What do you think?
Rate this book
Tales of Valdemar #8
No True Way
In March 1987, Mercedes Lackey, a young author from Oklahoma, published her first novel, Arrows of the Queen. No one could have envisioned that this modest book about a magical land called Valdemar would be the beginning of a fantasy masterwork series that would span decades and include more than two dozen titles.
Now the voices of other authors add their own special touches to the ancient land where Heralds “Chosen” from all walks of life by magical horse-like Companions patrol their ancient kingdom, dispensing justice, facing adversaries, and protecting their monarch and country from whatever threatens. Trained rigorously by the Heralds Collegium, these special protectors each have extraordinary Gifts: Mindspeaking, FarSeeing, FarSpeaking, Empathy, Firestarting, and ForeSeeing, and are bonded for life with their mysterious Companions.
Travel with these astounding adventurers in sixteen original stories.
Now the voices of other authors add their own special touches to the ancient land where Heralds “Chosen” from all walks of life by magical horse-like Companions patrol their ancient kingdom, dispensing justice, facing adversaries, and protecting their monarch and country from whatever threatens. Trained rigorously by the Heralds Collegium, these special protectors each have extraordinary Gifts: Mindspeaking, FarSeeing, FarSpeaking, Empathy, Firestarting, and ForeSeeing, and are bonded for life with their mysterious Companions.
Travel with these astounding adventurers in sixteen original stories.
346 pages, Mass Market Paperback
First published December 2, 2014
138 people are currently reading
1428 people want to read
About the author
Mercedes Lackey
441 books9,530 followersMercedes entered this world on June 24, 1950, in Chicago, had a normal childhood and graduated from Purdue University in 1972. During the late 70's she worked as an artist's model and then went into the computer programming field, ending up with American Airlines in Tulsa, Oklahoma. In addition to her fantasy writing, she has written lyrics for and recorded nearly fifty songs for Firebird Arts & Music, a small recording company specializing in science fiction folk music.
"I'm a storyteller; that's what I see as 'my job'. My stories come out of my characters; how those characters would react to the given situation. Maybe that's why I get letters from readers as young as thirteen and as old as sixty-odd. One of the reasons I write song lyrics is because I see songs as a kind of 'story pill' -- they reduce a story to the barest essentials or encapsulate a particular crucial moment in time. I frequently will write a lyric when I am attempting to get to the heart of a crucial scene; I find that when I have done so, the scene has become absolutely clear in my mind, and I can write exactly what I wanted to say. Another reason is because of the kind of novels I am writing: that is, fantasy, set in an other-world semi-medieval atmosphere. Music is very important to medieval peoples; bards are the chief newsbringers. When I write the 'folk music' of these peoples, I am enriching my whole world, whether I actually use the song in the text or not.
"I began writing out of boredom; I continue out of addiction. I can't 'not' write, and as a result I have no social life! I began writing fantasy because I love it, but I try to construct my fantasy worlds with all the care of a 'high-tech' science fiction writer. I apply the principle of TANSTAAFL ['There ain't no such thing as free lunch', credited to Robert Heinlein) to magic, for instance; in my worlds, magic is paid for, and the cost to the magician is frequently a high one. I try to keep my world as solid and real as possible; people deal with stubborn pumps, bugs in the porridge, and love-lives that refuse to become untangled, right along with invading armies and evil magicians. And I try to make all of my characters, even the 'evil magicians,' something more than flat stereotypes. Even evil magicians get up in the night and look for cookies, sometimes.
"I suppose that in everything I write I try to expound the creed I gave my character Diana Tregarde in Burning Water:
"There's no such thing as 'one, true way'; the only answers worth having are the ones you find for yourself; leave the world better than you found it. Love, freedom, and the chance to do some good -- they're the things worth living and dying for, and if you aren't willing to die for the things worth living for, you might as well turn in your membership in the human race."
Also writes as Misty Lackey
Author's website
"I'm a storyteller; that's what I see as 'my job'. My stories come out of my characters; how those characters would react to the given situation. Maybe that's why I get letters from readers as young as thirteen and as old as sixty-odd. One of the reasons I write song lyrics is because I see songs as a kind of 'story pill' -- they reduce a story to the barest essentials or encapsulate a particular crucial moment in time. I frequently will write a lyric when I am attempting to get to the heart of a crucial scene; I find that when I have done so, the scene has become absolutely clear in my mind, and I can write exactly what I wanted to say. Another reason is because of the kind of novels I am writing: that is, fantasy, set in an other-world semi-medieval atmosphere. Music is very important to medieval peoples; bards are the chief newsbringers. When I write the 'folk music' of these peoples, I am enriching my whole world, whether I actually use the song in the text or not.
"I began writing out of boredom; I continue out of addiction. I can't 'not' write, and as a result I have no social life! I began writing fantasy because I love it, but I try to construct my fantasy worlds with all the care of a 'high-tech' science fiction writer. I apply the principle of TANSTAAFL ['There ain't no such thing as free lunch', credited to Robert Heinlein) to magic, for instance; in my worlds, magic is paid for, and the cost to the magician is frequently a high one. I try to keep my world as solid and real as possible; people deal with stubborn pumps, bugs in the porridge, and love-lives that refuse to become untangled, right along with invading armies and evil magicians. And I try to make all of my characters, even the 'evil magicians,' something more than flat stereotypes. Even evil magicians get up in the night and look for cookies, sometimes.
"I suppose that in everything I write I try to expound the creed I gave my character Diana Tregarde in Burning Water:
"There's no such thing as 'one, true way'; the only answers worth having are the ones you find for yourself; leave the world better than you found it. Love, freedom, and the chance to do some good -- they're the things worth living and dying for, and if you aren't willing to die for the things worth living for, you might as well turn in your membership in the human race."
Also writes as Misty Lackey
Author's website
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 98 reviews
February 1, 2015
don’t know if I would be the voracious reader I am today, if not for the librarian at my local library, who handed me a copy of Arrows of the Queen back in the fifth grade. So it should be no surprise that I pick up every book by Mercedes Lackey that comes out each year, including the anthologies she edits, despite the fact I’m not a fan of anthologies in general.
While I haven’t read anything by the majority of the authors in One True Way, Lackey proves yet again that she knows just how to pick the perfect authors to help flesh out her world. The best part of these anthologies is the fact that we often get a look into locations or gifts on Velgarth that we don’t get to see in the main series.
I’m never entirely sure how to review the few anthologies that I do read, this time I figured I will just review each story as I read it and see how that goes. I will do my best to keep spoilers out of each short stories and hope no one really notices how many time I say something is my favorite story in the anthology.
The Whitest Lie by Stephanie D. Shaver:
The Whitest Lie tells the story of Wil, who attempts to decrypt a series of documents left behind by his late wife using his odd version of Foresight. This short story is one of my favorites for two reasons. First we get a look at a version of Foresight we’ve seen before, instead of just seeing confusing flashes of the future, Wil can focus and get glimpses of all points in time, past present and future. Secondly we get a look at what happens in Haven almost directly after Arrows Fall. It was interesting to get an idea of the events that lead up to Winds of Fate.
Old Loom, New Tapestry by Dayle A. Dermatis:
While she raised four children of her own who grew up to be Chosen, Lady Syrriah Trayne never expected to be chosen herself, or to find herself with an extremely powerful gift of Empathy. That is often the case with Heralds though, it is those who least it expect it who find themselves living the life. This story was a great example of the one belief that keeps Valdemar running strong. A Companions choice is never wrong and they are always chosen for a purpose. The events of Old Loom, New Tapestry show that although she came to it late in life, Syrriah was always destined to be a Herald.
The Barest Gift by Brenda Cooper:
In most of Mercedes Lackeys Valdemar books it is the Heralds with the powerful gifts who end up saving the day. It is not always the biggest most powerful gifts are needed though. Sometimes it is the smallest most inconsequential gifts that are needed the most. Just as it is not always the Herald who is there to save the day, but the innkeepers daughter who is there to save the Herald. It is stories like The Barest Gift that make me wish we got to see the world outside of Haven and the Heralds a bit more often than we get to.
Consequences Unforeseen by Elizabeth A. Vaughan:
This story was interesting in that it shows an aspect of Valdemar that we rarely see in the books. What happens in the kingdom after one of its many wars, and what life is like out in a country estate. Surprisingly this turned out to be one of my favorite stories in the anthology, and I really hope it gets continue in next years anthology.
