Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Interpreting Charismatic Experience

Rate this book
For eight years David Middlemiss was a minister who had to assess charismatic phenomena, such as the claims of 'prophets' who would tell him with great certainty what 'God was saying to the church'. During church services he had to interpret the varied and sometimes dramatic manifestations which go with charismatic experiences. This period left him with major questions. Is a person on the floor of the church 'slain in the Spirit', hypnotized or hyperventilating? Why does God give such a confused system of 'guidance' to people? Why do people look for 'the demonic' in heavy metal music or obscure corners of the personality when there is much evident evil in the world? Does the charismatic movement have any intellectual or biblical credibility? In the end he left the church to spend three years in study seeking an answer to his questions. Central to them all was the question, 'If a person claims to have encountered God in his or her experience, how can one tell if this is what has really occurred?' This issue led him on a long personal journey through church history, theology and on into philosophy, and he was driven almost to despair before finding a way forward. In the end he could argue that there are rational means of interpreting Christian experience and that these may be used. They may seem over-critical of charismatic experience but that experience contains much nonsense which has to be cut out if what is of value in it is to be preserved. When parts of England are experiencing what is called the 'Toronto Blessing', which is not proving wholly beneficial, here is a voice which needs to be heard.

298 pages, Paperback

First published March 19, 2012

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
0 (0%)
4 stars
1 (50%)
3 stars
0 (0%)
2 stars
1 (50%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 1 of 1 review
Profile Image for Mark Mathur.
10 reviews
October 17, 2026
A Philosophical Investigation of Charismatic Phenomena

I love, and hate, this book. Or rather, I loved it until I got to the last pages.

Why I love it: This book is a unique attempt to answer the question "How can you be sure that an encounter with God actually was an encounter with God and not something else?"

The author was a Baptist pastor who was involved in the Charismatic movement back in the end of the 20th century. Being a church leader it was expected of him to be able to discern which charismatic expressions were authentic, and which were fake. This stressed him out and he enrolled at uni attempting to find an answer to this haunting question. This book is a result of that quest.

His search, like the book, began in theology but ended up in philosophy. He realized that earlier in history, there had been charismatic movements too, but in those days it was called Enthusiasm. Philosophers like Locke and Leibniz had written papers on the topic of Enthusiasm, and tried to answer the same question: How can we be sure these Enthusiasts have really received messages from God? Theologians like John Wesley and Jonathan Edwards had also dealt with the question.

So after a couple of chapters it turns into a philosophy book. Unfortunately the title and the cover don't reveal this, and I really think you need to have studied philosophy a bit to be able to follow the arguments. The author is thorough in his attempt to find an absolute answer to his inquiry, which requires a hardcore philosophical approach.

So why do I hate it too? Well, all through the book he dissmisses various philosophical models and their ability to solve the problem, but always indicating that there is a working solution at the end of the book. So my expectations are enormous when I approach the final chapters, as this question has vexed me all my life.

[here comes the spoiler...]
Eventually he reveals that the only working solution is to use a cumulative approach and starts listing a number of rational strategies for sifting the chaff from the wheat. OK, this is promising, but it is still not clear how exactly we are supposed to apply this cumulative method. Could he please give us an example of a divine encounter that has actually passed this rigorous test?

No. Instead the solution turns on itself in the final chapter. He repeats that the cumulative method is the only possible solution, but then admits that applying this to something as unfathomable as God and encounters with him would require a lifetime of analysis. In other words, it's virtually impossible for us! And finally he ends with the famous quote from Wittgenstein: Whereof one cannot speak, thereof one must be silent.

I nearly tossed the book into the wall!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Displaying 1 - 1 of 1 review