The Ruling Caste

by David Gilmour

Between 1837 and 1901, fewer than 100,000 Britons at any one time managed an empire, of 300 million people spread over the vast are that now includes India, Pakistan, Bangladesh, and Burma. How was this possible? The British administration in India took pride in its efficiency and broad-mindedness, its devotion to duty and sense of imperial grandeur, but it has become fashionable to deprecate the empire for its arrogance and ignorance. In this balanced, witty, and multifaceted history, David Gilmour goes far to explain the paradoxes of the "Anglo-Indians," showing us what they hoped to achieve and what sort of society they thought they were helping to build.

Genres: History, India, Nonfiction, 19th Century, Asia, British Literature, Historical

381 pages, Paperback

First published January 1, 2005

About the author

Librarian Note: There is more than one author in the GoodReads database with this name. See this thread for more information.

Sir David Robert Gilmour, 4th Baronet is a Scottish author. He is the first son of Ian Gilmour, Baron Gilmour of Craigmillar, 3rd Baronet, and Lady Caroline Margaret Montagu-Douglas-Scott, the youngest daughter of the 8th Duke of Buccleuch. HRH Princess Margaret was his sponsor at his Christening. He became the 4th baronet on the death of his father in 2007.

Gilmour was educated at Eton and Balliol College, Oxford.

Gilmour is a Fellow of the Royal Society of Literature (FRSL).

He lives in Edinburgh with his wife and four children.

Reviews

[Caroline · Rating 4 out of 5]

There still seems to be an enduring fascination with Britain's colonial history, a certain glamour and exoticism that survives despite the criticism and disapproval of the reasons for being there in the first place. This book fully exposes how little glamour and exoticism there actually was in the service of the Raj, how hard and gruelling the life of an Indian Civil Service officer (known as Civilians to distinguish them from the Army) could be, how lonely and isolating. Some men thrived, others sickened or went mad; some rose to the challenge, others were disorganised, inefficient and incompetent. Some were never promoted to the level they believed they deserved; others went all the way up to Viceroy.

David Gilmour's book follows the life of an ICS Civilian from recruitment to pension, charting the rise and fall of trends and empire-building, ranging from holidays at hill stations like Sinda and Ooty, to the 'frontiers' of the North-West Provinces, Burma and Aghanistan. It looks at the kind of men attracted to the ICS, how they were chosen, what their postings involved, the different roles and stations, their leisure time and personal lives. I could have done with more of a focus on the lives of their families, particularly the women - it must have been an incredibly lonely life for a new wife or mother. But the focus in this is very much on the men, not their dependants.

You wouldn't have thought a book about a civil service, even the Indian Civil Service, could be so interesting, but I thoroughly enjoyed this. Gilmour takes a very balanced approach, at no point approving of Britain's colonial past, but by the same token not condemning the men of the time by today's standards. The majority of the men in the ICS felt they were doing their very best for the people of India; some even went on to support independence. It would be unfair to dismiss all their motives as racist and self-serving, despite the inherent paternalistic oppression in the very nature of colonialism.

[Eleanore · Rating 2 out of 5]

Cartoonish images of civil-servants pervade the literature of British imperialism almost to the same degree as that cheerfully pompous figure of British military blundering, “Colonel Blimp.” David Gilmour, a writer who often finds himself earnestly battling the caricatures of Imperial history, turns his attention in The Ruling Caste towards the restitution of the reputation of the Indian Civil Service (ICS). Grounded heavily on the experience of Sir Alfred Lyall as an exemplar of the life of an ICS man, this nicely compact volume briefly examines almost every possible angle on the life of a Civil Service Officer from their first recruitment and training to their eventual retirement and the activities of their twilight years. While Glimour focuses on the Victorian period of British Rule, his prose picks up the salient points from the earlier periods of Hastings and Clive all the way up to Independence. Along the way, he makes an effort to correct popular impressions with the objective of demonstrating that the ICS “represented the British Empire at its best and at its most altruistic.”

Structured thematically and ordered loosely across the experience of a hypothetical lifetime, Gilmour renders the individual civilian’s experience in categorical chapters: District Officers, Campers, Magistrates and Judges, Black Sheep, Players, Husbands and Lovers, Pensioners. Motivated by an evident sense of delight in the particularities of how the British Empire was organized and how it ruled, Glimour’s work at times reads like a guidebook and occasionally even a brochure for the Indian Civil Service, dwelling on such mundane details as the purchasing of appropriate clothing by first-year “Griffins.” While informed by careful and interesting research, The Ruling Caste touches too briefly on any one topic to elicit meaningful insight and ranges too broadly to capture attention. Perhaps David Glimour imbibed the famous guidance of Henry Lawrence, Chief Commissioner of Oudh, too well: “Settle the country, make the people happy, and take care there are no rows!”

[Carolyn Johnson · Rating 3 out of 5]

This book was a long slog for me, but the subject was significant for. I did learn all about what the Indian Civil Service actually did, (the organization the British men in India during the Raj worked in.) More than I needed to know, but now I can go on with my reading with more understanding. Next for me is "The Raj Quartet" by Paul Scott.

[Alex · Rating 3 out of 5]

Great book; well written, organized, and engaging. The writer has a great sense of humor.

However, I would highly recommend anyone looking to read this book have a least a couple books on the history of the British Raj under their belt, otherwise you'll be pretty lost.

[Robert Davidson · Rating 4 out of 5]

Informative and detailed on how the I.C.S. worked although i would have liked to have more detail on the day to day life of Expats and how they coped. Incorruptible and the fact that most of them actually liked India and the people, made for interesting lives.

[Patricia · Rating 3 out of 5]

A good representative of what it is. After a slow start I quite enjoyed descriptions of life, work and play in the Indian Civil Service.

[Dominic Arbuthnott · Rating 5 out of 5]

Excellent study of the men and their wives who effectively ran India for over 200 years. It delves into their personal lives as well as giving the big picture. Recommended

[Brian Frederick Jerome Eadon · Rating 4 out of 5]

I read this book as it was recommended by the very helpful staff of the mobile library service that serves the rural area in which I live. The staff know of my interest in the history of India and the history of the British Empire. It was a good choice and I enjoyed the book and learnt a lot.
Earlier this year I listened to a BBC programme about the mechanics of administering the Indian General Election and the conscientious way the Indian Civil Authority goes about meticulously ensuring that every registered voter gets a chance to vote no matter how remote the area in which a voter may live.
This book is about the Indian Civil Service (ICS) in Victorian Times. It details the people who made careers in it. The way they were selected and subsequently worked in the Raj. For me it shows the dedication, conscientiousness and effectiveness of the tool that was the ICS as it administered British India during Queen Victoria's reign.
Britain's colonial history is being re-examined today. The book doesn't enter this debate. It is about the people who manned the posts (and they were all men) and their families. I believe these Victorians managed the Raj effectively. They didn't think too much about whether their part in colonial expansion was right. They were people of their time displaying accepted values of that time. Now I don't support colonialism as I'm of my time. However the book shows the ICS had the conscientiousness and dedication that the current Indian Civil Authority has in ensuring the world's biggest democracy works. Perhaps that's the legacy of the Raj's ICS?
I enjoyed learning from this book.

[Sarah · Rating 3 out of 5]

Interesting subject but not always very clear.

[Thorsten · Rating 3 out of 5]

meh. was alright, but kinda dry i thought. Ended up skipping through most of it, although definitely had some interesting stuff, and was well enough written, i just don't think i had enough interest invested to read it all the way through.

[Bob]

Lots of good details. Surprising diversity of characters.