Written in the Wind by Jennifer Brozek:
Here we get a good explanation of why even after the end of Storm Breaking it is still rare to find a Herald Mage. This was one of the saddest stories I’ve ever read, I feel like I will be recovering from it days from now. I found it to be one of the more moving and better written stories in the anthology. I really hope Mercedes Lackey moves out of Valdemar’s past and back into its future one day.
Nwah by Ron Collins:
I found this story as it was a bit odd, being told from the point of view of one of the Kyree. Although we get glimpses of the Kyree throughout the series, this is the first time I’ve truly understood just what it means to bond to one of the Kyree. It is always interesting to see the Velgarth through the eyes of one of its non human inhabitants. From Nwah we get a fairly good idea just what the Kyree are possible of when their lives are in danger.
Spun Magic by Kristin Schwengel:
Stardance is one of the fabled Tayledras, more commonly known to the rest of the world as the Hawk Brothers, and this is the story of her mastery test. While I enjoyed this story (As I’m sure I will every story in this anthology) and thought it was well written, it was not one of my favorite stories; I feel like stories of the Tayledras dealing with the after effects of the Mage Storms have been overdone.
Weavings by Diana L. Paxson:
This is another story that I enjoyed quite a bit, it has everything I love about a story set in this world. There is a Herald and his Companion, strange and dangerous creatures coming out of the Pelagir to attack people, and interesting an interesting variation on a known Gift. It’s nice to see a series that has been going strong for 28 years now still has some interesting tricks up its sleeve!
A Wake of Vultures by Elisabeth Waters:
Here we get another really detailed look at one of the minor gifts only briefly touched upon in the main books. Animal Mindspeech. A fascinating look at exactly what it is an what you can do with it, as well as a look into one of the religions only briefly mentioned in the books.
Maiden’s Hope by Michele Lang:
This one is little slice of story about what happens around the Forest of Shadows and Errolds Grove after the events of Owlknight. While there are no appearances by any old friends there are references to them an the healing sanctuary at K’Vala Vale. After finishing it I find myself really wishing we knew exactly what happens to Darian and Keisha,
Ex Libris by Fiona Patton:
I didn’t think there would be horror stories in this anthology, but to me that is exactly what this story is. Books are disappearing one by one from an elderly scholars personal library and Sergeant Hektor Dann, of the Haven City Watch, is determined to find out who and why. Ex Libris is an interesting look into the life and work of the City Watch.
A Dream Reborn by Dylan Birtolo:
I was a bit uncertain about this story at first, but it grew on me rather quickly. It is interesting to get glimpses at the future of Valdemar in a good portion of these short stories. This story is a good reminder that not every hero is a Herald.
Forget Me Never by Cedric Johnson:
The discovery of never before seen gifts, or gifts that manifest themselves in odd ways seems to be a common theme in the majority of these short stories. Forget Me Never is a good example of this, as they don’t even have a name for the gift revealed in it yet. Though, I feel like Mag’s has this same gift in some small way.
Beyond the Fires by Louisa Swann:
Swann’s story gives us a look into the life of a Tedrel camp slave, and it is a horrible life to live. The only thing that kept me going through the story was the fact that I already knew the outcome of the Tedrel Wars.
A Brand from the Burning by Rosemary Edgehill and Rebecca Fox:
This story was fun mainly because it gives us a look into the early life of an important character in the history of both Valdemar and Karse. At this point in her life Solaris is nothing but a young orphan girl with no idea what future has in store for her. While she may be young and naive in some ways, you get the occasional glimpse of just who, and what, she will one day be.
Vixen by Mercedes Lackey:
While every story in this anthology really expands the world of Velgarth and the country of Valemar, it is no surprise to me that Mercedes Lackey’s story is my favorite of the lot. First, it’s the only story about a real healer in the anthology, and it’s always nice to learn some more about an ability or gift that’s not explained all that well throughout the books. Then there is the fact that it’s the first new story I can think of featuring Vanyel Demonsbane since the end of the Magic’s Price trilogy. Vanyel is a fascinating character like always, and you get a good idea once again why he quickly gains the nickname Magic’s Pride from his fellow Heralds. Vixen is a sharp tongued healer with no time for bullies or fools, and together they make a great team as they face down massive lizards an spiders.
I think anyone who is a fan of Mercedes Lackey should go out right now and buy this anthology, there are a lot of great stories, and the return of many old faces. As for anyone who hasn’t read any of her books should pick up a copy of Arrows of the Queen at the first possible chance, they won’t regret it!
While I haven’t read anything by the majority of the authors in One True Way, Lackey proves yet again that she knows just how to pick the perfect authors to help flesh out her world. The best part of these anthologies is the fact that we often get a look into locations or gifts on Velgarth that we don’t get to see in the main series.
I’m never entirely sure how to review the few anthologies that I do read, this time I figured I will just review each story as I read it and see how that goes. I will do my best to keep spoilers out of each short stories and hope no one really notices how many time I say something is my favorite story in the anthology.
The Whitest Lie by Stephanie D. Shaver:
The Whitest Lie tells the story of Wil, who attempts to decrypt a series of documents left behind by his late wife using his odd version of Foresight. This short story is one of my favorites for two reasons. First we get a look at a version of Foresight we’ve seen before, instead of just seeing confusing flashes of the future, Wil can focus and get glimpses of all points in time, past present and future. Secondly we get a look at what happens in Haven almost directly after Arrows Fall. It was interesting to get an idea of the events that lead up to Winds of Fate.
Old Loom, New Tapestry by Dayle A. Dermatis:
While she raised four children of her own who grew up to be Chosen, Lady Syrriah Trayne never expected to be chosen herself, or to find herself with an extremely powerful gift of Empathy. That is often the case with Heralds though, it is those who least it expect it who find themselves living the life. This story was a great example of the one belief that keeps Valdemar running strong. A Companions choice is never wrong and they are always chosen for a purpose. The events of Old Loom, New Tapestry show that although she came to it late in life, Syrriah was always destined to be a Herald.
The Barest Gift by Brenda Cooper:
In most of Mercedes Lackeys Valdemar books it is the Heralds with the powerful gifts who end up saving the day. It is not always the biggest most powerful gifts are needed though. Sometimes it is the smallest most inconsequential gifts that are needed the most. Just as it is not always the Herald who is there to save the day, but the innkeepers daughter who is there to save the Herald. It is stories like The Barest Gift that make me wish we got to see the world outside of Haven and the Heralds a bit more often than we get to.
Consequences Unforeseen by Elizabeth A. Vaughan:
This story was interesting in that it shows an aspect of Valdemar that we rarely see in the books. What happens in the kingdom after one of its many wars, and what life is like out in a country estate. Surprisingly this turned out to be one of my favorite stories in the anthology, and I really hope it gets continue in next years anthology.
Written in the Wind by Jennifer Brozek:
Here we get a good explanation of why even after the end of Storm Breaking it is still rare to find a Herald Mage. This was one of the saddest stories I’ve ever read, I feel like I will be recovering from it days from now. I found it to be one of the more moving and better written stories in the anthology. I really hope Mercedes Lackey moves out of Valdemar’s past and back into its future one day.
Nwah by Ron Collins:
I found this story as it was a bit odd, being told from the point of view of one of the Kyree. Although we get glimpses of the Kyree throughout the series, this is the first time I’ve truly understood just what it means to bond to one of the Kyree. It is always interesting to see the Velgarth through the eyes of one of its non human inhabitants. From Nwah we get a fairly good idea just what the Kyree are possible of when their lives are in danger.
Spun Magic by Kristin Schwengel:
Stardance is one of the fabled Tayledras, more commonly known to the rest of the world as the Hawk Brothers, and this is the story of her mastery test. While I enjoyed this story (As I’m sure I will every story in this anthology) and thought it was well written, it was not one of my favorite stories; I feel like stories of the Tayledras dealing with the after effects of the Mage Storms have been overdone.
Weavings by Diana L. Paxson:
This is another story that I enjoyed quite a bit, it has everything I love about a story set in this world. There is a Herald and his Companion, strange and dangerous creatures coming out of the Pelagir to attack people, and interesting an interesting variation on a known Gift. It’s nice to see a series that has been going strong for 28 years now still has some interesting tricks up its sleeve!
