Since the early 1990s, the federal role in education-exemplified by the controversial No Child Left Behind Act (NCLB)-has expanded dramatically. Yet states and localities have retained a central role in education policy, leading to a growing struggle for control over the direction of the nation's schools. In An Education in Politics, Jesse H. Rhodes explains the uneven development of federal involvement in education. While supporters of expanded federal involvement enjoyed some success in bringing new ideas to the federal policy agenda, Rhodes argues, they also encountered stiff resistance from proponents of local control. Built atop existing decentralized policies, new federal reforms raised difficult questions about which level of government bore ultimate responsibility for improving schools.
Rhodes's argument focuses on the role played by civil rights activists, business leaders, and education experts in promoting the reforms that would be enacted with federal policies such as NCLB. It also underscores the constraints on federal involvement imposed by existing education policies, hostile interest groups, and, above all, the nation's federal system. Indeed, the federal system, which left specific policy formation and implementation to the states and localities, repeatedly frustrated efforts to effect changes: national reforms lost their force as policies passed through iterations at the state, county, and municipal levels. Ironically, state and local resistance only encouraged civil rights activists, business leaders, and their political allies to advocate even more stringent reforms that imposed heavier burdens on state and local governments. Through it all, the nation's education system made only incremental steps toward the goal of providing a quality education for every child.
This book is basically a slog, even though it does deliver more or less what it promises. I wanted a fairly straightforward history of modern educational politics on the federal level, up to and through the No Child Left Behind Act in 2002, and this book gave me that. Unfortunately the author decided to clog it up with irrelevant and inane academic theorizing (See theory number four: "the existing institutional context bounds the scope of entrepreneurial change during the process of implementation." This is both obvious and ridiculous.)
Still, the main outlines of the story is worth knowing and pondering. First, the book shows that the famous or infamous 1983 Department of Education report "A Nation at Risk," was actually only one of a veritable explosion of reports in the early '80s calling for renewed "excellence" in public education. For instance 13 major CEOs and some state governors joined for the 1983 report "Action for Excellence," while in 1984 Kati Haycock, soon to be the official gadfly of the left-establishment, helped publish, under the California Achievement Council, "Excellence for Whom?" which tied the emergent civil rights order to a form of the excellence movement. Meanwhile, the right-wing, then represented by Diane Ravitch, Chester Finn, and ED Hirsh, gathered under the Educational Excellence Network to publish reports like 1984's "Against Mediocrity: The Humanities in America's High Schools." Although all had different takes, this excellence movement emerged suddenly and almost ubiquitously in American education.
Its results, though, first blossomed in Southern governors' offices, where people like Lamar Alexander in Tennessee, Richard Riley in South Carolina, Bill Clinton in Arkansas, and George W. Bush in Texas took up the standard of excellence to improve lagging southern schools. Alexander and Riley rode their achievements to the Department of Education during Bush I and Clinton respectively, while the latter two of course helped ride it to the presidency. What's shocking here though is how close Clinton and Bush were both before and after entering office. Almost everyone forgets Clinton's twin 1994 initiatives Goals 2000 and Improving America's Schools Act, but they contained almost all the paraphernalia of NCLB: demanding testing, accountability, and types of national standards. Yet after the Republican Revolution of that year Clinton almost refused to issue any of the regulations for enforcing it, leading to the need to reenact an even tougher version under Bush II.
Still, starting with the first fine of a state ever for failing federal education requirements (Georgia in 2003) statehouses began a revolt against the standards which they once championed, claiming the federal leviathan was preventing even simple changes in their systems. Waivers, once refused by Bush, started to proliferate, and then proliferated further under Obama. Each president aimed for more federal power and suffered pushback from those who wanted more local control. In fact the real mystery here is why, when almost all polls the author presents show most people wanted less federal involvement in education, each president pushed the government further and further into local territory. It's a real triumph (or tragedy, depending on your perspective) for the network of educational reform, stretching through universities and civil rights groups to the Business Roundtable and sectors of the right-wing intelligentsia. They seem to have real power.
So this is a fairly succinct overview of modern educational policy, but it could have been much better written and more readable. But that wouldn't please academic editors would it?