is predictable and annoying.
But the Old Magic was growing stronger... and in the gae bolga, it had a new and potent ally. Unless Max discovered new reserves of will, this was a battle he would someday lose.
What a setup for Book 5! I expect the next installment to include this "someday", and I look forward to picking it up soon.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
November 26, 2012
As an avid fan of The Tapestry series, I eagerly awaited the arrival of The Maelstrom. It was more than I even hoped for! In this fourth installment, the series moves into epic territory. Some of my favorite elements: After being on separate adventures in The Fiend and the Forge, the duo are reunited. And, truly, it feels so good! I really enjoyed seeing them rekindle their friendship and spur each other on in matters from mystic and demonic to romantic and even silly. Yes, The Maelstrom covers some serious territory as Rowan races the clock in preparation for war with Prusias. But once again, Neff does an excellent job of peppering humor throughout--there are plenty of laugh-out-loud moments for comic relief (many thanks to Toby the Smee, an absolutely genius character). We also get reacquainted with the old gang: Cynthia, Lucia, Sarah, Yaya, Tweedy...even a cameo by an under-the-weather Kettlemouth! Along with old favorites, we learn more about newer characters like Elias Bram and little Mina, the mysterious girl Max saved from the farmhouse in Blys...and a mystic to rival David. Another welcome addition is Umbra, a refugee who seems to be as fierce as Max himself. And Nox, about whom I will say no more, but whose appearance may bring a tear your your eye and a smile to your heart. Incredible new creatures, creepy new demons, revealing backstories and sparks of young love. There is so much to enjoy throughout this book, and it all builds to a truly EPIC battle that will have you on the edge of your seat! With The Maelstrom, Neff is certainly hitting his stride as a writer and storyteller. I can't wait to see how he brings it all to a close in The Red Winter!
September 22, 2013
As noted about the other volumes in this work I hesitate about the YA fantasy shelf. It is considered YA, but I urge parents and guardians to read these first to be sure they are appropriate for the youth you have in mind.
Well, things have come to a head in some ways. Rowan is a (supposedly) independent kingdom but now that push has comer to shove (I assume you have read the volume preceding this one) the demons who rule the rest of the world are somewhat...displeased. They have decided to enforce their will and give Rowan a list of demands that must be met otherwise they will invade and then things will get somewhat unpleasant.
Strangely among their list of demands they don't demand Max. You see the most deadly group of assassins in the world have written Max's name in their "book". No one ever...ever gets away from these assassins.
Things don't look good.
Having already gone through one siege that defeated them can Rowen survive this...can Max?
These are good, readable, well constructed books. There is a decidedly young feel to the story itself but there are elements that are very dark and painful. I find that the way the mythology of Ireland, the Celts and others is handled in a way here that doesn't "burn" me as some other's handling of them.
This one "sort of" closes a part of the story but sets up what looks to be the extended climax of the saga. Sadly this is the last book in print...back to waiting for the next book to be published.
sigh.
Well, things have come to a head in some ways. Rowan is a (supposedly) independent kingdom but now that push has comer to shove (I assume you have read the volume preceding this one) the demons who rule the rest of the world are somewhat...displeased. They have decided to enforce their will and give Rowan a list of demands that must be met otherwise they will invade and then things will get somewhat unpleasant.
Strangely among their list of demands they don't demand Max. You see the most deadly group of assassins in the world have written Max's name in their "book". No one ever...ever gets away from these assassins.
Things don't look good.
Having already gone through one siege that defeated them can Rowen survive this...can Max?
These are good, readable, well constructed books. There is a decidedly young feel to the story itself but there are elements that are very dark and painful. I find that the way the mythology of Ireland, the Celts and others is handled in a way here that doesn't "burn" me as some other's handling of them.
This one "sort of" closes a part of the story but sets up what looks to be the extended climax of the saga. Sadly this is the last book in print...back to waiting for the next book to be published.
sigh.
Want to read
October 2, 2012HOW ARE YOU RATING A BOOK THAT HASNT COME OUT YET
November 2, 2012
Loved it.