A Wake of Vultures by Elisabeth Waters:
Here we get another really detailed look at one of the minor gifts only briefly touched upon in the main books. Animal Mindspeech. A fascinating look at exactly what it is an what you can do with it, as well as a look into one of the religions only briefly mentioned in the books.
Maiden’s Hope by Michele Lang:
This one is little slice of story about what happens around the Forest of Shadows and Errolds Grove after the events of Owlknight. While there are no appearances by any old friends there are references to them an the healing sanctuary at K’Vala Vale. After finishing it I find myself really wishing we knew exactly what happens to Darian and Keisha,
Ex Libris by Fiona Patton:
I didn’t think there would be horror stories in this anthology, but to me that is exactly what this story is. Books are disappearing one by one from an elderly scholars personal library and Sergeant Hektor Dann, of the Haven City Watch, is determined to find out who and why. Ex Libris is an interesting look into the life and work of the City Watch.
A Dream Reborn by Dylan Birtolo:
I was a bit uncertain about this story at first, but it grew on me rather quickly. It is interesting to get glimpses at the future of Valdemar in a good portion of these short stories. This story is a good reminder that not every hero is a Herald.
Forget Me Never by Cedric Johnson:
The discovery of never before seen gifts, or gifts that manifest themselves in odd ways seems to be a common theme in the majority of these short stories. Forget Me Never is a good example of this, as they don’t even have a name for the gift revealed in it yet. Though, I feel like Mag’s has this same gift in some small way.
Beyond the Fires by Louisa Swann:
Swann’s story gives us a look into the life of a Tedrel camp slave, and it is a horrible life to live. The only thing that kept me going through the story was the fact that I already knew the outcome of the Tedrel Wars.
A Brand from the Burning by Rosemary Edgehill and Rebecca Fox:
This story was fun mainly because it gives us a look into the early life of an important character in the history of both Valdemar and Karse. At this point in her life Solaris is nothing but a young orphan girl with no idea what future has in store for her. While she may be young and naive in some ways, you get the occasional glimpse of just who, and what, she will one day be.
Vixen by Mercedes Lackey:
While every story in this anthology really expands the world of Velgarth and the country of Valemar, it is no surprise to me that Mercedes Lackey’s story is my favorite of the lot. First, it’s the only story about a real healer in the anthology, and it’s always nice to learn some more about an ability or gift that’s not explained all that well throughout the books. Then there is the fact that it’s the first new story I can think of featuring Vanyel Demonsbane since the end of the Magic’s Price trilogy. Vanyel is a fascinating character like always, and you get a good idea once again why he quickly gains the nickname Magic’s Pride from his fellow Heralds. Vixen is a sharp tongued healer with no time for bullies or fools, and together they make a great team as they face down massive lizards an spiders.
I think anyone who is a fan of Mercedes Lackey should go out right now and buy this anthology, there are a lot of great stories, and the return of many old faces. As for anyone who hasn’t read any of her books should pick up a copy of Arrows of the Queen at the first possible chance, they won’t regret it!
October 24, 2022
Eighth in the young adult anthology, Tales of Valdemar, an urban fantasy subseries for Valdemar with sixteen short stories by assorted authors.
Five of the stories in this anthology are so depressing that you’ll want to cry, two are poorly written, and there are five stories that are cheerful, so consider this in either reading it or in the timing of reading it.
Series:
"The Whitest Lie" (Herald Wil & Lelia)
"Spun Magic" (Stardance)
"Ex Libris" (Dann Family of Haven)
The Stories
Stephanie Shaver’s "The Whitest Lie" will leave you crying and sobbing and wondering if you missed a story. It’s Herald Wil in a catch-22 as he is forced to find a foster parent for his young daughter.
Dayle A. Dermatis’ "Old Loom, New Tapestry" is a culture-specific phrase for the new Herald Syrriah. A new widow in her middle age, Companion Cefylla Chooses her. It’s in Syrriah’s internship on the Circuit that she finds her new purpose in her new life as a Herald. It’s a very sad story with a heartening outcome. I could wish such Gifts for our own time.
Brenda Cooper’s "The Barest Gift" is yet another sad tale with a bittersweet ending. A tribute to a grand lady.
Elizabeth A. Vaughan’s "Consequences Unforeseen" finds a relieved widow writing to her father of her lord’s death. I do love this story as it appeals to my sense of making-do. Lady Cera is a merchant’s daughter and practical when it comes to ensuring that her people and her estate will not just survive but thrive.
Jennifer Brozek’s "Written in the Wind" is another story that will leave you crying as well for the twins, children who feel so alone. It is so depressing at the end.
Ron Collins’ "Nwah" is about a kyree who has lost her Mind-pair in a vicious attack. This one will make you angry and burn with a desire for vengeance almost as great as Nwah’s. It’s also a frustrating short story as it’s only a short peek into Nwah’s anguish and Kade’s life under his stepmother. It starts with pain and ends with a hope.
Kristin Schwengel’s "Spun Magic" is another peek into Stardance’s life when her original home vale needs help with magic issues in k’Lissa Vale. It’s a father hoping that his daughter will choose to remain with them when the crisis is averted, but why he thinks Stardance would choose to remain in a vale strange to her, with a family she has never met, I don’t know.
For that matter, I don’t understand why her mother being dead and her mother’s parents being dead would be good reasons for her father, Firewind, to send Stardance to another Vale. If she’s being raised by a hertasi in k’Veyas, why couldn’t she be raised by a hertasi in her original home?
There’s another reason, of course, why Stardance will choose to return. These Hawkbrothers are really quite subtle *she says with a smile*.
Diana L. Paxson’s "Weavings" is another sad story of running away, of loss, of a mother’s realization that her child must weave her own story.
Elisabeth Waters’ "A Wake of Vultures" is certainly unique with the problem Waters presents. It’s a good idea, but I wish that it had been better written. It reads stiffly.
Michele Lang’s "Maiden’s Hope" is another unique if very confusing story. I wish Lang had better explained this cloud floating bit that Brock is either stuck in or lives in or ??? Sparrow is meant to communicate, I think, with Brock in the clouds and report back. What she is to report, I have no idea. It makes no sense. It especially makes no sense that she’s not Chosen. Heck, if Lang can come up with this confusion of goofiness, why can’t Abilard have two Chosen?
Fiona Patton’s "Ex Libris" appeals to my heart as it’s all about books and the lending of them. I do enjoy Patton’s stories — especially those about the Dann family — and this one is no exception. It’s amazing how much heartwarming Patton can put into a short story.
Dylan Birtolo’s "A Dream Reborn" is a cute tale of redemption as a beggar girl remembers her past.
Cedric Johnson’s "Forget Me Never" is a sweet story that starts with meanness. The theme of this is similar to "Written in the Wind" with a girl who is alone and ignored. One of the few in this anthology that ends with a truly happy ending.
Louisa Swann’s "Beyond the Fires" is a terrifying journey for a young girl who saw her parents slaughtered and has endured horrible beatings and rape. It’s a raven who entices Liana beyond the fires and a Companion and his herald along with the raven and his friends who help deliver her, in every sense of the word.
Rosemary Edghill and Rebecca Fox’s "A Brand From the Burning" is a rather depressing tale of Karse and one of its priests. The immediate tale is encouraging with this Hierophant who takes in those without, but it rapidly deteriorates as Edghill/Fox write of the corruption that infests the priesthood of Vkandis Sunlord. They do leave us with hope however and a deep desire on my part to find the story that includes Solaris.
Mercedes Lackey’s "Vixen" is another of my favorites in this anthology with an angry Healer who softens up when faced with great danger and acceptance from Herald-Mage Vanyel.
The Cover and Title
The cover is consistent with other Valdemaran covers. This one has a black background of pale gray Companions prancing from bottom to top on a diagonal slant, racing between pale gray arrows slanting downwards. At top and bottom are rectangles of purple bordered in gold holding a golden title and the editor’s name. The central motif is an inset shield shape bordered in riveted steel with a Companion’s head in profile emerging with a young man in pale yellow with light brown hair holding the Companion’s cheek. A shield is at the base of this inset with a red phoenix against a black background while another shield shape with a star-flecked lighter purple background provides a good foil for a white winged unicorn in profile.
