What do you think?
Rate this book
Visions of the Cailleach: Exploring the Myths, Folklore and Legends of the pre-eminent Celtic Hag Goddess
The Cailleach is the British Celtic hag goddess who shaped the land by moving the rocks and rivers. She is also a weather goddess who rules the months of Winter and shape-shifts into animal form. This crone goddess features heavily in the folklore of Scotland and Ireland, and the authors bring together tales from these countries and many others to form a unique and definitive study.
132 pages, Kindle Edition
First published March 1, 2009
About the author
Sorita d'Este
48 books274 followersSorita d’Este is an author, researcher and priestess who has devoted her life to the Mysteries. She is the author of around 20 books exploring subjects related to the practice and history of magic, mythology, religion, folklore and witchcraft. Her previous books include titles such as Hekate Liminal Rites, Practical Elemental Magick, Visions of the Cailleach, Wicca: Magickal Beginnings and The Isles of the Many Gods. Her latest release is Circle For Hekate: Vol I. She lives on a hill in Glastonbury (Somerset, UK) from where she works as a publisher and writer. She is frequently distracted from her work by her love of gardening, exciting visitors and the promise of interesting esoteric knowledge.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 30 reviews
May 21, 2012
A fasinating history and compilation of various Cailleach myths. Though I had heard stories fo her before, I wasnt aware of the scope and geographic spread of the legends and the connections to a possible priestess society. Or the connections to Malta, a place I have been intrigued by.
This book was very readable as well as informative making it more accessible than I expected. Very enjoyable.
This book was very readable as well as informative making it more accessible than I expected. Very enjoyable.
December 31, 2022
Visions of the Cailleach is a solid introduction to the figure of the Cailleach, as well as some other mythical figures which may be related to or have common origins with Cailleach. The text is well organized, clear, and very readable. The authors have demonstrated their thorough research, having included an extensive bibliography and footnotes throughout, and have helpfully included an index as well. I'm not sure about the subtitle, as now having read the book (and a few other sources) I'm not convinced 'goddess' is the right term here, and I do wish there was a short conclusion included as the book does seem to end rather abruptly. I do think some of the connections made in the book between Cailleach and other figures as well as the positing of the existence of a possible cult seem like over reaching with insufficient evidence; however, the authors are consistently very clear about what is speculative vs. what is based in textual evidence, which is important, so I have no qualms with the speculation. Recommended.
July 2, 2017
A short-ish look at a figure from the folklore of the British Islands with possibly related figures. This survey takes all these figures and stories and breaks them down into characteristics they have in common. This is not a retelling of the legends and stories. The tellings here are bare bones, as the authors try and tease out commonalities and possible links to older, pre-literate societies.
This work is a work on folklore and folktales, it's a glimpse into an older thought process that was bigger, more complex, stranger and more diffuse than we imagine from the Christian writings on them from later times. Recommended.
This work is a work on folklore and folktales, it's a glimpse into an older thought process that was bigger, more complex, stranger and more diffuse than we imagine from the Christian writings on them from later times. Recommended.
August 26, 2012
This is a good collection of the stories of Cailleachan, but the interpretations around them can be very odd. Despite being aware that Cailleach may be a class of beings rather than one being/goddess, the stories are often treated as one set of motifs, rather than being clearly separated by area. Additionally, the writers' belief that an ancient priesthood survives in the Cailleach stories is based on dated scholarship and influenced by Murray. That said, this is a helpful set of stories, some of which are hard to find elsewhere.
April 20, 2009
The editing could have been tighter, but the research can't be faulted - the bibliography is huge and varied. This book has brought together all the various tales and legends about this figure in a very accessible and enjoyable way.
January 22, 2014
This book was an interesting read. I am not 100% sure on some of the connections made, but it does give the reader something to think about.
April 21, 2015
Great resource
Well done but a little disorganized in its presentation. A wonderful resource about this folkloric character, nevertheless, and an interesting collection of tales.
Well done but a little disorganized in its presentation. A wonderful resource about this folkloric character, nevertheless, and an interesting collection of tales.
January 30, 2026
well researched and scholarly. it can be hard to find books on folklore that don't devolve into woo-woo and poorly annotated pseudo history. This book rarely veers into speculation and when it does it is very clear and doesn't try to pass anything unsubstantiated as fact. There are some passages that are difficult to read without a substantial existing knowledge of Celtic language conventions as well as a passing knowledge of folklore which may make it somewhat less accessible for introductory readers however YMMV in this respect.
August 10, 2025
This is the story of the Cailleach, a Celtic figure that represents winter. The authors pull together stories and traditional tales that mostly, probably represent the Cailleach. Sometimes, I think it may be a stretch, but it's interesting folk tales nonetheless. It helps put some things in context for me.
