I’ll start with the negatives, it was predictable, cookie-cutter and cliched. But maybe I’d rather use the terms careful, assiduous and by the book. I’d rather use those because while I have to admit it felt like a story I’d read before that’s exactly what I wanted it to be; I didn’t pick up a Star Wars book expecting it to break new ground, I picked it up because I wanted space battles and Jedi, which is exactly what it delivered to me.
Perhaps this makes me biased in my reviewing since if I was to be objective it was likely a worse book than some I’ve rated lower, but the difference in my eyes is that it doesn’t pretend to be anything more than it is, which I can’t say for others.
But enough of my meta-commentary back to the actual review. I’m glad I read it as a omnibus instead of three separate books since it started slowly with a lot of set up throughout the first book, which would have frustrated me if I’d finished an entire book with no payoff. Luckily that’s a situation I only need to imagine as I was straight onto the second book which picked up heavily and really put the trilogy in gear, with the antagonists establishing their threat and the protagonists at their lowest. The third book then paid it all off with the protagonists coming back and vanquishing evil. This was a standard hero’s journey that worked really well for me because the scope of the trilogy allowed for about 4 protagonists and 3 villains. This number of main characters could make a lesser book confusing but it was balanced really well so kept things flowing between them all. What I also enjoyed was that the antagonists were realistically also opposed to each other which added an extra layer to the stakes.
Now onto the actual negatives this time, the ‘sun crusher’ itself unbalanced the stakes of the novel, it’s a small ship with indestructible armour that can shoot torpedoes that cause a sun to explode and destroy its surrounding system and ships, which then also has a hyperdrive so can get anywhere it needs to. I understand what the author was trying to do by making it something every side would want and explaining how a second one can never be built, but it is simply too perfect for a story like this. It’s hard to be invested in a space battle where one side cannot lose. My other complaint is more of an annoyance that the largest villain who is established to have been able to drain an entire planet’s life force was destroyed by the power of friendship, but this is more forgivable since his power mostly came from influencing other people.
All together I thought it was a good book that I’d recommend to Star Wars fans. If you aren’t a Star Wars fan it’s probably not worth the read as you’d need to know who all of the pre-established characters are and there are a lot