The title is simple and reminds us that there is No True Way: All-New Tales of Valdemar to live our lives. That life is different for each of us, whether we live in Valdemar or own worlds.
Five of the stories in this anthology are so depressing that you’ll want to cry, two are poorly written, and there are five stories that are cheerful, so consider this in either reading it or in the timing of reading it.
Series:
"The Whitest Lie" (Herald Wil & Lelia)
"Spun Magic" (Stardance)
"Ex Libris" (Dann Family of Haven)
The Stories
Stephanie Shaver’s "The Whitest Lie" will leave you crying and sobbing and wondering if you missed a story. It’s Herald Wil in a catch-22 as he is forced to find a foster parent for his young daughter.
Dayle A. Dermatis’ "Old Loom, New Tapestry" is a culture-specific phrase for the new Herald Syrriah. A new widow in her middle age, Companion Cefylla Chooses her. It’s in Syrriah’s internship on the Circuit that she finds her new purpose in her new life as a Herald. It’s a very sad story with a heartening outcome. I could wish such Gifts for our own time.
Brenda Cooper’s "The Barest Gift" is yet another sad tale with a bittersweet ending. A tribute to a grand lady.
Elizabeth A. Vaughan’s "Consequences Unforeseen" finds a relieved widow writing to her father of her lord’s death. I do love this story as it appeals to my sense of making-do. Lady Cera is a merchant’s daughter and practical when it comes to ensuring that her people and her estate will not just survive but thrive.
Jennifer Brozek’s "Written in the Wind" is another story that will leave you crying as well for the twins, children who feel so alone. It is so depressing at the end.
Ron Collins’ "Nwah" is about a kyree who has lost her Mind-pair in a vicious attack. This one will make you angry and burn with a desire for vengeance almost as great as Nwah’s. It’s also a frustrating short story as it’s only a short peek into Nwah’s anguish and Kade’s life under his stepmother. It starts with pain and ends with a hope.
Kristin Schwengel’s "Spun Magic" is another peek into Stardance’s life when her original home vale needs help with magic issues in k’Lissa Vale. It’s a father hoping that his daughter will choose to remain with them when the crisis is averted, but why he thinks Stardance would choose to remain in a vale strange to her, with a family she has never met, I don’t know.
For that matter, I don’t understand why her mother being dead and her mother’s parents being dead would be good reasons for her father, Firewind, to send Stardance to another Vale. If she’s being raised by a hertasi in k’Veyas, why couldn’t she be raised by a hertasi in her original home?
There’s another reason, of course, why Stardance will choose to return. These Hawkbrothers are really quite subtle *she says with a smile*.
Diana L. Paxson’s "Weavings" is another sad story of running away, of loss, of a mother’s realization that her child must weave her own story.
Elisabeth Waters’ "A Wake of Vultures" is certainly unique with the problem Waters presents. It’s a good idea, but I wish that it had been better written. It reads stiffly.
Michele Lang’s "Maiden’s Hope" is another unique if very confusing story. I wish Lang had better explained this cloud floating bit that Brock is either stuck in or lives in or ??? Sparrow is meant to communicate, I think, with Brock in the clouds and report back. What she is to report, I have no idea. It makes no sense. It especially makes no sense that she’s not Chosen. Heck, if Lang can come up with this confusion of goofiness, why can’t Abilard have two Chosen?
Fiona Patton’s "Ex Libris" appeals to my heart as it’s all about books and the lending of them. I do enjoy Patton’s stories — especially those about the Dann family — and this one is no exception. It’s amazing how much heartwarming Patton can put into a short story.
Dylan Birtolo’s "A Dream Reborn" is a cute tale of redemption as a beggar girl remembers her past.
Cedric Johnson’s "Forget Me Never" is a sweet story that starts with meanness. The theme of this is similar to "Written in the Wind" with a girl who is alone and ignored. One of the few in this anthology that ends with a truly happy ending.
Louisa Swann’s "Beyond the Fires" is a terrifying journey for a young girl who saw her parents slaughtered and has endured horrible beatings and rape. It’s a raven who entices Liana beyond the fires and a Companion and his herald along with the raven and his friends who help deliver her, in every sense of the word.
Rosemary Edghill and Rebecca Fox’s "A Brand From the Burning" is a rather depressing tale of Karse and one of its priests. The immediate tale is encouraging with this Hierophant who takes in those without, but it rapidly deteriorates as Edghill/Fox write of the corruption that infests the priesthood of Vkandis Sunlord. They do leave us with hope however and a deep desire on my part to find the story that includes Solaris.
Mercedes Lackey’s "Vixen" is another of my favorites in this anthology with an angry Healer who softens up when faced with great danger and acceptance from Herald-Mage Vanyel.
The Cover and Title
The cover is consistent with other Valdemaran covers. This one has a black background of pale gray Companions prancing from bottom to top on a diagonal slant, racing between pale gray arrows slanting downwards. At top and bottom are rectangles of purple bordered in gold holding a golden title and the editor’s name. The central motif is an inset shield shape bordered in riveted steel with a Companion’s head in profile emerging with a young man in pale yellow with light brown hair holding the Companion’s cheek. A shield is at the base of this inset with a red phoenix against a black background while another shield shape with a star-flecked lighter purple background provides a good foil for a white winged unicorn in profile.
The title is simple and reminds us that there is No True Way: All-New Tales of Valdemar to live our lives. That life is different for each of us, whether we live in Valdemar or own worlds.
December 3, 2014
Loved them all!
I am an unrepentant Lackey fan, as should be expressed early, so my bias where her world of Velgarth is concerned can be understood immediately. The stories contained in this issue of Valdamar's anthologies are in many cases a return of old friends. Most of these stories are from the view of characters previously met in other anthologies. It is a comfort to be able to grieve with Herald Wil, to laugh with Vanyel, and to see new triumphs and tragedy woven through a place that is like this anthology, both familiar and new. Excellent work from all of the contributors.
I am an unrepentant Lackey fan, as should be expressed early, so my bias where her world of Velgarth is concerned can be understood immediately. The stories contained in this issue of Valdamar's anthologies are in many cases a return of old friends. Most of these stories are from the view of characters previously met in other anthologies. It is a comfort to be able to grieve with Herald Wil, to laugh with Vanyel, and to see new triumphs and tragedy woven through a place that is like this anthology, both familiar and new. Excellent work from all of the contributors.
January 30, 2015
This was a pretty solid collection of tales of Valdemar. I always feel there could more levity in these stories... it seems as though when she invites authors to play in the world they always want to write in the dark corners of it. Still, a good bunch, very enjoyable, so I'm fairly pleased.
January 24, 2015
Solid set of stories, wouldn't've minded seeing several of them extended.
January 26, 2021
Unlike many anthologies, this collection was surprisingly even. All the stories by different authors could be described as average. None of the stories stood out from the rest, and I liked then all equally (if tepidly). Except one particular story, which I disliked immensely: Written in the Wind by Jennifer Brozek. In this story, the author kills both protagonists: the ten-year-old twins. I hate tragedy, especially when it concerns children, and it saddens me that such a brutal story was included in this otherwise uplifting anthology.
August 27, 2015
This is the eighth anthology of short stories set in the kingdom of Valdemar and it's surrounding countries, and I'm already looking forward to the ninth. If you guys have been reading this blog for any length or time, you know that I love Valdemar the way others love Hogwarts, Narnia, or Middle Earth. If there was a teleportation portal that connected our two worlds, I would gladly go across. It's the world I escape to when I'm needing to forget what is going on around me. It's my second home, and I never miss an opportunity to visit.
What I love about these anthologies is that other authors get to add their imprint to the Valdemar. They introduce us to new characters, some of which come back in several anthologies. Some of the characters are from the past, enriching Valdemar's history, others are from the present, striving to make sure Valdemar has a future. It's a way to make the world all that much concrete and vibrant, and I appreciate all the effort that goes into it.
