Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

A People Numerous & Armed: Reflections on the Military Struggle for American Independence

Rate this book
Americans like to think of themselves as a peace-loving people, and in remembering their own revolutionary past, American historians have long tended to focus on colonial origins and Constitutional aftermath, neglecting the fact that the American Revolution was a long, hard war. John Shy shifts the focus to the war itself and explores the ways in which the experience was entangled with both the causes and the consequences of the Revolution. This is not a traditional military chronicle of battles and campaigns, but a series of essays that recapture the social, political, and even intellectual dimensions of the military effort that created an American nation.

376 pages, Paperback

First published May 27, 1976

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

John W. Shy

11 books4 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
20 (22%)
4 stars
34 (39%)
3 stars
27 (31%)
2 stars
6 (6%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 12 of 12 reviews
Profile Image for Bob Croft.
87 reviews7 followers
January 10, 2019
Insightful series of essays about the Revolution, perhaps centering on the interaction of society and the military at war. An example, covered in several essays from differing perspectives, is the effect of militia (both Patriot and Loyal). Given its often ineffectiveness in a traditional line of battle (note Washington's feelings about the militia), the Patriot militia became a local police and enforcement force (call it a constabulary), supplied a draft for the conventional forces, almost always turned out when asked in short-term relatively local emergencies (think Bennington or, more informally, Kings Mountain), and, while not generally able to stand up to British (or Hessian) regulars in force entering the neighborhood, re-established Patriot control when the British moved on. Charles Lee advocated (and demonstrated in his slow march across New Jersey) something that seems to me akin to our Vietnam era "strategic hamlet" strategy, using the regular army to establish control, arm, organize and nurture the local militia, and then move on to a new area once the militia was capable of maintaining control. The British tried a similar strategy through the last half of the war, but encountered generally insurmountable issues with 1) being in most areas a small minority of the population; 2) finding that ethnic groups professing loyalty were often mutually antagonistic (think Scots and Germans in the Carolinas) and were more enthusiastic about killing one another than killing Patriots; and 3) British attempts at fomenting slave insurrections and Indian uprisings offended many of their potential supporters.
Profile Image for Levie Galapon.
45 reviews4 followers
September 7, 2014
Summary

John Shy takes a new look on the War for Independence by exploring interesting aspects of the War. By doing so, Shy makes new analysis in a topic that seems to have been fully explored. Furthermore, an interesting point that Shy makes early in the read, is to read history in the perspective of those experiencing it (xv). This idea should also be placed upon the reading of Shy's compilation. Because, it would seem to be affected by two events The coming of the bicentennial of the American Revolution and the concurrent American experience in Vietnam (17 and 226).

Analysis

Throughout the different essays, Shy explores different aspects regarding the War for Independence. One of them was his case study on Charles Lee. Lee was an interesting character, not only in his brilliance as a field commander, but as a forward thinker in unconventional warfare (138-139). This shows that at the time of the Revolutionary War, there was capacity in the military leadership to engage in guerilla warfare. This begs the question, why not? Especially after early conventional defeats in Bunker Hill, Long Island, and New Jersey (239). Furthermore, it would seem logical for the militia and continental army to wage unconventional war against Britain. This is due to the idea espoused by Lee such as, "popular war of mass resistance" and the utilization of "the same tactics the free men at Lexington and Concord had instinctively employed." (161) However, Shy answers this tough question with an interesting analyses. Shy states that extensive use of guerilla warfare would have "undermine the political process, and throw power to a junta" (161). It is interesting to note that the Charles Lee essay was written in 1964 during the Vietnam War (133). It could be seen that Shy was possibly influenced by the fighting of conventional U.S. forces against unconventional vietcong forces.

Another interesting aspect that Shy explores is the imperial interpretation of the War for Independence. In Shy's essay on Lawrence Gipson, Shy pointed out the interesting arguments that Gipson made about how the colonists had no reason to rebel. Gipson makes his argument by showing that Parliament had no choice but to tax colonies after the French and Indian War. Furthermore, that Parliament actually repaid colonies their "wartime expenditures" (127-128). However, Shy critiques Gipson by mentioning that Gipson has failed to understand the colonists (125). This particular essay is interesting because Shy is trying to teach that there are different perspectives in evaluating and analyzing history. The side of the loyalists or imperials during the war for independence is hardly known. However, we should not forget that "all major historical events must make sense". (125)

