Wilderness and Waterpower explores how the need for electricity at the turn of the century affected and shaped Banff National Park.
Today's conservationists and energy researchers will find much to think about in this tale of Alberta's early need for electricity, entrepreneurial greed, debates over aboriginal ownership of the river, moving park boundaries to accommodate hydro-electric initiatives, the importance of water for tourism, rural electrification, and the ultimate diversion to coal-produced electricity.
It is also a lively national story, involving the irrepressible and impetuous Max Aitkin (later Lord Beaverbook), R.B. Bennett (local legal advisor and later prime minister), and a series of local politicians and bureaucrats whose contributions confuse and conflate issues along the way.
Surprisingly accessible academic work on how the boundaries and landscape of Banff National Park was shaped by the development of the Bow, Spray and Ghost rivers for hydroelectric power generation. It is not necessarily a moralizing tale, but shows how corporations, conservation and environmental groups, municipalities and provincial and federal governments competed and cooperated to see the rivers developed. An interesting historical account of unlikely allies and competing priorities within the same government department played out over the decades. A must read for anyone interested in Canadian environmental history and the development of our national parks.
I lead a discussion of this book for the NICHE (Network in Canadian History of the Environment) New Scholars. One can find some of the main points of the book, my opinions, and discussion questions here: http://www.historyapplied.com/2013/11...
Overall, the topic was interesting, but I think that the concept of second nature, the story of the local people (including the Nakoda), the importance of recreation were given too little play, while too much emphasis was placed on political maneuvering.