Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The Age of a Lobster

Rate this book
Ian Marlow has everything it takes to be a great mortician - innate kindness, a strong sense of humor, and determined insomnia. Even so, managing a profitable funeral home in the heart of Colorado was never something that the twenty-three year old hoped to do with his life, and Ian is trapped reflecting on the exciting romance he shared with the wild at heart Andrew Reyes in California five years prior. When Alli, Ian's estranged cousin, calls to invite him back to San Diego, Ian realizes that this trip is exactly what he needs - an opportunity to live authentically free from expectation.

153 pages, Kindle Edition

Published June 7, 2023

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Stephen Mathews

7 books2 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
12 (26%)
4 stars
13 (28%)
3 stars
13 (28%)
2 stars
6 (13%)
1 star
1 (2%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 30 reviews
Profile Image for Sofija.
320 reviews14 followers
June 30, 2023
The Age of a Lobster is Stephen Mathews' debut novel. Ian Marlow works as a mortician at Creekside Memorial & Cremation in Colorado. It was not his decision to take that job, but his parents. At the start, Ian is 23, and he reminisces about his summer spent in San Diego 5 years ago at his cousin Allie's place. We find out how his parents almost shunned him to California when they found out he had been on a video call with a boy. His father read Ian's scared face like an open book. That summer in Cali changed many things for Ian, and it gave him a glimpse into a nearly perfectly free life.

Ian spends his summer days working at a diner, the Gilded Naupaka, with Allie. On his first day of work, he meets Andrew, whom he nicknames the king of California. Ian feels an initial attraction to Andrew, but his anxiety forces him to act rude and stand-off-ish, which prompts Andrew to call him Lemon. The other servers at the diner quickly adopt the nickname. "As if it was some ceremonial effort, Andrew set the lemon on the top of my head, whispered Lemon, then sailed past me." Despite the initial coldness, Andrew invites Ian to his birthday party and thus begins their relationship. Throughout the summer, their relationship deepens and grows into something beautiful.

Despite the overall relaxing atmosphere set by the sweltering heat and sandy beaches, the themes explored are dark. Ian struggles with an eating disorder, which is portrayed quite graphically. His habit of not keeping down his food decreases as he spends more time creating a new life in California. Also, Ian drinks a lot to cope with the overbearing feelings he is trying to suppress. The newly discovered parts of himself, immortalized by his new name Lemon, granted him the wanted freedom of his parent's expectations. Ian thrives under the San Diego Sun. But all good things must come to an end. When he returns home to Colorado, his parents have already sealed the deal with Carlos, the owner of the Crematorium.

In the second half of the book, the atmosphere becomes increasingly melancholy. Ian's separation from Andrew, as well as his feasible life, causes his descent into alcoholism. At the start of the book, Ian gets a call from Allie, inviting him back to California. Her unprompted call makes sense at the very end. Without spoiling anything, the invitation gives another chance to turn his life around. He is aware of his unhappiness, yet he dares to take matters into his own hands. His new life awaits him in California.

I liked Mathews' writing style. It is descriptive, atmospheric and pulls you into the story. You feel like you are there with Ian. The pacing is slow and gentle, like sitting on the beach on the edge of the waves as you feel the sun burning your skin. The Age of a Lobster is a character-driven story. We become the quiet observer of the fluctuations in Ian's life. We witness his cousin Allie becoming a safe space as she sees his true self and accepts him. "Understanding, acceptance, unconditional love... all of these things that parents promise to give but can't, sometimes, because not even their own parents knew what it meant."

Mathews wrote a heartbreaking book. I did not expect to feel this ache in my chest while reading. The final chapter brings out a new perspective on the story of Ian's life. As much as that presents a needed closure, it feels too brief. I wish the ending is either longer or introduced with more ease to blend into the story better. The Age of a Lobster is a melancholy, skillfully written coming-of-age story. It reminds me of Andre Aciman's Call Me by Your Name, without the debatable age gap. Both have somber, yet hopeful endings that tug at your heartstrings.