But it could be seen from Shy's writing, that he has learned from Gipson's writing. According to Shy, "(t)he closer Gipson gets us to concrete events and flesh-and-blood people, the more persuasive he becomes:" (129) This particular skill of weaving anecdotes into a historical narrative, gives a certain weight to the story that statistics and numbers cannot. Shy used this skill to great effect when writing about Lieutenant William Scott. The history of Lieutenant Scott as presented by Shy, brings to life a person from centuries ago. It's impressive to see the amount of information that Shy was able to retrieve on Lieutenant Scott. However, the rest of this essay does not focus much on Scott but on different aspects of the revolution. The most interesting of which is the location of Tories. Shy makes a realist analysis of where the Tories are located by stating that Tories were found in mass wherever British held strong forces, its a "pattern of raw power." (178) According to Shy, this analysis shows the "brutally direct effects on behavior...of military power." (179)

Overall, Shy makes a great case on how history remains relevant throughout time "not by proximity, but by priority in historical time." (232) Shy wraps up his collection of essays with an overarching conclusion that ties revolutionary history and the american culture of war. Shy's pertinent analysis of the revolutionary war is that it set up patterns of US perception on war. That is, wars are fought aggressively and could achieve desirable results (239-240). Furthermore, once again brought back in the frame of the Vietnam War, Shy ends on a note where he believes that US will admit defeat in Vietnam. An aspect of american war culture, that is to be despised and at all costs should be avoided (258 and 17).

Profile Image for Al.
411 reviews33 followers
October 22, 2012
A very good collection of essays that explore the socio-political impact of the American Revolution, as well as the problems both sides had in developing and reassessing a strategic vision. The most interesting essays included chapter 7 which explored the motivation of those men who served in the Continental army for the long haul, as well as how socio-economic background may have played a role. Chapter 9 (and part of chapter 8) provided a fascinating look at the development of British strategy in the South, how the strategy shifted, and the results of that strategy. I thought chapter 10 was the strongest essay in the book. This essay sought a definition of the war; was it a civil war, an insurgency, a conventional war? It also explored British and American understanding of the issues that supposedly lay at the root of the war. Another fascinating aspect was the impact of membership in the militia and how the militia functioned as a part of the mechanism which generated support for the war; perhaps not enthusiastic support, but lukewarm acceptance was better than active resistance.

Overall, this is a tremendously informative look at the American Revolution that remains very relavent today.
Profile Image for Erik.
95 reviews19 followers
October 16, 2011
Fascinating collection of essays about the Revolutionary War that were all written during or just after the Vietnam War. Thus the questions are very interesting. Could the British have won American "hearts and minds"? (Probably not.) Could the Revolution have been averted if the British had been more sympathetic to the Americans? (The British were probably as sympathetic as they were going to be.) The final essay, about the American military experience from colonial days to Vietnam, is thought-provoking and still applicable, I think, post-Iraq.
Profile Image for Christopher.
86 reviews24 followers
August 18, 2015
Exceptional—maybe even one-of-a-kind. All students of military history should read this book of essays, whether or not they're particularly interested in the American Revolution. (That said, it's an excellent primer in the historiography of the war, especially the subject of British and American strategy.)

I wish I felt some confidence that military historians could still write books like this one.
13 reviews
March 16, 2011
An excellent collection of essays on various aspects of the American Revolution, written mostly at the time of America's involvement in Vietnam. Shy ably demonstrates that the history of our nation's founding has a lot to teach us about modern revolutionary conflict, a fact of which policy makers remain blissfully ignorant.
Profile Image for Brent.
21 reviews20 followers
October 12, 2009
Great book that delves into various aspects of the military struggle for American Independence. I heartily recommend it for anyone interested in American History, and on the nature of the American insurgency itself.
Profile Image for Nate Hill.
55 reviews13 followers
July 4, 2014
A revealing consideration of the American populace in war, this book is unique in that it looks at the continental population through both the US and the British historical record.
37 reviews
July 31, 2014
An insightful collection of essays on the American Revolution. It exposed me to new ideas and concepts, and was well-written.
212 reviews
December 9, 2014
A well written and thought provoking book. Please note that a certain knowledge of key events and people is presupposed-which impacts a full understanding of some of he essays.
Profile Image for Alexander Seifert.
Author 1 book3 followers
January 17, 2015
A compilation of essays that cover various topics, this was one of my favorite books that I read for my American Revolution class.
Displaying 1 - 12 of 12 reviews