While I loved all sixteen of the stories that were presented this time around, the one that really stuck out for me was "Written in the Wind" by Jennifer Brozek. It's one of the shorter stories in the collection, and it's small in scope, but it's so powerfully moving, especially if you are familiar with the Vanyel and everything going on in his time period. Vanyel doesn't make an appearance in this story, nor is he mentioned, but if you have read The Last Herald Mage trilogy, which I think everyone should, then you now this piece of Valdemar's history. Someone is setting out to destroy the Herald Mage's and rob Valdemar of their strength. It's not noticed at first since the casualty rate has always been high with Herald Mages, but it starts to take it's toll. Fewer and fewer youngsters with the Mage ability are being chosen, and nobody seems to know why. It seems as if someone is targeting the kids before they even have a chance to be chosen, killing them off, one by one. This story is about Orun and Milla, twin brother and sister who not only have a Mage gift, but seem to have ForeSight as well. For years now they have know they will be chosen on their birthday, and from that day onward, there are two paths. One of them leads to a rich long life, the other to a short one ending in violent death. Sadly it's that second one that find these two young people, and wipes them out before they even make it to Haven. What I found remarkable about them,,and what I admire about anyone who is chosen to be a Herald, is the willingness to do what is needed of them, despite the dangers to themselves. These two children knew they were probably going to die before they were even going to be able to start training, but they stepped up, got on the backs of their Companions, and set off to Haven in the hope that they could at least let others know what is going on. They are remarkable kids, and this is really the first time we get a glimpse at what could have been.
While I do think you guys should start your explorations of Valdemar with the Last Herald Mage triogy; Magic's Pawn, Magic's Promise, and Magic's Price, the anthologies are a good way to step the toes in the water, and test out Valdemar for yourselves.
What I love about these anthologies is that other authors get to add their imprint to the Valdemar. They introduce us to new characters, some of which come back in several anthologies. Some of the characters are from the past, enriching Valdemar's history, others are from the present, striving to make sure Valdemar has a future. It's a way to make the world all that much concrete and vibrant, and I appreciate all the effort that goes into it.
While I loved all sixteen of the stories that were presented this time around, the one that really stuck out for me was "Written in the Wind" by Jennifer Brozek. It's one of the shorter stories in the collection, and it's small in scope, but it's so powerfully moving, especially if you are familiar with the Vanyel and everything going on in his time period. Vanyel doesn't make an appearance in this story, nor is he mentioned, but if you have read The Last Herald Mage trilogy, which I think everyone should, then you now this piece of Valdemar's history. Someone is setting out to destroy the Herald Mage's and rob Valdemar of their strength. It's not noticed at first since the casualty rate has always been high with Herald Mages, but it starts to take it's toll. Fewer and fewer youngsters with the Mage ability are being chosen, and nobody seems to know why. It seems as if someone is targeting the kids before they even have a chance to be chosen, killing them off, one by one. This story is about Orun and Milla, twin brother and sister who not only have a Mage gift, but seem to have ForeSight as well. For years now they have know they will be chosen on their birthday, and from that day onward, there are two paths. One of them leads to a rich long life, the other to a short one ending in violent death. Sadly it's that second one that find these two young people, and wipes them out before they even make it to Haven. What I found remarkable about them,,and what I admire about anyone who is chosen to be a Herald, is the willingness to do what is needed of them, despite the dangers to themselves. These two children knew they were probably going to die before they were even going to be able to start training, but they stepped up, got on the backs of their Companions, and set off to Haven in the hope that they could at least let others know what is going on. They are remarkable kids, and this is really the first time we get a glimpse at what could have been.
While I do think you guys should start your explorations of Valdemar with the Last Herald Mage triogy; Magic's Pawn, Magic's Promise, and Magic's Price, the anthologies are a good way to step the toes in the water, and test out Valdemar for yourselves.
January 19, 2015
Like many of the people leaving a review for this book, I've been an avid fan for years. Mercedes Lackey is one of the few authors that I buy the books in hardback edition simply because I tend to read these books over and over. I've yet to read a story that disappointed me.
No True Way: All-New Tales of Valdemar keeps true to that unwritten promise. This anthology has a little of everything from desperate decisions to gentle fondness, sometimes in the same story. The anthology features well known authors such as Diana L Paxton and Jennifer Brozek as well as newer authors like Dylan Birtolo and Stephanie Shaver.
Each story takes on one of those little corners that develop when a larger story comes to life. While some of these stories fill in the gaps others happily find their place in the wild world and invite you in. Each lets you know a bit more about Valdemar and the people within.
One of the most emotionally powerful stories was Jennifer Brozek's "Written in the Wind." In just a few short words Brozek emotionally ties you a set of twins--newly Chosen--and their Companions. It was the single story in this anthology that really made me stop and reread the last page.
Elizabeth Vaughn launches the reader into the plight of Lady Cera, wife of one of the men who tried to assassinate Queen Selenay (just before Arrows of the Queen.) A strong woman can do many things when she sets her mind to it, including pulling the tired and worn people of Sandbriar together to survive the winter and perhaps make the land prosper again.
We take our public libraries for granted, but what about Valdemar? What kind of need would push people to loaning out expensive volumes to those they don't know? Fiona Patton explores this idea in "Ex Libris."
In "A Dream Reborn," by Dylan Birtolo, a chance encounter with a Companion leaves a young woman with some lingering doubt about her actions.
Mercedes Lackey revisits the Herald Mage, Vanyel, in "Vixen." When a sharp-tongued healer is trapped in a small village while a monster attacks, she must use her talents and her good sense to help everyone, including a very unlikely savior.
Every story in this anthology offers something for every fan of Valdemar.
No True Way: All-New Tales of Valdemar keeps true to that unwritten promise. This anthology has a little of everything from desperate decisions to gentle fondness, sometimes in the same story. The anthology features well known authors such as Diana L Paxton and Jennifer Brozek as well as newer authors like Dylan Birtolo and Stephanie Shaver.
Each story takes on one of those little corners that develop when a larger story comes to life. While some of these stories fill in the gaps others happily find their place in the wild world and invite you in. Each lets you know a bit more about Valdemar and the people within.
One of the most emotionally powerful stories was Jennifer Brozek's "Written in the Wind." In just a few short words Brozek emotionally ties you a set of twins--newly Chosen--and their Companions. It was the single story in this anthology that really made me stop and reread the last page.
Elizabeth Vaughn launches the reader into the plight of Lady Cera, wife of one of the men who tried to assassinate Queen Selenay (just before Arrows of the Queen.) A strong woman can do many things when she sets her mind to it, including pulling the tired and worn people of Sandbriar together to survive the winter and perhaps make the land prosper again.
We take our public libraries for granted, but what about Valdemar? What kind of need would push people to loaning out expensive volumes to those they don't know? Fiona Patton explores this idea in "Ex Libris."
In "A Dream Reborn," by Dylan Birtolo, a chance encounter with a Companion leaves a young woman with some lingering doubt about her actions.
Mercedes Lackey revisits the Herald Mage, Vanyel, in "Vixen." When a sharp-tongued healer is trapped in a small village while a monster attacks, she must use her talents and her good sense to help everyone, including a very unlikely savior.
Every story in this anthology offers something for every fan of Valdemar.
April 5, 2015
There's something warm and comforting about reading Valdemar, since this was the series of my teen years. Despite being "shocking" when I first read it (Arrow's Fall and Magic's Price!), the world is now surprisingly innocent (and I have to wonder if it's too stale for "modern" teens to get into). The series has a bit of "stuck in the nineties" fantasy about it, but that's okay for me. I've found the short story collections a lot more enjoyable than anything published in the main series since circa 2000.
Like all anthologies, it's a mixed bag, but no true stinker stands out. The "gifted, misunderstood individual finds place" got really old, but most of the pieces were enjoyable. These were my favorites from this collection:
The Whitest Lie: More of the Herald Will story. I enjoy how this story series has developed over the anthology. I wish Stephanie Shaver was able to write a full book in Valdemar since I think it would be interesting.
Consequences Unforeseen: Ceraratha goes to take control of the Manor, a sequel to a story in an earlier collection. I like the heroine, and I'd love to see more. I enjoyed the "Lady of the Mannor" aspect to this.
Weavings: I have to wonder if the authors were originally given a theme of yarnwork for this book since there's a lot of stories centered around weaving/spinning, etc. This was my favorite of them since I liked how the villagers reacted to the situation they were in.
Beyond the Fires: A tale of one of the "wretches" (camp followers/slave what-have-you) from the Tedrel War. I always thought the women were pitiful, but I like the explanation for their actions (or lack their of).
Vixen: Mercedes Lackey spins a tale set in the Vanyel-years. It's a bit quirky and fun, and reminds me of the Tarma and Kethry adventures. I do think Vanyel's actions were a bit OOC, but anything that doesn't have him wallowing in melodramatic, Chosen One angst seem OOC to me.
