What? I'm surprised that this is the same author as Walk Two Moons....well I guess I'm not surprised, but the difference in quality could not be any different! It's another quirky girl finding herself after a loved one leaves her life. But this book was just odd! I don't even want my kids reading it. The plot was weird and the lessons were not what I want my kids reading.
The aunt and the whole drawer thing is off, but it's even worse that she kept her dead baby in one. And then the creepy shrine and dolls and world that they ran away to. What? I can look past the young girl spending 10 days at a time alone in the wilderness, especially since dad flies by to check up on her, but that long with the rest of the book is a turn off.
Don't even get me started on the stalker, creepy older boy! Seriously? This is not ok. Boys, DO NOT take a page out of this kid's books! This is not how you get a girl. When she says no, it means no. I tend to think people go overboard on the no means no idea, but this is just one big N-O! Get a clue and stop being a creep! And then the stealing? Huh? This is portrayed as not ok, but it was still glorified. And Zinny wanted him to steal a horse because she was so desperate. Kids should not be in situations like that!
And then Zinny is ok with his actions. Not at first, but then she becomes more and more ok. And super ok by the end. No! Why is this ok to portray?
I could go on and on. Things that don't usually bug me did in this book because she much was off. Like how Zinny didn't feel like she belonged in her family, which is big and loud. Her parents don't try to help. They just let her go out on an odd trail on her own and check in every 10 days. Yes please, child. Leave and be gone for weeks and only check in for a bit. I think this is a great way to help you feel more loved and accepted. And why do big families have to be so chaotic? I don't have a big family. I didn't come from a big family. But I'm offended that they have to be portrayed this way.
Anyways....overall I don't want my kids to read this because of the morals it seems to preach. Theft, creepy ways to deal with dead people, stalking, not standing up for yourself, leaving your family, not healthy self discovery, not healthy coping skills, and so much more. Just wow. Super shocked and sad!