For sports fan people, this is more like four stars. This is going to be one of those books that I enjoyed a lot, however my comments are going to sound like a long list of complaints. It's not so much complaining as it is a recognition of the fact that the book raises a lot of issues that make interesting conversational topics.
Each chapter of this book deals with a different aspect of the intersection of sports and society, with (as the title says) an emphasis on politics. A few quibbles on that later. However, most were previously published as articles, and that shows. They don't feel like they were written with a unified purpose, because they weren't. You can also pick up on some subtle changes in tone -- I like Zirin's sports writing a lot, and when he writes for a sporty audience, he includes a lot of witty little sports asides. He dials this way down when writing for a more general audience, understandably.
I wish this book had been a little more coherent. It's not clear to me what Zirin thinks people -- either fans, or players or other people directly involved, should do. I kept waiting for the call to action.
One thing I thought was hilarious is that he describes the Green Bay Packers ownership model and strongly advocates for it to be re-introduced into professional sports (he probably could have better explained the rules that would need to change to enable that). He sets out some good arguments ... but he also doesn't seem to realize that this model is already every fan's fantasy. We're familiar with the concept.
I like that he hates the NCAA, and most specifically, it's refusal to entertain the idea of compensating student-athletes. This is one of those issues where over the years, I went from being very against compensation, to feeling neutral about it, to really strongly supporting it and being appalled that they're not.
I can understand why publishers wanted to include it, but I thought the chapter on the Penn State scandal doesn't quite belong here. That's not about politics, that's about crime. That should be in a book that also looks at why Ben Roethlisberger is still playing football.
And this is a real nitpick, but social justice and politics are used very interchangeably throughout, and that's really not right. Obviously, it's easy to do because there's so much overlap, but there are some nuances about social justice movements and activism that are important to understand.
And in closing, I don't love the book's title. The game isn't over, that's the whole point. It's not as if politics shut down athletics. I'm sure there's a sports phrase that would work just as well and be more appropriate to the subject matter.