3.5 stars
The nitty-gritty: Being a radio DJ is a killer job in this lively, bloody and humorous take on slasher movies.
This might be the first horror story I’ve read that revolves around a radio show, and I thought Maria Lewis did a great job of taking the slasher trope and making it fresh and new. And I loved a lot of elements in The Graveyard Shift, but unfortunately some elements fell flat, hence my lower rating. This book was a solid four star read for me until I reached the last couple of chapters, where the story took an unexpected turn that didn’t work for me at all.
Tinsel Munroe works at Melbourne radio station 102.8 HitsFM, and her nighttime radio show The Graveyard Shift has developed a loyal following despite it’s 11:00 p.m. to 6:00 a.m. time slot. Tinsel’s show pays homage to the horror genre, as she plays both popular and obscure songs from horror movies as well as horror-centric tunes like Monster Mash. On the Halloween night that we first meet Tinsel, she’s running a contest on her show for tickets to the premier of the much anticipated horror movie Band Candy (a Buffy reference, perhaps?) Mera Brant calls in to try to answer Tinsel’s trivia question, but while on the phone Mera is murdered in her apartment. Tinsel thinks Mera’s screams are nothing more than a Halloween prank, but later when the police arrive to get a statement from her, she learns that Mera was actually stabbed to death while on the air.
Tinsel is shattered by this horrible event, but she’s determined to keep her show going, especially when the ratings for The Graveyard Shift take off, a macabre side effect of the on-air murder. A young, handsome detective named Vic James is assigned to the case, and when Tinsel is targeted by the killer, Vic insists on protecting her. And the killer isn’t finished. More dead bodies turn up, all of them seemingly linked to the film business, although the victims don’t seem to fit any particular demographic. As Tinsel and Vic get closer, the danger ramps up, until it gets a little too close to home.
Lewis sets up the tension right out of the gate in an unusual but effective way. The first chapter is from Mera Brandt’s point of view, as she’s in her apartment listening to Tinsel’s show. We see her murder first hand, and then the next chapter jumps to Tinsel in the studio where we “hear” the murder from a completely different point of view. I quite liked this approach, and I thought starting out with a murder was the perfect way to launch this story.
I also loved the radio station setting, and I learned a lot of behind the scenes information about how a radio station is run, with social media being a big part of Tinsel’s job. She’s actually responsible for monitoring the HitsFM twitter account as she’s performing her DJ duties, as well as checking the station’s text messages. (Note: Lewis obviously wrote her story before Twitter changed to X, so it was a bit nostalgic in that respect!) I’ve been a big fan of radio since my pre-teen days, so it was a treat to get a peek inside.
The author fills her story with music references, which isn’t surprising since Tinsel is a radio DJ, but we also get plenty of horror movie trivia. Readers who are familiar with slashers in particular will have fun with all the name dropping, and if you’re Australian, you’ll most likely get a lot of the music references, since the author includes Aussie bands and singers in her story.
Besides Tinsel and Vic, one of the main characters is Tinsel’s sister Pandora, a successful true crime podcaster who proves to be very good at solving crimes. I loved the name of her podcast—Pandora’s Box—and I especially loved the relationship between the two sisters. Both are adopted, and although Tinsel is single and Pandora is married with children, the two share a very close bond.
For the most part, this is a fast-paced, lively and tension-filled story, but the pacing does lag in places. There is a heavy romance element that I wasn’t expecting, so there are several chapters that focus on Tinsel and Vic’s relationship, and this is where the story started to lose me. Honestly, I could have done without the romance, since I was quite happy with the serial killer mystery, although when you get to the end there’s a good reason for the author to include their relationship. Overall, The Graveyard Shift skewed toward the younger side of things. I believe Tinsel is in her mid twenties, and she’s heavily into social media, dating and clubbing, all perfectly normal activities for someone her age, but not all readers are going to connect with her lifestyle.
The biggest negative for me, though, was the ending. Endings can make or break the story for me, and I just didn’t like the ending of The Graveyard Shift. Two things happen at the end that sort of made me mad, and I was left wondering why the author made those choices. This is a mostly upbeat, humorous story, aside from the murders of course, and simply put, the ending was a big downer and didn’t fit the tone of the rest of the story.
Still, there’s a lot to like here, and based all the four and five star reviews on Goodreads, I would give it a shot if you’re a fan of horror movies, popular music and cozy sibling relationships.
Big thanks to the publisher for providing a review copy.