„Lobsters, with claws or otherwise, have come to mean a great deal to me. No one really knows the true lifespan of a lobster. The same is true for the moments in our own lives. Moments that we could never know how long they would have lasted because we ended them too soon. Lobsters are moments.“
Thank you to Book Sirens for the review copy!
Profile Image for alexis.
45 reviews1 follower
April 29, 2023
I don’t know how I feel about this one. The description and cover felt a little… misleading in terms of the actual content, so I was thrown for a loop once I got into it. I was certainly unprepared for the graphic eating disorder content, the homophobia, the alcoholism, *that* ending, and the overall melancholy tone of the book. I’m not upset about the tone but I felt I could’ve benefitted from some kind of content warnings for the rest of it, so I knew what I was getting into. The main character was insufferable at times but I felt for him. There were parts that were relatable and heartfelt, but overall I don’t think this one was for me.

Thank you to BookSirens for the ARC!
Profile Image for Sully (sulliedjedi).
998 reviews302 followers
January 8, 2024
Calling it quits at 32%. 2024 is going to be the year of honesty. I need to stop reading books when I'm not enjoying it.

I don't know what this book was trying to do or be, but it was trying too hard. Existential, pretentious prose that fails to be clever or interesting. Reminds me of my early twenties and listening to that one guy who was a film major. You know that guy, he's the one who is clever and deep, man, he sees and understands things you're too much of a plebeian to get.

This is a description of a regular get-together/small party at an apartment:

"Small crowds morphed and divided through some metropolitan mitosis, and the ones who danced were the lucky ones because they didn’t need words or wages. They had their music and primal movements. Occasionally, a holler broke out above the speakers, calling others to join in on the pulse-beat electric."

And

"Every flat surface accessible was coated in empty cups, and even emptier thoughts clung to the inner minds of those passed out on the floor."

What? 😆 Please.

And then:

"Stray dogs – the people who run around neighborhoods at night with nothing to do but wander. People who were reckless, wild, and free for no other reason than because they wanted to be. They were feral people who had been liberated from prophecy through their esoteric conjecture and howled in the streets at each other instead of at the moon because stray dogs didn’t know where the moon was most of the time. Stray dogs were hard to catch but easy to find because stray dogs were everywhere, and I would be lying if I said I didn’t want to be one of them."

Also, let's talk about the on-page bulimia and descriptive vomiting, being forced to eat, etc. There needs to be a CW for that. It's a lot.

It's a coming-of-age story, it has a cool title and an attractive cover.

I got it for free during the Smashwords end-of-year sale.
Profile Image for Brynn Parker-Zillich.
32 reviews
March 26, 2024
I honestly don't know how to rate this book as it is so deep with the homophobia experienced by the main character and the graphic eating disorder. It was definitely not the fluffy read I thought it was going to be, but there were some good parts to it (love, finding one's self, and finding the people you want to spend your life around). Lots of philosophy and angst, and told in a coming of age reminiscent way rather than the 23-year-old perspective that I was expecting.
Profile Image for Rose Galante.
126 reviews6 followers
May 17, 2023
This books took me on a ride. It’s a coming of age story, it’s a love story, it’s a heart ache tale, it’s a mental health insider look, it’s strangely hopeful, it’s not what you expect. I thought this book could have been slightly longer, I would love to see more expansion on topics revolving around Ian and his mental health. I felt like this book isn’t afraid to upset you. I do appreciate when I book doesn’t give you the fairytale happy ending, I respect an honest human-experience ending. This one gave me similar vibes to Sally Rooney’s Normal People. I received this book as an ARC
Profile Image for Chris.
122 reviews5 followers
May 24, 2023
Where do I begin with this story? I was drawn to this because the cover art was wild and the title to go with it was insane. It had me from that point.

I really enjoyed this book. The main character really irked me sometimes and Andrew deserved better. That part shattered me, but I understand it was needed so that Ian could actually grow up.

Overall, solid story! Thanks BookSirens for letting me read an eARC for my honest review!

The Age of a Lobster by Stephen Mathews releases June 7, 2023!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Hermes_Fang.
49 reviews1 follower
June 2, 2023
This book tore a hole in my heart, and it may take forever to heal.

I have complicated feelings about this book, to be honest.