Like all anthologies, it's a mixed bag, but no true stinker stands out. The "gifted, misunderstood individual finds place" got really old, but most of the pieces were enjoyable. These were my favorites from this collection:
The Whitest Lie: More of the Herald Will story. I enjoy how this story series has developed over the anthology. I wish Stephanie Shaver was able to write a full book in Valdemar since I think it would be interesting.
Consequences Unforeseen: Ceraratha goes to take control of the Manor, a sequel to a story in an earlier collection. I like the heroine, and I'd love to see more. I enjoyed the "Lady of the Mannor" aspect to this.
Weavings: I have to wonder if the authors were originally given a theme of yarnwork for this book since there's a lot of stories centered around weaving/spinning, etc. This was my favorite of them since I liked how the villagers reacted to the situation they were in.
Beyond the Fires: A tale of one of the "wretches" (camp followers/slave what-have-you) from the Tedrel War. I always thought the women were pitiful, but I like the explanation for their actions (or lack their of).
Vixen: Mercedes Lackey spins a tale set in the Vanyel-years. It's a bit quirky and fun, and reminds me of the Tarma and Kethry adventures. I do think Vanyel's actions were a bit OOC, but anything that doesn't have him wallowing in melodramatic, Chosen One angst seem OOC to me.
January 22, 2021
Yet another great selection of stories in this book.
Story 1: The Whitest Lie, by Stephanie D. Shaver.
This involves Herald Wil, and a mystery surrounding some ledgers he has found, written by his dead wife, the Bard Lelia. It also involves their 3 year old daughter, Ivy. A brilliant story that brought tears to my eyes!
Story 2: Old Loom, New Tapestry, by Dayle A. Dermatis.
Heralds Syrriah and Joralgo go to the village of Blenvane where the Lady if the Manor has been held for murdering her husband. As a former Lady of the Manor herself, Syrriah, along with her Gift of Empathy, gets to the bottom of the reasons for the murder and, in doing so, confirms her own identity as a Herald.
Story 3: The Barest Gift, by Brenda Cooper.
This is a lovely tale of a young girl who, on her Grandmother's death bed, learns that she inherited her little Gift from her. Her Grandfather tells her the story of why his wife had a song written for her.
Story 4: Consequences Unforseen, by Elizabeth A. Vaughn.
This is a follow-up story of Lady Ceraratha, or Cera, the widow of one of the Lords who had plotted to kill Queen Selenay, and how she was determined to prove her loyalty to the Queen, and Valdemar. On being given the land that had been awarded to her husband before the attempt, she finds out that it bore the brunt of the Tedrel Wars, along with its neighbouring lands.
This story tells of the hope she brings to those who had borne the worst of it all.
Story 5: Written in the Wind, by Jennifer Brozek.
This is a story that tells of twins, Chosen together, and with Foresight as their Gift. On their journey to Haven, they sense a darkness that they had foreseen.
This was a short, but powerful, story, and left me feeling very uneasy. Great writing!
Story 6: Nwah, by Ron Collins.
This story starts with Nwah, a Kyree, waking up to the prodding of a young boy, Kade, and finding herself both injured, and with no memory as to how it happened. The boy tries to help heal her, but his stepmother doesn't want Nwah there and so, when Kade goes put of the house with his father, she sells Kade to someone who calls at the house. Nwah instinctively hates the man and, when Kade rescues her, they go off together, determined to find out what had happened to Nwah!
I REALLY want to know what happens next in Nwah's story, and hope that Ron Collins has written more about her!
Story 7: Spun Magic, by Kristin Schwengel.
This is a wonderful follow-up story about Stardance, the Healer Mage, and how she is called back to her original Vale, to try and work out why so many of their Healers have developed an illness that gradually weakens them near to death. Her actions will have some unexpected results!
I loved reading more about Stardance and her Mage abilities. I do hope Kristin writes more stories about her.
Story 8: Weavings, by Diana L. Paxon.
This story involves Deira, a weaver, whose village is attacked by a monster from the Pelagirs. When a Herald comes to help, she does her best to keep him away from her, and her daughter. But, with the monster killing in order to get food for it's soon to be hatching eggs, Deira finds the strength to face her past, so that she can help to save her future.
I feel as though I've read about Deira before, as she seems very familiar but, if not, she certainly fitted in well with all that I've read so far. A great story.
Story 9: A Wake of Vultures, by Elisabeth Waters.
I really love the way that Elisabeth wraps the grouping of animals into the wonderful tales she writes, and this one is just as good as her previous efforts.
While travelling to visit family friends, escorted by two Heralds, Lena, the Animal Mindspeaker, comes across a group of Vultures standing around a dead body. When the vultures warn her against going near the body, Lena knows she must find out both who the dead man is, and why the vultures are calling him Death!
Story 10: Maiden's Hope, by Michele Long.
While in the forest gathering herbs to help heal her father, Sparrow is approached by a Companion, bearing the unconscious body of his newly Chosen. The boy turns out to be someone very surprising, and changes the course of Sparrow's life.
A lovely tale, and well worth reading.
Story 11: Ex Libris, by Fiona Patton.
I loved this story for so many reasons! One, because it was about my favourite City Guard family, again - Yay! Secondly, because it involved books, of course! Thirdly, because there are just so many characters that I like reading about who are, in one way or another, involved with the Dann clan. Love it, love it, love it!
Story 12: A Dream Reborn, by Dylan Birtolo.
This story deals with a young girl called Sera, who uses her Gift when begging, because that's the only life she has known ever since her parents died. Then something happens to her, and it changes her life. This was a nice tale.
Story 13: Forget Me Never, by Cedric Johnson.
This tale is about Korinda, a trainee Bard in Rethwellan who, tired of being ignored by everyone around her, leaves the Collegium where she was being trained, and sets out, in the general direction of Valdemar, to seek adventure and, possibly, fortune. What happens along the way, and how she copes with it, brings an offer she can't refuse.
A good story.
Story 14: Beyond the Fires, by Louisa Swann.
Lianna is a captive of the Tedrels. Gang raped, and constantly brutalised, at fourteen, and now eight months pregnant. While the Tedrels go off to fight the people of Valdemar, she is led away from the camp by a Raven. What happens to her will change her life...
A story that both shocks, but also gives hope - and deals with difficult subjects in a way that shows the realities of life.
Story 15: A Brand from the Burning, by Rosemary Edghill and Rebecca Fox.
In Karse, in the Palace of Hierophant Virtulias, is an acolyte who will change everything, not only for Karse, but for the whole world of Velgarth itself. Her name is Solaris, and she has Hettes, the Hierophant's housekeeper, to keep a watch over her, until the time is right to move.
I loved this glimpse into the plotting and striving that goes on in the early years of Solaris' life!
Story 16: Vixen, by Mercedes Lackey.
A Healer on Circuit, Vixen did all she could to help those in genuine need - but had a tongue so sharp for those who waste her valuable time, that it had earned her the sobriquet of Vixen. As she gets near to one of the villages on her Circuit, a Companion asks for her help - and then things get rather strange!
A brilliant tale, and I'd so love to read more about Vixen!
Story 1: The Whitest Lie, by Stephanie D. Shaver.
This involves Herald Wil, and a mystery surrounding some ledgers he has found, written by his dead wife, the Bard Lelia. It also involves their 3 year old daughter, Ivy. A brilliant story that brought tears to my eyes!
Story 2: Old Loom, New Tapestry, by Dayle A. Dermatis.
Heralds Syrriah and Joralgo go to the village of Blenvane where the Lady if the Manor has been held for murdering her husband. As a former Lady of the Manor herself, Syrriah, along with her Gift of Empathy, gets to the bottom of the reasons for the murder and, in doing so, confirms her own identity as a Herald.
Story 3: The Barest Gift, by Brenda Cooper.
This is a lovely tale of a young girl who, on her Grandmother's death bed, learns that she inherited her little Gift from her. Her Grandfather tells her the story of why his wife had a song written for her.
Story 4: Consequences Unforseen, by Elizabeth A. Vaughn.
