※Initial Thoughts※
This book took me 8 days to read. I never take that long to read a book of this length, so it is clear I really did not want to pick it up.
I think this book is for a select group of readers. Readers who enjoy introspective and aesthetic stories and do not require much action or an exciting plotline would do well with this story.
I may come back to this review later when I have a little more time and I am on my laptop, so FRTC—maybe.
※Further Thoughts※
I think this story definitely had potential. Three adult siblings, not well respected in their village, are sent to live as settlers in an arctic world to pay their absent father's debts. There are problems in their relationships that are exasperated in the intensely harsh yet dull world they now find themselves in. Despite supposedly being out there alone, they eventually meet 2 other people who add to the small cast of characters. There is a lot of potential here, and perhaps, if I were a different type reader, this story would have resonated with me.
The themes in Frost Light were (1) finding beauty no matter where you are and (2) honest communication and letting go of guilt brings healing to relationships.
However, for me there were too many detractors. The first is that this is written in first person present tense, which is not my favorite pov. (I think that were it written with a different pov, I would have been able to connect with the author's writing style. She seems to have real talent with putting words together beautifully, but it was hard for me to tell due to the pov.) With such a small number of characters, the first person present tense made it seem too laser focused on our protagonist's circling thoughts and feelings. Which leads me to....
...the second issue I had: it is extremely introspective. I understand the purpose of it being so--it highlighted the loneliness and dullness of the world to which they had come, but it became quite repetitive. Not only does the protagonist repeatedly think the same types of thoughts over and over, but the author was repetitive in how she presented it. I can't begin to tell you how many times the protagonist thought, "I didn't even see… him get up or her move to the window” or some other type of action the protagonist missed. (And the number of times she forgot her gloves? Yeesh, she deserved frostbite.) This introspective pov also had me wondering at first if unimportant things the protagonist would see or do were actually important, because so many mundane non-events in this character's daily life were described.
Also, I think this story would have been better without the fantasy elements of mythical creatures. Those elements had nothing to do with the story, and it seemed tacked on instead of a genuine part of the world.
Furthermore, (I’m sorry🫣) there were many distracting grammatical errors and typos.
This book has good ratings, so don't go by my review alone. Read the others--perhaps another review will enlighten you to a side of Frost Light I did not see or appreciate. Maybe you'll find you best read of 2024.
※※"Be blessed in your endeavors." ※※
(Megan Whalen Turner)