January 3, 2019
Nice compilation, if a bit redundant at times. However, some sites were misidentified as to country - an island in the Hebrides as Ireland? Not enough depth or analysis in spite of the hefty amount of footnotes and references. The end just ends. No summary or conclusion as to various theories or associations made in passing. Great starting point for someone wanting to do further research. Definitely a quick read - I finished in two days over the holiday. Overall, a flat read.
March 7, 2024
I expected a bit more academic rigor and better editing. I’m glad I read it as there are few books on the subject. Some of the interpretations were odd with no proof provided to back them up, not even UPG. The book also lacked cohesion and felt more like research prep for a more solid volume. Maybe it was rushed?
March 30, 2012
A fantastic resource for anyone interested in Irish or Goddess mythology, this is an exhaustive collection of Cailleach myths and connections with a huge bibliography.
January 12, 2013
review soon @ thefaeryromanticlibrarian.blogspot.com
December 24, 2018
'Tis the season for the Cailleach!
This is place-centered Celtic folklore.
This is place-centered Celtic folklore.
August 29, 2026
Visions of the Cailleach is at its best when it resists the temptation to flatten the Cailleach into the familiar modern category of “the Crone.” Sorita d’Este and David Rankine instead approach her as a diffuse and extraordinarily persistent complex of mythic, folkloric, and landscape motifs: giantess, winter hag, stone-carrier, guardian of animals, keeper of wells, sovereignty figure, shaper of terrain, and occasionally something far stranger than any single theological label can accommodate.
What interested me most is the authors’ use of place as evidence. The Cailleach does not survive merely in texts. She survives in hills, rocks, wells, burial places, weather lore, local names, seasonal customs, and stories attached to specific features of the land. That immediately gives the material a different texture from mythology treated as literary narrative alone. The landscape itself becomes a kind of archive, preserving memories of supernatural figures long after their original religious contexts have become obscure.
The recurring image of the Cailleach as earth-shaper is particularly compelling. Stories in which she carries or drops stones, builds mountains, forms islands, or alters the terrain situate her within that very old stratum of European folklore where gigantic supernatural beings explain the morphology of the land. D’Este and Rankine are attentive to the persistence of these motifs across regions, and the cumulative effect is more persuasive than any attempt to construct a tidy divine genealogy.
They also do useful work tracing the Cailleach into adjacent hag traditions. Black Annis, the Gyre Carling, Nicneven, Mia Lia, the Old Woman of the Mountain, and other figures are examined as possible reflections, transformations, or relatives of the same broader mythic pattern. The authors do not always have enough evidence to prove direct continuity, but that is part of what makes the book interesting. One sees mythology behaving less like a fixed canon and more like a migrating body of motifs that are localized, demonized, renamed, and reinterpreted over time.
The discussion of Christianization is likewise more nuanced than the standard pagan narrative of simple suppression. The Cailleach seems at points to be tolerated, absorbed into local explanatory folklore, and only gradually pushed toward more monstrous or demonic forms. That transformation says as much about changing attitudes toward female supernatural authority, old women, witches, and dangerous landscape spirits as it does about theology itself.
Where I am more cautious is with the book’s more speculative historical propositions. D’Este and Rankine explore the possibility of very ancient origins and even raise the question of a surviving priestess cult associated with the Cailleach. They do provide literary hints and later references, but they are also candid that these fragments raise more questions than they settle. That caveat is important. The material is fascinating, but the evidentiary line between recurring folklore, cultic survival, and direct historical continuity is necessarily difficult to establish.
This is precisely why I think the book is most valuable when read as a work of mythic and folkloric archaeology rather than as a definitive reconstruction of an ancient religion. Its real achievement lies in assembling a dispersed body of evidence and allowing the reader to see just how pervasive the Cailleach complex becomes when folklore, toponymy, literature, weather tradition, and sacred geography are examined together.
There is also something methodologically useful here for contemporary witchcraft. The book demonstrates how much can be recovered by looking beyond formal mythology. A supernatural figure may survive most vividly in a place-name, a ruined well, an agricultural custom, an old rhyme, or an explanation for an oddly shaped hill. Those materials are often messier than canonical myth, but they are also closer to the lived religious imagination of ordinary people.
Visions of the Cailleach therefore feels less like a conventional goddess book and more like a dossier assembled from the remnants of a vast regional presence. The Cailleach emerges not as a neatly bounded deity but as a being whose identity has accumulated through centuries of storytelling, local cult, seasonal memory, and landscape encounter.
That ambiguity is ultimately one of the book’s strengths. The Cailleach becomes more impressive, not less, when the authors allow her to remain larger than any single definition.