This is a follow-up story of Lady Ceraratha, or Cera, the widow of one of the Lords who had plotted to kill Queen Selenay, and how she was determined to prove her loyalty to the Queen, and Valdemar. On being given the land that had been awarded to her husband before the attempt, she finds out that it bore the brunt of the Tedrel Wars, along with its neighbouring lands.
This story tells of the hope she brings to those who had borne the worst of it all.
Story 5: Written in the Wind, by Jennifer Brozek.
This is a story that tells of twins, Chosen together, and with Foresight as their Gift. On their journey to Haven, they sense a darkness that they had foreseen.
This was a short, but powerful, story, and left me feeling very uneasy. Great writing!
Story 6: Nwah, by Ron Collins.
This story starts with Nwah, a Kyree, waking up to the prodding of a young boy, Kade, and finding herself both injured, and with no memory as to how it happened. The boy tries to help heal her, but his stepmother doesn't want Nwah there and so, when Kade goes put of the house with his father, she sells Kade to someone who calls at the house. Nwah instinctively hates the man and, when Kade rescues her, they go off together, determined to find out what had happened to Nwah!
I REALLY want to know what happens next in Nwah's story, and hope that Ron Collins has written more about her!
Story 7: Spun Magic, by Kristin Schwengel.
This is a wonderful follow-up story about Stardance, the Healer Mage, and how she is called back to her original Vale, to try and work out why so many of their Healers have developed an illness that gradually weakens them near to death. Her actions will have some unexpected results!
I loved reading more about Stardance and her Mage abilities. I do hope Kristin writes more stories about her.
Story 8: Weavings, by Diana L. Paxon.
This story involves Deira, a weaver, whose village is attacked by a monster from the Pelagirs. When a Herald comes to help, she does her best to keep him away from her, and her daughter. But, with the monster killing in order to get food for it's soon to be hatching eggs, Deira finds the strength to face her past, so that she can help to save her future.
I feel as though I've read about Deira before, as she seems very familiar but, if not, she certainly fitted in well with all that I've read so far. A great story.
Story 9: A Wake of Vultures, by Elisabeth Waters.
I really love the way that Elisabeth wraps the grouping of animals into the wonderful tales she writes, and this one is just as good as her previous efforts.
While travelling to visit family friends, escorted by two Heralds, Lena, the Animal Mindspeaker, comes across a group of Vultures standing around a dead body. When the vultures warn her against going near the body, Lena knows she must find out both who the dead man is, and why the vultures are calling him Death!
Story 10: Maiden's Hope, by Michele Long.
While in the forest gathering herbs to help heal her father, Sparrow is approached by a Companion, bearing the unconscious body of his newly Chosen. The boy turns out to be someone very surprising, and changes the course of Sparrow's life.
A lovely tale, and well worth reading.
Story 11: Ex Libris, by Fiona Patton.
I loved this story for so many reasons! One, because it was about my favourite City Guard family, again - Yay! Secondly, because it involved books, of course! Thirdly, because there are just so many characters that I like reading about who are, in one way or another, involved with the Dann clan. Love it, love it, love it!
Story 12: A Dream Reborn, by Dylan Birtolo.
This story deals with a young girl called Sera, who uses her Gift when begging, because that's the only life she has known ever since her parents died. Then something happens to her, and it changes her life. This was a nice tale.
Story 13: Forget Me Never, by Cedric Johnson.
This tale is about Korinda, a trainee Bard in Rethwellan who, tired of being ignored by everyone around her, leaves the Collegium where she was being trained, and sets out, in the general direction of Valdemar, to seek adventure and, possibly, fortune. What happens along the way, and how she copes with it, brings an offer she can't refuse.
A good story.
Story 14: Beyond the Fires, by Louisa Swann.
Lianna is a captive of the Tedrels. Gang raped, and constantly brutalised, at fourteen, and now eight months pregnant. While the Tedrels go off to fight the people of Valdemar, she is led away from the camp by a Raven. What happens to her will change her life...
A story that both shocks, but also gives hope - and deals with difficult subjects in a way that shows the realities of life.
Story 15: A Brand from the Burning, by Rosemary Edghill and Rebecca Fox.
In Karse, in the Palace of Hierophant Virtulias, is an acolyte who will change everything, not only for Karse, but for the whole world of Velgarth itself. Her name is Solaris, and she has Hettes, the Hierophant's housekeeper, to keep a watch over her, until the time is right to move.
I loved this glimpse into the plotting and striving that goes on in the early years of Solaris' life!
Story 16: Vixen, by Mercedes Lackey.
A Healer on Circuit, Vixen did all she could to help those in genuine need - but had a tongue so sharp for those who waste her valuable time, that it had earned her the sobriquet of Vixen. As she gets near to one of the villages on her Circuit, a Companion asks for her help - and then things get rather strange!
A brilliant tale, and I'd so love to read more about Vixen!
September 1, 2020
Thanks to a friend who has a story in this anthology, I was reminded that it had just come out and so I bought it and read it through yesterday. The stories were varied and interesting, with several continuing on the tales of various characters from previous anthologies, and overall they were very good. I did find two stories to be below the level of the rest, in a slightly indefinable way, which is why I knocked off one star (again, wish we could have half-star ratings on Goodreads!) - that might be rough of me, but I hold Valdemar to a very high standard!
I greatly enjoyed the story of a kyree, as something we haven't seen much of apart from the famous Warrl, as well as a story set in the Tayledras vales that didn't involve anyone from Valdemar. I also liked that there was some time shift to the stories, some were "recent" (aka post Mage Storms) and some were decidedly not (a young Vanyel story). I definitely spent a delightful afternoon revisiting old friends and reading tales of new ones, and I loved them all. Anyone who is a fan of Valdemar will not regret this purchase!
Finally, while I wasn't expecting it to be so, my favorite story was The Innkeeper's Daughter, and I'm ever so proud of my friend for writing such a caring and lovely tale.
I greatly enjoyed the story of a kyree, as something we haven't seen much of apart from the famous Warrl, as well as a story set in the Tayledras vales that didn't involve anyone from Valdemar. I also liked that there was some time shift to the stories, some were "recent" (aka post Mage Storms) and some were decidedly not (a young Vanyel story). I definitely spent a delightful afternoon revisiting old friends and reading tales of new ones, and I loved them all. Anyone who is a fan of Valdemar will not regret this purchase!
Finally, while I wasn't expecting it to be so, my favorite story was The Innkeeper's Daughter, and I'm ever so proud of my friend for writing such a caring and lovely tale.
February 2, 2015
This volume was so much better than they've been! I think it helped that there were only 3 stories that were continuations of previous characters/story lines from other anthologies - one of those was the only story that I didn't finish. I really enjoyed the stories that filled in the gaps: why no new Herald Mages were getting to Haven (chilling and really well done), life in the Tedrel camps, the wife of one of Karath's friends and how she determined to make something positive of her life after that event, Solaris as a child and a look at the corruption inside the Sun Priests, and a rare glimpse at a moment when Vanyel is there but doesn't have to be the hero.
I was struck by how much loss and grief were themes in these stories, especially in the first half of the book. But a Vanyel novella anchors this collection and his story was entirely about loss and grief (with some hope and love thanks to Stef). That's why I so enjoyed the quiet story of someone else saving him and Vanyel getting to take a break (even if forced), and also a moment when he was just a normal Herald on circuit.
I was struck by how much loss and grief were themes in these stories, especially in the first half of the book. But a Vanyel novella anchors this collection and his story was entirely about loss and grief (with some hope and love thanks to Stef). That's why I so enjoyed the quiet story of someone else saving him and Vanyel getting to take a break (even if forced), and also a moment when he was just a normal Herald on circuit.
April 11, 2017
Like most compilations of this type, the quality varies from story to story. A lot of the tales collected here are simply echoes of the beloved world of Valdemar and thus less effective than they might have been. The ones that I liked best explored corners left untouched by the novels. A family of innkeepers talking about their history, a weaver who once loved a herald unluckily, a kyree caught by poachers, a woman with animal mindspeech solving a murder mystery, and other characters step forward from the backdrop of the land of Valdemar when these stories are at their best. They add depth and breadth to an already beautifully developed world. And of course Lackey's own story at the end about Vanyel and Vixen was completely charming.
I highly recommend this book to fans of the land of Valdemar, though I do think readers of the earlier books will get the most out of it.
I highly recommend this book to fans of the land of Valdemar, though I do think readers of the earlier books will get the most out of it.
