A brand-new original anthology series, a companion to the acclaimed Fantasy Magazine, an edgy and sophisticated magazine featuring a diverse spectrum of authors ranging from Holly Phillips and Theodora Goss to Stewart O'Nan and Peter S. Beagle.
Sean A. Wallace (born January 1, 1976) is an award-winning American science fiction and fantasy anthologist, editor, and publisher best known for his work on Prime Books and for co-editing two magazines, Clarkesworld Magazine, and Fantasy Magazine. He has been nominated a number of times by both the Hugo Awards and the World Fantasy Awards, won two Hugo Awards and one World Fantasy Award, and has served as a World Fantasy Award judge.
3 stars, just enough to claim space on my anthology shelves. 11 stories that adequately summarize one's expectations of FANTASY MAGAZINE...which means to say, this is why I cannot subscribe, as contents are a crapshoot. 4-5 oddities that range from dreamy eloquence to messenger pieces, all of which essentially tread water. 2 terrific tales (from Maura McHugh & Lisa Mantchev) and 4 other enjoyables make this a keeper. But only take the time to read this book if you already enjoy this magazine's style of fantastical writings.
“Like your fantasy edgy, modern, and sophisticated?” OK, if that’s not a pretentious, self-congratulatory tagline, I don’t know what is. But the stories collected here aren’t bad. This slim volume seems to be aimed at getting people to subscribe to ‘Fantasy’ magazine (Now ‘Lightspeed’).
**** Goosegirl – Margaret Ronald. A very effective re-telling of the old fairytale of a princess and a goose-herder who switch places on the way to meet the princess’ betrothed. Although this is a many-times-told tale, I feel this telling really did bring something new and original to the story, while maintaining its kernel.
** All the Growing Time – Becca de la Rosa. Aims for a surrealist meditation on time and a relationship. But it didn’t work for me – the style was distancing.
**** Somewhere Beneath Those Waves – Sarah Monette. Just read this in Monette’s collection of the same title. In a seaside town, a woman is caught in a loveless marriage, a selkie is trapped by the cruel man who has stolen and hidden her skin, and a creepy museum curator hold the spirits of female ship’s figureheads in his gallery. When the three elements come together, all will gain their freedom.
*** Shallot – Samantha Henderson. I don’t know why it’s spelled like the vegetable. What if the Lady of Shalott was an alien with hypnotic powers? I feel like I’ve read a very similar story about the Lady of the Lake.
*** Bone Mother – Maura McHugh. (Not Maureen McHugh.) A tale from the point of view of Baba Yaga. Not bad, not more memorable than average.
*** The Greats Come A-Callin’ – Lisa Mantchev. As an inheritance gift, a woman receives the ghosts of her ancestresses. There are both good and extremely inconvenient aspects to this.
*** Zombie Lenin – Ekaterina Sedia . A Russian girl is rather obsessed with zombies, and seems to see them following her around. Nice, works on multiple levels, but seems a bit like an early work by Sedia.
** The Yeti Behind You – Jeremiah Tolbert. The stress and fear brought about by hearing there’s a baby on the way manifest, for this man, as invisible extinct animals that follow people around. Didn’t really work for me.
*** The Salvation Game – Amanda Downum. A nice, dark, paranormal-action fantasy. Good fun.
*** Sugar – Cat Rambo. A plantation owner runs her factory by using golems, and is emotionally torn between two women – one, dying, one living, and her complicated relationship with both of them. (I know Britomart is a name from Greek mythology, but it always sounds like a 24-hour grocery store, to me.) The setup here was very nice, but the style was distancing, to me.
*** Brother of the Moon - Holly Phillips. In a war-torn land, a twin leaves his sister and goes to make some kind of sacrifice that may save the land. Again, a nice feel to this, but too many unanswered and undefined questions – like, if this magic was possible, why didn’t one of the twins do this much earlier? What exactly IS the sacrifice, what happens? It felt either unfinished or like an excerpt.
Not a bad collection of short stories, but nothing to get too excited about.
"Goosegirl" by Margaret Ronald. Not bad, but it left me with more questions than answers. 2/5 "All the Growing Time" by Becca De La Rosa. Intriguing premise. 3/5 "Somewhere Beneath Those Waves is My Home" by Sarah Monette. Bit of a cliched premise, but handled well. 4/5 "Shalott" by Samantha Henderson. Arthur, meet aliens. 3/5 "Bone Mother" by Maura McHugh. Where did Dracula come from? 4/5 "The Greats Come A-Callin'" by Lisa Mantchev. This one bored me. 2/5 "Zombie Lenin" by Ekaterina Sedia. You can't go completely wrong with zombies and chthonic deities. 3/5 "The Yeti Behind You" by Jeremiah Tolbert. Baby anxiety leads to yeti visions. It's complicated. 3/5 "The Salvation Game" by Amanda Downum. A sister strikes a deal with a witch to save her twin brother. 4/5 "Sugar" by Cat Rambo. A sad tale of golems, sorcerers, and lost loves. 4/5 "Brother of the Moon" by Holly Phillips. What happens when an old, worn down hero doesn't want to fight anymore? 3/5
This collection had many amusing and different story subjects. From fairy-tale twists, Arthurian aliens, persistent imaginary friends, and dead relatives who take up your workspace. It could have actually had more tales included, since it's a relatively short anthology. Also some stories had actions that seemed unclear. But that didn't deflect much from the overall feel of each piece.
I enjoy short stories for the most part and some of these where very good others though needed to be a tad longer and have more to them. I am going to mail this book out as soon as I can to a friend and see what they think if they read it.
i won this in a raffle at Octocon 08, and really liked it. it's a collection of stories from Fantasy magazine (which i am now considering a subscription).
Slim collection of stories intended to serve as an introduction to Fantasy Magazine (although the stories are all original to this volume). Pretty good reads.