'The Seventh Day' gives an unparalleled picture of how the Israelis feel about making war--or peace--with the Arabs. The honesty and emotion with which these soldiers talk and the understanding and openness with which they discuss their experiences make this a book that is both timely and extraordinarily moving.
I imagine that this book is meant as a chronicle of the heroism and nobility of Israelis and, in particular, their soldiers, before, after and especially during the Six Day War. I also imagine that it conveys just that to the lay reader and did even more so at the time of its publication in the early 1970s (before the October 1973 war). To the reader versed in the relevant history, however, it is an entirely different sort of book. Rather than a chronicle of heroism and nobility, it is instead an astonishing testament to a profound sickness within Israeli society.
The book is a series of interviews, excerpts from letters, and other generally brief texts in which Israelis discuss their views of the war and the events around it. If there is a single, generalized theme it is this:
We are a beautiful people. Our kindness, our gentleness, our humanity know no bounds. And it is our profound tragedy that we are doomed to be surrounded by cruel, violent Nazis who know nothing but savagery and brutality and whose only purpose for existence is to attack us. Still, so pure are we that, despite their barbarism, we remain ever willing to bring them within our warm and loving embrace as friends and as neighbours. If only their reptilian brains could grasp how fortunate they are that we are here to bestow upon them our gifts.
I realize how ludicrously over the top that sounds, but I think that’s an entirely fair representation of the message of the book. The Israelis being interviewed do all but weep at the depths of their greatness. Their army is, of course, the most moral in the world. It showers its kindness upon the enemy, giving him food and drink. Succor and healing. No one is killed except without the profoundest regret, and even then only soldiers are harmed. Not a single hair on a civilian’s head would ever be disturbed by these noblest of men.
To put it succinctly, the interviewees come across as utterly mad. For one, they talk as though they’ve been not through the Six Day War, but the Hundred Years’ War. One of them (p. 252) expresses the horror of having spent the war in a bunker. For SIX DAYS! What have Palestinians been through in the decades since Zionism came to them? What have Gazans endured over the past three years? I am sorry that they had a bad (almost) week but complaints for the inconvenience should be directed to their government, which (as per Menachem Begin) chose to attack its neighbours.
Another common theme across interviews is that there was no choice given what “the Arabs” would do to them if they’d won. “I knew they’d have slaughtered us all” (p.134). “Their barbarity, their lack of any minimum decency, their complete failure to show any respect towards enemy soldiers” (p. 139). “They (Jews fighting in 1948) hated them (Arabs) because they’d wiped out villages(!), murdered, killed and raped” (p. 163). “We saw it all on the Syrian Heights …. a whole country entirely devoted to attacking you” (p. 174). “They would have killed, smashed children up against walls, raped and done everything in the cruellest way possible” (p. 177). “We never had any intention of annihilating or conquering or oppressing other people. On the contrary, it was the Arabs who had these intentions and we who defended ourselves” (p. 183). Of course, we all know what Palestinians have been telling us for decades of how the Israeli military behaves. And so I’d direct the reader to any decent history of the Nakba and point to the definition of “projection.”
On a similar note, many of them wax eloquent about the innocence of Israeli motives. “Everyone knows the Israelis didn’t want territorial gains,” says one on p. 135. And yet they refer to the places under occupation as the “liberated territories” (p. 178) while recalling that in 1948, Jerusalem became “a symbol of something that had been taken from us” (p. 268). The segment starting on p. 277 goes on at length about how Jerusalem was controlled by “foreigners” and at the mercy of“blood-thirsty ruffians” (i.e., its Palestinian inhabitants).
Of course, there is no recognition that the indigenous population has any rights at all. I believe that there is only one reference to “Palestinians” in the entire book, on p. 304 where an interviewee asks if Palestinians see themselves as such or if they could just be Jordanians, Iraqis or Kuwaitis. But otherwise, they are just generic Arabs with no identity. On p. 156, a soldier criticizes neighbouring countries because “they didn’t let [Palestinian refugees] assimilate into the other Arab states.” This, after expressing rage at those refugees for insisting that they came from places in Israel - after all, it had been 19 years and so they obviously should have forgotten and moved on (although he now forgives them since “all the Arab states inflamed their feelings and hopes”).