Can't wait for the next book to come out.
The only bad thing about the book is that it ends on a cliff-hanger
Can't wait for the next book to come out.
The only bad thing about the book is that it ends on a cliff-hanger
January 18, 2014
3.5 stars to The Maelstrrom. Judging from the other ratings for this book, I feel I am in the minority. So I will start by saying that I enjoyed this book. A lot. Mr. Neff has created a series that I've followed with eager interest and anticipation. I truly can't wait for the final book and see how he wraps everything up.
So why the average rating? I will explain, but be warned I will give away major spoilers, so if you haven't read this book but are planning to do so, stop now. Also, this review kind of drones on about one thing I had a bee in my bonnet and I apologize in advance.
There are a few threads in this book that didn't satisfy me and/or left me with a furrowed brow--literally. I also confess that it took me several weeks to finish this book. I did enjoy it, but at times I wondered why it stretched on and on n certain parts.
Anyway, my first gripe is the romantic subplot. Anyone who has read my previous reviews will know that I'm a big romantic. I love romance novels and I also adore books that aren't specifically romance, but have a strong and positive romantic subplot.
For myself, I've suspected that Max never really cared for his ex-girlfriend, Julie Teller, the same way she did about him. In life, this happens. And as in this book, the two went their separate ways. Julie's parents didn't want her dating a character that was always surrounded by danger. Max agreed, but in truth, he was thinking his ability to break off with Julie so easily had more to do with his heart being engaged elsewhere.
To me, I wasn't surprised, although disappointed. I'm one of those readers that I latch on to certain characters and who they're paired up with romantically and hope that they'll be together to the end. In the case of Max and Julie, I saw the writing on the wall and knew this would not be a Harry Potter-Ginny Weezly kind of deal. However, as I mentioned, I was okay with this. What I had a hard time coming to terms with is that in this fourth book, Max finds that Scathach, the female who trained him in the other dimension, has come to Rowan to look out for him. Both of them verbally acknowledge feelings, and it is obvious that Max is thrilled by the turn of events.
I want to say that when I concluded the book and mulled over the final pages, I realize that I like the turn of events. I'm more than all right with Max and Scathach and how Mr Neff made it so that she was able to join the Red Branch and be alongside Max. If I'm to understand what being in the Red Branch means, Red Branch members will live for a long, long time, and only pass on when they pass their Red Branch membership to another person. If I have this part wrong, I hope someone will correct me. But this is what I understood. So Scathach and Max both being members means that the two of them are equals. As a romantic couple it wouldn't be one member always running off into danger while the other, weaker half stays out of the fray and worries. Love it.
I know this review is going on, so I'll get to my point and digress back to the Max-Julie thing. I was and still am unsettled at how Max and Julie parted. Julie comes to see Max and the two of them clear the air. However, to me, it seems that Julie still has lingering feelings for Max, but knows that her future is not with him. She has chosen Thomas, a steady man who cares deeply for her. She doesn't love him the way she should, but she'll take that over a rocky romance with Max. Putting aside the fact that Max doesn't feel the same way about Julie. I feel it's almost unfair that Max finds his love, but Julie is just...well, again, she's settling for Thomas
I apologize for rambling in this review. I know some will roll their eyes and say, come on, this is how it works sometimes. As I mentioned, I'm a romantic. If I can't have the couple I originally wanted together, I'd at least hope that the two could separate as friends and go on to find their soulmates. I got one part of my wish, but not the other. And, if I may speculate, the war isn't over. Who knows if Max or Scathach will survive the final book? From the way that Mr. Neff isn't shy about making noteable characters die, I'm not counting on anything.
Also, a small note. I'm puzzled by the sudden romantic coupling of David and Cynthia. To me this came out of the blue. I'm suspecting it may have been something added to turn the story back to romantic couples and thus, the Max and Scathach thing could be brought up and it not seem so odd. But to me, it seemed out of place. I'm not upset by it. I just feel it was kind of out-of-the-blue and kind of took me off guard. I'm sure Mr. Neff had his reasons for doing this. Again, I'm not unhappy by it. It was just the abruptness of it all.
