It was a hot, humid day Saturday in June when I heard about “The Club” by Christy O’Connor. It was after a 9-11 a.m. Milwaukee Hurling Club traveling team practice. Pat Foley had just come off the pitch, talking to me about signing up for “Line App” on my cell phone to stay in touch with the panel decisions. The NAACB’s, or North American County Board Championships would be hosted in Chicago that year, and considering the championship was the Mecca of all American Hurling Events, Milwaukee wanted to send two teams to Chicago to ram our talent down their throats; the usual sibling rivalry.
Pat had studied at the University of Limerick, Ireland like myself and was telling me about a great book he read about hurling. Later that evening, he texted me a reminder: “The Club” by Christy O’Connor and statement that read “It’s the Irish version of the Milwaukee Hurling Club. I had a lot to do, so I put the book on a lengthy to do list, and waited to till Christmas to ask someone else to buy it for me.
“Beyond a Boundary” written by Trinidad Marxist C.L.R James was one of the most important sports books I read in my life. It detailed the effect of English racial segregation inside the Caribbean Cricket leagues. It was the first book I read the managed to weave how dialectically the political and social climate invariably affects sports. We can even see this in the United States, when NBA players responded to the deaths of Dontre Hamilton and Eric Gardner by police through their wearing of the “We Can’t Breath” shirts during primetime games. It is as C.L.R James famously states in his book “What do they know of Cricket who only Cricket know?” Christy O’Connor is no exception, implicitly stating “What do they know of Hurling who only Hurling know,” through his examination of Hurling Club Play.
St. Joseph’s Doora-Barefield was at the height of Clare County hurling in 1999 after winning the All-Ireland County match. They were considered a club that had provided several players for the All-Ireland Clare team, and had won back to back Munster hurling titles. By 2009, the Club has fallen into the depths of obscurity and the book details the Club’s last attempt with many of the veteran players from 1999’s All-Ireland team to regain their respect and title during the 2009 season. This is a tragic tale, that ends with many veteran players realizing that while loss can be disheartening, their roles in the Club’s rebirth lie with supporting the Club, rather than playing for the club.
Like C.L.R James Christy O’Connor looks at the effect of a community and an organizational structure has on Club teams and individual players. O’Connor examines the role of urban sprawl in Ireland in impacting the amateur players away from the sport. Hurling is a sport that those in the Club level do out of love, since they receive no monetary compensation. Many young, potential hurlers are lured away to the cities to work and are overexposed to professional sports like Football and Rugby. O’Connor also details the unforgiving organization of the GAA which makes dual participation in Gaelic sports like Hurling and Gaelic Football, very strained. This often leaves a club to decide which sport to adopt, rather than hosting both.
What O’Connor does more than James, is look at the effect of community on the psyche of the players. St. Joseph’s Doora-Barefield is a small, rural parish community. The community experiences the deaths of a Ger Hoey, a remarkable Hurling player and teammate of the 1999 All-Ireland team, and the parish priest. O’Connor describes how these deaths served as a rallying cry for some players, and an obstacle to some. We see through Doora-Barefield’s run for the title, how family and work affect player commitment to practice. When Doora-Barefield is defeated it is tragic, but ultimately expected by the author. The future lies with efforts of the organization to cope with obstacles presented to the community not on the shoulders of the past.
Pat Foley asked me what I thought of the book. All I could say is that the book, though written in a different country and in a different organization, struck a chord with the experience of the Milwaukee Hurling Club. As an organization, we must look to building the younger future of our club, rather trying to rekindle the fire of the veterans.