Tropes: forced proximity, dislike to love, paranormal, found family, kind of a forbidden relationship, kind of hookups to lovers
Feels: 2/5
Steam*: 2/5
Kinks: paranormal species as a kink kind of
Angst: low
HEA: yes, but this book is not standalone so plot is not resolved by end
Pairing: MM
Triggers/potential icks/content warnings: violence/murder, war
This series is marketed as standalone, but I disagree with that. You won't be happy if you read this book as a standalone, you get no resolution to the plot until the end of the series. I did what I usually do for non standalones, which is hold off on reviewing until I've read the whole series and can put it in context. I won't mention spoilers for the other books, but know I have read the series.
This book follows 200 year old (ish) Alistair who is a hellhound and Sam's best friend. He is immature. He does a lot of one nighters only, because his first and only real relationship (a human) tried to burn him and his house town when he found out that Alistair wasn't human. Overall, Alistair is a drama queen/king personality and reacts in extremes and fixates on things and pouts over things. Honestly while he was entering to me he wasn't appealing to me as a leading man, he was a man child.
He gets assigned to a mission with his species leader Aidan, who is a cat shifter. Aidan is hundreds of years old but I don't think it's as specific about how old he is. They feeling attraction for each other but initially there's a reluctance to do anything about it given the power that Aidan holds over Alistair, it makes the relationship a little bit improper /unequal. But they get over that and start hooking up.
2.5 stars
I think it's important to say this as a starting point on my review (I said this on other books in this series too)...This author's style of writing has me feeling very conflicted. There are some things that I really like: I like the outrageous wacky funny moments - they remind me fondly of the chaotic OTT humour that Cora Rose uses. I enjoy the found family and the fact that there is an interesting plot outside of the relationships (once I got over the fact that these books are misrepresented as standalone). But there are some things that I really dislike as well, and I've actually decided after reading the 4 books that this author isn't for me, I am not going to read the spinoffs. I'm open if I hear good reviews of her future books, but I'm not interested in the romantic relationships in this world she built.
Here's why I don't enjoy her romantic relationships in this world (no real spoilers, but this really is true for all couples):
- The relationships come off as casual on one or both MC's side for the majority of the book. Too much of the book happens while the characters just don't like or feel about each other, it doesn't get me invested
- The writing style doesn't evoke the senses, it's not got any true sensuality to it. There's some UST but it's more talk then show, yawn. The sex scenes come off as physical rather than having true emotion/senses/longing behind it.
- One or both of the characters are hundreds of years old, and some make reference to past loves (completely understandable). Their lifespans are often different as they are different species. The current relationship the book is the subject of comes off as nothing special, as something casual, a footnote in their lives. There's no sense of "this person is it for me". Even when they go into the paired souls concept, the author still makes it seem like there are multiple special people that you can be compatible with, so even then the relationships aren't special.
- The author doesn't dive deep into the backgrounds of the characters, she keeps it light and casual, but often you feel like you just read an entire book & you don't know much about the characters, so again, not interested or invested.
Some things of note for this review, you can see how I'm all over the place, liking and disliking:
- Page 53 - Ick. This author doesn't seem to write sensually or build UST or emotional feelings well. She makes things too casual, too light, it doesn't really feel like a satisfying romance book. I find myself enjoying the funny moments between friends and the Tish mystery but not liking the romantic relationships that are supposed to be the foundation of the story.
- Page 58 - Three separate food deliveries for one meal, dinner, seems excessive. If you want a lot of food just order it from one delivery service. I find it annoying in this book how much focus there is on the fact that shifters eat a lot of food. So much of the book is focused on the practicalities of getting the characters food. And I'm like I f****** get it, let's move on and focus the words / pages of this book on the relationship and the plot. I don't need to hear about every meal / delivery / grocery run. Fuck off lol.
- At 75% mark - The pacing seems to be off in these books. We're at the 75% mark and Aida is thinking that it's too soon for them to have any plans for their relationship. Which is fair given what how little has happened relationship development wise so far but from a storytelling perspective I don't like the book getting to 75% and they're being so little relationship development done and there only being 25% left to tell their story!
- I like the living force / magic being visible and communicating with certain beings. It's an interesting take on magic.
- I'm a little unimpressed by the employees of CSG overall in this series. They kind of suck even though they are so powerful. They keep losing / getting beaten by the bad guys. They don't often use all these powers that they have. It's sometimes comes off as more of a government intrigue given they aren't as actively using powers to win as they could. It makes me think of like Harry Potter and how he was such a special magician, always saving the day. That doesn't really happen in this book series.
Some notable moments:
I love the chaos/humour: "“David,” Andrew says quickly. “If we’re judging by people who will always feed me, then definitely David is my best friend.” David stops dead in his tracks halfway to his desk. “What did you just say? Why is this news to me?” “He also needs to tell you that you’re pretty,” I remind Andrew. We all look at David. “I don’t even know what’s happening here,” he says."
Aw, Sam/Gideon, I love this reaction: "Caolan hesitates, then says, “You are also a paired soul.” The joy that breaks across Sam’s face is almost painful to see. “I knew it!” he shrieks, throwing himself at Gideon and climbing to wrap his arms and legs around him. “You’re mine forever!” Gideon buries his face against Sam’s hair, but not before I get a glimpse of his massive grin."
This is deep and interesting "“There are some souls with greater compatibility. Relationships change as people grow, and sometimes that means a connection between two souls comes to a natural end. When people with paired souls are in a relationship, they always grow in the same direction. Their souls will always complement each other.”"
I love how everyone turns and looks at Alistair "“They can make themselves undetectable in their dragon forms,” Caolan volunteers, and David perks up. “But they can be… stubborn sometimes. And they like pranks.” As one, we all turn to look at Alistair. “What?” he demands. “I’m not a dragon.”"
*FYI about steam: I rate steam based on a combination of quality & quantity. I note kink separate from steam because I don't want to underrate steamy reads that don't have much kink.
**Note about spoilers: I like to comment on the plot of a book in reviews, so I almost always mark my reviews as containing spoilers. But I try to avoid spoiling the big dramatic moments! As a reader, I personally like to know what I'm getting into before I read a book so I know more about the content and if it's to my taste/mood, so I try to give that information in my reviews for myself when I'm considering rereading and also for other readers.