Many, such as one on p. 97, are appalled at the idea that any Israeli soldier would loot private property and firmly condemn it. This, from soldiers of a country much of which was built on pelf stolen from ethnically cleansed Palestinians.
Candidly, this is a difficult review to write because of the extent of the insanity. I jot down references to noteworthy passages while reading a book, to refer to in my review, but in this case there are simply too many that make the jaw drop. “I had a right to conquer” (p. 101). “We extend[ed] its borders to places which long, long ago should have been ours” (p. 105). “Friends of ours who’ve just been killed by the people we didn’t finish off in the Sinai Campaign … [Arabs] don’t know the meaning of the word humanity” (p. 144) “We tried to be too humane and it cost us quite a bit” (p. 167). “The government had no intention of turning the Arabs of the West Bank into refugees” (p. 222). “We thought it was so important (before 1948) not to buy land which was worked by Arabs, so that not a single Arab was dispossessed. In 1948, the Arabs fled. It’s very important for us to remember that we did them no wrong” (p. 244). And this is only a sampling because it was impossible to keep up.
There are some rare attempts at introspection, but they aren’t worth much. On p. 308 one can find a soldier explaining that Jews have enemies because “we’re successful, an over-clever people.” That might explain thousands of years of antisemitism, but in this particular context I’m sure if we think very hard we can find a more immediate cause for why Palestinians and Arabs generally might not be fond of Israelis. But what can you expect from people who kill an enemy soldier and express outrage at his dying grimaces that express “hate, yes, such hate.” What did you expect the man to do as you machine-gunned him to death? Show you love and affection?
This book will be of interest to two audiences. First, anyone looking to learn as much as possible about the 1967 war since there is information in here in that regard. But second, and more importantly, anyone who wants to understand what Palestinians and Arabs generally were up against in trying to find a modus vivendi with their new neighbours. How do you come to term with people who see themselves as angels in human form and you as some kind of demented orc? There is a recurring theme of soldiers hoping that there would now be peace, but without any recognition of what it would take to get there: assuming responsibility for the ethnic cleansing of Palestine and the implementation of UNGA Resolution 194, under which the refugee are entitled to opt for either repatriation or compensation. On p. 184, an interviewee claims to be “offering them equality, not supremacy - and they don’t want to accept it.” Two sentences later, the same man asserts that “we’ve got something to offer the area: culture and enlightenment.” The Israeli version of “equality” is for Israel to do whatever it wants and for everyone else to be grateful for it. That is the “peace” deal that has always been on offer to the Palestinians: the acceptance of permanent subjugation and whatever crumbs Israel chooses to throw their way.
Israel in 2026 isn’t the same Israel as in 1967. Then, Israelis clearly wanted to see themselves (and for others to see them) as generous humanitarians who want only peace and friendly relations. Of course, their actions couldn’t have been less congruent with that desire, but the desire was clearly there. Now, there is barely a glimmer of any nod even to the concepts of human rights or the rule of law. Apartheid and genocide are on open display and spoken of openly and proudly, even if the legal terms themselves are disavowed. That brutal candour and the shamelessness is engenders might just might - prove to be the undoing of Zionism. Because despite the insistence (p. 173) that “no one was going to come to our aid,” the fact is that Zionism has always depended on a Great Power patron: first Britain (from Balfour to the end of the Mandate), then (briefly but crucially) the USSR, France in the 1950s and for many decades now, the US. It is conceivable that public opinion has moved too far to enable that phenomenon to continue. Time will tell, but after three years of genocide and open calls for ethnic cleansing from the highest ranks of Israeli society, the Palestinians may not have enough of it left before they are subjected to a final reckoning with the longstanding Zionist goal of their complete expulsion from their homeland.
One of the very best books about the complexities of combat for soldiers, even those fighting in what they consider a just cause. Stands alongside J. Glenn Gray's The Warriors: Reflections on Men in Battle. The format is conversations between Israeli soldiers (and a few elders and wives) who fought in the 1967 Six-Day War. The perspectives cover a very broad range, but what comes through is the real and continuing cost for those who fought and those caught up in the fighting. Many places where I found myself thinking about the deep history of what's happening now in Gaza and beyond. No simple answers but many reminders that neither "side" has anything resembling a monopoly on righteousness.