Now that I've said all that, the other parts of this book that I feel conflicted are thus: I will probably go back and read it again, but the explanation that David gives on how he figured out how to stop the imps destroying Rowan is murky. I'm still not quite clear on the explanation, and furthermore, how Mina, the young Child that Max brought to Rowan comes walking out and does what Max and David combined couldn't do--take down Prusias with hardly any effort and send him into a retreat.
The other things is Elias Bram. He's released from the prison of Astaroth and livs at Rowan. He keeps to himself and makes no effort in helping defend Rowan when Prusias's army attacks. I'm sure things will be revealed in the final book, but to me, I'm only confused. This character contributed little to the plot. He was simply there. I mean no disrespect. I'm sure he's vital. But why have a powerful magic-user like Bram if he's not going to at least help the citizens of Rowan when it was on the brink of destruction? Almost 500 Rowan citizens perished, including some well-known characters.
Overall, despite my rating, I really liked the book. I'm looking forward to the final one. No matter what the outcome, this is definitely a series to read.
So why the average rating? I will explain, but be warned I will give away major spoilers, so if you haven't read this book but are planning to do so, stop now. Also, this review kind of drones on about one thing I had a bee in my bonnet and I apologize in advance.
There are a few threads in this book that didn't satisfy me and/or left me with a furrowed brow--literally. I also confess that it took me several weeks to finish this book. I did enjoy it, but at times I wondered why it stretched on and on n certain parts.
Anyway, my first gripe is the romantic subplot. Anyone who has read my previous reviews will know that I'm a big romantic. I love romance novels and I also adore books that aren't specifically romance, but have a strong and positive romantic subplot.
For myself, I've suspected that Max never really cared for his ex-girlfriend, Julie Teller, the same way she did about him. In life, this happens. And as in this book, the two went their separate ways. Julie's parents didn't want her dating a character that was always surrounded by danger. Max agreed, but in truth, he was thinking his ability to break off with Julie so easily had more to do with his heart being engaged elsewhere.
To me, I wasn't surprised, although disappointed. I'm one of those readers that I latch on to certain characters and who they're paired up with romantically and hope that they'll be together to the end. In the case of Max and Julie, I saw the writing on the wall and knew this would not be a Harry Potter-Ginny Weezly kind of deal. However, as I mentioned, I was okay with this. What I had a hard time coming to terms with is that in this fourth book, Max finds that Scathach, the female who trained him in the other dimension, has come to Rowan to look out for him. Both of them verbally acknowledge feelings, and it is obvious that Max is thrilled by the turn of events.
I want to say that when I concluded the book and mulled over the final pages, I realize that I like the turn of events. I'm more than all right with Max and Scathach and how Mr Neff made it so that she was able to join the Red Branch and be alongside Max. If I'm to understand what being in the Red Branch means, Red Branch members will live for a long, long time, and only pass on when they pass their Red Branch membership to another person. If I have this part wrong, I hope someone will correct me. But this is what I understood. So Scathach and Max both being members means that the two of them are equals. As a romantic couple it wouldn't be one member always running off into danger while the other, weaker half stays out of the fray and worries. Love it.
I know this review is going on, so I'll get to my point and digress back to the Max-Julie thing. I was and still am unsettled at how Max and Julie parted. Julie comes to see Max and the two of them clear the air. However, to me, it seems that Julie still has lingering feelings for Max, but knows that her future is not with him. She has chosen Thomas, a steady man who cares deeply for her. She doesn't love him the way she should, but she'll take that over a rocky romance with Max. Putting aside the fact that Max doesn't feel the same way about Julie. I feel it's almost unfair that Max finds his love, but Julie is just...well, again, she's settling for Thomas
I apologize for rambling in this review. I know some will roll their eyes and say, come on, this is how it works sometimes. As I mentioned, I'm a romantic. If I can't have the couple I originally wanted together, I'd at least hope that the two could separate as friends and go on to find their soulmates. I got one part of my wish, but not the other. And, if I may speculate, the war isn't over. Who knows if Max or Scathach will survive the final book? From the way that Mr. Neff isn't shy about making noteable characters die, I'm not counting on anything.
