Throughout his long career, Henri Matisse (1869&;1954) continually expanded the boundaries of his art. By repeating images in pairs, trios, and series, he conducted an ongoing dialogue with his earlier works in order to, as he put it, "push further and deeper into true painting." In this fresh approach to a much-studied artist, prominent scholars from the United States and Europe examine more than sixty works in concise chapters that focus on this aspect of Matisse&;s working process. From early pairs such as Young Sailor I and II (1907&;8) through a series of late studio scenes from Venice (1946&;48), Matisse is shown revisiting a given theme with the aim of devising innovative, often radical, solutions to such problems as how to portray light, handle paint, select colors, and manipulate perspective. New technical studies of the early paired works and photographs documenting the evolution of his later paintings help to elucidate Matisse&;s complex evolution. In numerous excerpts from letters and interviews, he is revealed as an artist who regularly questioned himself and his methods, a man of powerful intellect who regarded each new painting as an adventure. A significant addition to art historical literature, In Search of True Painting is a revelatory study of a seminal figure in 20th-century modernism.
Matisse: In Search of True Painting, edited by Dorthe Aagesen and Rebecca Rabinow, was an interesting exploration of Henri Matisse’s habit of returning to the same subjects again and again - sometimes in pairs, sometimes in whole series - to experiment with color, perspective, light, style, and composition. I went into it without knowing Matisse’s work particularly well, so this was very much an exploratory journey for me.
The repeated images were what kept me looking. The Pont Saint-Michel paintings (circa 1900), for example, show essentially the same view from Matisse’s window rendered with different colors, moods, and approaches. Seeing related works next to each other makes the changes much easier to notice. Some series almost look like a progression from unfinished to finished work, while others seem more like Matisse asking, “What if I tried it this way instead?”
The technical material reinforces that impression. X-radiographs of paintings such as Nude with a White Scarf (1909) reveal changes beneath the final surface, and photographs documenting works in progress show just how much Matisse could revise a composition before deciding he was done. The book makes a convincing case that, for him, the process was every bit as important as the final canvas.
I also found the Lorette paintings fascinating. She was a professional model who worked intensively with Matisse in 1916–17, appearing in roughly fifty works during a remarkably productive period. The book does discuss her importance to his artistic process, but naturally I went down an internet side quest anyway. I found myself wanting more of the personal context around the people he painted—not gossip for gossip’s sake, but information that might help explain why certain subjects appeared so repeatedly and how those relationships intersected with changes in his work.
The same curiosity came up with Lydia Delectorskaya, who later modeled for Matisse and appears in the development of The Large Blue Dress series (1936-1937). The surviving progress photographs are especially interesting because they show the painting changing from a more naturalistic composition into something more flattering and stylized.
The book also places works by other artists alongside Matisse’s paintings and includes correspondence and discussion of artistic influences, which helps situate his experiments in a larger conversation. The paintings themselves come from collections scattered all over the world, so there is something slightly ironic about seeing these related pairs and series reunited on the page when the originals may now live thousands of miles apart.
There are plenty of female nudes, portraits, interiors, landscapes, and repeated models, all presented with detailed commentary from art historians and curators. The text is fairly academic, though, and I found myself skimming more than I expected. When something in the artwork caught my attention, I would go back and read that section more closely, but the essays could ramble a bit for my taste.
That said, a tremendous amount of work clearly went into this catalog. The technical analysis, archival photographs, comparisons, and sheer number of works gathered together make it easy to see how deliberately Matisse revisited artistic problems over decades.
I did not come away obsessed with Matisse, but I understand his process much better than I did before. For me, the book was more compelling as a look at how an artist experiments and revises than as an introduction to Matisse himself—and the artwork kept my attention considerably more than the academic prose.
Matisse's pairs of paintings are part of a continuum. He repeated images throughout his career, and each repetition has its own story and circumstances. While this manner of working is certainly not unique to Matisse, his need to progress methodically from one painting to the next is especially striking. Taken as a whole, it reveals Matisse as an artist who conducted a dialogue with his earlier works, someone who continually questioned himself and his methods in order to, as he put it, "push further and deeper into true painting."