WARNING: No HEA or HFN. Well, not with one of the MCs anyway
I have this on my folder but just remember to read it when I see it has new cover. I need the one with new cover. I'm OCD that way :). Gene saves a man, who claims that he's a fae, a Daoine Sidhe, and will gives Gene's heart desire if Gene saves him. There are two that are important for Gene, his hand (Gene lost his hand after a motorcycle accident, which made him unable to play music as well), and one other thing (which you need to find himself). After a passionate love making, the fae left, and he gives exactly one of those desires.
This story is really poignant -- from both men. Gene thinks about what has happened, what he has lost (not just his hand, his ability to play music, but also a person he loved the most). Cambrion's story is no less heartbreaking. While the ending is definitely bittersweet, this is kind of a story that also packs a punch and might last longer in my mind. The 'only; niggle I have is how easy Gene accepts Cam's being a fae. But in overall, it is not a huge problem, not with a story this good :D