Summary: Simon McAllister-MacCoinnich was in his early teens at the end of the last book, Redeeming Vows. He was just beginning to understand his Druid powers and was thriving in his new life in sixteenth-century Scotland. It is now 1596, and Simon is no longer a child. He is thirty years old, and he has become a formidable Highland warrior like the other men in his family. Now an expert at his Druid skills of shape-shifting and communicating with animals, Simon takes responsibility for scouting and spying on their enemies.
In present day California, Simon and his mother Lizzie have been missing persons for only two years. Helen Adams has been investigating Simon’s disappearance; not officially, but rather as a private citizen. Helen has an unusual talent for being able to find anything she is looking for – almost like a human GPS. Her current quest for Simon became important to her shortly after purchasing an unusual stone necklace in a second-hand store. Since that time, she has been led to other items that are connected to the missing boy and his family.
After discovering additional clues in an old book, Helen travels to Scotland in pursuit of answers. Her internal GPS talent leads her to a secluded meadow, where she is suddenly hurdled through a time vortex, landing in a forest in 1596 Scotland. She has indeed located Simon, but certainly not at the age or in a location she was expecting. And before any explanations can be made, both Helen and Simon are thrust back through time to present day California.
Simon understands that for the Ancients to bring them together in such a way, there must be a greater purpose to the time travel and Helen’s presence in his life. While his family is facing attacks from an unknown enemy in 1596, Helen has become the target of some very suspicious behavior in her time. In order to solve both mysteries, and protect the entire MacCoinnich family, Simon and Helen must face multiple trips through time together. Through their adventures and misfortunes, they begin to fall in love. But even if they are able to survive the dangers they must face, how can they have a relationship with so many centuries of time between their homes?
Review: I LOVED this book, it has definitely become my favorite in the series. Before reading it, I was really curious to see how Simon’s character from the earlier novels would translate into an adult character in this story. I wasn’t sure if I would recognize him as the same person, and I was especially curious to see how his shape-shifting powers would be presented within the context of a romance (would the heroine still think he’s sexy after she has seen him as a bird or an dog?) On both counts, I think the author did an incredible job. Simon is no longer a timid boy, he is as masculine and courageous as the generation before him. But at the same time, I could still see young Simon through the protective nature of his parents, Lizzie and Finlay. And as far as the shape-shifting, it is so second-nature to Simon now, that it never felt anything but normal – even within the romantic storyline.
I also enjoyed Helen’s character, and I loved her talent. Every time a new character has been introduced in this series, I’ve asked myself which of their talents I would want if I could have my choice. It used to be a toss-up between Lora’s premonitions and Ian’s control of storms and weather. But after reading this book, I think I’d choose Helen’s sixth sense for finding whatever she is looking for. It sounds incredibly useful to me, and it is also really unique.
Because Grainna was finally destroyed in Redeeming Vows, I knew that this book would be introducing a new villain or villains. I was really pleased to see that Bybee took an entirely different approach to the antagonist storyline in Highland Shifter. This time, we readers don’t get the inside scoop of the evil doings until the characters are figuring things out themselves. The way that the threats were eventually resolved was also something we haven’t seen before. These changes made the book feel fresh and new, while still being grounded with the family we know and love.
Once again, I found myself appreciating that this author does not abandon the characters from earlier books when she focuses on someone new. Even though this is definitely Simon’s story, I was happy to see Duncan & Tara, Todd & Myra, and Fin & Liz all involved in the action. It wouldn’t have felt right without them.
I don’t have any criticisms of this book at all. The only thing I wish I could have seen before the story ended was an actual exchange of vows between Simon and Helen. But to be honest, that didn’t even occur to me until I sat down to write this review. This book ends with a completely unexpected and killer cliffhanger, so at the time, I was too busy picking my jaw up off the floor to realize that the Simon and Helen weren’t married yet.
I have been a big fan of this series all along, so I was really excited to find out that the original trilogy was going to grow into a series of at least six books. Highly recommended to fans of Historical Fantasy/Romance, Time-Travel Romances, and anyone who enjoys novels based on Scottish or Druid folklore.