The first 3 chapters are nightmares to me. It makes no sense. And chapter 4 to 12 make me like Sisyphus pushing up a rolling stone to the mountaintop. I lost in the memories and stream of consciousness of the main character, Ian. The reading is really painful. Sometimes I don't know what I'm reading.
And then comes chapter 13. It is a masterpiece. All things make sense now. And I'm strongly connected and related.
The book after chapter 13 gets better and better until the end.

And if you read it again from the beginning, everything gets clear.
It's a short book, but not fast-paced. And it requires multiple readings to understand everything.

Although I don't agree with Ian's choices, I can understand everything he did (and regretted).
Overall, I like this book.
But I think the author could do better for the first 12 chapters. The pace is too slow, and the writing is really confusing.
I'm really satisfied with the second half of the book, and am looking forward to read more about Ian as a mortician.
A sequel, please?

I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily. The Age of a Lobster will be released on 7 June 2023, and the eBook version of it only costs $0.99 until 21 July 2023 (Yes, I pre-ordered it after finishing the ARC, and it is definitely worth it.)
Profile Image for Marisabel Arauz.
25 reviews3 followers
June 6, 2023
I really enjoyed reading this book. The main character Ian was so raw, honest, innocent, and driven. Navigating through the teenage years as a closeted gay kid, that is looking forward to love and connection and at the same time be so afraid of hurting his parents.

The book was insightful through Ian's perspective, fears, hopes, and dreams. I liked how towards the end, as the years pass, he can look back and openly regret his actions and actively choose his own path. Live throws moments at us that make us change our perspective and our direction.

You can clearly see how our fears chose for us which of these moments we will act upon and it was very powerful how at the end, he chose to live his true self. The other characters, his parents, extended family, friends, and co-workers, all have an impact on his life and how he feels open or close to them was a direct effect on how approachable and acceptable they were towards him.

The Year of a Lobster was an absolute coming-of-age read that resonated with me and touched my heart.

I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Profile Image for Eli Pruitt.
144 reviews59 followers
Did Not Finish
May 13, 2024
DNF'd at 40%

For what should be a pretty straight forward queer coming of age, this is incredibly overwritten with prose far too flowery and purple for it's own good. You know when you're reading something and you can tell someone pulled out a thesaurus and switched out words just for the sake of it? This doesn't do exactly that but you can tell it's edited in a way that takes a second pass to simply make something sound more intellectual and, for lack of a better term, wordy. But it's done in a way where it pulls you out of the reading and makes you go "huh???"

And while I'm not particularly triggered (by much of anything really) it was odd to read about the MC's eating disorder with such nonchalance... I'm not entirely certain why that was. Another thing that sort of pulls you out and makes you go "huh???"
Profile Image for Voodoo Julio.
1 review
July 1, 2023
The longer I think about this story, the more it grows on me. Initially I thought this was going to be a sappy, gay romance novel about rekindling love, but I was delightfully fooled by the cover. No, this story is much less surface-level and way more intense into the psyche of coming of age when you don't feel loved and supported.

The author captures a feeling that I think many in the LGBTQ community feel as we get older--at least, I completely understood Ian's feelings of guilt, shame, and regret-- as I feel like there's always a part of us going "what could my life have been like if ___ happened?" "What if I stood up for myself when I was X age, or if I took control of who I was when I chose to do __." I regret not being myself sooner. And this book hit me like a truck because of that.

So did I sob like a baby reading this? Yes. But did I love every minute of it? Yes. Stephen Matthews made a short, bittersweet, summer world, and it was a pleasure to visit.
Profile Image for Matthew McKnight.
4 reviews1 follower
Read
August 15, 2024
I was just the same, sad kid I was before California, only with people to miss. I was back in old patterns, and I will say, watching leaves change without changing with them was hard.


The book isn't always a pleasure to read as the writing has a note of "pretentiousness" that bothered me (mostly in the beginning) as it tries to introduce the audience to the main character.

HOWEVER, I think it course corrected itself by the time the romantic interest comes along and those two have a very sweet journey for a while there. Went to bed after finishing the last 80 pages positively depressed.