What interested me most is the authors’ use of place as evidence. The Cailleach does not survive merely in texts. She survives in hills, rocks, wells, burial places, weather lore, local names, seasonal customs, and stories attached to specific features of the land. That immediately gives the material a different texture from mythology treated as literary narrative alone. The landscape itself becomes a kind of archive, preserving memories of supernatural figures long after their original religious contexts have become obscure.
The recurring image of the Cailleach as earth-shaper is particularly compelling. Stories in which she carries or drops stones, builds mountains, forms islands, or alters the terrain situate her within that very old stratum of European folklore where gigantic supernatural beings explain the morphology of the land. D’Este and Rankine are attentive to the persistence of these motifs across regions, and the cumulative effect is more persuasive than any attempt to construct a tidy divine genealogy.
They also do useful work tracing the Cailleach into adjacent hag traditions. Black Annis, the Gyre Carling, Nicneven, Mia Lia, the Old Woman of the Mountain, and other figures are examined as possible reflections, transformations, or relatives of the same broader mythic pattern. The authors do not always have enough evidence to prove direct continuity, but that is part of what makes the book interesting. One sees mythology behaving less like a fixed canon and more like a migrating body of motifs that are localized, demonized, renamed, and reinterpreted over time.
The discussion of Christianization is likewise more nuanced than the standard pagan narrative of simple suppression. The Cailleach seems at points to be tolerated, absorbed into local explanatory folklore, and only gradually pushed toward more monstrous or demonic forms. That transformation says as much about changing attitudes toward female supernatural authority, old women, witches, and dangerous landscape spirits as it does about theology itself.
Where I am more cautious is with the book’s more speculative historical propositions. D’Este and Rankine explore the possibility of very ancient origins and even raise the question of a surviving priestess cult associated with the Cailleach. They do provide literary hints and later references, but they are also candid that these fragments raise more questions than they settle. That caveat is important. The material is fascinating, but the evidentiary line between recurring folklore, cultic survival, and direct historical continuity is necessarily difficult to establish.
This is precisely why I think the book is most valuable when read as a work of mythic and folkloric archaeology rather than as a definitive reconstruction of an ancient religion. Its real achievement lies in assembling a dispersed body of evidence and allowing the reader to see just how pervasive the Cailleach complex becomes when folklore, toponymy, literature, weather tradition, and sacred geography are examined together.
There is also something methodologically useful here for contemporary witchcraft. The book demonstrates how much can be recovered by looking beyond formal mythology. A supernatural figure may survive most vividly in a place-name, a ruined well, an agricultural custom, an old rhyme, or an explanation for an oddly shaped hill. Those materials are often messier than canonical myth, but they are also closer to the lived religious imagination of ordinary people.
Visions of the Cailleach therefore feels less like a conventional goddess book and more like a dossier assembled from the remnants of a vast regional presence. The Cailleach emerges not as a neatly bounded deity but as a being whose identity has accumulated through centuries of storytelling, local cult, seasonal memory, and landscape encounter.
That ambiguity is ultimately one of the book’s strengths. The Cailleach becomes more impressive, not less, when the authors allow her to remain larger than any single definition.
April 16, 2020
There are dozens of brilliant books about Celtic mythology, most of them dealing specifically with Irish folklore and the Irish pantheon. As someone who spent their formative years in Scotland, however, I am more interested in the myths and stories of my adoptive homeland. I was therefore overjoyed when I discovered this slim volume by renowned pagan authors Sorita D'Este and David Rankine.
I thought the book was extremely well researched, the overall tone was academic without being too dry, which made it a pleasure to read. The authors cite older texts throughout the book, sometimes written in medieval English or Scots, which might pose a challenge to some readers at times, especially if your first language isn't English.
The books starts with a short overview of the origins of the Cailleach myths before moving on to some of her individual aspects, such as earth-shaping, the significance of water, her shape-shifting abilities or her role as goddess of winter. The book concludes with a list of possible Cailleach derivatives, includding Black Annis , Nicneven and Mala Lia.
Finally, the authors present a very comprehensive bibliography for further study.
Visions of the Cailleach is a solid introduction to the Cailleach, the myths and folklore surrounding her and her significance in shaping the local landscape. As a reader, you should have prior knowledge of Celtic mythology, as the authors regularly refer to individual figures and stories from Celtic cultures. The book would work both as a reference work and a text one would read cover to cover. It is a very compact, slim little book which gives the reader a very good overview of the topic. I personally would have wanted a bit more detail in certain parts though. However, the extensive bibliography at the end provides ample scope for further research, so this is not a major issue. A short conclusion at the end would have been helpful, as the book ends rather abruptly.
