Tyler Morgan is Dear Cari, a successful syndicated advice columnist living in Washington State. She begins to receive letters from a man who writes that years before he was in love with his younger sister's best friend, but couldn't tell her because of her age. He asks Dear Cari's help in winning back his lost love. He signs himself Lonely and Loved Starved in Philly.Tyler suspects that Lonely and Loved Starved is Wyatt Jordan, now a high-powered lawyer.She spent her entire teenage life loving and adoring Wyatt. Tyler decides to her own love advice and goes after what she wants, returning to Philadelphia.Sparks fly in this battle of wills as these star-crossed lovers struggle to find happiness when everything around them seems determined to stop their relationship.