I feel bad for saying bad things about the beginning of this book to a dear friend because I actually ended up relating to the book in a particular way that really stuck with me.
Profile Image for Roman Froxet.
Author 1 book4 followers
June 10, 2023
I connected to Ian [MC] way more than I'd like to admit—which created this unsettling yet riveting reading experience for myself. I didn’t always like him, but I could still empathize with him. I wish things could’ve ended up better for a certain character, but I understand that things had to play out the way they did.

It took some time to get onboard with Stephen's writing style but I grew to really like it.

My time with Ian and his story showed me a glimpse of both how to and how not to live life and I'm thankful to have experienced it. I’m happy I clicked on the instagram ad that led me to read this. 4/5.
Profile Image for Jennifer.
591 reviews14 followers
June 11, 2023
4.5 stars. The writing is beautiful in this heartbreaking and heartfelt story. This isn’t a straight line narrative where everything is explained - it jumps in to the middle and is more a snapshot of moments.

I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Profile Image for Nicholas Westerfer.
Author 1 book21 followers
September 14, 2025
Such a great read. The Age of A Lobster by Stephen Mathew is a poetic, intense, and deeply relatable novel. I loved how authentically it portrayed the often-hidden struggles with eating disorders, especially within the gay community. Though at times graphic, it never felt gratuitous…just honest. The characters were compelling and well-drawn, adding emotional depth to an already powerful story. A beautifully written and important work. Thank you for sharing this story.
3 reviews
June 17, 2023
I really enjoyed this story.

Stephen Mathews is a talented writer and I enjoyed this story of the main character, Ian, finding his true self. Engaging from the beginning to the end, The Age of a Lobster is fast moving and a good reminder of finding what’s important in life. I look forward to reading more from Stephen.
Profile Image for Allison Bettine.
18 reviews
March 6, 2024
Ian explores freedom away from his homophobic family while staying with his cousin in California. In a hot, hazy blur of late nights and awkward teenage moments, we watch a young person struggle with self acceptance and survival. This bildungsroman offers many vignettes into the future that sometimes felt ill-placed but provided some momentum when lacking. There are many beautiful moments that come full circle and make a short novel feel satisfyingly complete. Note that the tone is distinctly different from the vibe of the cover and title! If you’re looking for a brief heartbreaking tale rather than a light summer beach book, then this one’s for you. Great for anyone who has felt the sting of love lost and the warmth of found family.

Thank you to BookSirens for the ARC. This is my honest, voluntary review.
Profile Image for Carter.
177 reviews
May 28, 2023
ARC REVIEW <3

Like many other readers, the blurb and book cover really did not reflect the actual story I ended up reading. There were so many openings to chapters that seemed irrelevant and did not contribute to the story or the characters feelings. It was full of angst and fixable problems that the character was too stubborn to take action against. All in all this book was not my cup of tea.
(I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily)
Profile Image for Gerhard.
75 reviews27 followers
June 5, 2023
This gay-interest novel by Stephen Mathews is primarily a flashback that focuses on the events of five years ago while the young protagonist Ian Marlowe recalls spending three months as a waiter at a high-end eatery in San Diego, and meeting up with the charismatic Andrew, a young co-waitron whom would soon prove to be just the kind of shot-in-the-arm needed by Ian at that stage of his confused and introverted life. Firmly lodged in the closet and suffering from bulimia, Ian is a mass of insecurities and complexes, exacerbated by seemingly caring and supportive parents who are in fact the cause of many of his problems – mainly their ruthless denial of any signs of queer behaviour expressed by their son.

I am not a part of Mr Mathews’ target audience unfortunately and therefore what follows should be read keeping this firmly in mind. My occasionally cynical outlook found the proceedings decidedly pat and a tad unrealistic. I do not believe that gay men (especially one so emotionally challenged and compromised as Ian Marlowe) just happen to find their ideal soulmates in the twinkling of an eye. My own experience in this regard leads me to this perhaps unduly pessimistic observation as I recall the wasteland of unrequited love in which I wallowed in my young days – a sad state of affairs only so very seldom alleviated by the advent of a “meaningful relationship” with a fairly like-minded person.