January 15, 2015
Pure joy
I am always skeptical anthologies. They are usually like eating at a small town Chinese buffet restaurant not a lot of variety and when it is all said and done the same six ingredients just chopped a bit different...No True Way wasn't the same bland standard fare it was a nice mix of old and comfortable arenas with some wonderful new characters. Misty, if you read this review please edit a couple more anthologies of the lands and people of Vanyel's universe using this formula...it was delightful,fun,fresh with the right amount familiar.
I am always skeptical anthologies. They are usually like eating at a small town Chinese buffet restaurant not a lot of variety and when it is all said and done the same six ingredients just chopped a bit different...No True Way wasn't the same bland standard fare it was a nice mix of old and comfortable arenas with some wonderful new characters. Misty, if you read this review please edit a couple more anthologies of the lands and people of Vanyel's universe using this formula...it was delightful,fun,fresh with the right amount familiar.
March 4, 2016
I used to really like these anthologies but as time has gone on, the stories have moved further and further away from my favorites. For example, different tales of choosing, bards, healers and heralds working together were the ones that I really liked. These are still good and I like them, but they are not as good as the early collections (imo)
March 3, 2015
Good selection of stories
I liked all of the stories, and really liked quite a few. There are several that I wished were longer as I found those stories intriguing and worth a longer visit.
I enjoyed reading about old friends, and meeting new ones. If you enjoy Valdemar and the surrounding areas, you will enjoy these stories.
I liked all of the stories, and really liked quite a few. There are several that I wished were longer as I found those stories intriguing and worth a longer visit.
I enjoyed reading about old friends, and meeting new ones. If you enjoy Valdemar and the surrounding areas, you will enjoy these stories.
March 10, 2015
Really awesome story collection. I was a little sad that some of the previous authors who have been writing about the same characters for a while hadn't been back in this one. Maybe they finished the stories they wanted to tell, maybe they just didn't have one written. But mostly it was a good book. Just felt a little sad that I couldn't catch up on some of my favorite characters.
April 21, 2015
I liked this better than some of the other Valdemar anthologies. There were less stories that required remembering who the characters were.
January 2, 2015
Most of the stories were good. A couple didn't seem to have a real sense of what Valdemar, Heralds, Companions, and Hawkbrothers are really about. The story Written In The Wind was tragic and depressing. Don't read if you hate evil winning and children being murdered.
January 15, 2015
Excellent collection of short stories about all things Valdemar. Many feel like the gateway to brand new adventures set in Lackey's world. I hope they are just that--a gateway to a new era by a gifted bunch of authors.
February 25, 2015
One of the best anthologies.
One of the best anthologies I've read since the last book of short stories about Valdemar. In fact, in each of the previous anthologies there were some, (usually at least 2) that I disliked. Not this time!
One of the best anthologies I've read since the last book of short stories about Valdemar. In fact, in each of the previous anthologies there were some, (usually at least 2) that I disliked. Not this time!
December 25, 2014
good stories
One story was very, very sad. One story was just... Weird. The rest were great and I recommend them to all.
One story was very, very sad. One story was just... Weird. The rest were great and I recommend them to all.
February 25, 2015
A wonderfully diverse collection of all new tales from the magical and exciting world of Valdemar.
May 16, 2017
Overall, a very good anthology. Two rather negative stories that I'll skip rather than read next time. But also some fun stories and some that are continued from previous anthologies.
March 27, 2015
I had to skip one short story - it referenced anthrax, which would not exist in the world of the stories.
April 27, 2015
Valdermar
Loved these books from my first one, still love them and want to hear more about the characters and Companions
Loved these books from my first one, still love them and want to hear more about the characters and Companions
January 18, 2017
Continuing the 4-5 year read-through of stories which carry the same characters forward. See book #5, which is as far back as I went.
May 25, 2024
My review is broken into pieces following each individual story in the order I read them in. I read 7 stories from this anthology.
“Vixen” by Mercedes Lackey: I quite liked this one. Hadn’t thought Animal Mindspeech might be a totally separate thing from regular Mindspeech, but it makes sense. I liked Healer Vixen, too. She’s very relatable, as one who was bullied in early childhood and sometimes feels like a disappointment. Interesting to have a giant spider critter around and glad this wasn’t illustrated. Lol.
“Written in the Wind” by Jennifer Brozek: Well that was dark. Hella heartbreaking, too.
”A Brand from the Burning” by Rosemary Edghill and Rebecca Fox: Ah, the intrigues around choosing a new Pope. Oh, sorry, Son of the Sun. I knew Solaris was familiar! I remember her from later on… or a snippet from the wiki, more probably. But yay for setup.
“Weavings” by Diana L. Paxson: Joy, giant spider. Another lady who loved a Herald and essentially lost him.
“Beyond the Fires” by Louisa Swann: I liked it. Pretty cool story.
“Consequences Unforseen” by Elizabeth A. Vaughan: Lady Cera settling into her new lands and learning what there is to learn about them. It was alright, if not particularly exciting.
”Spun Magic” by Kristin Schwengel: The way Stardance works magic reminds me a lot of Sandry from Tamora Pierce’s Circle of Magic series. I have the feeling we were supposed to see some kind of attachment formed between Stardance and her father, but there was literally nothing in the text to make me feel any sort of attachment to him or their rekindled? relationship. Honestly, the human relationships here leave much to be desired. The magic, though, is very well detailed and definitely feels like Sandry’s style to me.
“Vixen” by Mercedes Lackey: I quite liked this one. Hadn’t thought Animal Mindspeech might be a totally separate thing from regular Mindspeech, but it makes sense. I liked Healer Vixen, too. She’s very relatable, as one who was bullied in early childhood and sometimes feels like a disappointment. Interesting to have a giant spider critter around and glad this wasn’t illustrated. Lol.
“Written in the Wind” by Jennifer Brozek: Well that was dark. Hella heartbreaking, too.
”A Brand from the Burning” by Rosemary Edghill and Rebecca Fox: Ah, the intrigues around choosing a new Pope. Oh, sorry, Son of the Sun. I knew Solaris was familiar! I remember her from later on… or a snippet from the wiki, more probably. But yay for setup.
“Weavings” by Diana L. Paxson: Joy, giant spider. Another lady who loved a Herald and essentially lost him.
“Beyond the Fires” by Louisa Swann: I liked it. Pretty cool story.
“Consequences Unforseen” by Elizabeth A. Vaughan: Lady Cera settling into her new lands and learning what there is to learn about them. It was alright, if not particularly exciting.
”Spun Magic” by Kristin Schwengel: The way Stardance works magic reminds me a lot of Sandry from Tamora Pierce’s Circle of Magic series. I have the feeling we were supposed to see some kind of attachment formed between Stardance and her father, but there was literally nothing in the text to make me feel any sort of attachment to him or their rekindled? relationship. Honestly, the human relationships here leave much to be desired. The magic, though, is very well detailed and definitely feels like Sandry’s style to me.
February 2, 2022
I had this weird sense of deja vu while reading this Valdemar collection. At least half of these stories I've read before. But I have no record of it - no previous addition to GR, no hard copy on my shelf, no recollection of the other half of these stories so I probably did not read this exact book before. Did half these stories get sold and end up in other short story collections as well? It's just so strange.
Anyway, as usual with SS collections I find them either 1. too simple or 2. I want more. Since the authors don't need to focus on creating the setting (Valdemar is so established by now, it's probably rather easy to write in this world as an outside author), I expect a higher quality of story. You should be writing compelling characters with interesting plots. And I expect even more from the authors who are writing series (like the Dann siblings one), since they have even less character work to do! But overall these stories left me feeling a bit meh.
I'll keep reading the Valdemar SS collections. How can I not when I adore the world? I'm hoping that their quality also improves as I move up in the years.
Anyway, as usual with SS collections I find them either 1. too simple or 2. I want more. Since the authors don't need to focus on creating the setting (Valdemar is so established by now, it's probably rather easy to write in this world as an outside author), I expect a higher quality of story. You should be writing compelling characters with interesting plots. And I expect even more from the authors who are writing series (like the Dann siblings one), since they have even less character work to do! But overall these stories left me feeling a bit meh.
I'll keep reading the Valdemar SS collections. How can I not when I adore the world? I'm hoping that their quality also improves as I move up in the years.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 98 reviews