3.5 stars
My last Tabitha Suzuma book…T.T unless she writes another one sometime! They are all pretty good reads, although this one wasn’t particularly my favorite. I think the best two remain Forbidden and From Where I Stand. But Zoë, when are you going to talk about THIS book you twat? Okay, okay, onto the book itself now.
This wasn’t a bad book—in fact it started off good. But the second half is where it started to fall down for me =/ I actually thought it was going to go in a completely different direction.
The Characters
The characters were very complex and real. Even though they are all pretty flawed in their own ways, I still found myself caring about them and wanting each of them to be okay. I know I’m not supposed to, but I really felt bad for the father, even though what he did was horribly wrong and unfair to his children. Not to mention risky as hell! It could’ve had even more dire consequences than they did. Especially during the part where Louis starts to shout at him about having found at, after the dad said, “The perfect ending to the perfect day.” The irony. I didn’t really know which parent’s side to take—both of them did wrong, as far as I’m concerned. The father, obviously, put his kids in a very tough position, but the mother shouldn’t have made it so that they would never see their father again either. It was very difficult for me to support either one of them. Poor kids.
But the person I felt the most sorry for though was Millie, because her poor cat got left behind! Yes, I know people will be like, “Oh, the mother can just take care of the cat, Millie can get a new cat, blah blah…” Those people clearly don’t understand what a pet truly means to someone. If it were my cat, I’d go back to her in a flash. :P
Max and Miss Kano were probably my least favorite characters. Nope, wait—that would go to Tess’s mom. She was annoying from the beginning but then when she decided to read her daughter’s diary and get into everybody else’s business, maaaaan…I wanted to hurt her. Parents who do that are despicable. She disrupted the peaceful life they’d finally made there, not to mention she invaded her daughter’s privacy. I would never trust her again if I were Tess.
Speaking of Tess, I still don’t really know whether I liked her or not. She was kind of annoying. Kind of. But it’s easy to overlook when she’s so nice at the same time. But she does stupid things though…like leave her vulnerable diary with very PERSONAL information in it that’s not even hers, lying around for her stupid mom to find. Luckily though she went and warned the others, so I guess that makes her not completely useless.
The Plot
There were so many unanswered questions at the end!
-How did Louis’s mother react?
-Will Louis ever reunite with his father, brother, and sister? How do they fair after he leaves?
-Will Louis go back to dancing in Paris, go back to the same school, go back to his same friends?
-Will any of them ever see Tess again?
-Are Treasure and Tresor okay?
Seriously. I could’ve done with a lot more answers. I even could’ve done with a super sad, super depressing ending like a lot of her books, if only everything was tied up. But this felt so rushed and abrupt. It just ended. It could’ve been a little longer and expanded a little more, as it wasn’t a very long book to begin with. When I saw the word “Epilogue” I was like, Already?! I thought what was going to happen was that they’d eventually get caught and, in devastating Tabitha Suzuma-fashion, the father would go to jail. I’m not saying I wanted that to happen, I just think that would’ve been the most realistic ending. Although, perhaps predictable.
The first half of the book kept me really engrossed, although I think it took a little long for them to find out what we already knew. But I still think the build-up was good and I could believe it through their eyes, even if in the back of my head I already knew what was coming. The second half of the book took a huge turn that I wasn’t expecting though, and I’m not sure I liked it. First they brought in a little romance—or, I should say, potential for some romance, even though the main character is 12. And I get it, 12-year olds have hormones and whatnot, and he had an innocent crush on a girl, but I still wish there could’ve been no mention of romance at all. I also thought the way they’d settled in so easily was a little unrealistic. I don’t think they covered their tracks that well, and I didn’t really understand why the dad let Louis take the dance class in the first place when it was obvious it would end up exposing them in some way or another. When on the run, you have to remain inconspicuous and somewhat hidden, even if it’s not always fun. Surely they knew they wouldn’t be able to get away with this.
Meh. Not the best Suzuma work, but if she writes another book, you now I’ll be all over that like bees on honey. Most of her books are SPECTACULAR and I am proud to say I have now read all of them. And one thing she always succeeds at no matter what is creating good characters. Which, let me tell you, a lot of authors fail miserably at.