I get that the state of California (and in particular the city of San Diego) act as a metaphor for Ian’s emerging sense of self-worth and the promise of freedom from all that ails him – but to label Andrew the “King of California” seems too silly for words. Also, if Andrew is as important to Ian and such an integral part of the plot, why is the author content to let him fizzle out without the common courtesy of appending at least a hint of clarification? Or did I not get it?

Editing seems to be taken very lightly throughout, with words frequently omitted and even a character’s name changing from Dillan to Dylan in the same paragraph.

I did not always get what the author was saying, as he occasionally uses an obscurely poetical way of expressing himself. Of course, there’s always a very good chance that I’m just too slow on the uptake, but I was really stumped when Andrew, after teaching Ian the basics of surfing and the latter taking a spill, called out approval to him in a way denoting sarcasm-robustica. Huh?? There are also references to “in-person palm trees”, "metropolitan mitosis”, “pulse-beat electric” – to describe the vibe at a party – and Ian waxing lyrically about the lights of La Jolla framing the “scriptures” of Andrew’s face while “daffodil cream” from the light fixture behind the ecstatic Ian lit up the other parts of his beloved. Romantic for sure, but decidedly maudlin into the bargain.

This simply did not resonate with me in any way, for which I am truly sorry as I’m convinced that 90% of future readers will find a lot to enthrall and entertain them in these pages. And yes, I will most definitely give the author another go in future. But for now I’m sticking to the opinion that this novel is surface-slick, but with a disappointing emptiness underneath.

I received a review copy from BookSirens, and I’m leaving this review voluntarily.
32 reviews
December 28, 2023

The Age of a Lobster is Stephen Mathews's debut novel. Ian Marlow works as a mortician at Creekside Memorial & Cremation in Colorado, a job he was compelled to do by his parents.

When the novel begins, Ian reminisces about a summer spent in California several years ago. He was dispatched to San Diego five years ago to his cousin Allie's place as his homophobic parents discovered his relationship with another boy on account of a video call.

This journey from Colorado to California is symbolic, as Ian faces freedom and independence from the control of his parents for the first time. So riddled is he with his past fears, his anxieties and unhappy experience, that he is very rude to Andrew who is also a waiter at the Gilded Naupaka, in spite of the fact that he is attracted to him. Despite the initial coldness and aloofness, Ian’s relationship with Andrew becomes a loving and beautiful one which is sensitively depicted by the author,

Ian is forced to return to Colorado where he takes up the job at the mortuary. This very fact is symbolic of Ian’s life which is dead and has no traces of vitality or hope. Hence, he has no hesitation when he receives a call from his cousin inviting him back to California. This is a second chance for him to live life on his own terms.

The novel does not have an “and he lived happily after” ending but then the whole point of the novel is Ian’s coming to age. He actively choose his own path for the future. He seizes the moment and makes a life change.
How does one tell the tale of a lobster? Fish have tiny stones in their ears with rings that can be counted to determine age, and deer and horses can be aged by their teeth, but there is a great deal of debate as to correctly tell the age of a lobster. Many feel that the age can be estimated on their size. However, in recent times, there is a theory that the rings around a lobster’s eyes can be used to determine the age but this is also open to dispute.
Ian manages to accurately guess the age of the lobster. We can possibly assume he has also made the right choice in living his life on his own terms.

Profile Image for V ❣️.
331 reviews27 followers
March 23, 2024
“Lobsters are moments.”

