Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book
Rate this book
P.J. Night's latest installment in the spooky and spectacular Creepover series for middle-grade girls is a level 5 on the Creep-o-Meter.

In Is She For Real?, Bethany has just moved to Old Warwick, a quaint old town that is said to be haunted by the ghost of Lady Warwick. Lady Warwick lived centuries ago and died of a broken heart…but her grave was found empty shortly after her death. Legend says that Lady Warwick was buried alive and still roams Old Warwick today in search of her lost love. Bethany hears all about the legend from her new friends and thinks it’s all pretty corny—until really strange things start happening to her. With a ring on her finger that looks just like the one Lady Warwick wore, and a new boyfriend with chilling similarities to Lady Warwick’s lost love, Bethany’s friends have to wonder: Is real life imitating legend...or becoming legend?

This tale is a level 5 on the Creep-o-Meter. Super scary!

160 pages, Kindle Edition

First published April 3, 2012

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

P.J. Night

52 books158 followers
P.J. Night Revealed
Revealing Questions

Q. How would you describe your life in only 8 words?
A. Reading, writing, and scaring up new ideas!

Q. What is your motto or maxim?
A. There are mysteries everywhere . . . you just have to know where to look.

Q. How would you describe perfect happiness?
A. Sitting with my cat on my lap and reading a book I just can't put down.

Q. What’s your greatest fear?
A. Flowers and teddy bears :)

Q. If you could be anywhere in the world right now, where would you choose to be?
A. At some very old and very haunted place. Transylvania or the Tower of London, anyone?

Q. If you could acquire any talent, what would it be?
A. Psychic powers

Q. If you could be any person or thing, who or what would it be?
A. A black cat

Q. Who is your favorite fictional hero?
A. Nancy Drew

Q. Who is your favorite fictional villain?
A. The Wicked Witch of the West

Q. What’s your fantasy profession?
A. Ghost hunter

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
231 (54%)
4 stars
81 (19%)
3 stars
81 (19%)
2 stars
23 (5%)
1 star
9 (2%)
Displaying 1 - 27 of 27 reviews
Profile Image for Joshua Hair.
Author 1 book111 followers
February 8, 2022
Oh man. I think I cursed myself by talking about how great all these books are. There’s no way this was written by the same author. The other Creepover books have been well-written, witty, and creepy. This one was an amateur attempt at best. The story made no sense, the dialogue sounded unreal, and the same sentence or information would often be repeated a paragraph later. Up to this point, these books have been what I hope to see kids reading. This one is a severely dumbed down version that feels like an insult to the target audience. I have to hope that whoever wrote this one didn’t have their hand in any others.
8 reviews
June 12, 2019
This series is really well-written, articulate, and spooky. As an adult, I sincerely enjoy reading these. The plot is interesting, the characters are well developed, and the finale sends shivers up your spine. I would definitely recommend these as fun "beach-reads" for anyone!
Profile Image for Mehsi.
16.2k reviews480 followers
July 14, 2014
Re-read 2020: A great book and I had tons of fun reading it, though I would have definitely pulled off the ring longer if I had noticed that it made me feel weird. I mean come on, everyone could see it was all about the ring. I also found the milord and milady on the one hand cute, on the other hand creepy. Also I had a laugh that no one noticed whose ring it was until the end.
Bethany's change was creepy and while I was a bit unhappy with her, but then again, with the ring controlling her she couldn't help it. The ending was a bit creepy but I also would have liked a bit more. We suddenly switch to an epilogue and I would have loved more before that had happened.
I still got a few of these Creepover books left to reread so I can't wait!

----------------------------------------------

This was a good book, however there were also things I hated.

First things I liked:
1. The historical stuff. We have quite a background about 2 people and their little town.
2. Possession (through ring). One of my favourite settings, someone possessed by someone/something.
3. Lissa and her friends. I really liked them, they were interesting and fun. Though it was kind of unbelievable how fast they became friends with Bethany.
4. The cover. Creepy with a dash of romantic.

Now the bad things:
1.Bethany, I know, I know, she was under the spell of the ring, but it was just excruciating to read from her point of view. She was annoying, jealous and whiny. Her self-esteem was super low. She kept ranting about Nate, and him being mean, and him probably dating or looking at other girls. Oh boo hoo. I felt sorry for Nate. I cannot for life imagine why he would stay with her. At the end? I was happy she
2. The switching of POVs, we had 3 this time. Nate, Lissa and also Bethany. At times it was just confusing who was chatting/thinking this time.

As you can see only a few bad things and mostly good things, so 4 stars. Though I had hoped for better.