A very good book, which I would wholeheartedly recommend to anyone interested in Cailleach mythology.
I thought the book was extremely well researched, the overall tone was academic without being too dry, which made it a pleasure to read. The authors cite older texts throughout the book, sometimes written in medieval English or Scots, which might pose a challenge to some readers at times, especially if your first language isn't English.
The books starts with a short overview of the origins of the Cailleach myths before moving on to some of her individual aspects, such as earth-shaping, the significance of water, her shape-shifting abilities or her role as goddess of winter. The book concludes with a list of possible Cailleach derivatives, includding Black Annis , Nicneven and Mala Lia.
Finally, the authors present a very comprehensive bibliography for further study.
Visions of the Cailleach is a solid introduction to the Cailleach, the myths and folklore surrounding her and her significance in shaping the local landscape. As a reader, you should have prior knowledge of Celtic mythology, as the authors regularly refer to individual figures and stories from Celtic cultures. The book would work both as a reference work and a text one would read cover to cover. It is a very compact, slim little book which gives the reader a very good overview of the topic. I personally would have wanted a bit more detail in certain parts though. However, the extensive bibliography at the end provides ample scope for further research, so this is not a major issue. A short conclusion at the end would have been helpful, as the book ends rather abruptly.
A very good book, which I would wholeheartedly recommend to anyone interested in Cailleach mythology.
May 6, 2022
I enjoyed the stories in this book and because I identify strongly with the Cailleach I am grateful to have more knowledge of stories pertaining to her / the archetype.
Some of the information is quite repetitive, even on the same page, like they were trying to make the book longer (I remember this strategy from writing college papers!)
I think the authors fail to make a compelling argument for a priestess cult in ancient British Isles or elsewhere. The evidence just isn’t there… or if it is it was not presented well in this book! I came into the book with the knowledge that this has been debunked and is considered ahistorical, although it is a lovely idea and story.
Some of the information is quite repetitive, even on the same page, like they were trying to make the book longer (I remember this strategy from writing college papers!)
I think the authors fail to make a compelling argument for a priestess cult in ancient British Isles or elsewhere. The evidence just isn’t there… or if it is it was not presented well in this book! I came into the book with the knowledge that this has been debunked and is considered ahistorical, although it is a lovely idea and story.
April 9, 2023
Great introduction into the Cailleach! The best way to learn about deities, in my opinion, has always been to explore the folklore behind them and that is exactly what this book does. It is broken down into her different aspects and gives lore for each of them from differing regions throughout the Celtic world. I thought it was an easy read as well, pretty short and easy to understand too. If you are looking for a book on how to work magically with the Cailleach this is NOT that type of book! 100% recommend this book to people wanting to learn more!
July 1, 2026
This book was a bit of a letdown. It’s mostly a compilation of facts and stories with very little introspection and contemplation. I feel like I’ve got more questions than answers after reading this one. I also feel like the authors are well read but not well practiced. They don’t seem very in tune or engaged with the Cailleach.
There’s a section towards the end where paragraph has been duplicated and the book also just flat out ends. No final notes or circling back. This book needs a good edit and restructuring.
There’s a section towards the end where paragraph has been duplicated and the book also just flat out ends. No final notes or circling back. This book needs a good edit and restructuring.
May 31, 2021
This book gives an orderly and concise history of exactly what it says- myths, stories and history of Cailleach in Celtic myth. It is not a long book but is packed with information, poetry, connections between the different Celtic countries. If you are interested in this important figure in the Celtic pantheon, this is definitely worth reading.
January 22, 2023
I enjoyed this book though I am new to learning about the Cailleach. There were a lot of points made by referencing geography and specific images. It would have been very helpful to have maps and/or photos in the book to illustrate the points they made rather than just describing with text. That said, I appreciate the breadth and scope of the content and the references.
December 31, 2020
Very complete review of history and myth around this goddess or class of goddesses.
January 11, 2021
Interesting history of the Cailleach.
November 12, 2021
A slim volume containing all aspects of the Cailleach. A short but intense read.
September 27, 2023
The was a very interesting collection of myths, folklore, and legends about the Cailleach that help you understand more about her.
April 5, 2024
Fascinating survey of myths and legends that mention the Cailleach and some possible connected stories as well.
June 16, 2025
It was hard to follow the stories. Not a good book, but many short stories.
September 29, 2025
Very disappointing. Just a mishmash of stuff all based on circumstantial evidence. It was haphazard, dry, and watered down the folklore of this primordial goddess
August 16, 2026
Enjoyed this.
August 3, 2015
Loving learning about the Cailleach. A goddess not to be messed with
Displaying 1 - 30 of 30 reviews