What evil lurks within the hearts of men? Wayne Wise knows.
Horror is probably the most difficult genre to write. Not only do you have to scare the crap out of your audience, you have to make sure the mood remains tense between scary episodes. Scratch is one of those novels where you spend just about every page waiting for something horrible to happen, and when it finally does, boy does it ever.
Scratch and Gabrielle are spirits imprisoned by the townsfolk of Canaan, West Virginia. They were bound long ago, when America truly was the New World, and their keeping has been handed down through one family line to the present day. Gabrielle is imprisoned in the church, and her gift for healing is used to cure the various injuries and illnesses the town suffers. Scratch, for his part, is doomed to feel all the pain that Gabrielle absorbs during a healing. Scratch is strong enough to leave his pain-wracked body and travel the village in spirit, feeding off of the many secrets and dark emotions buried in Canaan. It's a dirty little cycle with no sign of ending...until the Mansfield family, fleeing their own troubles, comes to live in Canaan.
There's a lot going on here, and Wise does an excellent job not only keeping all the plotlines straight, but humming along at the appropriate clip, cris-crossing them as needed. The subplots are SO intricate and layered into the main plot that you'll find yourself wondering 50 pages from the end, how the hell he's going to tie up every loose thread...but he pulls it off beautifully. The cliffhangers that occasionally end each chapter are timed and placed perfectly; they feel organic and not manipulative. The descriptions of both Pittsburgh (where the Mansfields run from) and the West Virginia countryside are vivid without being overdone; this really could be made into a movie. I also loved how plot resolutions were both subtle and clever; you'll think you know how a thing is going to turn out, but at the revelation point, the truth turns out to be slightly more interesting than what you'd guessed.
Character-wise, the players seem drawn from life, people you might actually know with problems you can genuinely relate to. Adam Mansfield is technically the hero here, and his growth and development is a major theme. However, everybody in this novel has strengths and weaknesses with which they grapple; some people win those fights, while others lose. Over and over again we see people wrestling with their own fears, flaws, and desires, and when the town finally gets what's coming to it (in spectacular fashion), justice is meted out fairly based on how hard each person has worked to be on the side of the angels, so to speak. In fact, the most brilliant thing about this novel is that the worst evils here don't live in supernatural creatures. They live in human hearts.
It's really unfortunate that a lot of libraries won't consider this as a purchase because it's a self-published work. Its also unfortunate that a good chunk of the rest of the world is really not ready for the mythic themes that run through this novel like an electric current (would that we were). But, per our old friend Ranganathan, "Every reader his/her book." and "Every book its reader," so consider your patron population and choose accordingly. Recommended for people who are drawn to psychology, philosophy, or alternative spirituality, as well as for libraries that have horror collections, especially in the tri-state area. Also recommended for larger fiction collections, where eclectic work has a fighting chance at finding its true audience.