Throw Them All Out: How Politicians and Their Friends Get Rich Off Insider Stock Tips, Land Deals, and Cronyism That Would Send the Rest of Us to Prison by Peter Schweizer
“Throw Them All Out” is an eye-opening expose of how politicians in Washington have made politics into a prosperous business. Research fellow, consultant and author, Peter Schweizer provides a relentless account of practices that would send anyone other than a politician to prison but allows them the path to legal riches. This troubling 240-page book is broken out into the following three parts: 1. Congressional Cronies, 2. Capitalist Cronies, and 3. Breaking the Back of Crony Capitalism.
Positives:
1. A well-written, well-referenced book.
2. An eye-opening expose on a fascinating topic. If you care about ethics, this book will make your blood boil.
3. Introduces and defines concepts in support of his well-argued conclusions. “This is a book about how a Permanent Political Class, composed of politicians and their friends, engages in honest graft. Let's call it crony capitalism. Here the "invisible hand" is often attached to the long arm of Washington. And business is good.”
4. A relentless approach. Schweizer provides example after example of crony capitalism. “Politicians have made politics a business. They are increasingly entrepreneurs who use their power, access, and privileged information to generate wealth. And at the same time well-connected financiers and corporate leaders have made a business of politics. They meet together in the nation's capital to form a political caste.”
5. Does a great job of explaining the power of access to information. Congressional trading of pharmaceutical stocks.
6. Exposing those who benefitted from the 2008 financial crash. “And for certain members of Congress, it also meant trading stocks at critical times.” Many examples.
7. Unfair access to IPOs. An interesting example of the VISA legislation. “Companies recognize the importance of having friends in powerful places, and granting them access to an IPO is one way to reward them. Members of Congress often participate in IPOs that are difficult, if not close to impossible, for ordinary Americans to join.” Schweizer names politicians involved, I’m not going to spoil it.
8. A recurring theme, clear examples of unethical yet clear conflicts of interest. “Persuading a corporation to spend money on an initiative that you as an executive would personally profit from would raise huge questions. And if you were a middle-level employee in the executive branch of government, such a conflict of interest would trigger an investigation. Trying to help companies in which you have a large financial stake become more profitable through congressional legislation is the very definition of conflict of interest.”
9. Earmarks used for personal gains. “In the words of the White House Office of Management and Budget, it's a way that "circumvents otherwise applicable merit-based or competitive allocation processes" to make favored projects happen.” A bonus and pardon it’s length but too good to pass up, ‘Members of Congress have used federal earmarks to enhance the value of their own real estate holdings in several ways: by extending a light rail mass transit line near their property, by expanding an airport, or by cleaning up a nearby shoreline. Federal funds have been used to build roads, beautify land, and upgrade neighborhoods near commercial and residential real estate owned by legislators, substantially increasing values and the net worth of our elected officials, courtesy of taxpayer money. Not only is this legal—by the bizarre standards of the Permanent Political Class—it's also deemed ‘ethical.’ Congressional ethics rules simply say that as long as a member can demonstrate that at least one other person will benefit from an earmark, that earmark is in the ‘public interest.’"
10. Describes how wealthy friends and donors make use of power to enrich themselves. “The game of funneling taxpayer money to friends has exploded to astonishing levels in recent years. Now that annual federal outlays exceed $3 trillion, there are extraordinary opportunities to get a piece of the action. Government checks routinely find their way to very wealthy Americans. Convincing the public that billionaires need the money can, needless to say, be tricky. But if a government check somehow serves the "public interest," it can become part of a larger program and might escape scrutiny.”
11. An interesting look at grants and guaranteed loans under one stimulus program run by the Department of Energy, for alternative energy projects.
12. A chapter dedicated to Warren Buffett where Schweizer makes some interesting observations. “Buffett needed the TARP bailout more than most. In all, Berkshire Hathaway firms received $95 billion in bailout cash from the Troubled Asset Relief Program. Berkshire held stock in Wells Fargo, Bank of America, American Express, and Goldman Sachs, which received not only TARP money but also $130 billion in FDIC backing for their debt. All told, TARP-assisted companies constituted a whopping 30% of his entire publicly disclosed stock portfolio. As one investigation by the Houston Chronicle put it, Buffett was "one of the top beneficiaries of the banking bailout."
13. There are some great short quotes that capture the sentiment of this book, “Perhaps the best investment a hedge fund can make these days is not in a financial wizard but a politician.”
14. The role of lobbyists. “Elliott Portnoy, a lobbyist in Washington, says that the biggest field of growth for lobbyists is not in influencing legislation but in obtaining "political intelligence" for hedge funds and large investors.”
15. Crony capitalism. “Crony capitalism favors the politically active, and the manipulative. It does not favor one party over the other. It does not care about policy. It just knows how to make money off any policy—your tax dollars, leveraged to the rich.”
16. Unequal treatment. “Members of Congress and their staffs are effectively considered exempt from many of the laws they define for the rest of us, and from executive-branch regulation.”
17. The problem in Washington. “The Permanent Political Class is unresponsive to our concerns and needs because it is partly immune to the economic realities the rest of us face.”
18. A great comment worth sharing.” The Constitution is a contract between the people and the elected. When members of the Permanent Political Class use their public office for personal interest, they have breached that contract.”
19. A great chapter on what needs to be done broken out in shorty sections. A list of some initiatives to break the cycle of crony capitalism.
20. Links to notes.
Negatives:
1. Though Schweizer appears to make an effort to be fair and balanced the book is not. There is much more written about Democrats than Republicans. Despite stating a number of times that this is a bipartisan problem Schweizer certainly provides much more details on Democrats. The book does focus more on recent politics so that may be a plausible explanation.
2. Are there any ethical politicians in Washington? Schweizer never bothers to answer that question thus leaving that up to the reader despite a title that posits the contrary.
3. No formal bibliography.
In summary, this is a solid book. Schweizer delivers a page-turner of an expose that clearly shows how politicians and their friends prosper from access to information and rules that don’t apply to them. The author apparently takes more glee in exposing Democrats or it just may be causing some troubling cognitive dissonance to this progressive-minded reviewer. Be that as it may, Schweizer gives me much food for thought and I am first and foremost a realist. A book worthy of reading regardless of your political persuasion, I recommend it.
Further recommendations: “Plutocrats” by Chrystia Freeland, Winner-Take-All Politics” by Jacob S. Hacker, “The Price of Inequality” and “Globalization and its Discontents” by Joseph E. Stiglitz, “The Crash of 2016” by Thom Hartmann, “The Have and the Have-Nots” by Branko Milanovic, “Affluence and Influence” by Martin Gilens, “Republic, Lost” by Lawrence Lessig, “The New Elite” by Dr. Jim Taylor, “Why Nations Fail” by Daron Acemoglu, “Outliers” by Malcolm Gladwell, “ECONned” by Yves Smith, “The Great Divergence” by Timothy Noah, and “Bailout” by Neil Barofsky.