Review first posted at http://twirlingbookprincess.com/
1 review
March 9, 2021
My gosh! What a gripping tale! The storyline, with its rich, historical background transported me into this sleepy seaside village. I'm an adult and I was totally mesmerized by this book. Imagine, someone was calling me and so immersed was I in the novel, it took me a moment to realize I'm sitting at my desk in work! This surely captured and held my attention and I'm sure others will find it impossible to put down as well. I can assure you all that this tale and its implications will be in my thoughts for days to come. I can see others being gripped by this novel for sure!
Profile Image for Jess - The Hexed Library.
1,220 reviews150 followers
October 19, 2020
3.25

I feel like once you've read the synopsis for this book, you can just read the epilogue because there's nothing left to learn. It's decent for a midgrade but it doesn't even really excel from there.
Profile Image for Hayley.
9 reviews
July 19, 2013
It was a scary I got scared I loved the ending don't let history repeat itself!!!
Profile Image for Maddie .
16 reviews
August 22, 2013
That book was amazing an scary !
History repeated its self again !
I LOVED THE ENDING IT WAS VERY MYSTERIOUS AND CREEPY !!!...
Profile Image for Jennifer.
497 reviews
October 9, 2014

Another solid and scary entry in this generally excellent series, this time written by Kama Einhorn.
Profile Image for eda.
369 reviews22 followers
July 19, 2020
I found the plot twist was really obvious and not very good. Not my favourite creepover book in the series.
Profile Image for Liberty.
246 reviews15 followers
January 27, 2025
I love this series I really do. It's very obvious that each book is written by a different person under a pseudonym. But some of these books like this one and the ones that preceded it leave me with more questions than answers. What the heck do the parents do when their children go missing? Did they just move away? Did they suddenly forget they had a child. On the one hand, you can suspend disbelief. But come on.

Why didn't any of them stay with her when she was on the beach? Why would you bury her in the sand despite her very obvious protests? Why would you leave the ring on your finger if you're starting to figure out that it's making you feel weird?

Did she become the ghost? Did her parents notice she was gone? Did they not exist at all? It was an elaborate plot by ghost. I don't know it doesn't answer it it just jumps to an epilogue. I would like some answers please. And why the heck would you throw the ring back in the ocean when it's just going to walk back up and probably start the cycle all over again.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Kiara.
9 reviews
December 30, 2024
Listen, the ending was crazy! I felt so bad for the boy and the fact that everyone just seemed to move on with time and he remained, not quite ready to let go. The scene where he tossed the ring back into the sea, for me that was saying yes, this will definitely happen again and another poor soul will have to experience that.

All I can say though is if you are indeed ready for a scare, this book, let alone this series, I highly recommend. These books just get better and better, some more creepier than others, really enjoyed this series as a child.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
108 reviews
January 6, 2026
I am not quite sure how to rate this. I read it to see if it would be fine for Tori to read. I think she’ll hate it. It is so focused on cheesy romance and not on the creepy story, which they talk up the whole story but then just end the book without any fanfare. Was super abrupt.
Profile Image for Alex.
7,050 reviews1 follower
March 23, 2023
I didn't like this one as much as others in the series, but it was still a lot of fun to read.
Profile Image for Finnick.
19 reviews
March 24, 2023
Scared the shit out of me in like 1st grade. Almost cried when the lights went off at school
Profile Image for C.C. Bruno.
Author 4 books14 followers
August 30, 2024
A creepy book to top off the summer.

P. J. Night has a real knack for making children's stories creepy and I love it!
Profile Image for Angie Titus.
Author 3 books21 followers
January 31, 2025
This is my least favorite of those I've read in the series so far. A little too much middle grade romance for me as an adult. The only part I really liked was the ending.
20 reviews
October 18, 2026
This was my least favorite of the series so far. Slow and hard to get into
Profile Image for Yashira.
1 review
Read
November 24, 2015
When I first started reading this book I didn't really like it. It was boring. But I felt that maybe if i kept reading to see what i like about it, maybe that'll get me interested in reading more and hopefully finishing it. I liked it in the ending. It was a mysterious yet shocking and entertaining book. I hope to read more books in the romance genre area. Like romance with a twist and action in it.
Profile Image for Natsu.
211 reviews5 followers
May 21, 2014
at first I thought this book was just a children horror story like Goosebumps or so, but hell, it's way creepier than GB..
never thought it would give me the creep -_-
the story wasn't all that cheesy, it was pretty good for a children book, I must say. I like the ending. The story was predictable but what happened to Bethany was like, waooww..
and somehow I wanted more story of this book..
Profile Image for Rosalie.
111 reviews
July 11, 2013
I wasn’t to sure about this when I started. The character seemed rather out of their age group for most of it. In the end I did enjoy the storyline and the progression of events.
Profile Image for Faith.
1 review
Want to Read
August 18, 2014
How do you read? I can't open the book
Displaying 1 - 27 of 27 reviews