Overall: it is a huge red flag to me when a book about parenting has numerous matter-of-fact quotes from family members stating how the author is not a good husband and/or father. "That's why I am writing the book." Really? And you expect people to join you in this? Why did anyone ever publish this?
I recently became a father, so like every good dad-in-training I scoured the internet for "christian dad books" and landed on a short list of books I could find at my local library. "All Pro Dad" rose to the top of the list because of the un-intimidating look and feel of the writing and the three and a half pages of endorsements at the front (which will now become a red flag for me. If you need to pump something up this much to sell it, then it must be garbage).
Mr. Merrill's hollow, lazy and lack-luster book has so many quotes from Tony Dungy, you might as well read one of his autobiographies "Quiet Strength" or "Uncommon." I can't quite figure out whether throwing in a bunch of quotes from modern-day celebrities is boastful ("look at all the famous people I got to sit down with!"), lazy ("this long quote from Bono will help me add pages to my book!") or stupid ("here's what these people have to say about what I AM WRITING A BOOK ABOUT"). Regardless, it is annoying, self-serving and makes for a whitewashed version of something which could have and should have been at least mediocre.
Frequent quotes aside, the other irksome thing about the book is it's use of acrostics. "The 7 M's" of this and the "Five P's of" that. It feels sophomoric and, again, lazy. I understand acrostics are learning tools to help things stick in the mind of the readers, but there are so many of them, they blur together to get the 4 Q's of Parental Marital Bliss Balance.
The most upsetting part for me was the end. Mr. Merrill sells "All Pro Dad" as a "Religious Life" book, but God does not enter the picture until the last chapter, which feels tacked on in order to hit the mass market of Christian book-buyers (I am told it is the largest market out there). Example (go to page 137-8), after spending two pages building a metaphor about the importance of flying with a "compass" which can guide you to safety regardless of our, sometimes misguided, feelings, Merrill states, "I hope these essential 7 M's ... will become our magnetic compass that we can always rely upon as dads." Wait. God is not the compass? The Bible? The Holy Spirit? I am pretty sure the answer is Jesus here Mr. Merrill. YOUR "essential seven M's" are supposed to supplant my God-given conscience and the voice of the creator of the universe as my compass? Cool.
The chapter after this metaphor homerun (chapter 8) is a weak attempt at apologetics
(literally, there is a list of five pieces of evidence that God exists and a verdict which states He is the God of the Bible) in order to get the reader to "come to Jesus." Don't come to Jesus to guide the plane of your life, mind you, that's what the 7 M's are for; but to be a good dad you need Jesus.
Terrible!
I am assuming "All Pro Dad" is supposed to appeal to "manly" men who like sports, money, eating Chick-Fil-A six times a week (because they are closed on Sundays like good Christians), and hate reading, but I found it to be poorly regurgitated baby food. Ideas are all over the place only connected by a thin thread of "Seven Essential M's" and quotes by athletes, business moguls and celebrities. If every man dadded like this book is written (with our knowledge up front and Jesus tacked on to the end like some secret password when we get to heaven) then we would have a nation of fame and money obsessed, porn-addicted, in-debt, barely there, if not absent christian men trying to be good fathers by phoning it in on the weekends between football games and Chick-fil-A runs. Oh, wait... we already do.
I was able to read this book (which exactly 200 pages long like he was required to write at least 200-pages and decided to put in the minimum effort to qualify) in three days because it is so hollow and fluffy. Filled with large font, large margins, quotes, lists, restatements and blank pages between chapters, "All Pro Dad" would have seriously put a dent in the forests of North America if it had gone Best Seller (which I assume it has not since it's not plastered all over the covers).
In summation. Do not read this book. As a new dad even I know this book is a pointless attempt to bolster speaking engagements and make some money at the book game. Go back to being a "recovering lawyer" Mr. Merrill and leave the rest of us to find our ways to fatherhood and Jesus.
I would recommend this book to: no one! Not even women trying to get their men to be better fathers or Christians or sports heros.