Also, a small note. I'm puzzled by the sudden romantic coupling of David and Cynthia. To me this came out of the blue. I'm suspecting it may have been something added to turn the story back to romantic couples and thus, the Max and Scathach thing could be brought up and it not seem so odd. But to me, it seemed out of place. I'm not upset by it. I just feel it was kind of out-of-the-blue and kind of took me off guard. I'm sure Mr. Neff had his reasons for doing this. Again, I'm not unhappy by it. It was just the abruptness of it all.
Now that I've said all that, the other parts of this book that I feel conflicted are thus: I will probably go back and read it again, but the explanation that David gives on how he figured out how to stop the imps destroying Rowan is murky. I'm still not quite clear on the explanation, and furthermore, how Mina, the young Child that Max brought to Rowan comes walking out and does what Max and David combined couldn't do--take down Prusias with hardly any effort and send him into a retreat.
The other things is Elias Bram. He's released from the prison of Astaroth and livs at Rowan. He keeps to himself and makes no effort in helping defend Rowan when Prusias's army attacks. I'm sure things will be revealed in the final book, but to me, I'm only confused. This character contributed little to the plot. He was simply there. I mean no disrespect. I'm sure he's vital. But why have a powerful magic-user like Bram if he's not going to at least help the citizens of Rowan when it was on the brink of destruction? Almost 500 Rowan citizens perished, including some well-known characters.
Overall, despite my rating, I really liked the book. I'm looking forward to the final one. No matter what the outcome, this is definitely a series to read.
May 17, 2022
บ้าไปแล้ว!!!!
เล่มนี้เล่นใหญ่สุด ๆ ใส่มหาสงครามสเกล WWII ลงมาในโลกแฟนตาซีได้อลังการมาก
นอกจาก็ความตื่นเต้นของการเดินเรื่องแล้ว การที่เล่มนี้กลับมาอุดมด้วยอารมณ์ขันอีกครั้งนี่เป็นอะไรที่โคตรรักเลย
เหนืออื่นใดเราชอบมุมมองที่ผู้เขียนมองโลกชะมัด หลาย ๆ เรื่องนี่เห็นด้วยสุดลิ่ม ยิ่งเรื่องระบบการ���ึกษาที่ตัดเกรดแบบอิงกลุ่มเป็นเรื่องไร้สาระ ปราศจากประสิทธิภาพใด ๆ นี่เราโคตรเห็นด้วยจริงๆ
เล่มนี้เล่นใหญ่สุด ๆ ใส่มหาสงครามสเกล WWII ลงมาในโลกแฟนตาซีได้อลังการมาก
นอกจาก็ความตื่นเต้นของการเดินเรื่องแล้ว การที่เล่มนี้กลับมาอุดมด้วยอารมณ์ขันอีกครั้งนี่เป็นอะไรที่โคตรรักเลย
เหนืออื่นใดเราชอบมุมมองที่ผู้เขียนมองโลกชะมัด หลาย ๆ เรื่องนี่เห็นด้วยสุดลิ่ม ยิ่งเรื่องระบบการ���ึกษาที่ตัดเกรดแบบอิงกลุ่มเป็นเรื่องไร้สาระ ปราศจากประสิทธิภาพใด ๆ นี่เราโคตรเห็นด้วยจริงๆ
May 19, 2023
By this point in the series most of the childish plot points and teenage drama are gone, which I was pleased to see. The universe this story lives in is well established and it is interesting to see how it evolves as things unfold. The new characters that get introduced bring a fresh new flavor while the familiar old characters remain deeply relatable (as much as sorcerers and epic warriors can be).
