I read this for a class, in which I had to write a reflection paper each week regarding what I had read. Below is an excerpt from one of those reflections. It addresses some of my misgivings about this textbook, which could have been a little better if the authors had done even a tiny bit more research.
This week, I was surprised to see a reference to my favorite Star Trek movie, the one with the whales, in my Multicultural Psychology textbook (Mio et al., 2020, p. 73). To be a nitpicky nerd, the patient is an adorable elderly woman, but the textbook says “his” twice in reference to the patient, implying that the patient is a man. I found this tiny bit of woman erasure to be ironic coming from this source. Dr. “Bones” McCoy is a role model of mine, with this scene being one of many reasons why. Before giving the patient the pill that fixed her kidney (not appendix, as the textbook states; the lack of fact-checking for something this menial is worrisome because it implies the authors’ research is not entirely trustworthy), he said, “What is this, the Dark Ages?!” I think of that quote often when reading about healthcare in America, whether it be some historical horror (e.g., the Tuskegee Syphilis Study mentioned in last week’s discussion) or the present costs of hospital visits.
Another part of the textbook that gave me some trouble was the paragraph regarding Caitlyn Jenner on page 103. Though I disagree with some of Caitlyn’s ideas and don’t have very fond feelings for her, I don’t think it’s appropriate to deadname or misgender her. I understand that language and the rules surrounding it change quickly, so the authors might not have had any bad intentions. Perhaps if this book was released today, the paragraph’s opening sentence might say something like, “Ever since Caitlyn Jenner, who was once known as the athlete Bruce Jenner, announced to the world that she was transgender, the topic of transgender individuals has been of interest in the broader society.” The paragraph goes on to say there isn’t “an equivalent female to male model.” I feel like this an uninformed opinion; Chaz Bono famously came out as a trans man in the early 2000s (GLAAD, 2009; Oprah, 2011). I wonder if sexism could be at play here. A person assigned male at birth is considered a “role model” for being publicly trans, while a person assigned female at birth is forgotten for doing the same thing, despite receiving media coverage.