In this short book, we are following Ian as he reminisces on his past 18 year old self. For the span of a summer, he visits California and stays with his cousin. While there, he meets his first love.
Do not let the bright cover fool you. This book is painful. Ian has so many battles within himself and I wanted to shake him several times like, “cmon!!! Just be YOU!!” His parents are vile homophobes, he is battling with an eating disorder -which I thought was super well done and brought a new perspective to men with ED’s- and is just self sabotaging left and right because he doesn’t want to fuck up being the son his parents want him to be.
California changes Ian for a time. When he meets Andrew, he becomes the person he’s hidden away for so long. He becomes confident, and madly in love. But… will it last? Or is it just the summer and savory seafood?
I had a few problems with this one, mainly Ian himself. Once he started feeling himself a little bit, he stopped being nice to those around him. Totally cut off his bff from back home and snubs his cousin even though she’s made it apparent several times that she’s there for him and accepts him. And when Ian has a chance to do something, to REALLY make a difference and stop being so stagnant and letting his family trauma dictate his life… he crumbles. It’s just so sad because here I was rooting for you!!!!
Nearing the end of the book, I huge event happens that actually wrecked me no matter how much I wanted to slap Ian for his decisions. I knew it was coming, but damn it sucked.
Long live Lemon, death to Ian!!!! Be the gay you deserve to be.
2.5/5

Thank you to BookSirens, the author, and the publisher for providing me with an ARC ebook copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. All of these thoughts and opinions are my own.
Profile Image for Jill Rey.
1,424 reviews70 followers
May 12, 2025
Author Stephen Mathews’ writing is beautiful. Literary and light, strong yet timid, this coming-of-age tale is one of sadness and belonging. Returning to San Diego years later isn’t what Ian imagined for himself. Yet, neither was working as a mortician. “The Age of a Lobster” reflects on the summer he was sent to live with his cousin and the beauty of life he found there.

Flashing back to that summer, readers are slowly drawn in through the events leading up to that summer. From the smashed laptop to the reluctance to befriend new people, Ian is struggling to accept his real self if it means giving up the life he’s known. Embracing his job at the restaurant, near to his cousin Alli, Ian quickly settles into life in San Diego.

Doused with fear and freedom, encapsulated in Ian’s short-term bubble of safety and acceptance, this extraordinary debut settles deeply as we experience love, loss, and a life unexpected. Mathews has captured immense emotion as we see San Diego for the first time, through the lens of a lost young boy. Then he startles readers once again, as we make a return trip, and realize where the life he chose has taken him.

Showcasing enormous literary talent, “The Age of a Lobster” is quite possibly one of the most powerful coming of age tales I’ve ever had the pleasure of reading. Ian draws you in as you unravel the family dynamics, beliefs, and feelings bursting to be free. Mathews has made his presence known in this defining debut and work of art.
818 reviews14 followers
January 5, 2024
Snappy beats, effective dialogue, and brisk exposition. What I wasn't expecting were those scary episodes of homophobia and eating disorders, for however realistic they may be. While I'm annoyed by Ian, I sympathized with him too. The story unfolded in a predictable way, even the ending. And that's fine with me in a coming-of-age story.

Next time though, I'd like a new twist on that ending. It doesn't have to be entirely different, but I would like a different literary narrative for gay love interests.

I don't think the lobster metaphor landed well with me. I can see where it's coming from and what it's supposed to represent though, given how late it came within the novel.

What I was grateful for was the details for being a mortician and the embalming process. It's wildly on the nose with how it's in tune with Ian's character arc. The process of it interested me, and I was surprised it was included with such detail at all. At least until I read the author's bio.

The Age of a Lobster is a book that feels complete and crafted from head to toe. I would have liked further characterizations that goes another layer deeper than what we're given. But I realize that not all books have to be literary explorations into the psyche, and I appreciate that the book clearly accomplished what it set out to do: present a story about young love and forming identity. I'd probably recommend this to someone who is new to LGBTQ fiction.

I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Profile Image for Taylor Stanecek.
Author 5 books5 followers
July 27, 2024
I came across this novel while at the Pride event in Lamar, CO this summer. Getting to meet the author himself there was a pleasure as I found him to be friendly and very down to earth.
The novel was a quick read, and while it did take several chapters to get into, I did find the latter half of the story to be gripping and couldn't put the book down for the last fifty or so pages.
I appreciate the realistic aspect to Stephen's storytelling. He doesn't exaggerate or make the plot/characters seem too farfetched, which is great for an LGBT novel as I feel like we have too many fantasy stories and not enough that give the readers relatability.
And while the ending was a bit anticlimactic, it is quite thought provoking and lingers on the mind about one's life choices.
One thing I will say that was problematic was the lack in thorough/professional editing. I've noticed this happening more and more lately with self-published authors and I think it can really make or break the readability of a story.
Overall, I'd give this novel an average rating. The author's unique story is one worth telling and can be beneficial to those looking for advice about life or wanting to know they're not alone. With more editing, this could easily be bumped up to a 4-star. I am curious to see what Stephen has in store next. Keep writing, man!
Profile Image for Björn Visser.
Author 2 books5 followers
November 24, 2025
🎫🐙
Genuinely glad I ended up reading this through. I’ve been craving the way I felt in 2011 reading Ben Monopoli for the first time, and this felt exactly like that. I’m a big fan of a protagonist, especially a gay one, who can admit to their own flaws without assuming it’s societal. A character who lives in the real world while excitedly navigating both trauma and explicit joy.