February 19, 2025
Some real pathos in this one
June 3, 2015
As The Maelstrom by Henry H. Neff opens, war is on the horizon. After protagonist Max's arch-enemy, the demon Prusias, gained the Book of Thoth and the ability to change the past, present and future, Earth has been turned upside down. Normal society no longer exists, technology has been rewinded and most humans live in a world similar to medieval times. Rowan, a school for those with mystic (magical) abilities has become a haven, taking in refugees and trying to escape the notice of the demons' grandiose plans. However, with defiant acts from certain individuals, the may have to face war whether they want to or not. As the book progresses, Max tries to prepare himself and his friends for the inevitable rebellion that will have a high price.
Besides creating a vibrant setting, Neff is skilled at setting a mood or atmosphere, a vital part of a setting that is often missed. For example, when Max discovers that a character is not who they seem, Neff sets a mood of slight suspense, familiarity, and a certain peace (Max discovers a friend). "Max had seen the caravan before. It sat alone on a shallow rise at the edge of the woods, shaded by the boughs of an ancient oak and rooted to the spot by many brambles that twisted and wined through its spokes. Its door faced east, its planks worn and weathered by sun and sea. No lights peeked from the inside." "Lighting a lantern, Scathach hung it from a chain. The caravan must have belonged to a fortune teller once, for upon the walls were faded images of towers and chariots, hermits and the gallows. The caravan was old, but it was snug and neat with a small bed and tiny table with a single chair." Neff also incorporates details about the setting into his action. "Disoriented, he gazed helplessly about, unable to see anything until an arc of brilliant light suddenly tore through the darkness." This gives the reader a sense of how Max is experiencing the setting. Also, because Neff's setting descriptions are dispersed throughout the text, the reader is less likely to skim over them. Neff imaginative worlds also contribute to the setting. When Max is overseas trying to coordinate spy work and gain allies for a possible war, he meets Madam Petra and her slightly grusome home. "It was almost a minute before Max observed the heads. There were seven of them in total, each spitted on tall poles placed throughout the gardens. They were in various states of decomposition, some little more than skulls while others were jarringly fresh. Four of the heads had belonged to goblins, two were human, and the last possessed the feral, wolfish face of a vye. When Toby finally noticed them, he nearly fainted." Through creating an atmosphere, dispersing discriptions of the setting throughout the action, and creating imanginative worlds, Neff creates a vibrant picture of The Maelstrom's world.
Besides creating a vibrant setting, Neff is skilled at setting a mood or atmosphere, a vital part of a setting that is often missed. For example, when Max discovers that a character is not who they seem, Neff sets a mood of slight suspense, familiarity, and a certain peace (Max discovers a friend). "Max had seen the caravan before. It sat alone on a shallow rise at the edge of the woods, shaded by the boughs of an ancient oak and rooted to the spot by many brambles that twisted and wined through its spokes. Its door faced east, its planks worn and weathered by sun and sea. No lights peeked from the inside." "Lighting a lantern, Scathach hung it from a chain. The caravan must have belonged to a fortune teller once, for upon the walls were faded images of towers and chariots, hermits and the gallows. The caravan was old, but it was snug and neat with a small bed and tiny table with a single chair." Neff also incorporates details about the setting into his action. "Disoriented, he gazed helplessly about, unable to see anything until an arc of brilliant light suddenly tore through the darkness." This gives the reader a sense of how Max is experiencing the setting. Also, because Neff's setting descriptions are dispersed throughout the text, the reader is less likely to skim over them. Neff imaginative worlds also contribute to the setting. When Max is overseas trying to coordinate spy work and gain allies for a possible war, he meets Madam Petra and her slightly grusome home. "It was almost a minute before Max observed the heads. There were seven of them in total, each spitted on tall poles placed throughout the gardens. They were in various states of decomposition, some little more than skulls while others were jarringly fresh. Four of the heads had belonged to goblins, two were human, and the last possessed the feral, wolfish face of a vye. When Toby finally noticed them, he nearly fainted." Through creating an atmosphere, dispersing discriptions of the setting throughout the action, and creating imanginative worlds, Neff creates a vibrant picture of The Maelstrom's world.
July 6, 2022
5 stars...this ending....I cannot even begin.
