Don Paterson's first Selected Poems seems a long time coming. Simon Armitage published his first collection only four years before Paterson, yet published his Selected Poems a decade ago. You could make a case that Armitage is more prolific, and that would carry some weight. You could make another case that Paterson is better, and that might carry more. Most other British poets are the warm-up. Paterson is the main event.
He'd probably swing for me for saying this, but it's hard not to feel an almost paternal sense pride at seeing a writer whose work you've followed since his first book do so well. Not to belittle either his numerous awards or the big names that have tuned in to him, but it's the feeling that you found him first that sticks.
One of the pleasures of a Selected Poems is guessing in advance which poems will make the cut, which won't, and seeing the final result. I'm happy to note only three I'd expected to see aren't included here ('Graffito' and 'Seed' from Nil Nil, 'Prologue' from God's Gift to Women), and happier still to note the entire 'Alexandrian Library' series has been left out.
What's been left in tells an interesting, between-the-lines story. The bite and brashness of the early work is vividly intact, as in 'Filter', in the closing stanza of 'Nil Nil', and in my enduring favourite 'An Elliptical Stylus' - a poem that breaks the fourth wall in the middle and closes with a fist shaken at the audience:
'But if you still insist on resonance -
I'd swing for him, and every other ****
happy to let my father know his station,
which probably includes yourself. To be blunt.'
Most great writers are two people, if not more: their art grows out of the splits in their personalities. The man that 'tilted the bottle towards the sun / until it detonated with light / my lips pursed like a trumpeter's' is also the man that twice urges you that nothing really matters. Among other things, it's the split between Paterson's erudition and urge to demolish that charges his poems.
The oeuvre, too. Not that the early work lacks tenderness, but the further you go, the more you see of it in the poems, trusted to stand on its own without getting too misty-eyed or too wised-up, as we see in 'Advice to Young Husbands', 'Waking with Russell', 'The Swing' and 'Correctives':
'The shudder in my son's left hand
he cures with one touch from his right,
two fingertips laid feather-light
to still his pen. He understands
the whole man must be his own brother
for no man is himself alone;
though some of us have never known
the one hand's kindness to the other.'
Helping to keep the whole in balance is Paterson's sense of fun. This applies to typography (as in 'Sigh' and 'Poem'); the poet's subject matter ('Two Trees') and in the prankish 'On Going to Meet a Zen Master in the Kyushu Mountains and Not Finding Him'.
As a volume, this has been long overdue: tender and angry, alert and vigorous, I doubt a better Selected Poems will be published this year.