Mary Beard is the number one celebrity classicist in the contemporary English speaking world and her personality and erudition certainly has captured the interest of this once-aspiring postgrad student of ancient Roman sexual history. In ‘All in a Don’s Day’ Beard’s classicist and ancient historian persona is deeply embedded in much of the text. However, this is not a dry as dust study of the life of an academic at Cambridge University. This book is a collection of numerous blogs from the period 2009-11 and Beard ranges over issues as varied as the pissing boy statue in Brussels to the consequences of protesting, and lots of variegated points in between, yes, this compendium of blog entries is mostly focused on the academic life, yet it is not purely devoted to the esoteric nature of life on and in one of the most elite education facilities in the world.
Beard’s opinions on all the subjects she tackles are informed by her erudition, her desire to engage as honestly as she can with the issues, and dare one say a somewhat matriarchal charm reinforced by her ‘English’ nature. She does not write comparatively nor is she so devoted to her own ego or the value of her arguments that she won’t except criticism. There are occasions when what she writes does not quite gel with more contemporary and perhaps PC values. However, there is an underpinning of reasonableness and intelligence that makes reading Beard’s blog entries far more informative and engaging than other more controversial or self-possessed columnists’ work.
It is also interesting to see that at the end of almost all places in this volume Beard and her publisher have included some of the responses to her pieces. There is a semi regular lineup of respondents who get the opportunity to have their views published in this text, and some of them they will be if not colleagues at least fellow academics. On some occasions these responses are more like a shared remembrance or anecdote. In other entries these replies reject Beard’s views. Beard, her editor and publisher deserve recognition for including such commentary on her writing.
It goes without saying that a good portion of this book is focused on Mary’s issues, processes, problems and other aspects of her life as a university academic. The life that she describes is certainly demanding (physically and mentality) but it must be noted that Beard obviously enjoys the job she has, the role she has undertaken. For all the concerns and challenges that she sites in this book at bottom the reader encounters the thoughts, feelings, actions and musings of a passionate intellectual. Also, Beard is willing to mix her intellectual stylings with arguably more mundane experiences.
There is no doubt that anyone who is interested in the world of academia, what it is like to be at Cambridge University, and perhaps the celebrity nature of Mary Beard will find plenty to enjoy in ‘All in a Don’s Day’. Relatively short and not too challenging for those who most likely will read the book (students and those with an interest in academia) this is a book that will be very engaging fir it’s probable audience. The nature of the text means that there is a rather fragmentary approach to the books narrative but that’s relatively inconsequential. At the end of the day this is a book about and by Mary beard and if one likes her work and her public persona then you will want to read it. If not you probably won’t.