So as I already said, this author is so good with handling so freaking many plot threads without making them confusing. Like I feel like I know some of these people forever. And I grieved for a lot of them for different reasons. And William Cooper made me cry...how could you? For a few seconds I hated this book with all my heart. And now I loved it again.
So war is on Rowan doorstep yet again in this instalment and there are some horrible threats at play. I loved how we got a good glimpse at war preparations and the Trench rats battalion and its training were so interesting. I learned to appreciate how some characters that seemed inconsequential in the previous books reoccurred and sometimes with quite significant roles. Mina, Skeedle, Scathach just to name a few.
Next thing I would to like to address is that at first this book kind of suffered from being the book before the finale, as I believed there were quite some thing that set up the scenes at the beginning. However the ending made up for it thousand times.
And as always some storylines were resolved in this book, but the most interesting ones are yet to be addressed. Aside from the whole Astaroth and Bram thing, I simply cannot wait to see Connor and Mum again. I hold a lot of hopes for the last book but I am also a bit scared and hesitant, because I know the finale can make or break the whole series.
And lastly I curse the people who decided to stop translating this book by the third instalment and made me wait so many years for this. If I read this when I was younger I probably would have loved it as religiously as some people love Harry Potter. But there is a chance I will love it like that even now.
So as I already said, this author is so good with handling so freaking many plot threads without making them confusing. Like I feel like I know some of these people forever. And I grieved for a lot of them for different reasons. And William Cooper made me cry...how could you? For a few seconds I hated this book with all my heart. And now I loved it again.
So war is on Rowan doorstep yet again in this instalment and there are some horrible threats at play. I loved how we got a good glimpse at war preparations and the Trench rats battalion and its training were so interesting. I learned to appreciate how some characters that seemed inconsequential in the previous books reoccurred and sometimes with quite significant roles. Mina, Skeedle, Scathach just to name a few.
Next thing I would to like to address is that at first this book kind of suffered from being the book before the finale, as I believed there were quite some thing that set up the scenes at the beginning. However the ending made up for it thousand times.
And as always some storylines were resolved in this book, but the most interesting ones are yet to be addressed. Aside from the whole Astaroth and Bram thing, I simply cannot wait to see Connor and Mum again. I hold a lot of hopes for the last book but I am also a bit scared and hesitant, because I know the finale can make or break the whole series.
And lastly I curse the people who decided to stop translating this book by the third instalment and made me wait so many years for this. If I read this when I was younger I probably would have loved it as religiously as some people love Harry Potter. But there is a chance I will love it like that even now.
November 11, 2012
I LOVED IT!!!!!
It's weird to think about how much the world has changed since the first book. The world used to be like ours with modern technology, homes and museums. Now, in the fourth book, the world has been changed into something more like the medieval days.
This book was packed full of action and reminded me of the Lord of the Rings!!!!!
The only part that I was really suprised about and didn't really know what to make of it (I actually still don't) was Max's and Scathach's relationship. I pictured Scathach being a lot older than Max and more like a mentor I also was kind of sad to see that Julie was marrying someone else.
I do wish that Cooper and Bram had a bigger role in the plot. Bram also suprised me. At the end of the third book, I thought that Bram was going to go into battle and defeat all of the demons (but I guess there wouldn't be much of a plot if Bram just did everything) I was really wrong though. He was barely mentioned, and I hope that he will have a bigger role in the upcoming book!!!!
I can't wait a WHOLE ENTIRE YEAR!!!!! :D
It's weird to think about how much the world has changed since the first book. The world used to be like ours with modern technology, homes and museums. Now, in the fourth book, the world has been changed into something more like the medieval days.
This book was packed full of action and reminded me of the Lord of the Rings!!!!!
The only part that I was really suprised about and didn't really know what to make of it (I actually still don't) was Max's and Scathach's relationship. I pictured Scathach being a lot older than Max and more like a mentor I also was kind of sad to see that Julie was marrying someone else.
I do wish that Cooper and Bram had a bigger role in the plot. Bram also suprised me. At the end of the third book, I thought that Bram was going to go into battle and defeat all of the demons (but I guess there wouldn't be much of a plot if Bram just did everything) I was really wrong though. He was barely mentioned, and I hope that he will have a bigger role in the upcoming book!!!!
