L'America latina è, oggi più che mai, un continente “esplosivo” che riproduce in maniera esasperata i conflitti e le tensioni che lacerano tanta parte del mondo contemporaneo, e attira sulla sua drammatica situazione, “troppo a lungo considerata con sguardo distratto, un'attenzione per la prima volta viva e, talvolta, anche allarmata”. Questo volume che uno dei maggiori specialisti di storia latino-americana ha scritto appositamente per i nostri lettori, si offre come strumento utilissimo per comprenderne la tormentata e multiforme evoluzione, dalla fine del Settecento ad oggi. L'esposizione prende avvio dalla crisi del colonialismo, ricostruisce la ricerca di un'autonomia dei vari assetti nazionali, sempre frustrata dal peso preponderante degli interessi di potenze straniere, la Spagna e il Portogallo dapprima, poi l'Inghilterra della rivoluzione industriale e, tra le due guerre mondiali, gli Stati Uniti, sino all'attuale fase neocolonialista. Denso di dati e di fatti, particolarmente attento ai problemi economici, aggiornato sino alla morte di Guevara, il volume costituisce un'indispensabile premessa alla comprensione di una bruciante realtà attuale.
Un libro un poco difícil de leer, por su gran profundidad, pero muy completo. Me gustó que el autor logró exponer las grandes complejidades sociales de cada periodo histórico. Nunca el pueblo vs el poder opresor, o los locales vs los imperios malvados extranjeros, sino que queda claro que ese "pueblo" no es una masa homogenea, sino que son muchisimos grupos con diversos intereses cuyas perpertuas luchas gobiernan el devenir histórico. Me causa curiosidad saber qué escribiría el autor tras 40 años más de historia en esta Latinoamerica tan nueva pero a la vez tan la misma.
Difficult reading, but a thorough exploration of Latin American history from the late colonial period to the 1980s with a focus on the region's socio-economic history. Written by an Argentine historian, this history features a distinctively Latin American voice.
Por fin terminé este tomo, y no me quedan dudas que es entre los más impresionantes obras de historia que he leído. Halperin Donghi se queda más en el plano de estructuras sociales y sus lentos giros que en la historia de los eventos, pero sabe hacer de la economía y de la organización social algo parecido a un actor narrativo. Si bien las historias "nacionales" que presenta no podrían satisfecer a la curiosidad que llevaba a los casos que mas me interesaban, todavía no sentí que las detalles estaban totalmente perdidas. Los únicos autores que conozco que han podido cubrir tanto espacio y tiempo en una manera tan satisfactorio son Braudel, en Civilización Material, Economía y Capitalismo y F.W. Mote, en su China Imperial, 900-1800. Esa comparación es el mejor complemento que sé dar a un libro de historia, y Halperin Donghi va entre los más altos modelos para mí en mi vocación como historiador.
As the most recommended history on Contemporary Latin America, I definitely found this to be a helpful/informative overview.
That said, the structure (likely due to writing style and translation) was difficult to follow as the author often flows rapidly from year-to-year and country-to-country in a somewhat aimless fashion.
Regardless - would definitely recommend and found it super helpful as someone who is new to the topic.
A few things I learned or that were reinforced: - Replacing the portion of a subsistence economy with an alternative can be a dangerous formula for uprisings as it can limit basic needs to a subset of the population - Mass education and political history are super important...a lot of these economies seemed to follow dangerous cyclical patterns of falling back into similar economic mistakes based on populist leaders/ideologies - Leaders/governments rise or fall with the economy. Citizens in the historical case studies were often happy with whatever government as long as the economy was strong or accelerating - Liberalizing an economy / globalizing can be productive but often requires a specialization or niche in which the respective country can outperform with a service/product relative to the rest of the world
Comprehensive exploration of Latin American history. More succinct than Bethell's volumes, but this history does jump about between states and time periods which can be confusing at times.
It should be probably be called "The Contemporary Histories of Latin America." I read this book from the perspective of a generalist with an inclination to learn more about this subject, and I was not disappointed. The occasionally ponderous writing style is only a minor flaw- the book is translated from spanish to english, so I'm willing to cut everyone some slack. The jacket copy bills this as the most widely read single volume history of the area, and based on what I read I imagine it must be favored by universities in the U.S., Latin American and Europe to earn that title.
The history of Latin America encompasses three periods: the colonial period, the emergence of the nation state & the post WWI history of the nations. The idea of a shared "latin american history" for the first two time periods make sense, but only the fact that the nation states developed individual identities quite late in the time period covered makes the third part feel like anything more then a series of tacked on national histories.
As an American, it was interesting to read a take on U.S./Latin American relations that left beyond the Naomi Wolf style histronics of "Disaster Capitalism." I came away from this look feeling a little better about the U.S.'s mixed track record in Latin American foreign policy: It's quite impossible to blame the U.S. for any long term problems in the region- issues of economic underdevelopment and unstable politics have plagued Latin America from the very beginning.