There are parts that fall flat or just don’t line up, like the turning point with the parents in LA. Or the on again off again relationship with driving. But it’s a debut novel and it does what so few gay authors dare to do today: write a real human character, not a tick box selection of tropes. And one that exists now, not somewhere far. As a result, Ian feels not just real but often familiar. I saw a lot of my own youth in Ian, not the dramatic parts but the mentality and the decision making pattern so many gay men have shared. The relationship arc with Kelly really highlights that sudden neglect of others that surprises even the self. The best friend turned stranger through no one persons fault but rather situation is reflective and something I find myself fixing in hindsight.

Honestly, this was a breath of fresh air, and by the Grace Jones of Gaga was it nice to see myself in someone else again.

🌟 🌟 🌟 🌟
1 review
November 13, 2026
I have heard people criticize this book for its depth and descriptive writing, but that's exactly what I enjoy about it. From what I've read so far, it feels so real, raw, honest. It doesn't sugarcoat things and touches on very important topics. The mentions of eating disorders and the honesty of not know what you want from life is so important to me, I knew from the moment I picked it up, it would be heart breaking, and I'm not even done with it.

"With a bold breath, I inhaled and let the fullness of the night fill my lungs. I held it in even as I passed the joint back to Andrew. It burned, but I held it in only so I could exhale at the same time as Andrew and mix my smoke with his."

Incredible, a beautifully crafted story so far, can't wait to finish.

Edit: I finished the book, it was gut wrenching, so full of symbolism and despair, but hope, there was hope. I pray that Ian and Andrew, in another life, go to the aquarium together.
Profile Image for Ana Mathews.
3 reviews
August 16, 2025
I’ve been debating writing a review for this for a while; because I’m the author’s sister I was hesitant about any perceived bias. That said, I can honestly say this is one of my favorite books I’ve ever read, regardless of who wrote it. I just finished reading it for the second time, and will no doubt read it again very soon. I don’t want to say too much about the story or plot points, as I think this is really a book that needs to be experienced as it unfolds. I will say, though, that the writing style is beautifully poetic, transfixing me and pulling me in deeper with every page turn. I cannot recommend this book enough.
1 review
May 2, 2023
I got the ARC for this novel and keep remembering scenes as if they were from a movie. Literally so descriptive and vivid but a beautiful and touching story of looking back on young love. Perfect for this summer so I’m excited that I saw on social media that it’s ready to release just in time to go up on shelves with this beautiful cover! I highly recommend if you liked Dante and Aristotle!
1 review
July 16, 2026
I wrote this and I am beyond proud of it. There will always be changes that could have been made to the writing, but Ian's story is too honest to risk over-polishing it. A lot of heart and soul went into this book, and I hope that you recognize pieces of yourself in it's pages as well.
Profile Image for Catalina.
929 reviews48 followers
April 19, 2023
The "problem" with The Age of a Lobster is that the blurb is rather misleading. I was drown to it by the word "mortician" and hoped to read something I wouldn't normally do, but I ended up reading a sort of coming of age. And really, there is nothing wrong with that, if you are not bothered by the commonness of it all. That being said, the end made me realise I did care about Ian and I was heartbroken alongside him for all the wasted opportunities. But I was happy to see that in the end, he learned his lessons and took like by its horns, err I mean by its claws lol!

*Book from BookSirens, with many thanks for the opportunity to read it!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 30 reviews