What do you think?
Rate this book
Changing Order: Replication and Induction in Scientific Practice
This fascinating study in the sociology of science explores the way scientists conduct, and draw conclusions from, their experiments. The book is organized around three case replication of the TEA-laser, detecting gravitational rotation, and some experiments in the paranormal.
"In his superb book, Collins shows why the quest for certainty is disappointed. He shows that standards of replication are, of course, social, and that there is consequently no outside standard, no Archimedean point beyond society from which we can lever the intellects of our fellows."—Donald M. McCloskey, Journal of Economic Psychology
"Collins is one of the genuine innovators of the sociology of scientific knowledge. . . . Changing Order is a rich and entertaining book."— Isis
"The book gives a vivid sense of the contingent nature of research and is generally a good read."—Augustine Brannigan, Nature
"This provocative book is a review of [Collins's] work, and an attempt to explain how scientists fit experimental results into pictures of the world. . . . A promising start for new explorations of our image of science, too often presented as infallibly authoritative."—Jon Turney, New Scientist
"In his superb book, Collins shows why the quest for certainty is disappointed. He shows that standards of replication are, of course, social, and that there is consequently no outside standard, no Archimedean point beyond society from which we can lever the intellects of our fellows."—Donald M. McCloskey, Journal of Economic Psychology
"Collins is one of the genuine innovators of the sociology of scientific knowledge. . . . Changing Order is a rich and entertaining book."— Isis
"The book gives a vivid sense of the contingent nature of research and is generally a good read."—Augustine Brannigan, Nature
"This provocative book is a review of [Collins's] work, and an attempt to explain how scientists fit experimental results into pictures of the world. . . . A promising start for new explorations of our image of science, too often presented as infallibly authoritative."—Jon Turney, New Scientist
207 pages, Paperback
First published August 1, 1985
70 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 3 of 3 reviews
March 16, 2022
Makes some interesting points, but sometimes also just seems silly in its constructivist approach.
July 31, 2015
Harry Collins explica minuciosamente cómo el conocimiento científico es aceptado una vez que es legitimado y puesto en lo que Latour llamó "una caja negra", aunque para el inglés tiene más que ver con la distancia que otorga el tiempo. La replicación como paso básico en la construcción del conocimiento científico es más teórica que otra cosa, pues un hecho se acepta más fácilmente si no amenaza con romper ni tensar ninguna parte de las redes en las que están inmersos los científicos.
La edición es excelente, incluye un posfacio y un post-scriptum que insertan al libro en los debates de la sociología de la ciencia de los últimos treinta años.
La edición es excelente, incluye un posfacio y un post-scriptum que insertan al libro en los debates de la sociología de la ciencia de los últimos treinta años.
Read
December 27, 2012Int D 498
Displaying 1 - 3 of 3 reviews