This is a supremely succinct retelling of the tale of Cinderella. Each of the main elements is captured in a single word or phrase, "Girl. Chores. Mean stepsisters. Fairy godmother," being the text of the first few pages. Each idea is simply but completely and colorfully illustrated. Unlike the Favorite Words books attributed to Eric Carle, Belle, Caruso-Scott, and Lake manage to tell a complete story. Granted, some of this story I may have subconsciously filled in myself. The subject matter well lends itself to such a succinct retelling as it is a tale that children can grow into (which I know is the idea behind the Favorite Words books, but with Cinderella there is so much more growth to be had, not from nouns and matching pictures to a board book with a simple story, but phrases and matching illustrations to a modern English picture book, to an illustrated picture book of the original story with a cleaner ending, to a modern English short story, to the original short story with the original ending, to a modern retelling in novel format, to a comparison of Cinderella tale types from around the world).
Belle et al.'s book is a more standard board book size as compared to the very little size of Carle's Favorite Words books, giving the illustrator (Oliver Lake) more room with illustration. Rather than being a complementary illustration of a noun as are Carle's, the form leaves room for a complete picture with subject and background and secondary characters or plot points.
I would be interested in parents' reviews of the book. To me, Belle et al.'s book would seem to invite its own retelling by a child in time, for which I'd laud it. However, to me, the book seems to suffer the same flaw as the Favorite Words books: They cannot really be read aloud--or would be dull and extremely short to read aloud. These are books to give to young readers or would-be readers, essentially a set of flashcards in board book form attempting to tell a tale because of their arrangement.