I can't wait a WHOLE ENTIRE YEAR!!!!! :D
January 2, 2013
I have the "sad" habit of starting a book series and of course liking them so much that I have to read each one in the series but it often takes so long for each book to come out it is hard to remember what happened previously. Even so, I usually still enjoy the books and this book, #4 of The Tapestry is no exception.
Max, the Hound of Rowan, is back from his travels just in time to get ready for a major attack on Rowan. He and his half-brother David who is a sorcerer, must figure out how to save Rowan and defend themselves and their sister, Mina from being destroyed as they are the only hope for the entire world.
Fortunately, Mr. Neff gives enough back story that the reader will catch up easily to what has happened previously and will understand the present storyline. This book does start out a little slow but it builds steadily to a great end that will keep you enthralled.
Max, the Hound of Rowan, is back from his travels just in time to get ready for a major attack on Rowan. He and his half-brother David who is a sorcerer, must figure out how to save Rowan and defend themselves and their sister, Mina from being destroyed as they are the only hope for the entire world.
Fortunately, Mr. Neff gives enough back story that the reader will catch up easily to what has happened previously and will understand the present storyline. This book does start out a little slow but it builds steadily to a great end that will keep you enthralled.
January 7, 2013
I loved The Maelstrom by Henry H. Neff, the fourth book in his series, The Tapestry. It had some great action scenes, cool magic, revelations and secrets and a huge romantic plot twist. All in all, this book really sets up for the final book in the series, The Red Winter, due later this year. This book also has the illustrations of the last books, that help tie the whole story together with visuals, especially in the cases of the daemons, who are rather hard to visualize. This book adds new drama to the series, as well as some long-awaited romance. All in all, a great book, one that I will recommend to everyone!
October 20, 2013
The main character in the Maelstrom is Max. I think Max is foolish and brave because he is not afraid of the Astropos. He is both brave and foolish because the Astropos are deadly opponents but he takes a lot of courage to not be afraid of them. I also think Pruises will go to war with Rowan because he seems so confident. A famous student at Rowan, Ellias Bram, has returned but he seems suspicious. I think he is up to something.
May 15, 2019
I have been consistently impressed by the Tapestry series and personally think these are some of the best books in the genre. The story, world, and foreshadowing are amazing as are the characters. There are few books I can honestly claim to have been so drawn into, and had I not discovered this series during a particularly difficult semester I would have dedicated the week to reading the entire set. I highly recommend this to anyone who likes fantasy in any manner.
November 29, 2012
I love this series. This one was better than some of the others too-- while people did die in this one, and it was sad, it wasn't as depressing as the last book. I like David a lot more in this book too, it felt like he went all wonky for a while but I saw his personality in this book again.
Excellent read.
Excellent read.
December 11, 2014
Went back and re-read the first three to refresh my memory before reading the fourth and they were better than I remembered. This is an action-packed installment and I highly recommend the series. I just started the last book. It starts out like an American "port" of Harry Potter but diverges grandly from there.
March 10, 2020
This series has been growing increasingly more philosophical and rather gruesome. There aren’t just battles, there is outright carnage. And I have to tip my hat to any book that sends me scurrying to the dictionary half a dozen times. As a card carrying vocabulary freak, that rarely happens.
February 21, 2014
PG for violence, magic, and some gore.
It's uncanny: while most book series cannot compare with the opening novel, Neff's progression only gets better.
It's uncanny: while most book series cannot compare with the opening novel, Neff's progression only gets better.
February 10, 2014
I liked it but it was my least favorite so far. It felt like very little progression took place. Other than Mina and Scathach, little else progresses in the story. Was definetily looking for more.
December 5, 2012
I just love this book series. The author has a way with painting a picture so that everything is just wonderful. I am eagerly waiting for the next in the series.
December 11, 2012
This series is one the best books ever. Anyone who loves fantasy should love this.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 182 reviews