Intelligent books about Vladimir Putin have been few and far between because, of all the world leaders, the man his friends call 'Vlad' has managed to remain an enigma. This highly personal biography of Russia's leader is the result of six years' research by author Chris Hutchins, a successful investigative journalist and much-published biographer. His associate, Alexander Korobko, is a London-based Russian journalist and TV director. This book goes some way towards ending the enigma that is Vladimir Putin.
CHRIS HUTCHINS is an established author of highly acclaimed biographies of the rich, the famous and the royals. His first, FERGIE CONFIDENTIAL, was an intimate biography of the Duchess of York and chronicled her troubled marriage to the Queen’s favourite son. This was followed by a revelatory biography of the late Princess of Wales, DIANA’S NIGHTMARE, and an acclaimed psychological profile of her, DIANA ON THE EDGE. ATHINA, The Last Onassis penetrated deeply into the world of the Onassis dynasty. ELVIS MEETS THE BEATLES was about the night he took the group to meet Presley and the serious repercussions which followed. More recently Hutchins has turned his attention to matters Russian with fearless biographies of that country’s leader, PUTIN, and best-known oligarch ABRAMOVICH: The billionaire from nowhere. The author returns to the royal stage with HARRY: The People’s Prince.
Ha algum tempo procuro uma biografia de Vladimir Putin, e, após ler alguns reviews no Amazon e aqui no Goodreads acabei chegando até a obra de Chris Hutchins.
Eu imagino o quao dificil deve ser obter fatos fidedignos e meticulosos sobre o líder do país mais extenso do mundo, que além de ser uma figura pouco espalhafatosa ainda calha de ser ex-agente da KGB. Creio que seja tentador rechear o livro de especulações, fofocas e achismos. Felizmente, Hutchins nao escolhe o caminho mais fácil, ou o que venderia mais. Na verdade, o autor ajuda a demolir alguns mitos sobre Volodya e conduz o trabalho com honestidade e transparência, sempre que possivel.
Em determinada altura, o livro perde um pouco de seu vigor quando se apega a descricoes muito detalhistas de jornalistas, figuras menores do governo ou oligarcas menos interessantes que a dupla Abramovich/Berezovsky. Há ainda uma desnecessária explanação historica (praticamente um discurso de guia turístico) , que ocupa quase uma página, sobre um Mosteiro, apenas para falar da relação de Putin com um de seus moradores.
Felizmente, o livro recupera o fôlego com capítulos bastante interessantes, como o encontro de Putin com Paul McCartney ou sua atitude ante uma greve que tentara evitar. A descricao de seu relacionamento com outros líderes como Berlusconi, Blair e Schroeder tambem ajuda a trazer robustez à obra e a traçar um perfil interessante sobre o líder russo.
Uma das críticas que li acerca do livro é a de que o autor teria sido demasiadamente bondoso e que esta seja uma obra de propaganda pró-Putin. Creio que essa impressao seja comum entre leitores da Europa ocidental, EUA e Americas quando se deparam com um texto equilibrado e que trata como um ser humano comum algum líder mundial frequentemente demonizado pela mídia corrompida deste lado do globo. Para mim, trata-se de um trabalho equilibrado, que não considera Putin um santo e tampouco o acusa sem provas. Quando há um fato controverso, o autor simplesmente deixa em aberto para que o leitor tire suas conclusões, sem tentar afirmar com convicção ou rebater com veemência algo de que nao tenha certeza.
A honestidade e senso de responsabilidade do autor e a figura interessante de Putin contribuem para que este seja um livro sólido e recomendável àqueles não só interessados na Russia, mas em biografias em geral. Pessoalmente, gostaria de ler mais detalhes sobre a vida de Putin em seus primeiros anos de KGB e acompanhar mais de perto suas decisoes envolvendo a Chechênia. Porem, compreendo que enquanto o último nao é o objetivo do livro, faltam dados e informaçoes disponiveis para o primeiro. "Putin" é uma leitura agradável e seu autor aparenta gozar de grande credibilidade e deter conhecimento acerca do tema.
This book is very favorable to Vladimir Putin. Fine, but the author does not really provide evidence to support this, other than very superficial offerings. Hutchins appears to be averse to asking the hard questions and pointing out the contradictions in Putin's actions. For example, Putin acted very aggressively in the war against Chechnya secession. Yet when Georgia fought to keep South Ossetia from seceding, Putin's Russia very quickly invaded and continued on into Georgia. The author was complementary of Putin's battle to keep Chechnya, yet very supportive of Putin's invasion of Georgia.
The author appears to have a knee-jerk antipathy to the West, particularly Britain and the United States. He swallows the Putin propaganda hook, line, and sinker. Perhaps the most useful aspect of this book is that it may unintentionally provide insight into why Putin is so popular in Russia.
The book is also poorly written and organized. Often, the author will be describing an event and then suddenly jump to an event several years previously, with little warning or explanation. It is a superficial book. I was not surprised when I investigated other books the author wrote to find that most are celebrity books about the Beatles, Princess Diana, the Duchess of York, and Athina Onassis. "Putin" is People Magazine coverage of a very complicated man.
Note also that this book was published in 2012, so recent actions against Ukraine are not covered.
Another good book about Putin, though it rehashes much of "First Person" it also adds some details and brings it up to date to the time of publishing. Gives a few insights into Putin's character and how he is, though not many.
I guess the main downsides it mentioned to Putin was his love of cars, and women. Which makes his seem rather common, but I guess people come in all sorts, and everyone has their own vices. In any case it seems Putin keeps them in moderation and doesn't bring them to excess. It didn't mention Putin's many yachts and palace, though it had a theoretical discussion on his wealth, little else was said.
I guess people would call this a soft ball biography of sorts. Fair enough.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.